From Bookmarks Magazine The Charles Todd team is an old pro at the police procedural, and the pair continues to add layers to the damaged Ian Rutledge, a character whose PTSD keeps these books especially relevant and compelling. The series has been compared favorably to the Golden Age crime fiction of Margery Allingham and Ngaio Marsh, among others, as well as Pat Barker’s Regeneration trilogy, perhaps the finest contemporary fiction to center on World War I and its consequences. The Rutledge series shows no signs of becoming stale. New readers can jump right in, while those already a dozen books deep in Rutledge’s struggle for redemption and justice will find new aspects of the novels to keep them reading. From Booklist The ever-popular Inspector Rutledge of Scotland Yard returns in this compelling mystery. In 1920, a trio of murders brings Rutledge to a village in Sussex, armed with questions. Why were these men, survivors of the Great War, killed in the same vicious manner? What’s the meaning of the similar objects found inside the dead men’s mouths? When a fourth man is murdered soon after Rutledge arrives in town, the inspector realizes he has only a short time in which to solve these crimes and precious little to go on. Aided, as usual, by his ethereal partner, the spirit of a soldier for whose WWI death Rutledge feels responsible, the inspector pieces together the clues and slowly makes his way toward a solution. As always, the authors (“Charles Todd” is a pseudonym for a mother-son writing team) create a solid sense of time and place, and Inspector Rutledge remains a multifaceted hero, resourceful, engaging, and self-tortured. Another engaging entry in a fine series. --David Pitt “Masterly.” — New York Times Book Review on A Lonely Death “Todd once and for all establishes the shell-shocked Rutledge as the genre’s most complex and fascinating detective.” — Entertainment Weekly, on A LONELY DEATH (Grade: A-) “[The authors’] subtle prose and profound empathy for all their characters enhance a suspenseful and twisty plot.” — Publishers Weekly on A Lonely Death “Another engaging entry in a fine series.” — Booklist on A Lonely Death “Todd’s intriguing revenge tale will keep the reader turning the pages, but the main draw remains Rutledge, the relentless inspector haunted by the voice of a Scotsman he executed on the battlefield for disobeying an order. Highly recommended for all aficionados of British postwar historical mysteries.” — Library Journal on A Lonely Death “Eloquently blasts war for the obscenity it is.” — Kirkus Reviews on A Lonely Death “Todd’s attention to period detail, plotting and character exploration are at the forefront of the 13th Ian Rutledge Mystery….Todd and his hero are in fine form from start to finish.” — Romantic Times on A Lonely Death (4 ½ stars; Top Pick) “A strong entry in a strong series.” — Charlotte Observer on A Lonely Death “Suspense filled.” — Oklahoman on A Lonely Death “Todd invests this absorbing fiction with creative storytelling (including intriguing subplots), memorable characters and graceful, seemingly effortless prose….This is fiction that moves, entertains, and as always, underscores life’s victories over death.” — Richmond Times-Dispatch on A Lonely Death “Compelling…a provocative thriller.” — Iron Mountain Daily News on A Lonely Death “Fully realized characters, well-researched settings, and exquisite writing combine with a surprising and chilling solution to mark this 13th outing as a standout in Todd’s deservedly award-winning series.” — Mystery Scene on A Lonely Death Scotland Yard detective Ian Rutledge returns to solve his most exciting and shocking case yet in this latest entry in the bestselling series hailed as "outstanding" by the New York Times Book Review A breathtaking blend of psychological complexity, haunting atmosphere, compelling twists, and impressive detail, the novels in the Ian Rutledge mystery series have garnered their author widespread acclaim and numerous honors and awards. At the heart of the series is the compelling Scotland Yard detective inspector Ian Rutledge, a veteran of the Great War who understands all too well the darkness that lies within men's souls. Now three men have been murdered in a Sussex village, and Scotland Yard has been called in. It's a baffling case. The victims are soldiers who survived the horrors of World War I only to meet a ghastly end in the quiet English countryside two years later. Each had been garroted, with small ID discs left in their mouths. But even Scotland Yard's presence doesn't deter this vicious and clever killer. Shortly after Inspector Ian Rutledge arrives, a fourth soldier is found dead. With few clues to go on and the pressure building, Rutledge must gamble everything—his job, his reputation, and even his life—to find answers. Charles Todd is the New York Times bestselling author of the Inspector Ian Rutledge mysteries, the Bess Crawford mysteries, and two stand-alone novels. A mother-and-son writing team, Caroline passed away in August 2021 and Charles lives in Florida. Read more
Features & Highlights
“Todd’s Ian Rutledge mysteries are among the most intelligent and affecting being written these days.”—
Washington Post
Critics have called Charles Todd’s historical mystery series featuring shell-shocked World War One veteran Inspector Ian Rutledge “remarkable” (
New York Times Book Review
), “heart-breaking” (
Chicago Tribune
), “fresh and original” (
South Florida Sun-Sentinel
). In
A Lonely Death
, the haunted investigator is back in action, trying to solve the murders of three ex-soldiers in a small English village. A true master of evocative and atmospheric British crime fiction, Charles Todd reaches breathtaking new heights with
A Lonely Death
—a thrilling tale of the darkness in men’s souls that will have fans of
Elizabeth George
,
Martha Grimes
, and
Anne Perry
cheering.
Customer Reviews
Rating Breakdown
★★★★★
60%
(771)
★★★★
25%
(321)
★★★
15%
(193)
★★
7%
(90)
★
-7%
(-90)
Most Helpful Reviews
★★★★★
4.0
AH4PHUQB5OQ4ALDY7RQV...
✓ Verified Purchase
A big improvement on recent Rutledge offerings
In this, the 13th in the series of mystery novels featuring Scotland Yard inspector Ian Rutledge, the mother/son writing duo who make up author Charles Todd are in better form than they have been in the last two or three books in the series - and the Rutledge series is much more compelling than the new one, featuring nurse Bess Crawford, from the same writing team.
It is still 1920, and Rutledge is still struggling to do his job while battling with the after-effects of shell shock, a legacy of the trenches of the Western front in World War 1. He is still haunted by the specter of Hamish, his friend and sergeant whom he had to put in front of a firing squad for refusing to carry out orders; now Hamish's voice rings in his head and he is almost a physical presence to Rutledge, one that those around him in the "real" world can't see. Rutledge must solve crimes while not being driven around the bend by Hamish's comments and reproaches, on everything from the past to the present, and not disclosing his mental condition to his superiors or even to the woman he is coming to love. In Rutledge and Hamish, "Charles Todd" has created two great characters of detective fiction.
But Rutledge isn't the only one haunted by the past, as becomes clear in this book. One of his friends is unable to cope and kills himself; his former superior is still brooding over an unsolved crime dating back 15 years, the woman Rutledge is drawn to proves to have her own secrets in the past, while a series of murders of men from the same small Sussex town may have something to do with their wartime service. Or do the roots go further back, to a different kind of trauma? This is the main plot, and it's very suspenseful and successful; in the lead up to the climactic confrontation between Rutledge and the murderer, I actually found myself holding my breath several times while I turned the pages. Some of the secondary plot twists, particularly the 1905 "cold case" are deeply implausible, but work to shed a bit more light on Rutledge as a character.
If you've been following the Rutledge series but had found some of the recent books less compelling than the first, try this one. True, it's not as good as the first three or four in the series, but then few series manage to stay fresh this long anyway. Happily, Rutledge and Hamish are so unusual and the setting of the immediate aftermath of World War One so vividly portrayed that even a later book in this series is still better than a lot of other mystery novels out there -- including the other "Charles Todd" series, which feels more perfunctory, with a lot of dashing from point A to point B in motorcars. If you haven't been reading the series, however, this book isn't the place to start; go back to square one and read the debut, [[ASIN:0061242845 A Test of Wills (Inspector Ian Rutledge Mysteries)]].
25 people found this helpful
★★★★★
5.0
AFADQ3GJQPKCW6U6XXZ2...
✓ Verified Purchase
Quiet, enjoyable historical mystery, post-World War I
I had adored Charles Todd's [[ASIN:0061791784 An Impartial Witness]], so when Amazon Vine gave me the opportunity to read a pre-release copy of his latest mystery, I jumped at the chance. I'm so very glad I did.
A Lonely Death is far from the first in the series about Scotland Yard detective Ian Rutledge, who survived World War I and is still trying to come to terms with its impact on his life. But I can assure you that you don't need to read the earlier books in the series; it stood alone just fine.
Like An Impartial Witness (which is focused on a totally different character), the events in this novel take place soon after World War I -- in July 1920, specifically. Inspector Rutledge is called to a small town near Hastings after three ex-soldiers are killed. Each man was garroted, and left with an identity disk (the precursor to "dog tags") in their mouths. But it's someone *else's* identity disk. Rutledge must find the murderer before someone else dies...
As in An Impartial Witness, Todd's writing style is quiet. His characters spend a lot of time talking, and as a reader you mostly follow along as Rutledge asks people for information. You figure out Whodunnit along with the protagonist rather than spot a gun sitting on the table and wanting to shout, "LOOK ON THE TABLE! THERE'S A GUN!" This isn't an exciting book that will make your heart beat faster. But it absolutely made me turn pages wanting to know what would happen next, and I always found myself reading, "Just one more chapter..." before going to bed. Okay, maybe three more chapters. Or five.
Todd paints wonderfully visual word-pictures that draw you into the protagonist's world in small ways. "Iris Lane was just that, a short track edged its entire length with beds of iris, the broad green swords of their leaves unmistakable, although there were no blooms now. Old Well House was a pretty cottage, windows open wide to the morning air and a line of wash already hung out at the side of the kitchen garden." You feel as though you're breathing the summer air, as though you can almost smell the laundry soap.
This is an excellent and enjoyable mystery, meant for a solitary evening sitting by the fireside with a mug of tea. I heartily recommend it.
7 people found this helpful
★★★★★
3.0
AEQT2UUZNZIKIYQJ2A2L...
✓ Verified Purchase
Something Went Clunk
This is the first Inspector Rutledge book I've read that's left me dissatisfied. Even though some of the books by the writing team known as Charles Todd have been better than others,I've always felt that their worst Inspector Rutledge books have still been a good read. The books were well written with meticulous plotting and main characters who behaved consistently, dealing with the darkness in such a way that it allowed the reader that suspension of belief necessary to enjoy this kind of novel. However, in "A Lonely Death" the two authors were not being honest with their readers.
The problem wasn't Rutledge's juggling several different mysteries at once or all the traveling that entailed. The difficulty lay in what happened after he went across the Channel. The scene with Meredith Channing was so jarring, so out of place, and felt so untrue that even this die hard fan found it hard to accept it as anything other than a way to keep the pathos going in future books. I could feel the machinery creaking behind the scenes and something went clunk. The saddest thing of all was that it was so unnecessary. His is a life of inner torment and Rutledge has a long way to go before he can allow anyone to come that close to him. It would have been more interesting to see how he dealt with that particular problem.
Still, I'll keep reading the books, if only to see what happens next.
6 people found this helpful
★★★★★
3.0
AGSKM6R3LGSHR45N6ZVP...
✓ Verified Purchase
Just not my cup of tea
There is something very flat about this book. I can't get excited over any part of it and got rather tired of traveling from town to town in Inspector Rutledge's motor car and reading bout him getting in and out of the car in and out of a pub in and out of a restaurant in and out of a house, going up the stairs and then down.
Inspector Ian Rutledge is not a Sherlock Holmes or Peter Wimsey or Thomas Lynley or Hercule Poirot in that his character never seems to quite gel for me, at least, and as a personality isn't that interesting. If Poirot or Holmes could come to life and walk down the street you'd recognize them instantly. Rutledge is tall and I guess handsome, but so are millions of other men.
The year is 1920 with England struggling to gain normalcy after the Great War, and the shell-shocked Inspector Rutledge is in southern England in Eastfield near Hastings where three men have been garrotted with a wire. They are all veterans and were school mates when boys. Hamish, the Scottish voice in Rutledge's head, perhaps his alter ego, thinks the motive for the murders is revenge but the circumstances are unusual and bizarre.
"Lonely Death"opens with the murder of a man in Stonehenge on Midsummers night eve while Druids were dancing about. The man was found dead on the Sacrificial stone, an appropriate place, perhaps. This death had occurred in 1905 and Chief Inspector Cummins, who handled the case, had never solved it. Cummins is retiring from the force. He tells Rutledge about the Stonehenge death. Rutledge takes over this cold case, but the Stonehenge murder is really a secondary plot which does not belong in "Lonely Death" and the coincidences between the old murder and the new ones and how Rutledge ties them together in the same parcel are ludicrous.
While Rutledge weaves together very disparate pieces, the reader is left with many loose ends, including the suicide of Rutledge's close friend (why?) and a love affair apparently gone sour. But I suppose my main issue with the book is that it did not engage my emotions and barely held my interest.
6 people found this helpful
★★★★★
5.0
AEYGPUCRKH7G4VM22FM3...
✓ Verified Purchase
Superb "Inspector Rutledge" Mystery, Set in Post-WWI Sussex
One of the best "Inspector Ian Rutledge" mysteries yet! Charles Todd (actually a mother-son team) is a gifted mystery writer--a writer who crafts lean, polished prose, and who devises plots with intricate twists and turnings that always seem perfectly plausible to readers as they unfold. The Rutledge series is in itself a tour de force, as in each new offering Todd skillfully sustains Rutledge's established character--as a shell-shocked WWI survivor, barely holding on to his job as a Scotland Yard detective, whose mind is nearly split in two by survivor's guilt. Wherever Rutledge goes, he cannot escape hearing the soft voice of the good soldier, Hamish MacLeod, whose death by firing squad was ordered by Rutledge himself.
In A LONELY DEATH, Rutledge has two cases to solve: (1) a 1905 cold case involving the body of a young man found strapped to an altar stone at Stonehenge on the Salisbury plain; and (2) a 1920 present-day case involving a serial killer who is stalking ordinary Sussex citizens, garroting them, and placing fiberboard WWI identity discs in their mouths as his signature. In the midst of his 1920-case investigation, Rutledge is removed from the case, after a local citizen files a complaint about his conduct with his hated Scotland Yard supervisor Bowles. When Rutledge's replacement Mickelson is nearly murdered, Rutledge is briefly suspected of the crime, and suffers a terrifying incarceration that threatens to completely destroy him. As the investigation stalls, yet another Sussex citizen falls victim to the killer.
Regular readers of the Rutledge series won't want to miss the details of (1) Chief Inspector Cummins' retirement; (2) Rutledge's return to France and the site of Hamish's death; (3) Rutledge's renewed relationship with Meredith Channing; and (4) the possible discovery of Channing's MIA husband. The book also explores the problems faced by other WWI-damaged veterans who are Rutledge's friends; and it includes the usual realistic post-WWI settings made possible by author Todd's extensive historical knowledge of the period.
I thoroughly enjoyed reading A LONELY DEATH, and highly recommend the "Inspector Rutledge" series. Readers who are not already acquainted with Inspector Rutledge and Hamish may want to start with the first book, [[ASIN:0061242845 A Test of Wills (Inspector Ian Rutledge Mysteries)]]. However, the Inspector Rutledge mysteries all work as standalones, and do not have to be read in sequence to be fully appreciated.
5 people found this helpful
★★★★★
5.0
AEO46SAV7XNHTR2QHVHG...
✓ Verified Purchase
Charles Todd continues to thrill
The mother-son team that is Charles Todd continues their saga of post WWI Scotland Yard detective, Ian Rutledge, in A Lonely Death. As always, the mystery is tight and the characters compelling, but I find the best thing about this series is the insight into the minds and lives of those "lucky" men who survived the trench warfare of the"War to End All Wars". While trying to solve a series of grisly murders in the English countryside, Rutledge struggles, as always, with his own highly personal demons. The novel stands alone as a good read in the genre, but is even more significant to those of us who have followed Rutledge's struggles through the previous books in the series. If you have not already been introduced to this series, I strongly suggest you give it a try, especially if you enjoy Jacqueline Winspear and Anne Perry.
5 people found this helpful
★★★★★
4.0
AGGC3TGZRO54WRL3EHYA...
✓ Verified Purchase
Entertaining with a great villain
The writing of this book immediately sucked me in with its compelling prose and engaging style. I literally could not put the book down. The mystery is clever with lots of twists and turns, and the main character is three dimensional, not too perfect or too wounded/angsty. His internal struggles make him very sympathetic and I really enjoyed reading about him.
I realize this is one of a long series of books about the main character, but I was a bit disappointed at what I felt was only a small internal character arc. While I like the main character a lot, the fact he does not change much internally made the book, especially the ending, fall a little flat for me. I always more enjoy stories where the character has more of an internal arc. Because I know this is a personal preference, I haven't docked any stars from my rating because I know other readers might not care as much about the main character's internal arc.
However, I have docked a star--or more like half a star--because I felt that the last three pages of the book was just too coincidental for me to swallow. I will not say more, but readers will understand what I'm talking about. The ending was very surprising and an interesting twist, but a little too coincidental for my tastes.
That being said, the story itself is excellent. The villain is clever, more than equal to the main character, which made for a very entertaining and exciting book. The 1920s setting was fascinating and richly detailed--I loved it. The writing is gripping and the characters all uniquely drawn. This is an extremely talented writing team and I would definitely recommend this book to any mystery lover.
3 people found this helpful
★★★★★
5.0
AHE7X3NM27ZWFTTCDCMM...
✓ Verified Purchase
Rutledge and England still coping with the aftermath of WWI...
I was really pleased with this new book by the duo who write these books because the last few books by them have not been up to their usual standards. This one was much better. Their writing is usually much better than most of this genre, better language, better plots, better characterization. But as with many long running novels with the same characters in them, it becomes hard to keep coming up with good ideas or to keep the characters fresh. This time the book read like the first Todd books. When I read them, it is easy to bring up my memories of England and pictures of the time period, along with the darkness which must have existed in the minds of so many men coming back from a war that should never have been fought.
Ian Rutledge is once again sent to find a murderer who seems to have problems of his own left over from the war. At least, that is what the clues left behind lead them to believe. The men being murdered are all from the same army unit, and from the same village in England, if not from the same class. Rutledge has to deal not only with the murder, but the loss of a friend from suicide, and then his superior pulls another stunt on Rutledge politically to get him disqualified for a higher position that another friend had recommended him for. Rutledge of course, has to deal with his own problems left from the war, with Hamish his constant companion. Sometimes, the weight of his work and his memories from the war cause him to question his life.
This is a good mystery to settle down with for summer reading. It is well-written, and is intelligent. Just very enjoyable reading.
3 people found this helpful
★★★★★
4.0
AEDFALLGDP4XSVJOGKCD...
✓ Verified Purchase
Very good mystery novel
This was my first Ian Rutledge book. It was a very intricate mystery...good characters and storyline. There were also a couple of stories going one....Rutledge's personal life, the main mystery and a little side mystery. It actually reminded me of some of Sharon McCrumb's novels like "Missing Susan." I did get a little confused at times because there were so many different minor characters....hard to keep all the players straight at times.
Usually I don't mind starting a series mid book, but this one was difficult. There is so much backstory to Rutledge...Hammish, Meredith, his career with the police, that I knew I was missing some key things. I think I would actually recommend starting at the beginning of the series. I intend to go back and try to the first book.
This is an intricate novel that is best read slowly. Usually I devour mysteries in an evening, but this one of read over several days. There is a lot to digest and it doesn't really flow, even though it is a good book. I guess it was not a page turner for me....I got tired after reading it for a bit.
3 people found this helpful
★★★★★
2.0
AEVOZDLKYJHXXROIPZ3B...
✓ Verified Purchase
Very thick - a 1920 English murder mystery
I was much more excited about the prospect of this book than the reading experience it turned out to be. It was kind of slow and was easy to put down.
The characters are complex and intelligent, but I just wasn't that interested in them. It was hard to make an emotional connection to them.
The story is set in England in 1920. Rutledge, the main character, is a Scotland Yard detective who fought in World War I. He constantly hears - in his head - the voice of a deceased comrade, for whose death he feels responsible. This emphasizes the weight of his guilty feelings and is a clever storytelling device, but I found the whole thing really creepy. It made Rutledge seem like an unhinged schizophrenic. Integral to the story, though, was showing how unhinged all the veterans of the war actually were.
The gloomy settings and the characters seem authentic. The murder mystery is clever and original. However, I didn't like this one. It just wasn't fun to read.