"Keith McCafferty has pulled off a small miracle with The Royal Wulff Murders - a compelling Montana-based novel that will please both mystery readers and discerning fly-fishers. A terrific debut that rings with authenticity and style."---C. J. Box, New York Times bestselling author of Back ofxa0 Beyond and Force of Nature — C. J. Box " The Royal Wulff Murders hit all my buttons: mystery, flyfishing, Montana, the Madison River, beautiful women, and whole pickup loads of authentic Montana characters, many of them wonderfully quirky. Keith McCafferty is one terrific writer."---Patrick F. McManus, author of The Bear In the Attic and The Huckleberry Murders — Patrick F. McManus "Blue Ribbon is what they call a trout stream of extremely high quality and that's what I call Keith McCafferty's The Royal Wulff Murders - the debut of a frighteningly knowledgeable and wonderfully entertaining series." — Craig Johnson, author of The Cold Dish and Hell is Empty “A fish story with a homicidal hook… An entertaining debut.” — Kirkus Reviews “[A] thoroughly entertaining debut…McCafferty blends plenty of fly-fishing lore with a host of intriguing characters…Only the sharp-eyed observation of the medical examiner suggests the body was a murder victim rather than an accidental drowning. The eventual identification of the victim helps link Stranahan’s task to that of the sheriff. The vivid Montana setting is a plus.” — Publishers Weekly (starred review) "The dead man whose eye is skewered with a stick and who has a trout fly hooked into his lip sets the tone for this muscular, original first novel. McCafferty is one of the country's most convincing writers on survival and life in the wilderness, and this mystery is an impressive foray into fiction---taut, often highly amusing, filled with memorable characters like the lady sheriff and the former private eye who paints and fly fishes---and it's a real page turner." — Nick Lyons, author of My Secret Fishing Life “Keith McCafferty hits a bull's eye with Sean's story in his debut novel, The Royal Wulff Murders … like bacon and brownies--Stranahan's odd mix of painter, P.I. and fly fisher works... The mystery is a good fit for enthusiasts of Nevada Barr who have read through all the Anna Pigeon novels. Packed with wilderness action and starring a band of stalwart individualists, The Royal Wulff Murders will have readers begging McCafferty for more.” — ShelfAwareness.com "What a fine and thoroughly satisfying debut novel!xa0There’s so much to enjoy here—a fresh sense of place, a cast of compelling characters, and a plot line with as many twists and turns as a Montana trout stream.xa0Even if you know nothing about fly fishing, you’re going to love this book.xa0Mark my words: From this day forward, you’ll be buying everything Keith McCafferty writes." — William Kent Krueger, author of Northwest Angle and Iron Lake "Keith McCafferty's The Royal Wulff Murders is the mystery fly anglers have been waiting for. Finally, an author who knows the crucial difference between 2X and 4X tippet! But it's not just the fishing details that make this novel so enjoyable: it's the rich characters, the robust sense of humor, a sadly topical plot, and a writing style that is as gin-clear as a Montana trout stream." — Paul Doiron, author of Trespasser and The Poacher’s Son "The last time I fished the Madison River it was high, fast, and dirty—words that come to mind for parts of McCafferty’s tangy debut mystery.xa0But there are also episodes of angling wonder and Montana beauty, rendered in prose so gorgeous they make this book a truly rare catch, the page-turner that doubles as a poetic meditation.xa0(Now how about taking me out on the river, dude?)"—Mark Kingwell, author of Catch and Release: Trout Fishing and the Meaning of Life — Mark Kingwell “Sportsmen will find the one-of-a-kind novel captivating, intelligent, and at times uproarious." — Field & Stream "What fun it is to visit my favorite fishing spots , not in a guide- boat but in a wonderful murder mystery." — Henry Winkler, author of I've Never Met an Idiot on the River Keith McCafferty is the award-winning survival editor of Field & Stream magazine , with a circulation of 1.25 million. He lives and works in Montana. This is his first novel.
Features & Highlights
The first novel in the clever and fast-paced Sean Stranahan Mystery Series.
When a fishing guide reels in the body of a young man on the Madison, the Holy Grail of Montana trout rivers, Sheriff Martha Ettinger suspects foul play. It's not just the stick jammed into the man's eye that draws her attention; it's the Royal Wulff trout fly stuck in his bloated lower lip. Following her instincts, Ettinger soon finds herself crossing paths with Montana newcomer Sean Stranahan.
Fly fisher, painter, and has-been private detective, Stranahan left a failed marriage and lackluster career to drive to Montana, where he lives in an art studio decorated with fly-tying feathers and mouse droppings. With more luck catching fish than clients, Stranahan is completely captivated when Southern siren Velvet Lafayette walks into his life, intent on hiring his services to find her missing brother. The clues lead Stranahan and Ettinger back to Montana's Big Business: fly fishing. Where there's money, there's bound to be crime.
Customer Reviews
Rating Breakdown
★★★★★
30%
(418)
★★★★
25%
(348)
★★★
15%
(209)
★★
7%
(97)
★
23%
(320)
Most Helpful Reviews
★★★★★
5.0
AHEWLH24PXUDZB6L4JBI...
✓ Verified Purchase
A New and Refreshing Mystery Writer
This book captivated me from the first few pages. Not because of the mystery plot itself--although that will keep you scratching your head and reading into the night--but because of the quality of writing and depth of detail. This new mystery writer clearly takes as much delight in his unusual and well conceived characters as he does in the wilderness backdrop of Montana, where he seduces you with his love of fishing, his knowledge of birds and animals and rivers and local lore. Whether you're an outdoors person or not, you'll catch yourself imagining a life in Big Sky Country, where Sean Stranahan retreats from a broken marriage to take up landscape painting and, somewhat inadvertently, being a private detective. He's not your typical PI, full of swagger and martial arts. In fact, there are no prefab characters in this book--each one stands on their own haunches and casts a shadow (as Faulkner once said).
When you finish reading a book like this you don't want it to end. And I don't think it will. I believe this is the debut of a gifted mystery writer who obviously is full of knowledge and love of what he writes. I can't wait to see what comes next.
Heartily recommended.
15 people found this helpful
★★★★★
5.0
AGLPKBBA6KJSE34BXKWX...
✓ Verified Purchase
These Characters are Good Company
As finely wrought as the hand tied Royal Wulff trout fly in the title, this novel soon had me hooked. I like books infused with the romantic traditions of the Old West but I want them updated, please. And that's what this mystery does. The classic characters here include a spunky little woman who, because feminists like me rattled society's bars, is now cast as the town sheriff instead of its schoolteacher, a slinky saloon singer named Velvet Lafayette (not so updated) with a mysterious past, and a helpful Indian guide, I mean Native American tracker, who is not opposed to inter-racial dating. Because this is set in the contemporary west, McMansions owned by Californians line the best fishing rivers while locals struggle to earn a living from the visiting gentry without losing the land and culture they love.
McCafferty's underlying theme is stewardship of nature in a tourism based economy where greed can kill the golden goose. It's a conundrum facing many of our so-called Last Best Places that have become vacation locations for the wealthy "one percent" while the locals play service roles (and the rest of the country gets a landscape that's either prefabricated or, in poor neighborhoods, just plain boarded up). McCafferty's Montana is worth protecting.
I am not a science fiction fan. I like even my novels to teach me about a real place which the writer knows more about than I do. McCafferty knows his territory well. I learned a lot about trout fishing, the book's central passion, and about whirling disease, a real threat to trout in many rivers. I think with his long years of journalism at Field & Stream Magazine, McCafferty's combination of writing skills with outdoor skills is rare if not unique these days. Sociable, droll and generally optimistic, given that there's a killer on the loose, McCafferty's characters are good company and I hope they get to horseback ride and sing and fish their way through many more novels after this satisfying debut.
4 people found this helpful
★★★★★
5.0
AGFGGNBMD4HVPCNZ7KG5...
✓ Verified Purchase
Murder, Adventure, Montana
The Royal Wulff Murders is a riveting and oftentimes hilarious and poignant story of murder, mystery, and love. I was hooked on page one--when you've seen a lot of crime movies and television and read a lot of newspaper police reports and crime and noir novels it's a sort of dark delight to find a corpse that is, so to speak, new, and I think a guy with a trout fly in his lip, dead in a river fits that bill. The book is great, though reading about death and fishing doesn't do anything to calm my worst fears when I'm all alone on the Hoh or the Bogie or the Sol Duc River out on the Olympic Peninsula because fishing out here often means fishing alone and in the rain, sometimes spooking myself in the isolation--the OP is about as creepy and frightening a location as can be (maybe McCafferty should set a book out here someday--Twilight is fine for the tweens, but Forks is really a fisherman's town and a logger's town... but I digress). The book moves at a good clip along the rivers and roads of Montana, and charts the small town life in that relative Eden of the world where I've been lucky enough to have lived and fished a good deal myself. Montana is the most beautiful place I've ever been, and McCafferty does an excellent job of conveying that beauty in his prose. I love his character Rainbow Sam, a fishing guide who reminds me of more than a few crazy fish bums I've met, and I finished the book before I knew it, and can't wait to read whatever comes next from this outstanding author (whose very fine stories in Field & Stream magazine, by the way, have been a source of reading pleasure all my life).
3 people found this helpful
★★★★★
3.0
AHGIGGL55VRVHVCQYXOC...
✓ Verified Purchase
For Those Who Truly Love Fishing...and Mysteries
Fishing, fly or in any other variety, is not my thing at all. Heck, I hardly even at fish, mostly only under duress. I am perfectly happy to let them keep doing their thing. Nor do I have any desire to ever go fishing myself. Mysteries aren't my preferred reading either. But I try to be somewhat open-minded about my reading choices, so when the lure of a fly fishing mystery was dropped in front of me, I bit.
Should I have? Maybe not. The opening parts were definitely hard on me. There was so much fishing, like back-to-back fishing. This probably would have been okay if there had been some interesting conversations accompanying the fishing, but a lot of it was just someone out fishing with lots of details of fish and lures and bait and whatever. So not my thing.
Thankfully, things picked up when the sheriff got more page time. I liked her; she's a sassy woman kicking butt in a traditionally masculine profession. Plus, she doesn't fish, which meant that that did not happen much when she was around.
On the contrary, I did not like Velvet at all. The stage name is ridiculous, but her real name, Vareda Beaudreux, is no better. Really though, that's not the issue, because that would be absurd and unfair. Velvet/Varena is one of those women that men all of over the world seem to obsess over: beautiful, tortured, mysterious. A completely different writer, John Green, has written two books about girls like this. What is the fascination, guys? I'd like to know because I so do not get it. Throw the crazy ones back!
Basically, I'm not an ideal judge of this book. However, I do think that as mysteries go, it's a pretty good one. Anyone who loves to fish and to read mysteries should not miss this.
3 people found this helpful
★★★★★
5.0
AEV7YPZ7UWU6SFKTKNFQ...
✓ Verified Purchase
A treasure to savor
I read a lot of crime novels and mysteries, and then I also read "literary fiction." Few can pull off both the way Keith has done here. I loved the perfectly crafted passages that capture the essence of what one goes to Montana for: the transcendence of connecting with nature, vast silent space, overwhelming physical beauty, the unfolding of time at its own pace. I loved how the sense of place and time is seamlessly interwoven with a wonderfully complex and engaging story line, full of characters you hope to see at the bar next time.
If you've never been to Montana and wonder what all the fuss is about, read this book slowly, savoring the amazingly accurate descriptions of the land, the magic of being on the water, the majesty that is Montana. If you've been to Montana, you'll appreciate the artistry of this book even more. And if you just want a delicious, nutritious read that doesn't insult your intelligence, buy this book.
Hated to finish it, can't wait for another!
2 people found this helpful
★★★★★
3.0
AGE522R3Q7EE2UQ5VLYH...
✓ Verified Purchase
Unique outdoors mystery
In the small town of Bridger, Montana, Rainbow Sam and his client snag more than trout on their fishing trip. Instead of a trophy trout, they hook a dead body! Sheriff Martha Ettinger and her deputy Walter Hess try to determine if the young man drowned accidentally or if it was murder. In the meantime, Sean Stranahan, artist and part-time PI, is hired by a mysterious singer from Mississippi to find the location her late father had gone fishing the year before so she can spread his ashes in that spot of the river. Sean soon learns there is more to this case than meets the eye and ends up heavily involved in a murder investigation and in the life of his beautiful client.
The Royal Wulff is a type of trout fishing fly and this novel is all about fly fishing. It's not just a gimmick to catch the reader's eye, this is an authentic outdoors mystery and fishing is important to the characters and to the murder. The book also addresses whirling disease, a real issue of concern in many rivers, and something I had not been previously aware of.
I like the character of Sean who is both a man's man and a lady's man. He is an outdoorsman that is knowledgeable about fishing and lures, but is apparently irresistible to attractive, older women including a woman in his past, his client Velvet, and the sheriff. Martha is also a likeable character. She is intelligent and funny and determined to get to the bottom of the case she is handed. Velvet is a bit clichéd as the beautiful singer who hires and falls for Sean. She is an enigma, but I never quite understood why she had to act so mysteriously.
The novel is an unusual mix of a hard-boiled detective mystery and a literary novel. The book works best when describing the outdoors. The romantic storyline falls flat for me and some of the dialogue seems forced and a bit stilted. Parts of the book are definitely aimed more at male readers, such as detailed information about changes in pinup models throughout the years. While some portions of the book went on a little too long, the storyline is interesting and the mysteries being investigated by Martha and Sean have satisfying resolutions. However, the book's ending seems abrupt to me and I wished there would have at least been an epilogue to tie a few of the loose ends together. This is a unique book that fans of Robert B. Parker or C.J. Box may enjoy.
I received this book from NetGalley through the courtesy of Penguin/Viking.
2 people found this helpful
★★★★★
5.0
AE4PBZWY6Y2XJ2JD4MWQ...
✓ Verified Purchase
An Exciting New Mystery Writer
This book is not about fly fishing. It is, however, set in a place so inescapable that the place becomes a major character in the tale. Kay Scarpetta and Lucas Davenport could work anywhere, but John Carter and the Camel Club could only be in Washington, where the city and the government are major players. So it is with main characters of this book Sean Shanahan and Martha Ettinger, out and about in the wilds of Montana. After all, this is the home of John Colter's naked run to freedom, the Freemen-FBI standoff, and Sheriff Johnny France's single handed apprehension of Dan and Don Nicols. the father-son mountainmen kidnappers. It's not anywhere else.
Keith McCafferty, leprechaun savant, is a master story teller. He has crafted an intriguing, suspenseful and well paced mystery, with a complex set of circumstances into which the appealing, vibrant characters are drawn. The dialogue is spot on. The prose is evocative and sometimes lyrical. One commenter correctly called the story "tangy."
McCafferty's characters are well drawn, quirky and true to life. I live in Hyalite County and I swear I know these people. I definitely know the geography and although literary requirements have made a jumble of it, my corner of Montana is otherwise accurately portrayed. In his future work, I expect to see the mountains, wildlife and weather play major roles, as they do so crucially in our outdoor life here.
I don't want to rehash the story line but do want to share an example of the book. I had trouble finding selections that were both brief enough and wouldn't spoil your read, but here is something to show what this new novelist can do:
"There are many ways of feeling alone. There is the squeezed-chest loneliness of walking down a dark alleyway, and there is the self reliant isolation of fishing a midnight river in wilderness. There is that delicious hollow feeling of standing alone in a slumbering city, waiting for the light to change on the metropolitan avenue shining under the street lamps after the rain, secure in the knowledge that the woman whose bed you have left is dreaming about you and it is two against the world-a loneliness built for two. And then there is the devastation of being left by someone you love."
Some commenters have said they could not identify with or enjoy the book as they are not fly fishers. Since a large portion of native Montanans have never ridden a subway, should they reject books about New York City? Would you skip Steinbeck and Stegner because they're "California" writers? Of course not. Consider McCafferty properly in the company of Tony Hillerman, CJ Box and Craig Johnson. Consider The Royal Wulff Murders an opportunity to peak into an unique culture, accurately portrayed by McCafferty and different from your own, while enjoying a rockin' good tale of greed and lust and murder. And incidentally, fly fishing.
1 people found this helpful
★★★★★
5.0
AGV7NWL4QCTPSRKKM6O3...
✓ Verified Purchase
Thank you!!
The book came very fast and was in excellent shaped as advertised.
★★★★★
4.0
AE3ZO6O7B62I2GZBB3BM...
✓ Verified Purchase
Four Stars
Nice read
★★★★★
4.0
AFMUCL2OIU5VFWWWNVRI...
✓ Verified Purchase
If you like C. J
If you like C. J. Box Joe Prickett novels you should like this book. It has the west, fly fishing and some twist to the plot.