A Knot in the Grain and Other Stories
A Knot in the Grain and Other Stories book cover

A Knot in the Grain and Other Stories

Paperback – January 1, 1995

Price
$7.61
Format
Paperback
Pages
192
Publisher
Trophy Pr
Publication Date
ISBN-13
978-0064406048
Dimensions
5.5 x 0.75 x 7.75 inches
Weight
4.8 ounces

Description

"Mckinley haas an apparently effortlessly style, fresh, original ideas, a romantic outlook and an ability to evoke wonder and belief." -- --- The Horn Book Robin McKinley won the 1985 Newbery Medal for her book The Hero and the Crown , and a 1983 Newbery Honor for The Blue Sword, both set in mythical Damar.She is also the author of Beauty, a retelling of Beauty and the Beast.She lives in England.In Her Own Words... "I was an only child and my father was in the Navy. We moved every year or twox97California, Japan, upstate New York, New England. I early found the world of books much more satisfactory than the unstable so-called real world. I canx92t remember the first time I read Frances Hodgson Burnettx92s but this particular story, about a little girl all alone in a strange land who told stories so wonderful that she believed them herself, fasci-nated me. I never quite lived up to Sara Crewex92s standard, but I tried awfully hard. "Writing has always been the other side of reading for me; it never occurred to me not to make up stories. Once I got old enough to realize that authorship existed as a thing one might aspire to, I knew it was for me. I even majored in English literature in college, a good indication of my fine bold disdain for anything so trivial as earning a living; I was going to be a writer, like Dickens and Hardy and George Eliot. And Kipling and H. Rider Haggard and J.R.R. Tolkien. I was, however, going to tell breathtaking stories about girls who had adventures. I was tired of the boys always getting the best parts in the best books. What with reading and making up my own stories, I spent most of my life in my head; about the only irresistible attraction reality had for me was in the shape of horses and riding. And I liked traveling. Perhaps because of my childhood, staying in one place for very long just seemed to me like a waste of opportunity. "Itx92s funny, though, the things life does to you. Inadvertently I discovered myself settling down, looking for excuses not to climb on another airplane. I bought a house because I fell in love with it, and it was somewhere to leave the thousands of books I picked up everywhere I went. Later, I decided that I wanted something around that didnx92t necessarily sit politely on a shelf till I took it down, so I bought a dog, a whippet I named Rowan. Insidiously I began liking it that tomorrow was going to be much like yesterday: walking the dog, sitting at the typewriter. I declared myself to have found home in my tiny house in a small village two-thirds of the way up the coast of Maine. I also, a little ruefully, concluded that my individual mix of the writerx92s traditional absent-mindedness, a rather uncompromising feminism, and a naturally intransigent personality made marriage or any sort of permanent romantic attachment impractical. I didnx92t actually think I was missing much; I liked being single. "This no doubt explainsx97somehowx97why I am now living in a small village in a very large house in Hampshire, England, with my husband, the English writer Peter Dickinson, three whippets, and a horse, and what seems to me, the only child and ex-solitary adult, about half a million Dickinson grandchildren rioting underfoot, down the corridors, and across the garden. When Peter and I decided to get married, it was obvious to me I was the one who had to emigrate; I was the military brat with lifelong experience of pulling up and moving on. So I dug up my tender new under-standing of "home," packed it very carefully, and broughtit over here with me, with the eighty cartons of books and one bewildered whippet. It has taken root vigorously here, but the message to headquarters is very emphatic: "Donx92t you ever do this to us again." Ix92m not likely to: Ix92ve planted over four hundred rosebushes in what were once Peterx92s classic English garden bordersx97and look after them devotedly. I have the scars to prove it. I think Ix92ve discovered reality after all. Ix92m astonished at how interesting it is. Itx92s giving me more things to write stories about."

Features & Highlights

  • Lily. A woman with power to heal, but no powers of speech. Then she meets a mage---a man who can hear the words she forms only in her mind. Will he help her find her voice?
  • Ruen. A princess whose uncle leaves her deep in a cave to die at the hands of a stagman. But when she meets the stagman at last, Ruendiscovers fatehas a few surprises in store for her.
  • Erana, As a baby, she is taken be a witch in return for the healing herbs her father stole from the witch's garden. Raised alongsidethe witch's troll son, Erana learns that love comes in many forms.
  • Coral. A beautiful young newcomerwho catches the eye of an older widowed farmer. He can't believe his good fortune when Coral consents to be his wife. But then the doubts set in---what is it that draws Coral to Butter Hill?
  • Annabelle. When her family moves, the summer befre her junior year of High School, Annabelle spends all her time in the attic of their new house--until she finds the knot in the gain which leads her on a magical mission.

Customer Reviews

Rating Breakdown

★★★★★
60%
(331)
★★★★
25%
(138)
★★★
15%
(83)
★★
7%
(39)
-7%
(-39)

Most Helpful Reviews

✓ Verified Purchase

Little McKinley snacks

This is a short story collection containing five stories: The Healer, The Stagman, Touk's House, Buttercups, and A Knot in the Grain. The first four stories are set in McKinley's Damar universe, the first three even feature Luthe. The last is a departure for her because it is set in modern times and doesn't have a very large fantasy element.
The Healer, is the story of a girl named Lilly who has the power to heal but is also mute. She meets a mage who can hear her telepathically and they set off on a journey to restore Lilly's speech. This is a fairly strong story and a great pick to start the book with. The characters are fleshed out well and the love story was enjoyable.
The Stagman, is about a princess named Ruen who is left, by her greedy uncle, as a sacrifice to a human/stag hybrid. Is the Stagman really as bad as people think he is? This is probably my favorite story in the collection. I liked all the characters and the plot was very interesting. It would have worked much better as a novel though. By the time the story was over there were still far to many unanswered questions.
Touk's House, is the story of a girl named Erana who was raised by a witch. As she grows up, she befriends and eventually falls in love with the witch's troll son. This is a fairly decent story. The plot is really interesting but it would have been much better if the characters had been developed a bit more.
Buttercups, is the story of a old farmer named Pos who marries a young girl named Coral. Pos loves his wife very much but has doubts about her affection for him because she spends too much time on buttercup hill. This is a cute story but it's, unfortunately, very boring.
A Knot in the Grain, is about a teenage girl named Annabelle who is forced to move away and leave behind her entire life. She finds little comfort in her new house but one day she discovers a secret compartment in her new bedroom. It was a great idea to make this the last in the collection because the tone is very different from the others. It's not a love story and it's not even really a fantasy story. What makes this story special is how authentic Annabelle's character is. McKinley captures the emotion that goes along with moving to a new place very well.
I'd recommend this book to people who are already fans of McKinley's work. You don't really need to be familiar with the Damar series to enjoy the stories but it certainly helps. I also feel that McKinley is better suited to longer stories. If you are looking to get into McKinley's work it'd be a good idea to start with Beauty or one of the Damar books.
21 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

A Knot in the Book

As an ardent fan of McKinley's books, most especially her "A Door in the Hedge," I was eager to buy and read another collection of her original fairy tales. However, "A Knot in the Grain," although good to read, like eating thick honey for a week, lacked in subtle substinence.
"The Healer," the story of a mute girl who finds love in a telepathic ex-mage, began in a promising manner - using phrases like, "the creaky place that might once have been his heart," and so on - but ends strangely, with them returning to the village and some sense that a deeper meaning was intended but not, at least by me, realised.
"The Stagman," as others have noticed before me, was particularly head-scratch-worthy, dealing with a cruel Regent-uncle, the girl who should be Queen and does not know how, a prince who likes to hunt, and the elusive stagman who, apparently, the Queen leaves her kingdom, husband and four children for...what? Why? HOW?
"Touk's House" can be seen as an interesting 'take' on the Rapunzel legend, but ends with the message that kings are rotten and trolls (TROLLS! ) are lovable. Again, the ending is confusing, since the images cast upon us feel as though they ought to be wrought with great significance.
"Buttercups" is perhaps the best story, structurally, following the wedding of a farmer to a girl twenty years his junior, and their marital struggles.
The last story, from which the title of the book takes its name, is not quite as bad as the previous reviews had led me to believe. The story is a snippet of a modern girl's life, dealing not so much with the knot as with a magical wishing box she finds. However, it's only a snippet of her life and leaves several threads dangling.
All in all, fans of McKinley will probably want to buy this book if only for her voice and not as much for her pat plots. "A Knot in the Grain" is not a poor book, it merely isn't her best.
18 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Mixed bag of stories

This book is a short story collection of Middle Grade fantasy stories. I enjoyed Robin McKinley's novels set in Damar ("The Blue Sword" and "The Hero and the Crown") so I bought this book hoping to learn more about Damar. Two of the stories were set in Damar, but you won't know it from any other generic fantasy world if Luthe (a character from the novels) didn't briefly appear in them. We don't learn anything new about him, either.

Most of the stories follow the plot line of: a character has a problem, magic help comes along, the problem is fixed. The heroine generally doesn't have a difficult obstacle to overcome so much as a decision to make.

I felt like needed information was missing in some of the stories. The heroine in "The Stagman" was very passive, and the characters' weren't developed (or their motives really explained). "The Healer" was interesting and had a developed setting and characters, but I felt like too many things were left unresolved at the end. I've never really understood the magic part of "The Knot in the Grain."

"Buttercups" started well, but the conflict resolved too quickly and unrealistically easily, in my opinion. "Touk's House" was the best written of the five: it had some conflict as well as a good setting and character development. And it resolved everything at the end.

There was a minor amount of explicit bad language. There were no sex scenes. Overall, the stories were a mixed bag. Robin McKinley's fans might enjoy reading these stories, but I wouldn't recommend buying the book.
16 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

A Worthy Collection that Represents McKinley's Art

I was impressed by Robin McKinley's beautiful stories. I am more pleased by the beauty and composition of words along the way than the plots of these stories. Robin McKinley does create airy, ethereal settings in these tales, but as others have mentioned, they are left a little loose. What matters to me is why McKinley wrote these stories so; hopefully she intended to leave them with strings dangling and not because she "didn't want to write anymore"! I was fond of her retelling of Raphunzel (sp) and "Buttercups". I feel that those two stories were the most enchanting and fulfilling. I enjoy her tales because she can develop such a complex and beautiful plot without bringing in many characters or settings. The one place she chooses to write about seems to represent the whole world. I am now reading her earlier collection of short stories titled "The Door in the Hedge", which seems to be constructed more gracefully. "A Knot in the Grain" really does not deserve negative criticism; McKinley is a notable author who is allowed to experiment with different writing styles. Her "Beauty" is one of my favorite stories. She is able to travel deep into her character's minds and express things as no one else can. I admire her soft but powerful stories - stories that are neither weak or adventurous, ones that reveal just enough so the reader can understand. I think her style carries on into absolutely every piece she creates, and that is a priceless thing.
5 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Great reading but not enough!

I love "The Blue Sword" and "Hero and the Crown" so was very anxious to read anything and everything related to Damar that I could find, and this book fit the bill. My only complaint is that the stories are just snippits. Each story felt like it wanted to be it's own full-length book and I would have bougth every one of them!
4 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Lovely little book....

Robin is true to form, and weaves together a lovely collection of short stories. The settings vary. Some are set in traditional fantasy, while the last is a very modern tale. All feature Robin's excellent wry writing style. Nothing in here is going to blow anyone away, but then why would it? That's just not her style. Delightful read.
3 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Too short

Very interesting stories, but not enough of them. I request the author expand and write more.
2 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Good, but not up to standard

I've read most of Robing McKinley's books and one of the things I've noticed is a feeling of the story coming to an end with most problems resolved but still leaving enough for the reader to puzzle out. Perhaps this short story format doesn't give her a chance to shine as she usually does. This collection is a great start on four seperate paths for storylines (the fifth being too strange and nebulous), but most leave you wondering so... what next. The first is possibly the most complete, the second ends as if in the middle of the story, the third, not quite as expressive as McKinley usually tends to be, the fourth, mystically strange, and the fifth, the title story of the book, takes place in modern day New York, does not mix well with the others and is utterly undescribable and unformed. McKinley would have done better had she removed the last story and made the other four, (more typical of her work) a little more 'finished'.
2 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

4/5 were good

I liked all of the stories except for A Knot in the Grain. I think it was wonderful how she interwove 2/4 of the good stories (the Healer and the Stagman) they had intertwining characters that delighted me. Also, i like the fact that both those stories had characters that were connected to some of her other books like The Hero and the Crown, and The Blue Sword. All in all i thought that it was wonderful that she gave more backround and familiarity with characters from her other books. I thought that the REpunzal story was a different way to put things and to show that love comes in all forms and i loved the simplicity and purity of the story. Buttercups was a moving story that is well worthy of any praise and i loved it ( although not as much as the healer). A Knot in the Grain was a surprise however and somewhat dissapointing. It was too distant because it had no backround and wasnt connected to any other stories that i know of. She didn't let you know the characters like usual and the character wasn't strong enough that the distance would allow for it. But if any one wants to read a good story start with the hero and the crown and then move on to the Blue Sword :) they were the best of hers ive read so far (which isnt saying a lot :)
2 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Magical

Robin McKinley is one of my favorite authors, and this book did not fail to continue to impress me. A great addition to my collection.
1 people found this helpful