“Another winner....Todd again excels at vivid atmosphere and the effects of war in this specific time and place. Grade: A.”—
Cleveland Plain Dealer
“Readers who can’t get enough of Maisie Dobbs, the intrepid World War I battlefield nurse in Jacqueline Winspear’s novels…are bound to be caught up in the adventures of Bess Crawford.”—
New York Times Book Review
Charles Todd, author of the resoundingly acclaimed Ian Rutledge crime novels (“One of the best historical series being written today” —
Washington Post Book World
) debuts an exceptional new protagonist, World War I nurse Bess Crawford, in
A Duty to the Dead.
A gripping tale of perilous obligations and dark family secrets in the shadows of a nightmarish time of global conflict,
A Duty to the Dead
is rich in suspense, surprise, and the impeccable period atmosphere that has become a Charles Todd trademark.
Customer Reviews
Rating Breakdown
★★★★★
30%
(691)
★★★★
25%
(576)
★★★
15%
(345)
★★
7%
(161)
★
23%
(529)
Most Helpful Reviews
★★★★★
3.0
AHWH4MZ2KD5RASDETTSV...
✓ Verified Purchase
Dutiful, but Dead, Writing
"A Duty to the Dead," by New York Times bestselling author Charles Todd, presumably begins a new historical mystery series, starring Bess Crawford. So this will join Todd's popular, highly-thought of Inspector Ian Rutledge series, now at eleven books. (There is also one stand-alone.) Charles Todd sets "his" mysteries in Britain; "he" is, however, actually an American mother-son writing team. She lives in Delaware; he, in North Carolina.
It's 1916; independently minded Bess has been a nurse aboard the floating World War I hospital ship Britannic, sister ship to the famed Titanic of the watery North Atlantic end. She has agreed to verbally transmit a message from the dying, charming, Lieutenant Arthur Graham, for whom she feels more than she should, back to his upper-crust family back home in the U.K. The book is told in first person, from Bess's point of view, an interesting departure from the Rutledge books.
Unfortunately, this time out, the team's writing, while it does cover the appropriate ground, is flat, and they are unable to make their material come alive. They choose to open with a set piece, much as the infinitely greater British mystery author John LeCarre generally does: the well-known sinking of Britannic in Greek waters. However, LeCarre's set pieces can blow the socks off a reader, see [[ASIN:B00150B2SS Tinker, Tailor, Soldier, Spy]]; whereas the Todd team just can't make Britannic's sinking particularly vivid, and that's quite a failing. Perhaps actual World War I combat is a bit much for the Todd duo to handle. The book also, oddly enough, in several regards, strongly echoes a better historical mystery by Anne Perry, [[ASIN:034551355X The Face of a Stranger: The First William Monk Novel (Mortalis)]].
The North Carolina-based son that's half of Charles Todd once spoke at a Wilmington Library Mystery Weekend. He was intelligent, charming, entertaining, and quite presentable: I wish him better luck next outing.
45 people found this helpful
★★★★★
2.0
AGPAN57SKMRXVEN632MU...
✓ Verified Purchase
I Fell Asleep... Twice.
I must agree with a previous reviewer on this one, the one that says "dutiful, but dead writing.." I think that reviwer was right on the dot on this one. The story line certainly appealed to me. I was excited about a world war one nurse solving a mystery. The main problem for me, besides the fact that I fell asleep everytime I picked it up (after chapter one that is), is lack of emotions radiating from the heroine, Bess. When her ship sinks, (loved that part) I know she must be terrified but the way her emotions are told, I didn't get that feeling. Also, she was supposedly very much in love with Arthur... I don't feel love or the feeling of deep loss radiating from her either. Basically, I never feel like I am getting "to know" Bess or her deep thoughts or emotions. To sum it up, in my opinion, the prose regarding her mental thoughts is very dry.
The story is all right. Bess is on a medical ship near France and when it sinks she sets out to use her medical leave to accomplish a task she had promised a former patient she would complete upon his death. She finds Arthur's family and relays the mysterious message and while at the family home, one medical disaster after another ensures her presence remains there. While she is attending feverish, coughing, or shell shocked people, she discovers that Arthur's family is hiding a sinister secret.
I could not stay awake to read more than half. I think mystery fans may be more intrigued. As I noted above, the lack of intimacy with the main character didn't work for me.
8 people found this helpful
★★★★★
2.0
AEESBRQEXTSTVAZNI5NL...
✓ Verified Purchase
A disappointment
This novel, not one of the often excellent Ian Rutledge series, is the worst Charles Todd since "The Murder Stone" (2003). At least in "Murder Stone," also set in the First World War era, a good story struggled to make its way out of the morass, which unfortunately can't be said of the present book. Its heroine, Bess Crawford, a WWI nurse, is far too like Maisie Dodd for her own good, its plot is predictable and lifeless, and its characters cardboard cutouts.
Charles Todd is a master of WWI detail and has obviously done an awful lot of research, but this can only take the reader so far. ( I can't help wondering if the fact that he is actually two people contributes to the unevenness of "his" work.) "A Duty to the Dead" is subtitled "A Bess Crawford Mystery"--I hope subsequent novels will be an improvement on this one. Mr. Todd is certainly capable of better work.
7 people found this helpful
★★★★★
3.0
AEABUFZEBIG43MJDRHCE...
✓ Verified Purchase
Bess needs a little more personality
Since many other reviewers have described the book, the setting, the plot, I'll just add that my own problem with the book, which made it less than excellent, was the character of the protagonist herself. Some other reviewers have compared her to Maisie Dobbs, but in fact, Maisie Dobbs is a much better rounded character than Bess. I have no idea what Bess looks like, what she feels about the war, what she believes in, her place in society (fairly high), her life in India, what her education and future aspirations are, etc. I'm not even too clear as to how old she is. The only thing I know in this book is that she is a dedicated nurse driven by 'duty'. Since I have no real context for this 'duty', this is not a compelling character trait for me. Other characters in this book also seemed somewhat 2-dimensional, especially her father, the 'Colonel Sahib'. To be honest, I was a little surprised overall by the flatness of this story, since I was expecting the complexities of a character like Ian Rutledge in Todd's other books, and a more complex, riveting mystery. Hopefully this series will improve with time and the characters and stories will gain in depth.
7 people found this helpful
★★★★★
5.0
AE55UIFZEFQX7C5QHCD3...
✓ Verified Purchase
Grimly suspenseful
"A Duty to the Dead: A Bess Crawford Mystery" by Charles Todd is similar to the author's Inspector Ian Rutledge mysteries in high quality of writing, complex plot, and must-finish-the-book-before-I-go-to-bed suspense.
In the Rutledge books, the reader is relentlessly led to the World War One trenches, where all the reader's senses are assailed: The terrifying noise of mortars and machine-gun fire, the mud, the blood, the bodies, the screams in war, the dying moans, the stench, the suicide dashes over the top into No Man's Land. The brave and futile necessity at the Front of risking the few to save the thousands. All the horribleness of war.
Rutledge had been in the middle of it, and bore the physical and mental scars. Shell shock (the precursor to today's Post-Traumatic Stress Syndrome) left him with his wholly illusory psychological companion, named Hamish, the ghost of one of his best men. This ghost challenged everything Rutledge did or thought of doing in his return to duty as a Scotland Yard inspector. Hamish was a handy foil for the author to use in advancing the action.
Charles Todd deprives himself of this literary advantage in "A Duty to the Dead." Bess Crawford is a nurse stationed as near to the front lines as you can get. She and her fellow nurses and doctors daily and hourly receive the wounded and dying men from the battlefield, with all their battle dirtiness and bloodiness and immediate need for care to save their lives, if possible. Wounds spurting blood, feverish comas, projectile vomiting, explosive diarrhea, limbs blown off, eyes blinded. Who takes care of all these essentially revolting conditions? Who cleans them up? Who addresses them? Bess is among those who do. She and the others work to exhaustion in longer than 24-hour days.
I cannot call "A Duty to the Dead" a happy book. Not a book that leaves you happy. Nor can I think of anyone in it who is portrayed as happy (with one very minor exception). That's not really the point, is it? England, at war, is a grim place.
Bess volunteered for the service she is in. Occasional relief, and a brief few days break to return to England, is afforded when she and other nurses get to accompany groups of stabilized soldiers on a hospital ship going back home. Crosses painted red on the ships do not guarantee safety from German submarines. Bess is on one of those ships when it is torpedoed. She survives, but with a debilitating broken arm. During the time of healing, she decides to carry out the dying wish of one of the soldiers back at the Front. He had requested that she deliver an important but mysterious message to his family. Because she admired the man, she had promised, and decided now to do it.
For fear of revealing too much, I will just say that the sizeable family Bess finds at his home is full of secrets, including hidden resentment, rejection, murder, favoritism, deception, misdiagnosis, and other lesser and greater symptoms. The resolution is lengthy (over 300 pages) and will satisfy any need for complexity. A happy read? Are you kidding? Yet I look forward to the next Bess Crawford mystery.
5 people found this helpful
★★★★★
4.0
AGIXXLC6WCLHZRTD5C3A...
✓ Verified Purchase
Pleasant Read
A dying soldier asks his nurse to take a message to his family. Her promise to him sends her to meet his family and give them his last message. Little did she know this act would put her in the middle of a story of murder, intrigue and family secrets. How far will she go to live out her duty to the dead?
This is the first book in the Bess Crawford series. It follows a out-spoken nurse as she lives out the dangerous days of World War I. I enjoyed the character of Bess Crawford when her personality was allowed to shine. Unfortunately, I felt that the author(s) held back on allowing her voice to shine through during much of the book. She was out-spoken and smart yet that wasn't developed as much as I would have liked. I hope to see more of that wit come through the following books in the series.
The mystery itself was interesting but a little slow. It took a long time to uncover each piece of information and the reader was usually farther along in developing theories than the characters. It was a pleasant read, but not spectacular. I would recommend reading it as a pleasant way to pass the time. It is worth reading and my hope is that the following books in the series will be even stronger.
4 people found this helpful
★★★★★
3.0
AECY5GFGV7OMJYONMEP2...
✓ Verified Purchase
Good historical fiction
This novel is the first in a new historical mystery series set in Britain in World War I. It introduces the main character, Bess Crawford, a British Army nurse. She is outspoken, intelligent, resourceful and independent. The novel opens with the sinking of the Britannic (sister ship to the Titanic) in Greek waters. It is an effective opening grabbing the reader's attention right away. Bess is injured in the sinking and invalided home to recover with her parents. Her father is a retired Colonel who served in India, where she was raised. This background should provide fertile material for the series.
The plot involves Bess visiting the Graham family to deliver a message from a dying son of the family. I won't give away any spoilers but the story is engaging and not terribly complex. It is set primarily in the Kent countryside and the usual eccentric cast of villagers - the vicar, the matriarch, the tutor, the country doctor - is on display. The time period and the fact that Bess Crawford is an army nurse invite comparisons to the Maisie Dobbs series. This new series compares favorably to the Maisie Dobbs series, they both depict the sorrow and sacrifice of WWI Britain but this series seems darker to me, with characters not quite as well rounded as the Dobbs series. I would recommend this book; it is a straightforward historical mystery that does a good job of putting the reader in the time and place with a mystery that is just intriguing enough to satisfy.
3 people found this helpful
★★★★★
3.0
AGY5JM4JIEL6RX6X6NLU...
✓ Verified Purchase
3.5 Stars - One has a duty to the dead
First Sentence: At sea...the morning sun is lovely and warm.
Bess Crawford is an independent, upper-middle-call British gentlewoman who takes after her father. She became a nurse and travelled to the battlefields of France. On her way back to England aboard the Britannic, the ship strikes a mine and sinks. Bess suffers a badly broken arm but becomes fond of Lt. Arthur Graham who, right before dying, extracts a promise from her to deliver a message to his brother in England. Keeping that promise embroils her in a family surrounded by tragedy and secrets.
It is always interesting when an author you love begins a new series. Sometimes it works; sometimes not. In this case, it definitely worked.
Bess is a great new character. She is representative of many woman of her class; smart, independent; strong and with a belief that woman can be as capable as men. She has seen the results of war and knows the impact it has on the men who fight. It is also typical of the time that Bess is constantly asked whether she was in love with each young many of her acquaintance as people can't otherwise understand the courses of action she takes.
Todd provides a very strong sense of time and place with just a hint of a gothic feel. At the same time they make strong statements about the impact of war and the lack of understanding of those who stay at home. Their writing is very effective and can go straight to the emotions and the heart.
There were a couple small false steps. The story was a little slow getting started and Bess' reaction to the sinking of the ship seemed a bit too detached. There were a few portent--a writing element I really dislike--and a characters who had been locked in an asylum since being a young boy was much to intelligent and street-smart to be quite believable.
I very much enjoyed Bess and hope to see ore of both her and her father, whom I very much liked. I look forward to more books in this series.
A DUTY TO THE DEAD (Hist Mys-Elizabeth (Bess) Crawford -England-WWI/1916)- G+
Todd, Charles - 1st in series
William Morrow, 2009, US Hardcover - ISBN: 9780061933844
3 people found this helpful
★★★★★
3.0
AGY5JM4JIEL6RX6X6NLU...
✓ Verified Purchase
3.5 Stars - One has a duty to the dead
First Sentence: At sea...the morning sun is lovely and warm.
Bess Crawford is an independent, upper-middle-call British gentlewoman who takes after her father. She became a nurse and travelled to the battlefields of France. On her way back to England aboard the Britannic, the ship strikes a mine and sinks. Bess suffers a badly broken arm but becomes fond of Lt. Arthur Graham who, right before dying, extracts a promise from her to deliver a message to his brother in England. Keeping that promise embroils her in a family surrounded by tragedy and secrets.
It is always interesting when an author you love begins a new series. Sometimes it works; sometimes not. In this case, it definitely worked.
Bess is a great new character. She is representative of many woman of her class; smart, independent; strong and with a belief that woman can be as capable as men. She has seen the results of war and knows the impact it has on the men who fight. It is also typical of the time that Bess is constantly asked whether she was in love with each young many of her acquaintance as people can't otherwise understand the courses of action she takes.
Todd provides a very strong sense of time and place with just a hint of a gothic feel. At the same time they make strong statements about the impact of war and the lack of understanding of those who stay at home. Their writing is very effective and can go straight to the emotions and the heart.
There were a couple small false steps. The story was a little slow getting started and Bess' reaction to the sinking of the ship seemed a bit too detached. There were a few portent--a writing element I really dislike--and a characters who had been locked in an asylum since being a young boy was much to intelligent and street-smart to be quite believable.
I very much enjoyed Bess and hope to see ore of both her and her father, whom I very much liked. I look forward to more books in this series.
A DUTY TO THE DEAD (Hist Mys-Elizabeth (Bess) Crawford -England-WWI/1916)- G+
Todd, Charles - 1st in series
William Morrow, 2009, US Hardcover - ISBN: 9780061933844
3 people found this helpful
★★★★★
4.0
AGXYE526HIGVX2UUYH47...
✓ Verified Purchase
Starting A Series Out Right
With several active series of detective fiction set in post-World War I Britain it's impressive that any author would want to launch a new one, especially when the author in question already has one successful series ongoing. The writing team that comprises Charles Todd has gone as far afield from guilt-ridden Inspector Rutledge as imaginable while still staying in familiar territory. I admit my first reaction to the news of this new series was something along the lines of "why bother?" so I'm happy to report that it's a very good thing that Todd did bother.
A Duty to the Dead handles the business of launching a series with minimal fuss. The introduction of heroine (and military nurse) Bess Crawford - a smart, resourceful heroine without being a screaming anachronism - involves a minimum of exposition and background. Todd's choice of making Bess being the only child of a Colonel who was raised in colonial India presents many opportunities for the character to comment on a society that she both participates in and observes. It's easy to see that this will serve the series well.
The central plot sees Bess going to visit the family of a man who died under her care to deliver his last message to them. There's plenty of English cozy-genre trappings complete with addled vicar, misunderstood town doctor and family secrets. Bess can't so much as take a walk without someone in the town needing immediate nursing assistance or wanting to confide in her. And yet the clichés and the creaks didn't bother me because Todd kept the story going at a good pace. The mystery itself is satisfying without being too convoluted.
This isn't a perfect book but it is enjoyable. Some will compare it to Todd's Inspector Rutledge books - for me this stacks up well against the first entry in that series A Test of Wills. Others may compare it to Jacqueline Winspear's Maisie Dobbs - I'll take Bess Crawford over Maisie any day. Where Maisie is a humorless paragon of perfection, Bess is no nonsense and human. To each there own. If you're a fan of either series or Rennie Airth's fine [[ASIN:0143035703 River of Darkness: A John Madden Mystery]]series, A Duty to the Dead is a sure bet.