The Silver Linings Playbook: A Novel
The Silver Linings Playbook: A Novel book cover

The Silver Linings Playbook: A Novel

Paperback – October 16, 2012

Price
$12.49
Format
Paperback
Pages
304
Publisher
Sarah Crichton Books
Publication Date
ISBN-13
978-0374533571
Dimensions
5.45 x 1 x 8.2 inches
Weight
9.6 ounces

Description

"It's a charmingly nerve-wracking combination...The book is cinematic, but the writing still shimmers. This nimble, funny read is spiked with enough perception to allow the reader to enjoy Pat's blindly hopeful philosophy without irony." Barrie Hardymon, National Public Radio"Quick fills the pages with so much absurd wit and true feeling that it's impossible not to cheer for his unlikely hero." Allison Lynn, People Magazine"...compelling and fascinating ... a tour de force. ... From the beer-soaked Bacchanalian tailgating to the black holes of despair into which Iggles fans plunge themselves after a defeat, Quick is dead-on." Bill Lyon, The Philadelphia Inquirer"...charming debut novel...it is hard not to be moved by the fate of a man who, despite many ordeals, tries to believe in hope and fidelity, not to mention getting through another day with his sanity intact." Stephen Barbara, The Wall Street Journal"...endearing...touching and funny debut...Pat [Peoples] is as sweet as a puppy, and his offbeat story has all the markings of a crowd-pleaser." Publishers Weekly“Matthew Quick has created quite the heartbreaker of a novel in The Silver Linings Playbook.” Kirkus First Fiction Issue“heart-warming, humorous, and soul-satisfying … thought of starting off the review with a photo of me hugging the book and grinning like an idiot–I liked it that much.” Nancy Pearl, Pearl’s Picks + NPR’s ‘Summer’s Best Books’ (2009)“You don’t have to be a Philadelphia Eagles’ fan (or even from Philadelphia) to appreciate talented newcomer Matthew Quick’s page-turning paean to the power of hope over experience—the belief that this will all work out somehow, despite the long odds that life deals us. ” Justin Cronin, PEN/Hemingway Award-winning author of The Passage“More than a promising debut or an inspiring love story, this novel offers us the gift of healing.” Roland Merullo, author of Breakfast With Buddha“This is a funny, touching performance on the part of Mr. Quick—and the beginning, I hope, of a big career.” Dave King, author of The Ha-Ha Matthew Quick (aka Q) is the New York Times bestselling author of several novels, including THE SILVER LININGS PLAYBOOK, which was made into an Oscar-winning film. His work has been translated into more than twenty languages and has received a PEN/Hemingway Award Honorable Mention, among other accolades. Q lives in Massachusetts with his wife, novelist/pianist Alicia Bessette. Excerpt. © Reprinted by permission. All rights reserved. The Silver Linings Playbook [movie tie-in edition] A Novel By Matthew Quick Sarah Crichton Books Copyright © 2012 Matthew QuickAll right reserved. ISBN: 9780374533571 Chapter OneAn Infinite Amount of Days Until My Inevitable Reunion with NikkiI don’t have to look up to know Mom is making another surprise visit. Her toenails are always pink during the summer months, and I recognize the flower design imprinted on her leather sandals; it’s what Mom purchased the last time she signed me out of the bad place and took me to the mall.xa0Once again, Mother has found me in my bathrobe, exercising unattended in the courtyard, and I smile because I know she will yell at Dr. Timbers, asking him why I need to be locked up if I’m only going to be left alone all day.xa0“Just how many push-ups are you going to do, Pat?” Mom says when I start a second set of one hundred without speaking to her.xa0“Nikki—likes—a—man—with—a—developed—upper—body,” I say, spitting out one word per push-up, tasting the salty sweat lines that are running into my mouth.xa0The August haze is thick, perfect for burning fat.xa0Mom just watches for a minute or so, and then she shocks me. Her voice sort of quivers as she says, “Do you want to come home with me today?”xa0I stop doing push-ups, turn my face up toward Mother’s, squint through the white noontime sun—and I can immediately tell she is serious, because she looks worried, as if she is making a mistake, and that’s how Mom looks when she means something she has said and isn’t just talking like she always does for hours on end whenever she’s not upset or afraid.xa0“As long as you promise not to go looking for Nikki again,” she adds, “you can finally come home and live with me and your father until we find you a job and get you set up in an apartment.”xa0I resume my push-up routine, keeping my eyes riveted to the shiny black ant scaling a blade of grass directly below my nose, but my peripheral vision catches the sweat beads leaping from my face to the ground below.xa0“Pat, just say you’ll come home with me, and I’ll cook for you and you can visit with your old friends and start to get on with your life finally. Please. I need you to want this. If only for me, Pat. Please.”xa0Double-time push-ups, my pecs ripping, growing—pain, heat, sweat, change.xa0I don’t want to stay in the bad place, where no one believes in silver linings or love or happy endings, and where everyone tells me Nikki will not like my new body, nor will she even want to see me when apart time is over. But I am also afraid the people from my old life will not be as enthusiastic as I am now trying to be.xa0Even still, I need to get away from the depressing doctors and the ugly nurses—with their endless pills in paper cups—if I am ever going to get my thoughts straight, and since Mom will be much easier to trick than medical professionals, I jump up, find my feet, and say, “I’ll come live with you just until apart time is over.”xa0While Mom is signing legal papers, I take one last shower in my room and then fill my duffel bag with clothes and my framed picture of Nikki. I say goodbye to my roommate, Jackie, who just stares at me from his bed like he always does, drool running down off his chin like clear honey. Poor Jackie, with his random tufts of hair, oddly shaped head, and flabby body. What woman would ever love him?xa0He blinks at me. I take this for goodbye and good luck, so I blink back with both eyes—meaning double good luck to you, Jackie, which I figure he understands, since he grunts and bangs his shoulder against his ear like he does whenever he gets what you are trying to tell him.xa0My other friends are in music relaxation class, which I do not attend, because smooth jazz makes me angry sometimes. Thinking maybe I should say goodbye to the men who had my back while I was locked up, I look into the music-room window and see my boys sitting Indian style on purple yoga mats, their elbows resting on their knees, their palms pressed together in front of their faces, and their eyes closed. Luckily, the glass of the window blocks the smooth jazz from entering my ears. My friends look really relaxed—at peace—so I decide not to interrupt their session. I hate goodbyes.xa0In his white coat, Dr. Timbers is waiting for me when I meet my mother in the lobby, where three palm trees lurk among the couches and lounge chairs, as if the bad place were in Orlando and not Baltimore. “Enjoy your life,” he says to me—wearing that sober look of his—and shakes my hand.xa0“Just as soon as apart time ends,” I say, and his face falls as if I said I was going to kill his wife, Natalie, and their three blondhaired daughters—Kristen, Jenny, and Becky—because that’s just how much he does not believe in silver linings, making it his business to preach apathy and negativity and pessimism unceasingly.xa0But I make sure he understands that he has failed to infect me with his depressing life philosophies—and that I will be looking forward to the end of apart time. I say, “Picture me rollin’” to Dr. Timbers, which is exactly what Danny—my only black friend in the bad place—told me he was going to say to Dr. Timbers when Danny got out. I sort of feel bad about stealing Danny’s exit line, but it works; I know because Dr. Timbers squints as if I had punched him in the gut.xa0As my mother drives me out of Maryland and through Delaware, past all those fast-food places and strip malls, she explains that Dr. Timbers did not want to let me out of the bad place, but with the help of a few lawyers and her girlfriend’s therapist—the man who will be my new therapist—she waged a legal battle and managed to convince some judge that she could care for me at home, so I thank her.xa0On the Delaware Memorial Bridge, she looks over at me and asks if I want to get better, saying, “You do want to get better, Pat. Right?”xa0I nod. I say, “I do.”xa0And then we are back in New Jersey, flying up 295.xa0As we drive down Haddon Avenue into the heart of Collingswood—my hometown—I see that the main drag looks different. So many new boutique stores, new expensive-looking restaurants, and well-dressed strangers walking the sidewalks that I wonder if this is really my hometown at all. I start to feel anxious, breathing heavily like I sometimes do.xa0Mom asks me what’s wrong, and when I tell her, she again promises that my new therapist, Dr. Patel, will have me feeling normal in no time.xa0When we arrive home, I immediately go down into the basement, and it’s like Christmas. I find the weight bench my mother had promised me so many times, along with the rack of weights, the stationary bike, dumbbells, and the Stomach Master 6000, which I had seen on late-night television and coveted for however long I was in the bad place.xa0“Thank you, thank you, thank you!” I tell Mom, and give her a huge hug, picking her up off the ground and spinning her around once.xa0When I put her down, she smiles and says, “Welcome home, Pat.”xa0Eagerly I go to work, alternating between sets of bench presses, curls, machine sit-ups on the Stomach Master 6000, leg lifts, squats, hours on the bike, hydration sessions (I try to drink four gallons of water every day, doing endless shots of H2O from a shot glass for intensive hydration), and then there is my writing, which is mostly daily memoirs like this one, so that Nikki will be able to read about my life and know exactly what I’ve been up to since apart time began. (My memory started to slip in the bad place because of the drugs, so I began writing down everything that happens to me, keeping track of what I will need to tell Nikki when apart time concludes, to catch her up on my life. But the doctors in the bad place confiscated everything I wrote before I came home, so I had to start over.)xa0When I finally come out of the basement, I notice that all the pictures of Nikki and me have been removed from the walls and the mantel over the fireplace.xa0I ask my mother where these pictures went. She tells me our house was burglarized a few weeks before I came home and the pictures were stolen. I ask why a burglar would want pictures of Nikki and me, and my mother says she puts all of her pictures in very expensive frames. “Why didn’t the burglar steal the rest of the family pictures?” I ask. Mom says the burglar stole all the expensive frames, but she had the negatives for the family portraits and had them replaced. “Why didn’t you replace the pictures of Nikki and me?” I ask. Mom says she did not have the negatives for the pictures of Nikki and me, especially because Nikki’s parents had paid for the wedding pictures and had only given my mother copies of the photos she liked. Nikki had given Mom the other non-wedding pictures of us, and well, we aren’t in touch with Nikki or her family right now because it’s apart time.xa0I tell my mother that if that burglar comes back, I’ll break his kneecaps and beat him within an inch of his life, and she says, “I believe you would.”xa0My father and I do not talk even once during the first week I am home, which is not all that surprising, as he is always working—he’s the district manager for all the Big Foods in South Jersey. When Dad’s not at work, he’s in his study, reading historical fiction with the door shut, mostly novels about the Civil War. Mom says he needs time to get used to my living at home again, which I am happy to give him, especially since I am sort of afraid to talk with Dad anyway. I remember him yelling at me the only time he ever visited me in the bad place, and he said some pretty awful things about Nikki and silver linings in general. I see Dad in the hallways of our house, of course, but he doesn’t look at me when we pass.xa0Nikki likes to read, and since she always wanted me to read literary books, I start, mainly so I will be able to participate in the dinner conversations I had remained silent through in the past—those conversations with Nikki’s literary friends, all English teachers who think I’m an illiterate buffoon, which is actually a name Nikki’s friend calls me whenever I tease him about being such a tiny man. “At least I’m not an illiterate buffoon,” Phillip says to me, and Nikki laughs so hard.xa0My mom has a library card, and she checks out books for me now that I am home and allowed to read whatever I want without clearing the material with Dr. Timbers, who, incidentally, is a fascist when it comes to book banning. I start with The Great Gatsby, which I finish in just three nights.xa0The best part is the introductory essay, which states that the novel is mostly about time and how you can never buy it back, which is exactly how I feel regarding my body and exercise—but then again, I also feel as if I have an infinite amount of days until my inevitable reunion with Nikki.xa0When I read the actual story—how Gatsby loves Daisy so much but can’t ever be with her no matter how hard he tries—I feel like ripping the book in half and calling up Fitzgerald and telling him his book is all wrong, even though I know Fitzgerald is probably deceased. Especially when Gatsby is shot dead in his swimming pool the first time he goes for a swim all summer, Daisy doesn’t even go to his funeral, Nick and Jordan part ways, and Daisy ends up sticking with racist Tom, whose need for sex basically murders an innocent woman, you can tell Fitzgerald never took the time to look up at clouds during sunset, because there’s no silver lining at the end of that book, let me tell you.xa0I do see why Nikki likes the novel, as it’s written so well. But her liking it makes me worry now that Nikki doesn’t really believe in silver linings, because she says The Great Gatsby is the greatest novel ever written by an American, and yet it ends so sadly. One thing’s for sure, Nikki is going to be very proud of me when I tell her I finally read her favorite book.xa0Here’s another surprise: I’m going to read all the novels on her American literature class syllabus, just to make her proud, to let her know that I am really interested in what she loves and I am making a real effort to salvage our marriage, especially since I will now be able to converse with her swanky literary friends, saying things like, “I’m thirty. I’m five years too old to lie to myself and call it honor,” which Nick says toward the end of Fitzgerald’s famous novel, but the line works for me too, because I am also thirty, so when I say it, I will sound really smart. We will probably be chatting over dinner, and the reference will make Nikki smile and laugh because she will be so surprised that I have actually read The Great Gatsby. That’s part of my plan, anyway, to deliver that line real suave, when she least expects me to “drop knowledge”—to use another one of my black friend Danny’s lines.xa0God, I can’t wait.xa0Excerpted from The SILVER LININGS PLAYBOOK by Matthew QuickCopyright © 2008 by Matthew Quick Published in 2008 by Farrar, Straus and GirouxAll rights reserved. This work is protected under copyright laws and reproduction is strictly prohibited. Permission to reproduce the material in any manner or medium must be secured from the Publisher. Continues... Excerpted from The Silver Linings Playbook [movie tie-in edition] by Matthew Quick Copyright © 2012 by Matthew Quick. Excerpted by permission. All rights reserved. No part of this excerpt may be reproduced or reprinted without permission in writing from the publisher.Excerpts are provided by Dial-A-Book Inc. solely for the personal use of visitors to this web site. Read more

Features & Highlights

  • A
  • New York Times
  • bestseller,
  • The Silver Linings Playbook
  • was adapted into the Oscar-winning movie starring Bradley Cooper and Jennifer Lawrence. It tells the riotous and poignant story of how one man regains his memory and comes to terms with the magnitude of his wife's betrayal.
  • During the years he spends in a neural health facility, Pat Peoples formulates a theory about silver linings: he believes his life is a movie produced by God, his mission is to become physically fit and emotionally supportive, and his happy ending will be the return of his estranged wife, Nikki. When Pat goes to live with his parents, everything seems changed: no one will talk to him about Nikki; his old friends are saddled with families; the Philadelphia Eagles keep losing, making his father moody; and his new therapist seems to be recommending adultery as a form of therapy. When Pat meets the tragically widowed and clinically depressed Tiffany, she offers to act as a liaison between him and his wife, if only he will give up watching football, agree to perform in this year's Dance Away Depression competition, and promise not to tell anyone about their "contract." All the while, Pat keeps searching for his silver lining. In this brilliantly written debut novel, Matthew Quick takes us inside Pat's mind, deftly showing us the world from his distorted yet endearing perspective. The result is a touching and funny story that helps us look at both depression and love in a wonderfully refreshing way.

Customer Reviews

Rating Breakdown

★★★★★
30%
(2.8K)
★★★★
25%
(2.3K)
★★★
15%
(1.4K)
★★
7%
(644)
23%
(2.1K)

Most Helpful Reviews

✓ Verified Purchase

The Movie or The Book? -- I loved Quick's version beter

I will admit I spend a great deal of time in the movie theater, probably more than I should. But I do love to see how a director and the screenwriter visualize an author’s work. I’ve watched the movie, Silver Linings Playbook, several times. I was thrilled to see the quality of acting by Bradley Cooper, Robert DeNiro, and Jennifer Lawrence. The characters touched my heart during this wonderfully directed film.

More importantly, the movie motivated me to read the book.

Written in first person, author Matthew Quick draws you right in with the main character, Pat Peoples, and describes effectively the illness he faces. Peoples is diagnosed as bi-polar and the author stays true to the character in how he presents the story in every aspect.

What struck me as I read along were the vast differences in the way some of the characters were shown on the big screen compared to the book. Pat Peoples is trying to make his way back into the world after spending time in a mental facility. He is embraced by his mother but shunned by his father in the book. The movie presents Pat’s dad as caring, dedicated and loving.

There are other examples of extremes between the two that will eventually make you appreciate how the author presents his story. I won’t delve into this for fear of killing the wonderful surprises that arise in the movie and the book.

There are some similarities though with the two in the plot. But there weren’t enough of them to convince me that the movie stayed true to Quick’s novel.

The bottom line is this — you would be cheating yourself if you only saw it on the big screen. And you need to be patient with the book version. At first, I had the notion that the movie had done a better job in telling the story.

It took a while for Quick to reach deeper into the depth of the characters. This is the selling point of the book. Quick does a terrific job in letting the characters play off of each other in some funny and dire circumstances. This is present in the movie, too, but not on the scale of the book.

I will not spoil this for you by showing any more examples. You’ll notice how the story Quick wrote is done with strength and courage and truth to what he disease is and how it can manhandle even the strongest person.

What about the ending? The movie version ignores the ending of the book. It’s more Hollywood. Well, it is Hollywood.

The ending in the book version is better.

In fact, it’s perfect.

Quick’s story will inspire you. It will help educate you on what bi-polar is and can do to the individual person, their families, and their lovers. He takes you deep into that dark world and somehow manages to shine a bit of light and hope.

It will help you understand that everyone deserves to be loved, no matter what the struggle one faces.

It will motivate you to read more.

There’s something so magical about a book. It’s a grand feeling sweeping over your soul when you are falling in love with a story and the characters under a lamp at 2 a.m. in the morning.

Happy reading.
46 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

BAD book-zero stars

OH DAMN~ I hated this book personally as a lousy read and professionally as a psychotherapist and professor of psychology. I reluctantly went to my book club this evening as this was the "chosen" book. I expressed my disgust at the characterization of mentally ill as mentally challenged, the portrayal of Pat as being unable to reason or use anything beyond childish words (The Bad Place, Apart Time, not being able to calculate the amount of the restaurant bill and subsequently leaving "a tip Nikki would like/approve of"...About $35 for a $5 tab... I resented that there was no extant symptomatology that would indicate the necessity of a commitment into a "neural institute" (what the hell is that???), the very idea that a single episode of infidelity by the wife would result in a psychotic break, that a massive physical assault on her lover would be bargained down by a PA to commitment into a mental hospital, the "wonderful" (NOT) therapist Cliff that broke all boundaries and ethical standards of conduct, etc. etc. There were so many holes in this book, so many self indulgent confabulations by the writer that I felt it should have been presented as a fantasy, not a novel. It is sad that my book group naively accepted his portrayal as accurate, without analytical thought, that it did show the pain of being mentally ill. OH PLEASE, it was so hard not to go into a lecture from Intro Psych about the difference between insanity and psychosis and the idea that people can snap into a psychosis, legal commitment, danger to self and others, therapeutic boundaries, etc. etc. . This book is so misleading that I resent paper being wasted/words spent on discussing it, let alone time spent reading the poor writing.
22 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Horrible

I'm about 3/4 of the way through this book and it's taking everything I have to finish it. It reads like Pat (the main character) is a 5 year old which leaves me completely disconnected with him. There is no storyline and it drags on and on. I skipped paragraphs and paragraphs about Eagles play action that I thought was beyond boring. Every night I begin to read I think, tonight I will read something that will make this book worth it and then I'm disappointed again. After hearing the great reviews about the movie I thought I would read the book first to hold true to the "book is always better" and I wish I would have just skipped the book all together. The only reason I will even finish this book is to find out what "apart time" really means. I mean really, a 34 year old man calls a separation from his wife "apart time" and the institution he was in "the bad place". UGH!!!
17 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

The Silver Linings Playbook

Matthew Quick tugged at my heartstrings with The Silver Linings Playbook. We get the story through the eyes of thirty-something Patrick Peoples who as the story begins is finally going home after a few years stay in a mental hospital. Pat’s mom fought hard to get him out and as part of his release agreement he has to continue seeing a therapist and continue taking medications. When Pat gets home to New Jersey you see the dysfunction in his family. His father, his brother and himself are all die-hard Eagles fans. Football is a constant in Pat’s life and it is one of the few things that makes him happy and feel normal again. It is also the main thing that allows bonding time with him and his Dad.

Without going into too much detail, we learn the reason for Pat’s stay at the mental hospital later on in the story as it is finally revealed to himself since he mentally blocks it out.

Author Matthew Quick masterfully infuses humor throughout a story that tackles the topic of mental health. He creates characters we can root for and this is a book with plenty of heart. The story-line flowed smoothly and if it weren’t for daily obligations like work and such I would have finished this book in one sitting.

Patrick is trying to get his life together and that is always an admirable thing. The side characters like Pat’s mom, his therapist, his best friend Ronnie, his brother Jake and Tiffany, all added to the story-line.

The film version is one of my favorites, the cast is wonderful, and now that I have read the book, it’s a favorite as well. Although slightly different from the movie, the book is great because you really get to see the story through Patrick’s eyes. This is a story about starting over and moving on and the importance of friends and family as part of the healing process. I rooted for Pat all the way.
16 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

It happens very rarely, but this time the film was BETTER than the book

I almost can't believe those words came out of my mouth. But they did so let me elaborate. The book didn't give enough room to other characters so much, like Tiffany who has enough charm and mystery to intrigue the readers. We are given very vague snippets of her past and background. The book is all Pat and the Eagles football team. God knows I love and watch football regularly and I see how the love for Eagles fit the story, but it went on and on and on. The middle part was nothing but congestion of Eagles worship and I found myself dozing off and skipping pages. If it propelled the story further and gave some insight into Pat's relationship with his father, I would have understood it better and maybe even appreciated it, but none of those emotional aspects were there.

The film was so fantastic, I just had to read the book and it left me greatly disappointed. The writing is fantastic, the pace of story is fast and interesting, but the magic of silver linings the film represented so well, was not compelling enough in this book.
9 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Unfortunately just not that impressed

There will be spoilers.

I felt guilty for not liking this book. I wanted to. I wanted to read it before seeing the movie since everyone crowed about how wonderful it was and Jennifer Lawrence won an Oscar for her performance (that she should have won for Winter's Bone or The Poker House instead). Now I'm not in any hurry to see the movie, because unless the movie does something to make Pat less frustrating, I wouldn't be able to sit through it.

Our hero, Pat, is released from "the bad place", a neural rehabilitation center, into the care of his parents. There are vague hints about how he ended up in there, and we slowly realize that Pat's been through something very bad involving his wife - who we soon realize is only his wife in his mind - and is trying to rebuild his life. Pat works out and waxes eloquent about how he is going to be a better husband for his wife after "apart time" ends. He improves himself by working out obsessively all day, every day. He reads books so he can be more intellectual. He tries to reconnect with his family. Oh, and above all, he believes in silver linings. Everything has to have a happy ending, a silver lining. He has the requisitely quirky therapist he sees once a week. His therapist as well as his friends and family try to push him into a new romance so he can get over his wife. We know what "apart time" means, but Pat refuses to let go of his fantasy. His new relationship is with another depressed and damaged soul. And there you have one of the many glaring things that bothered me.

Pat was also singularly one of the most frustrating and annoying characters I think I've ever read. I couldn't and can't stand him. I didn't really feel one way or the other about Tiffany, except feel sad for her, and I wondered who on earth thought trying to distract Pat by using this fragile, damaged woman was a good idea. It's made clear many times that people have tried to get Pat to remember and live with reality, but his single-minded focus on his wife drove me up a wall. I get that he had explosive anger issues and what with the working out he was physically imposing and due to his history potentially dangerous, but it irritated me that rather than actually helping him, they enabled him. His parents to me were the real characters, and his mother was what made the whole thing tolerable for me.

Pat was a nonentity to me, a blank on the page. An annoying blank on the page. And why anyone was angry with Tiffany for doing what she did to try and help him (in her mind, as misguided as she was, BUT WHY WOULDN'T SHE BE), what were they thinking? Her character was more wooden than Pat, and while I can see her doing what she did and understanding why, if everyone knew she was that unstable and that depressed, why even think that either of them would be good for the other? And the dancing - yes, I get the whys and the hows, but it was written so strangely, it seemed wedged in and didn't really fit.

I'm not bashing the mentally ill, or the mentally handicapped. And Pat didn't strike me as mentally handicapped, he struck me as garden-variety delusional. I didn't feel that being in that home environment or with Tiffany was good for him in any way. I understand that in the real world we all make decisions that are not the ideal but are the best we can do under the circumstances. I know that's what Pat's mother and family wanted for him, but all I could see them doing was enabling him. And I completely feel that the therapist was written while the author pictured Ben Kingsley in all his quirky glory, even if that wasn't who plays him in the movie. At any rate, no therapist would A) risk setting off a delusional patient in the waiting room, or B) socialize with a patient outside of the therapeutic environment. And yes it's a book and yes it's supposed to make their connection stronger and yes I know that it's nitpicking but that's how much it bothered me.

It wasn't a badly written book, it just seemed threadbare, and not really at all in connection to mental health or recovery from a breakdown. And I understand that Pat's relentless delusional belief in happy endings was supposed to be charming and uplifting, but to me it was just sad.
5 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Quick read, kind of boring, unimpressed

I got this book because of the trailer alone, with Bradley Cooper and Jennifer Lawrence. I was expecting the same witty dialogue going back and forth between the two, which is almost non-existant in the book. Also, the concept of the narrator being mentally incapacitated in some way seems to be a trend these days, and I'm starting to think that it's a cover for the author to be able to write in very simple, and quite frankly, easy to write language. There are a few funny moments, but for the most part the book is monotonous, repetitive, and predictable. The characters don't go deep enough for me. If not for the movie, which I am still looking forward to because I think they've added where the book is lacking, I wouldn't have read it.
5 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

See movie forget the book

I can barely believe how this, one reader called it "juvenile", novel got published in the first place? Now this mediocre novelist, Matthew Quick, sorry bro' I know you worked hard to write a novel. But where were the editors, and why in the world did Sarah Crichton publish this novel? So the writer's catapulted into fame and fortune with only a germ of a story that was immensely improved by the script writer who should win an academy award for turning the "novel" into a really interesting movie when the original gave him so little to work with. The main character is just infuriating, and I can't just excuse this as a mental illness, even a "nut" would be more interesting than this guy. He's less than pathetic, he's "stupid." And the rest of the story, mostly about football, is mostly boring, especially when you see how Hollywood improved it.
The novel is poorly structured,averagely at best written, poorly plotted, the chapters titles are insufferable, the barrage of "letters" included in the novel too much, too long, and mostly uninteresting. Dump them for the most part as the script writer did and use the theme, as he did, to tighten and heighten the effectiveness of the story.
Now Matthew Quick has a two book deal,how in the world did he pitch this inferior novel to Hollywood? And it will be interesting to see what he can do in the future. I'm not optimistic, I don't think he can live up to the hype. He may have some talent, I'll give "Playbook" that much, but, you know, easy fame and fortune can ruin a writer, the expectations alone, now that he's "famous," have the potential of ruining him. The movie only proves just how much out of his depth he was when he wrote the novel, I can only hope that he improves, hope, I said.
What a strange odyssey. A maybe less than average novel is made into a good movie, the writer is largely ignored except to go out and "shill" the movie, he gets easy, unearned success, there are thousands of better novels self-published, or never published out there that makes me conclude that the whole scene, who didn't know this, is all money driven, and a young, inexperienced, he did get his MFA, writer becomes a mere pigeon for the powers that be and becomes a mere pawn in the game.
4 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

A book of many emotions

I LOVED this book! I honestly didn't know what to expect going into it apart from the commercials I spotted for the movie on TV. I really wanted to see the movie but never got the chance to, and then my friend lent me the book instead! As I figure it's always better to read the book before the movie, anyway, now I'll really have the chance to compare the two! (Though I do love Jennifer Lawrence, so that might be a little biased. xD)

Having Pat tell the story was amazing. He was such an unpredictable, unreliable narrator that I never knew what was coming next. He never did, either, as he something has mood swings as a result of something that he can't remember. He's telling the story because he's writing it all down so he can tell his wife about what he did while she was gone from him, in their "apart time". But he writes in even the bad parts because he's determined now to be a good husband and that means not lying about that kind of thing anymore. Because Pat can't understand himself, it takes the reader the whole novel to figure out what he's really like, too.

Tiffany was also a great character. Actually, all of the characters are great, though I don't know if that simply comes from Pat's blunt, to-the-point narrative. The writing style was spectacular enough to make me not mind that not much was happening for some of it. I don't really enjoy watching football but Pat is obsessed with it. He made me care, too, with what he had to say about it and the effect it had on the people around him. If a book, or a narrator, can do something like that, I think it's fantastic.

Pat thinks of his life in a movie, so my favorite part was definitely the montage. I loved reading about what parts he thought would be most important, what should be included in full and what needed to be breezed over. I can't wait to see how this all fits into the actual movie!

I give The Silver Linings Playbook 5/5 stars. Pat has a great philosophy in life; he thinks that everything can have a happy ending, if you only look hard enough for the silver lining. I think that everyone could use some thoughts like that, and you might even fall in love with this book as well.
4 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

I have mixed feelings about this novel.

I have mixed feelings about this novel. Admittedly, I breezed through this in one sitting. This shows two basic things about the book: it's engaging, and it's exceedingly easy to read.

But while I won't deny that it kept me entertained, I find it very problematic in its depiction of a person with mental illness. How so? In short: most people who are mentally ill don't sound like children. In other words, having, say, bipolar disorder or depression doesn't mean that you're going to sound as stupid as the protagonist does. The idea that mental patients are unintelligent by default is precisely what makes people start speaking down to the patients in psychiatric hospitals. (As a woman with bipolar disorder who has been hospitalized for it, I can assure you that it's absolutely infuriating when that happens.) Alas, this book will do nothing to change that; if anything, it'll make staff members more likely to assume that the crazy people in their care are also idiots. At least the film, for all its faults, had a protagonist who could have plausibly graduated high school.

Another problem is that, for a novel, it doesn't seem to like classic novels very much. For one, the plots of several classics ruined for anybody unfortunate enough to not have read them yet; secondly, the narrator complains, in his limited way, about almost each and every one of them. He has no appreciation for literature whatsoever! I suppose it wouldn't quite fit if the character was able to analyze books brilliantly due to his aforementioned stupidity. But it's rather strange to find a book in which the classics are so maligned, regardless of why that's the case. (Where's your respect for great books, Mr. Quick? Seriously, that's not okay!) But I guess that we should all be watching football instead of reading anyway, though, because clearly football fixes everything.

So I don't know. It was entertaining. But it was also very problematic as far as portrayals of the mentally ill go, and against intellectual pursuits. I guess in the end I'm going to have to go with "mixed feelings" and leave it at that. After all, I am bipolar; I couldn't possibly come up with anything more complex now, could I?
3 people found this helpful