Valentine: A Read with Jenna Pick
Valentine: A Read with Jenna Pick book cover

Valentine: A Read with Jenna Pick

Hardcover – Deckle Edge, March 31, 2020

Price
$12.00
Format
Hardcover
Pages
320
Publisher
Harper
Publication Date
ISBN-13
978-0062913265
Dimensions
6 x 1.05 x 9 inches
Weight
1.05 pounds

Description

An Amazon Best Book of April 2020: When a young Mexican girl is viciously raped and beaten by a brooding oil-slick cowboy, the small town of Odessa, Texas, must decide where the law lies and who they believe. Narrated by five women, Valentine is the story of how they survive amidst the 1970s violence, poverty, and racism that surrounds them. Despite their wounds, each of these women—whether victims or bystanders, young or old, lost or found, directly connected to the violence or not—are sunbaked strong and have been fighting for their lives as long as they can remember. Desperation, loneliness, and fear abound in this novel, but so too does care, compassion, and hope. Elizabeth Wetmore’s debut calls to mind Western greats like Larry McMurtry but supplants the hardened cowboys with fierce and courageous women. Haunting, powerful, and beautifully written, Valentine will linger with you long after you’ve finished the last page. —Al Woodworth “A thrilling debut. . . . Like Miriam Toews’ Women Talking, Valentine is a story about how women—particularly women without much education or money—negotiate a culture of masculine brutality. This is the story of their lives in a backwater oil town in the mid-1970s, which Wetmore seems to know with empathy so deep it aches. . . . Carefully wrought and emotionally compelling.”xa0 — Washington Post "A monument to a sort of singular grace, and true grit." — Entertainment Weekly “ Valentine, Elizabeth Wetmore’s fierce and brilliant debut novel, is set in Odessa, a rough-edged West Texas town built on cattle and oil. It evokes the physicality of the place with a visceral power that recalls Cormac McCarthy, and sets out its cultural ambience and mores with the ironic clarity of Larry McMurtry. This literary landscape has been defined by men as surely as the reality it represents. Wetmore sweeps them to the sidelines, defiantly and confidently claiming West Texas for the women and girls. . . . Valentine joins the best Texas novels ever written.” — Minneapolis Star Tribune “Excellent. . . . Tense and riveting. . . . D.A. emerges a gritty, welcome addition to American literature’s pantheon of young heroines. . . . Wetmore, a native of West Texas and graduate of the Iowa Writers’ Workshop, offers with her first novel a harrowing narrative of a region she knows well, described with precision and passion.” — Associated Press “Exceptional. . . .Wetmore, like Harper Lee before her, has little interest in preserving the illusions of people who believe that justice and love will always prevail. . . . an incredibly moving and emotionally devastating piece of work that heralds great things from Wetmore.” — Houston Chronicle "Wetmore’s characters offer perspectives that cross generations, socioeconomic classes and races. Yet all characters serve to showcase the resilience of women and the power that comes in deciding the direction of one’s own story." — San Francisco Chronicle “Gripping and complex. .xa0 . . Wetmore’s delight in language enlivens every page. . . . With its deeply realized characters, moral intricacy, brilliant writing and a page-turning plot, Valentine rewards its readers’ generosity with innumerable good things in glorious abundance.” — Chicago Tribune " Valentine shines with strong characters, some sympathetic, others detestable, and a complex plot with narrative threads smoothly knitted together." — The Missourian “Fierce and complex, VALENTINE is a novel of moral urgency and breathtaking prose. This is the very definition of a stunning debut.” — Ann Patchett “It is nearly impossible for me to believe that Elizabeth Wetmore is a first-time novelist. How can a writer burst out of the gate with this much firepower and skill? VALENTINE is brilliant, sharp, tightly wound, and devastating. Wetmore has ripped the brutal, epic landscape of West Texas out of the hands of men, and has handed the stories over (finally!) to the girls and women who have always suffered, survived, and made their mark in such a hostile world. These are some of the most fully realized and unforgettable female characters I’ve ever met. They will stay with me." — Elizabeth Gilbert, New York Times bestselling author of City of Girls “A testament to the resilience of the female spirit. . . .Wetmore’s prose is both beautiful and bone-true, and this mature novel hardly feels like a debut. You’ll wish you had more time with each of these powerful women when it’s over.” — Bookpage (starred review) “Stirring. . . . Wetmore poetically weaves the landscape of Odessa and the internal lives of her characters, whose presence remains vivid after the last page is turned. This moving portrait of West Texas oil country evokes the work of Larry McMurtry and John Sayles with strong, memorable female voices.” — Publishers Weekly (starred review) “A searing, propulsive debut. . . . Through these alternating narratives, Wetmore tells a powerful story of female anger, a repressed rage against systematic sexism and racism ready to explode. . . . From its chilling opening to its haunting conclusion, this astonishing novel will resonate with many readers.” — Kirkus Reviews (starred review) “Drawing comparisons to Barbara Kingsolver and Wallace Stegner, Wetmore writes with an evidently innate wisdom about the human spirit. With deep introspection, she expertly unravels the complexities between men, women, and the land they inhabit. Achingly powerful, this story will resonate with readers long after having finished it.” — Booklist “My goodness, what a novel. I clutched this book in both hands and by the end I could feel the dust of West Texas on my skin. Elizabeth Wetmore understands the nuances of the human heart better than almost any writer I’ve read in recent years, and I rooted for these women with everything I have. There is violence here, and despair, but in the end the story is a testament to quiet courage, to hope, to love. Every person should read this extraordinary debut.” — Mary Beth Keane, New York Times bestselling author of Ask Again, Yes “Elizabeth Wetmore shows us the vivid and complex culture of Odessa, Texas. The women in this book move through their difficult lives with strength and surprising grace. The landscape and characters are rendered with precise and lyric prose. Valentine is a beautiful book written with compassion, understanding, and deep honesty. A remarkable debut.” — Chris Offutt, author of Country Dark “In Valentine , Elizabeth Wetmore cracks open West Texas and lays bare what beats inside: a world at once ferocious, fragile, and furious, where women and girls fight menace from every fanged quarter—land, animal, human. But fight they do, for themselves, for each other, for what’s right. Wondrously, amid the sorrow, Valentine thrums with the most staggering beauty, a compassion and tenderness as vast as the sky. You’ll read this book like a letter from a lost love, clutched in your hands, heart in your throat. You’ll carry it with you forever.” — Bryn Chancellor, author of Sycamore "In outstanding prose, Wetmore has created a handful of extraordinary women out of the dust of West Texas, 1976. They are all so real, with their hard lives lived with absolute humanity. Valentine is both heartbreaking and thrilling, I loved it."xa0 — Claire Fuller, author of Our Endless Numbered Days Elizabeth Wetmore is a graduate of the Iowa Writers’ Workshop. Her fiction has appeared in Epoch, Kenyon Review, Colorado Review, Baltimore Review, Crab Orchard Review, Iowa Review , and other literary journals. She is the recipient of a fellowship from the National Endowment for the Arts and two fellowships from the Illinois Arts Council, as well as a grant from the Barbara Deming Foundation. She was also a Rona Jaffe Scholar in Fiction at Bread Loaf and a Fellow at the MacDowell Colony, and one of six Writers in Residence at Hedgebrook. A native of West Texas, she lives and works in Chicago. Read more

Features & Highlights

  • An instant
  • New York Times
  • Bestseller
  • Finalist for the Dayton Literary Peace Prize
  • A Read with Jenna
  • Today
  • Show Book Club Pick!
  • "A thrilling debut that deserves your attention." –Ron Charles, the
  • Washington Post
  • Written with the haunting emotional power of Elizabeth Strout and Barbara Kingsolver, an astonishing debut novel that explores the lingering effects of a brutal crime on the women of one small Texas oil town in the 1970s, longlisted for the Center for Fiction First Novel Prize and the VCU Cabell First Novel Award.
  • Mercy is hard in a place like this . . .
  • It’s February 1976, and Odessa, Texas, stands on the cusp of the next great oil boom. While the town’s men embrace the coming prosperity, its women intimately know and fear the violence that always seems to follow.
  • In the early hours of the morning after Valentine’s Day, fourteen-year-old Gloria Ramírez appears on the front porch of Mary Rose Whitehead’s ranch house, broken and barely alive. The teenager had been viciously attacked in a nearby oil field—an act of brutality that is tried in the churches and barrooms of Odessa before it can reach a court of law. When justice is evasive, the stage is set for a showdown with potentially devastating consequences.
  • Valentine
  • is a haunting exploration of the intersections of violence and race, class and region in a story that plumbs the depths of darkness and fear, yet offers a window into beauty and hope. Told through the alternating points of view of indelible characters who burrow deep in the reader’s heart, this fierce, unflinching, and surprisingly tender novel illuminates women’s strength and vulnerability, and reminds us that it is the stories we tell ourselves that keep us alive.

Customer Reviews

Rating Breakdown

★★★★★
30%
(2K)
★★★★
25%
(1.7K)
★★★
15%
(1K)
★★
7%
(470)
23%
(1.5K)

Most Helpful Reviews

✓ Verified Purchase

Not recommended.

Depressing, rambling, too disjointed and too many side stories. Was very disappointed. Bought because Jenna Bush Book Club recommended.
13 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

A familiar, devastatingly honest portrayal of Odessa

I moved to Odessa in 1980 to start my 4th grade year there. My father was in the oil business and made a very successful career from consulting. I lived there and in Midland until my own daughter was to begin Junior High in Midland. I did not want her to grow up there any longer than she had to. Despite what Midlanders say about Odessa, they are basically the same.

I do not believe my second husband, whom I met after moving to Central Texas, understands why I hate to pump gasoline into my own vehicle. If you grew up in Odessa or Midland, you would know why. The cat calls and the disgusting remarks still have left me scarred.

As a was researching the 1983 murder of a friend of mine, along with his older brother and mother, I came across the photographs of all the missing young women during the time, as well. I was so young back then and didn’t realize what was happening. No one spoke about these crimes to children. I never even knew what had happened to man who murdered my friend until a few years ago after I had to retire early as a Senior Crime Scene Specialist because of a brain disease. (If you Google Kenneth Venne, you will find out that a monster can kill 2 teenagers, most probably raping, and killing their mother, and is given a ridiculous sentence and set to be released in 2022.)

I guess parents back then believed that the less you knew, the better off you were. In my case, that didn’t work out too well. I never stopped sleep walking like most children do when they reach a certain age. So, I was at the FBI Academy in Quantico for training when I woke up and found that I had taken all of my clothing out of my dorm room’s dresser and put them into bed with me. When I arrived back at my agency, I started on the long road to dealing with PTSD.

This story has such a familiar, devastatingly honest portrayal of Odessa that I would find my hair standing on end. I even recognized the streets because I lived in the townhomes on either side of the streets where the characters lived when my daughter was born.

If I could give this book 10 stars, I would, and I hope everyone who reads this review purchases it right now and takes what they may from it. As for me, I know I made the right choice in leaving. I have a friend who attended the yearly Pow Wow in Big Springs. She was told by a Native American elder that the land is a proving ground. If you can leave it, and stay away from it, you have proven yourself.

I believe I and Elizabeth Wetmore have done just that. I only wish more would or could…
9 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

The language in this book is horrible!!

There is no need for books to use the word "GD " in any book! That's a good way to ruin a book. I must say this book has been highly disappointing.
8 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Tough subject matter but worthwhile read

There was so much sadness to this story as well as some parts that made me angry but it made for an incredible reading experience. I feel like this book just spoke to me as a woman, and that's not something I say very often, if ever. I'm kicking myself that I let a copy of this book sit on my shelf for months before finally picking it up. This is a book if you can handle tough subject matter, I do recommend giving this one a look.

The story takes place in 1979 in Odessa, Texas. Fourteen-year-old Gloria Ramírez has been taken to an oil field by a man who then rapes her. She is able to escape and finds a ranch house where a pregnant woman named Mary Rose lives with her young daughter and husband. The story shows the aftermath of the rape and how it affected Gloria as well as the public perception of it. The story alternates between Gloria as well as other female characters including Mary Rose, Corrine, a recent widow, a young girl named Debra Ann Pierce,and Karla, a waitress and young mother.

The opening chapters of this book were absolutely heart pounding and terrifying. I thought using females of varying ages was an effective way to tell the story. Near the end when the story finally featured Karla, I thought what could this character add so late in the game? But she really turned out to have a vital role in my opinion. While I was already feeling connected to all of the female characters, Karla really drove home the point that as women, we do have to look out for one another and so many times we do it without even thinking about it. By instinct and experience, we try our best to protect each other. The different things her co-workers did for her are just one example of how life for a female is different than that of a male.

This is a difficult book to read but I absolutely thought it was worth my time. There have been many recent fiction books that explore the subject of crimes against females but this is only one of a few I have read that actually features a different time period rather than the current one. While many attitudes have changed since 1979, it continues to be frustrating how victims are treated even 40 years later. I'm thankful the author deemed that as something important to explore in this novel.

I won a free copy of this book in a giveaway but was under no obligation to post a review. All views expressed are my honest opinion.
8 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

NOT one of the best TX novels ever written.

Having grown up in Odessa, I thought much of it was just plain mean. I'm not sorry I read it, but have no plans to recommend it to anyone else. Some of the characters seem strangely placed from a time perspective--either reacting to sistuations in a manner that evoked the Great Depression or going the other way with a reaction more evocative of the 90s A lot of it simply didn't sit well. I'm sure the Midlanders loved it. BTW, it's the T&P RR that goes through Odessa.
If you want a good book about that part of the country, read (or re-read) Friday Night Lights. As a Permian High grad, I found it spot-on.
6 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Ending was off for me

I like a book written from the viewpoint of different chacters, which happened in this book. It was a bit difficult to remember all the characters, but what gave this a 3 for me was the ending.
6 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Bad writing, impossible structure, uninteresting plot, very biased

This book was a waste of my time, but I made it to the end because we are discussing it in our book club. I found the style of writing awful: Not just the characters but also the narrative is in the author's native West Texan dialect, and I have never read a book so full of unnecessarily foul, lewd, obscene language. Again, not just by the characters, which would be understandable, but by the narrator. The main theme of the book seems to be that almost all men are devils incarnate and that vulnerable women are their victims. I confess that I had a very negative stereotype of West Texas anyway, from the famous film "Last Picture Show," which also takes place in a rural West Texas town, although not an oil town. If a native of West Texas portrays her own native land as hell, it's even more reason never to go near there.
The structure of the book is utterly impossible, with all chapters labeled by the women they are about, but with about 3 or 4 chapters devoted to each women, scattered all over the place, with very little order or logic. Even within chapters, the author shifts back and forth again and again in time, as if her purpose were to deliberately confuse the reader as much as possible.
I confess that am extremely biased against Texas and racist rural parts of Texas, in particular, as well as the entire barbaric, violent culture that the author describes. So the author confirms in spades my own biases. But it was not a very satisfying book. All I learned is that West Texas is even more hellish than I had imagined.
5 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Not very uplifting during this time

The book is written very well, but I'm disappointed in that they female characters had alot of grit, or complacency. Not really sure which one. Their lives are not uplifting at all and I have to wonder why anyone would live in West Texas. I was hoping for an inspiring novel about how women overcame their bad circumstances to get out of the situation. Only 1 was able to leave, and I won't go into what she gave up to do it (not worth it) and we have no idea if she ever found happiness. Sorry I just found it depressing all the way around and not sure why Jenna Bush Hager would think it was an amazing story, other than it the story is from her native TX.
5 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Long

Amazingly strong women of different ages and experiences. But my daughter and I had a hard time getting through it. Confusing as to who is speaking, how these women fit into the original crime And the trail is so disappointing. So short like an afterthought. A big disappointment .
4 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

This Former Odessan Wanted to Love It

I was excited to learn of this book and to buy it. I was born and raised in Odessa and was ten years old in 1976. Though I haven’t lived in Odessa much since graduating from high school (and don’t really care to return), I was thrilled to have an opportunity to read a book set there. I bought it for my Kindle, and I also ordered a large print copy for my mother, who now lives in the Midwest near me.

I was wondering if I were going to have an experience like The Help where I would recognize folks. Though I knew or knew of folks with the same last names as those of the main characters, the only actual person I recognized was Coach Wilkins.

Of course there is a disclaimer about the book being a work of fiction. Duly noted.

The first part of the book really held my attention. It described a horrific scene, and the author’s pacing was very effective in the opening chapters. I enjoyed the back and forth of the chapters, jumping from character to character. That was quite engaging. And others have remarked on not having quotation marks in character dialogue, but I was rather find of that style.

I was the same age as Debra Ann in 1976, so I was very drawn to her character. In fact, though my family life was very different from hers, I spent a large part of my childhood playing in pastures in a development northeast of town—so I could imagine her playing a lot on her own and discovering Jesse.

I’ll say—when Glory puts a pebble under her tongue when she was thirsty and wandering that took me directly back to my childhood and the survival skills I loved learning and relied on when roaming desert pastures on hot days—and surely in 1976.

I admit I skimmed most of the last half of the book, reading fully what seemed to be the key sections. I was not engaged in the story or the characters.

I found the figures of speech to be heavy handed, inauthentic, and not how I remember folks speaking—and not representative of how my friends who still live there speak now. And the use of those this speech or this type of writing (“as thin as a mesquite leaf”) was too thick for me. It distracted me and made me care less about most of the characters, because I didn’t experience them as real. Perhaps if the book were set elsewhere this wouldn’t have been a problem.

Early on, it seemed that places were being named to check off boxes. In fact, I told my mom that I’d create a bingo card for her to use as she reads. Lol.

I was very surprised that the Freedom Train was not mentioned at all, but it was a huge deal in Odessa in February, 1976. And it came a week before the story opened. It seemed strange that such a key event that took place February 7-9 wasn’t a part of the story at all that opened on February 14.

It was nice to see the Sand Hills and Prairie Pete Park referred to, if not by name. As a kid living in Odessa during that time, those were important landmarks.

There were some inaccuracies that really stuck with me and bothered me—namely locations. A street called Custer was supposed to be DA’s northern boundary, but the street runs north and south pretty much and is east of Grandview. I lived on Custer for the first few years of my life.

Glory said she lived on Muskingum but referred to attending Gonzales Elementary. I didn’t go to Gonzales, but unless there was a district anomaly, she wouldn’t have gone to Gonzales.

I couldn’t figure out if DA lived near the Sonic on Andrews Highway or on the other side of Grandview where she might have actually been able to ride her bike to Buffalo Wallow on 42nd Street—on the east side of town.

The newspaper was never referred to as The American but always The Odessa American. I’m guessing this was an intentional change, but it bothered me.

The story refers to Blue Bell ice cream several times, but I do not remember Blue Bell in that part of Texas until the early to mid-1980s. It’s certainly a staple now.

Toward the end, there was a reference to the perfume from Dillard’s department store, but we didn’t have a Dillard’s until Permian Mall opened in 1980. Winwood Mall had a Sears and J.C. Penney (and also a Montgomery Ward I think).

I’m seriously also doubting Coach Wilkins ever taught Girls’ PE in 1976. He sure didn’t when I was at Permian 1981-84. The man was a football god. But maybe when his son was also 10 in 1976 he did. Who knows?

Inaccuracies aside, it was the colloquialisms that I found too thick, far too quaint, and inauthentic that gave me the most issues.

In spite of that, I’m glad I read this book.

The author handled the racism endemic in the city deftly. I was very grateful to see her treatment of both the sexism and racism that polluted the city (okay, and still does—as well as the rest of Texas).

I know my mom will enjoy this book. And during this really stressful time (COVID-19), I’m very grateful she will have such a nice escape that reminds her of home.

After finishing the book, I listened to the interview with Wetmore on the NPR/WBUR program Here & Now, and the book is clearly doing very well, debuting at #2 on the NYT Bestseller’s list. I’m glad the author is having such success with it. It’s great to have a story about this town from a woman’s perspective. It’s certainly not Friday Night Lights!

I will look forward to trying the next book by Wetmore.
4 people found this helpful