Falls the Shadow: A Novel (Welsh Princes Trilogy Book 2)
Falls the Shadow: A Novel (Welsh Princes Trilogy Book 2) book cover

Falls the Shadow: A Novel (Welsh Princes Trilogy Book 2)

Price
$12.99
Publisher
St. Martin's Griffin
Publication Date

Description

“A marvelous literary and historical achievement…. Impossible to put down.” --- Boston Herald “Absorbing. . . . [Penman] manages to illuminate the alien shadowland of the Middle Ages and populate it with vital characters whose politics and passions are as vivid as our own.” --- San Francisco Chronicle “A remarkably detailed look at how people lived in medieval England and Wales. . . .Worth reading.” --- The Plain Dealer (Cleveland) “A vivid portrait of a lost time . . . full of fascinating personality studies . . . Once you enter her world you’re hooked.” --- Seattle Post-Intelligencer From Publishers Weekly It is a mystery why Simon de Montfort's name is not as instantly recognizable as those of Charlemagne and Richard the Lionhearted. The histories of France and England were significantly shaped by the causes he espoused and the battles he fought. Penman, a writer whose fidelity to historical detail is matched by her gift for narrative, makes Simon, Earl of Leicester, one of her central characters in this sweeping, dramatic saga set in the 13th century. The novel initially suffers from a dual focus, however, since Penman is equally concerned with the descendants of Llewelyn Farr of The Sunne in Splendour, who united the Welsh lords in an uneasy peace. The lives of highborn English, Welsh and French families intersect and painfully collide through complex ties of royal kinship: Montfort's wife, Nell is sister to King Henry III, one of England's most incompetent monarchs. Hot-tempered, high principled and "the most celebrated soldier in Christendom," Montfort enters into bitter conflict with his brother-in-law, becoming leader of the barons who oppose Henry's irresponsible leadership. Henry is forced to accept the Oxford Provisions that limit his power and affirm the rights of English citizens, but after two decades of intrigue, internecine conflict, shifting alliances and full-fledged civil war, Henry's son Edward Plantagenet prevails in the bloody battle of Evesham. Penman brilliantly evokes the medieval world with its deeply ingrained religious convictions that made men believe themselves directly favored or abandoned by God, a mental construct hard to reconcile with "the seductive allure of a chivalric brotherhood based on the sword." As usual, she illuminates the events of individual lives as well as the political and cultural forces that characterized this tumultuous era, in a thoroughly engrossing book. 75,000 first printing; $100,000 ad/promo. Copyright 1988 Reed Business Information, Inc. --This text refers to an alternate kindle_edition edition. From Library Journal For her third historical novel, Penman focuses on the mid-13th-century reign of England's Henry III and stories of those who opposed that inept king. A main detractor is French-born Simon de Montfort, Earl of Leicester, who leads the fight for parliamentary restrictions on the monarch, and later becomes Henry's brother-in-law through marriage to Eleanor, Countess of Pembroke. She emerges as a major figure, as does a distant relative by marriage, Llewelyn ap Gruffydd, who fights for supremacy in Wales. A promised genealogy should sort out the family relationships as well as the Welsh names. Penman's authentic historical treatment and characterizations capture the imagination and leave the characters well poised for an intended sequel. Recommended. Ellen Kaye Stoppel, Drake Univ. Law Lib., Des MoinesCopyright 1988 Reed Business Information, Inc. --This text refers to an alternate kindle_edition edition. “A marvelous literary and historical achievement…. Impossible to put down.” --- Boston Herald “Absorbing. . . . [Penman] manages to illuminate the alien shadowland of the Middle Ages and populate it with vital characters whose politics and passions are as vivid as our own.” --- San Francisco Chronicle “A remarkably detailed look at how people lived in medieval England and Wales. . . .Worth reading.” --- The Plain Dealer (Cleveland) “A vivid portrait of a lost time . . . full of fascinating personality studies . . . Once you enter her world you’re hooked.” --- Seattle Post-Intelligencer --This text refers to an alternate kindle_edition edition. From the Inside Flap "A marvelous literary and historical achievement...Impossible to put down."THE BOSTON HERALDThis is Simon de Montfort's story--and the story of King Henry III, as weak and changeable as Montfort was brash and unbending. It is a saga of two opposing wills that would later clash in a storm of violence and betrayal, a story straight from the pages of history that brings the world of the thirteenth century comletely, provocatively, and magnificently alive. Above all, this is a story of conflict and treachery, of human frailty and broken legends, a tale of pageantry and grandeur that is as unforgettable as it is real.... --This text refers to an alternate kindle_edition edition. From the Publisher As a publisher I have been lucky to be able to visit bookstores all over the country, independent and chain alike. What interests me first about these stores is what titles are being displayed in the 'Staff Recommends' section of the store. It is here that you can find treasured, beloved books quite dear to someone who works in the stores, someone waiting quite eagerly for the chance to hand sell their recommended titles. It is in these Staff Recommend sections that I kept on seeing our Penman's titles, HERE BE DRAGONS, FALLS THE SHADOW, THE RECKONING and also SUNNE IN SPLENDOUR and WHEN CHRIST AND HIS SAINTS SLEPT.It's funny, you can sell something for years before you notice that the author has been quietly making a powerful impact on people everywhere. I started with HERE BE DRAGONS and I have never looked back. Her trilogy of the decline of the Welsh kings ( DRAGON, FALLS THE SHADOW and THE RECKONING)is a holiday gift I give year after year, and I'm happy to say they have always been embraced and loved. From my 15 year old niece to my 70 year old mother and many ages in between, all readers are enchanted and transported to a land and an age gone forever. But Penman makes them live forever in our minds and hearts with fantastic, unforgettable characters and wonderful history. HERE BE DRAGONS is such a great title--medieval mapmakes would write those words across any part of the map that was unknown.. a wonderful metaphor for how little the Welsh and English knew of each other. SUNNE IN SPLENDOUR--Warning: This is not Shakespeare's Richard III. In this novel, Richard is a victim of circumstance and man vilified by the Tudors, but here presented as a decent and normal man, a man of conscience.AND he is not a murderer. Yes, those princes did die, but not by Richard's hand. WHEN CHRIST AND HIS SAINTS SLEPT Another wonderful title, for it refers to the 15 years of England's darkest time-the civil war between the cousins Queen Maud and King Steven. England was deserted, for Christ and his saints were sleeping. I had never even heard of these royals. Queen Maud was the legitimate heir to the throne, but a woman, and there fore not fit to rule. She is also the mother of Henry, who later married Eleanor of Aquitaine . Pretty heady stuff, more incredible men and women, another book to get totally lost in. Although it has been years since all these books were first published, I can name 5 stores I have been in in the past 3 months that have one of these titles in the Staff Recommends section.-Alice Kesterson, Ballantine Regional Sales Manger --This text refers to an alternate kindle_edition edition. Sharon Kay Penman is the author of six critically acclaimed historical novels and four medieval mysteries, one of which was a finalist for an Edgar Award for Best First Mystery from the Mystery Writers of America. --This text refers to an out of print or unavailable edition of this title. Read more

Features & Highlights

  • Simon de Montfort was a man ahead of his time in the thirteenth century, a disinherited Frenchman who talked his way into an English earldom and marriage with a sister of the English king, Henry III. A charismatic, obstinate leader, Simon soon lost patience with the king's incompetence and inability to keep his word, and found himself the champion of the common people.This is his story, and the story of Henry III, as weak and changeable as Simon was brash and unbending. It is a tale of opposing wills that would eventually clash in a storm of violence and betrayal—an irresistible saga that brings the pages of history completely, provocatively, and magnificently alive.

Customer Reviews

Rating Breakdown

★★★★★
60%
(977)
★★★★
25%
(407)
★★★
15%
(244)
★★
7%
(114)
-7%
(-113)

Most Helpful Reviews

✓ Verified Purchase

History Brought to Life.

Every time I read one of Sharon Kay Penman’s novels I’m awed by her writing. I’d give my soul if I could write historical fiction the way she does.
Falls the Shadow is the second book of her Welsh Princes Trilogy and continues the story where Here Be Dragons leaves off. Llewellyn Ap Iorwerth dies and leaves his domain to Davydd, his son by Joanna, the illegitimate daughter of England’s King John. Davydd’s reign is relatively short and the struggle for dominance of Gwynnyd falls to the sons of Llewellyn’s elder, but illegitimate son Gruffydd. Llewellyn favored his grandson and namesake Llelo, and has managed to impart to him both his military aptitude and his understanding of the need for Wales to be united against the constantly encroaching English.
The book, however soon diverges to tell the story of Simon de Montfort and his family. King Henry III’s sister, Nell, widowed at a young age, forsakes her vow of chastity to marry de Montfort, much against her brother’s wishes. The relationship between the monarch and his brother-in-law is intermittently stormy and at one point he is exiled from England.
Henry III proves a devastatingly inept monarch, both militarily and politically, and, although Simon de Montfort has sworn fealty to him, he eventually becomes the leader of a rebellion by the English barons. They attempt to impose a set of provisions on Henry which were a logical extension of the Magna Carta. The King, however, is convinced that he answers only to God and will brook no interference.
Penman astutely illustrates how a mischance or a happenstance can dramatically alter the course of history. What if Simon de Montfort’s eldest son, Harry, had not been so trusting? What if his second son Bran had been more trustworthy and competent? The course of English history might have been entirely different.
Penman paints a vivid picture of England and Wales in the 13th century. She relates the tragic plight of the Jews of that era who were the lowest and most vulnerable residents in the realm. One of the most remarkable characters in her story is Thomas Fitz Thomas, the mayor of London, a staunch supporter of Simon de Montfort, who tries to protect the Jews of his city.
Prior to reading this book I knew absolutely nothing about Simon de Montfort and his noble struggle. One of the reasons I love reading Sharon Kay Penman’s books is that she fills in glaring gaps in my knowledge of English history. At the same time, she is a masterful story teller.
11 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

I love the way the author completes each character

This is the kind of book that has made me a fan of historical fiction. The characters are rich and complete, the amount of dedication it takes to write a book of this period, with the twist and turns of fate, and the hearts of English kings, barons and lords, flat amazes me!
I don't often get so involved with a character in a book that I shed tears when that character dies on the pages. And I've cried several times reading this series. I love the way the author completes each character, showing the good side, as well as the bad, she has no favorites, but then neither does fate. From Llewelyn and Joanna, to Simon and Nell, I feel like I was there, in the cleaner world of the 12 century, the birds, the sky, the rivers, and mountains, all so crisp and clear.
Every time I finish a book, I am reluctant to start another, for fear that because favorite characters have passed from the story, I will have a hard time starting the next one, but the transitions are smooth and easy to slip into.
8 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

This is one of the best historical fiction books that I have ever read

I would give this novel 10 stars if I could. This is one of the best historical fiction books that I have ever read. I did not know of Simon de Montford and I am glad that I took a chance on this novel and found out who he was and his legacy which was a beginning of representative government in England. I found that the characters were complex and well defined as well as the extraordinary situations they were involved in. This is an emotionally wrenching read at times, but well worth it.
5 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Simon who?

This powerful second book is a close second to Here Be Dragons. As in the first book, readers will follow an historical figure on a minefield of life and death decisions both wise and not. History is the ultimate challenge for an author. How to engage the reader whilst maintaining accuracy, and without adding personal bias, is an art few can achieve but this novel manages to do so while taking the reader on a tremendous journey.

If historical fiction is a genre you enjoy, this series should well be at the top of your list.
3 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Beautiful, sweeping, heart-wrenching.

Beautiful, sweeping, heart-wrenching. Ms. Penman has commented on her love for writing about people who lived unlikely lives and the Welsh Princes trilogy brings this to life with color, depth, great clarity and attention to historical detail. This trilogy has easily become one of my favorite sets of books of all time and completely changed my opinion on historical fiction novels. I found Ms. Penman's devotion to accuracy the most compelling aspect of her work. At the heart of this trilogy is the epic struggle of Middle Ages Wales to have an independence from the English Crown, a dream never realized. During the 12th and 13th centuries this dream was kindled to legendary proportions in the great Welsh princes Llewelyn the Great and his grandson Llewelyn the Last taking the dream to heights never before thought possible, and since has never been renewed. Generally I read mostly non-fiction and have found few novels that really hold my attention and even fewer that I am eager to reread, yet I read 'Here Be Dragons' and promptly started it over again. 'Here Be Dragons' is easily my favorite of the three books, so compelling is the reign of King John and the long shadow he cast over the love story of Joanna and Llewelyn Fawr. The chronicles of history are full of men and women who lived unlikely lives, and Ms. Penman has done a masterful job of bringing to life the highborn men and women of Middle Ages Wales and England.
3 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Welsh nobility, Henry III, and Simon de Monfort---great book!

I purchased this book because I was looking for some information on the reign of Henry III---but I got so much more than that. I learned about Welsh nobility, and about Simon de Monfort, who I learned was the father of representative government. At first, I thought the dialogue seemed somewhat contrived---I almost felt that I was watching one of the early talking movies, with over the top acting. But as I continued to read, the characters came alive before me. By the end of the book, I was mourning the death of Simon along with the personalities in the book.
I am currently reading the next book, and it is meeting my expectations, as a very high bar was set in book 2.
2 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

The writing must have been good, I rarely stopped reading

The trilogy covers a period of history of little interest except
to Welsh- o -phobics. I recently became one after suffering through
the hopeless struggles of the Scots in the "Outlander" series. Both groups
of people suffered greatly under the beginnings of England's empire
building. The fiction part kept the historical part well connected. The Scots
had the Colonies to escape to. The Welsh were murdered off by King
Edward. Kings and Queens nor longer seem romantic to me. The
writing must have been good, I rarely stopped reading, except to reach for
kleenex. I so badly wanted to change history.
2 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

finally finished

took me an inordinately long time to get through this book. Not a book that i couldn't put down...sometimes for months. Not as satisfying as Here Be Dragons, for me. I would read more of this author's books, though.
2 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Good Men don't Prevail

May contain Spoilers. So don't read, until you have finished the book. What an interesting book about such a significant person in the mid 1200's about whom I had never known anything. Simon De Montfort, a saint in his time and memorialized as the father of the English Parliment system after his time. Worshippers attended his grave site for hundreds of years after his terrible death. His life was marked by courage and principle. He dared to oppose a weak and destructive English King, Henry III. Extending democracy in his Provisions restricting the King to trades people, knights, and city mayors was indeed revolutionary. De Montfort tried to lesson the effect of just having the "blood ruling class, born and bred" and let more of the common folk have a say in their own lives. Truly a George Washington of his time. A wonderful love story between Simon and his wife Nell, the king's sister. I knew how things were going to turn out, knowing that Henry's cruel son Edward Longshanks of Braveheart fame would ultimately triumph, made this a tear jerker for me. It is so sad when good men don't prevail.
2 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Highly recommend.

I am truly enjoying learning about England and Wales' history. Penman has brought history to life with her fictional narrative. Highly recommend.
1 people found this helpful