The Myth of the Holy Cow
The Myth of the Holy Cow book cover

The Myth of the Holy Cow

Paperback – February 12, 2004

Price
$14.00
Format
Paperback
Pages
120
Publisher
Verso
Publication Date
ISBN-13
978-1859844243
Dimensions
6.36 x 0.46 x 8.72 inches
Weight
8.7 ounces

Description

“A well-argued and soundly documented study...” ( Choice )“Not since Salman Rushdie's Satanic Verses ... has a book caused such a violent reaction.” ( Observer )“While cow veneration and vegetarianism may be the hallmarks of Hinduism today, Mr. Jha compiles copious evidence that this has hardly always been the case.” ( New York Times )“A meticulously researched, strongly worded, persuasively articulated challenge to long-held religious beliefs, The Myth of the Holy Cow is a unique and iconoclastic contribution to the study of Hindu beliefs, practices, history and customs.” ( Wisconsin Bookwatch )“Jha draws on an amazingly wide range of material … an enlightening endeavour, demonstrating a critical understanding of a popular misconception.” ( Journal of Asian Studies )“The pen might still be, if not mightier than the nuclear arsenal, at least a weapon worth scanning for, like knives at airports, a weapon capable of subversion.” ( Times Literary Supplement )“This book may not please Hindu fundamentalists, but its research is impeccable.” ( The Telegraph, Calcutta, India ) Dwijendra Narayan Jha is Professor of History at the University of Delhi. His books include Ancient India in Historical Outline and Feudal Social Formation in Early India .

Features & Highlights

  • A book the government of India demands be ritually burned.
  • Hugely controversial upon its publication in India, this book has already been banned by the Hyderabad Civil Court and the author's life has been threatened. Jha argues against the historical sanctity of the cow in India, in an illuminating response to the prevailing attitudes about beef that have been fiercely supported by the current Hindu right-wing government and the fundamentalist groups backing it.

Customer Reviews

Rating Breakdown

★★★★★
60%
(170)
★★★★
25%
(71)
★★★
15%
(42)
★★
7%
(20)
-7%
(-20)

Most Helpful Reviews

✓ Verified Purchase

Is this real?

As a beef eating Hindu I am very much interested in finding how cows became holy for Hindus and beef a forbidden thing to eat. I browsed through this book in a book store and found it to be very disappointing.

First, it appeared to be intended more for creating controversy than for informational purposes. It clearly had a bias which turned me off.

Second, I am generally up-to date on current issues and remembered that it did not generate all that controversy as mentioned on the cover of the book. There were some rumblings but nothing of the sort described on the covers ("the government of India demands be ritually burned").

Later I searched on google with the book title and words "ban", "government of India" and found no news reports relating any government of India attempts at banning this book. There were no reports on ban by Allahabad High Court either. All I found were book reviews on the book and other articles written mainly by political commentators known for their leftist opinions.

Third, I found some material on internet on how the author misinterpreted much of the scriptures to support his conclusions.

It basically left me disappointed and I am still searching for some reliable and accurate material on this matter.
20 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Poorly made assumptions, low quality discourse

I am by no means a supporter of any traditionalist thinking in and of itself. I bought and read this book because I thought it would be an honest pursuit for the truth. This book is not written in an honest pursuit of knowledge, nor meant to be a good-faith critique on the discourse surrounding religion, diets and consumption of beef in India. The arguments in this book are in bad faith, and completely lacking in nuance. The book makes strange assumptions starting with "holy cow", when the cow is *revered*/sacred, not "holy" (very nuanced difference that a book like this should be able to capture). The arguments are partisan and political instead of the honest examination and critique it presents itself to be. Not worth it. Still looking for honest, neutral academic work on whether the cow was consumed in India circa 1500 BCE, just from the perspective of a quest for objective facts.
4 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Evidence based factual treatise. Blind faith, your move.

Factually rebuts the notion of the "holy cow" being a salient part of Hindu religion. Quotes religious texts by verse and page to make the case. A perfect gift for your favorite indoctrinated friend or family member.
2 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

No No

Very Disappointing book about Cow. Hurt my Feelings.