The Garden of Last Days: A Novel
The Garden of Last Days: A Novel book cover

The Garden of Last Days: A Novel

Hardcover – May 17, 2008

Price
$23.56
Format
Hardcover
Pages
544
Publisher
W. W. Norton & Company
Publication Date
ISBN-13
978-0393041651
Dimensions
6.7 x 1.6 x 9.6 inches
Weight
1.95 pounds

Description

From Publishers Weekly Dubus's ambitious if uneven follow-up to House of Sand and Fog begins shortly before 9/11 with stripper April taking her three-year-old daughter, Franny, to work after the babysitter flakes at the last minute. Though she leaves Franny with the club's house mother and intends to keep tabs on her, April's distracted on the floor by Bassam, a Muslim who's in Florida to take flying lessons and (like one of the real 9/11 hijackers) spends early September 2001 throwing around money and living lasciviously. Meanwhile, AJ, a down-on-his-luck local, lingers in the parking lot after getting thrown out for touching a dancer. The slow-starting plot splinters once Franny wanders outside and disappears. Soon, AJ's wanted for kidnapping, April's run through the social service wringers as an unfit parent, and the murky particulars of Bassam's mission come into sharp focus as he struggles with his religious convictions. Dubus gives the breath of life to most of his characters (Bassam—not so much), though the narrative has a mechanical feeling, partially owing to the narrow emotional register Dubus works in: doom and desperation are in plentiful supply from page one, and as the novel fades to black, the reader's left with a roster of sadder-but-wiser Americans to contemplate. (June) Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved. From The New Yorker Dubusx92s follow-up to "House of Sand and Fog" is inspired by the rumored visit of 9/11 hijackers to a strip club shortly before their attacks. In the fictional Puma Club, in Sarasota, Florida, a twenty-six-year-old named Bassam al-Jizani watches Spring, a stripper, undress, and finds his "hatred for these kufar rising with the knowledge of his own weakness." We know he is entranced, because he does not imagine slitting her throat, as he does with most people he encounters. Bassam recoils from the hedonistic pursuits of the West, yet finds himself drawn to them; losing his virginity to a prostitute, he wonders, "How many years will she be given by the Creator before she will burn?" Imagining the mind of a terrorist, Dubus runs into a familiar problem: Bassamx92s thoughts are a case study in the banality of evil. "Hatred gives him strength," he writes. But it doesnx92t make him interesting. Copyright ©2008 Click here to subscribe to The New Yorker From Bookmarks Magazine Despite criticsâx80x99 high hopes, The Garden of Last Days proves to be a âx80x9cbig, uneven novel with aspirations it canâx80x99t quite fulfillâx80x9d ( Los Angeles Times ). Andre Dubus III nimbly navigates the chasm between culturesâx80"between the world of the intolerant extremist and that of the decadent Westernerâx80"and draws his characters with compassion. Unfortunately, though Dubusâx80x99s research is evident, Bassam emerges as little more than a stereotype, his stilted English, peppered with Arabic phrases, awkward and forced. Dubus slows the plotâx80x99s pace to allow his characters to fully develop, but this choice drains the narrative of tension and robs the climax of its punch. Dubusâx80x99s considerable talent notwithstanding, the daring Garden does not rise to the level of its best-selling predecessor. Copyright © 2004 Phillips & Nelson Media, Inc. From Booklist In the best-selling House of Sand and Fog (1999), Dubus engineered an electrifying conflict between an American woman and an Iranian colonel in exile. In his long-awaited new novel, Dubus fashions another disturbing and revealing encounter between an American woman on the edge and an intense Muslim man. But in this risky and relentless tale set on the verge of 9/11, sexual mores serve as a gauge of the perilous divide between American freedom and Muslim extremism. April is a single mother living in Florida and working as a stripper. When Jean, her babysitter and landlady, is unexpectedly hospitalized, she brings her three-year-old daughter to the Puma Club for Men, clearly courting trouble. And sure enough, while April performs in private for Bassam, a high-strung stranger with a surplus of cash and misery, all hell breaks loose. Narrating commandingly in five voices, Dubus ramps up the suspense while circling back to reveal April’s cruel indoctrination into the stripper’s life, the tragedy that made Bassam a jihadist, Jean’s sorrows, Lonnie the bouncer’s secret, and the dangerous despair of a man he forcibly ejects from the club. Improvising on the pre-attack actions of the 9/11 terrorists, Dubus’ hyperdetailed, visceral,xa0and prurient yet undeniably compassionatexa0thriller boldly explores the bewildering complexities of sexuality, and the dire repercussions of isolation and desperation. --Donna Seaman Andre Dubus III is the author of Such Kindness and 8 other books, including the bestsellers Townie , a memoir, and House of Sand and Fog , a National Book Award Finalist in Fiction and an Oprah’s Book Club selection. He lives in Newburyport, Massachusetts. Read more

Features & Highlights

  • From the author of the
  • New York Times
  • bestseller and Oprah's Book Club selection
  • House of Sand and Fog
  • --a new big-hearted, painful, page-turning novel.
  • One early September night in Florida, a stripper brings her daughter to work. April's usual babysitter is in the hospital, so she decides it's best to have her three-year-old daughter close by, watching children's videos in the office, while she works. Except that April works at the Puma Club for Men. And tonight she has an unusual client, a foreigner both remote and too personal, and free with his money. Lots of it, all cash. His name is Bassam. Meanwhile, another man, AJ, has been thrown out of the club for holding hands with his favorite stripper, and he's drunk and angry and lonely. From these explosive elements comes a relentless, raw, searing, passionate, page-turning narrative, a big-hearted and painful novel about sex and parenthood and honor and masculinity. Set in the seamy underside of American life at the moment before the world changed, it juxtaposes lust for domination with hunger for connection, sexual violence with family love. It seizes the reader by the throat with the same psychological tension, depth, and realism that characterized Andre Dubus's #1 bestseller,
  • House of Sand and Fog--
  • and an even greater sense of the dark and anguished places in the human heart.

Customer Reviews

Rating Breakdown

★★★★★
30%
(108)
★★★★
25%
(90)
★★★
15%
(54)
★★
7%
(25)
23%
(82)

Most Helpful Reviews

✓ Verified Purchase

Not good

I loved "House of Sand and Fog" so bought this book when it first came out. I gave up around page 300. Started skimming ahead and then realized that I really didn't care how it ended anyway. I found it very boring and repetitive--annoyingly so. I got it--A.J.'s wrist hurt. Don't waste your time.
18 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

A complete and utter failure.

Heard all the hype of this book...Stephen King saying it is the best thing he's read in a while...loved the movie of HOUSE OF SAND AND FOG...still have the book and will try it out someday...but this??
Does he have an editor? The endless back stories of each and every character....the monotonous plot...slow pacing, characters that no one can root for...more importantly, even care for.
Total waste of time...skimmed the last 350 pages.
A complete an utter failure.
17 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Predictable, horribly long. . . but finished it nonetheless

Unfortunately, my only response to this book was predictable, well, and let me add--too long--(editor, please note!). After slogging through 500 pages, I felt, okay, that sort of sums up what we all thought after the 9/11 tragedy: whose life had the terrorists touched, where did they spend their time, how did it impact our society and who, in the last moments before entering the plane, had these terrorists talked to. Well, unfortunately, we learn mostly of a seedy encounter at a strip club (with April the stripper), then the next seedy romp with a hooker. Sprinkled throughout in chapter vignettes are flashbacks of the terrorist and his family and upbringing--up to and including the last little terrorist prayer vigil before striking out to destroy lives (I personally did not care one iota about this character). A few other flashbacks and characters are mixed in: the club bouncer (Lonnie), the stripper's landlady (Jean), a man who is a stripper club attendee (AJ). Overall, the book is poorly developed--and do we really, really need all of the other details of the stripper, her wardrobe and all?--and her misbegotten tale of being a single mom, and as the saying goes, working for a living. The life of one of the 9/11 terrorists--who, gosh, has chosen April for his last fling before striking out to Boston--dousing her with cash and all for a little one-on-one time--is just not written well. The book lacked depth and character development. Stephen King review or not (and peer reviews--how subjective can they be anyway?). I recommend flipping through this book before purchase--seriously consider the time you will dedicate to it--and also consider how much of the 'strip club scene' are you really interested in reading about anyway? In my humble opinion, I recommend two other post 9/11 novels: Falling Man by Don DeLillo or Extremely Loud and Incredibly Close by Jonathan Safran Foer.
16 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Bloated Behemoth Needs Editing.

This is one of those books that makes your heart sink as you read it, not because of the leaden subject matter but because of the heavy hand with which it was written and the occasional flashes of brilliance buried between endless pages of absolute nothingness.

Having enjoyed Dubus' previous novel, "House of Sand and Fog" a great deal, I plunged into "The Garden of Last Days" eagerly, and just kept waiting for something, anything in this book to stick. I was left, mostly, with just the character of Jean, who is given short shrift and belongs in another, better book.

Had this book been able to condense what is essentially a character study covering only a few short days into something less than 550 pages (say something along the lines of the length of "House of Sand and Fog," for example) then maybe it would be worth the time spent on it. Still, a disappointment, but at least a worthy, three-star read. As it is, I found this book bloated, overwritten on every count, offensive and vaguely racist. There. I said it. I think Dubus' handling of the Bassam character was confused and stereotypical. Having read this after having read other, more successful dips into post-9/11 lit (Claire Messud's "Emperor's Children", Don DeLillo's "Falling Man"), it just seems slick and preachy, yet unsure of what it's trying to say. Moreover, the novel has undertones of misogyny that are unappealing, and a hasty tendency to paint things in harsh tones of black or white when it's so very, very obvious that Dubus himself thinks he's dabbling only in literary and moral gray-areas.

I did not like this book and I can not recommend it.

As a post-script, I must mention that there is a severe need in the literary world for EDITING. So many books are released these days with hundreds of spare, unnecessary pages that diminish the impact of the final product. This novel and James Frey's latest, "Bright Shiny Morning" (which is still a good read) being the two most obvious recent examples. Authors like Ian McEwan can get across entire lifetimes in under 200 pages...why is it so hard for these guys? The talent is obviously there, but an editor is sorely missed.
14 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Flawed thinking, inevitable disasters

The beauty of this book was the writer's uncanny ability to share the insides of his characters' heads in a believable way. The people are so genuine and the results of their random collisions with each other are so predictable that the tension is in the inevitability of the outcome. You KNEW some characters were going to be trouble right from the start and it was excruciating not to be able to intervene, to watch the night unravel.
Having been connected to the judicial system (in a good way) for 30 some years, I found the characters' flawed thought processes were consistant and believable. I didn't think it was slow and I didn't want to miss a moment of the writing, as I sometimes do when authors describe scenery and Yaddah Yaddah Yaddah. If you are a student of human motivation and behavior you will like this book.
11 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

The long crawl to the finish line

I too was excited to read this book after enjoying "House of Sand and Fog" and also reading Stephen King's review. It started off great, in my opinion, introducing the players, setting up a storyline, and setting the scene. However, after April's daughter disappears (which occurs about 1/3 of the way through), I felt it just went in circles. I was bored, I wasn't interested in any of the characters, and I felt like it was constant repetition. By the end, I was practically skimming, just wanting to get it over with.
11 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Hard to believe

Hard to believe that the author of House of Sand and Fog wrote this overlong novel featuring cardboard characters living through one night on the seamiest side of American life. Dubus repeats the character's thoughts, motivations, and descriptions so often that one third of the novel could have been edited down and would have been better for it. As a book lover, I don't like to skim, but I did it for the last two hundred pages; just so I could return it to the library the next day and be done with it.
9 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Life is too short

Like a previous reader, I bought this book based on my love for "House of Sand and Fog." In that book, Dubus created sympathetic characters involved in a truly original situation that escalated with unbearable suspense into a truly unforeseeable conclusion. This book starts out strong, with a sympathetic heroine placed in an untenable position. However, as the plot dragged into its 300th page, I found myself having to work at picking it up and getting involved again, until I realized that life is too short and there are other books to read. A strong editor was really needed here, one that is not afraid to pare at backstories and extemporaneous detail. I'm sure there is a fine story here, but fiction should not be so much work. Also, the minute detail of what goes on in a mens' club need not be repeated over and over again. We get it. If a reader is mature enough to pick up and read this story, they are able to imagine the almost soft porn details without endless repetition.
9 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Astounding and Emotional

This is a gritty and graphic novel of the last days of one of the 9/11 highjackers and his chance meeting with April, an exotic dancer. Although the club scenes are filled with salacious details of the strip club life, the protagonist April retains her sense of self and has the reader hoping she will find her way. Part of this sympathy is developed through April's toddler daughter, Franny, based on Franny's innocence and state of jeopardy throughout the novel. Other important characters, from Jean the old woman who helps April with babysitting, to AJ, a wife-beating man with a temper problem and a soft heart for little kids, and his wife Deena, with her broken dreams, make up just a part of the rich tapestry of this novel.

It is long; it is difficult; it is beautifully written.

Stephen King called my attention to this novel with his review in ET, and I certainly agree. This book is not to be missed. Amazing! By the author of "The House of Sand and Fog"--longer, more suspenseful, and equally heartbreaking.
9 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Best Book of the Year

This book is going to win both the National Book Award and Pulitzer prize-- it reminds me of the best of what Anne Tyler can do-- good old fashioned story telling-- but with a subtle global perspective that forces us to look beyond cultural and socioeconomic sterotypes and at each individual. The Garden of Last Days will appeal to almost everyone-- it is impossible to put down, with both deep and unique characterization. The structure is impeccable-- the back stories and action so relentlessly and seemlessly take you on a journey that it seems as if the novel could not have existed with even a single word changed.

Please do not think about this book as a novel about 911 or about getting inside the head of a terrorist-- it is so much more-- it is the story of a handful of marginalized people who's lives might have taken a different turn at any point. The tension is almost unbearable, because it could all end so badly, but each charcter's story concludes sometimes unexpectedly, always credibally, and leaving you with hope, new perspective-- and in the way of the greatest of novels, it becomes a part of you forever.
9 people found this helpful