The Blackhouse: A Novel
The Blackhouse: A Novel book cover

The Blackhouse: A Novel

Hardcover – January 3, 2023

Price
$20.45
Format
Hardcover
Pages
336
Publisher
Scribner
Publication Date
ISBN-13
978-1982199678
Dimensions
6 x 1.4 x 9 inches
Weight
1.08 pounds

Description

“Fans of Tana French will embrace author Johnstone's skill at weaving supernatural and setting-as-character aspects into her story, and readers of Lisa Jewell will enjoy her unexpected plotting and character development. The caliber of Johnstone's writing and masterful storytelling will delight both. This richly evocative story exists at the point where love, fear, guilt, bad decisions, psychosis, and mythology collide.” — Kirkus , Starred Review “Atmospheric, thrilling, and utterly captivating . ” — Booklist “A uniquely claustrophobic and disconcerting tale with notes of otherworldliness.” — Book Riot “ Spins Norse legends, Hebridean superstitions, Bronze Age history and canny Scottish wisdom into a deeply absorbing and wildly atmospheric mystery about the dangerous brew of self-loathing, familial duty and guilt. Johnstone cleverly sets revelations, sometimes sinister, always startling, across her plot... the alchemy of place, plot and character is the white-bright light at the core of Johnstone's novel.” — Minneapolis Star Tribune “[An] eerie gothic thriller... this ghost story ultimately packs a gale-force wallop. Johnstone is a writer to watch.” — Publisher s Weekly “Read THE BLACKHOUSE with the lights on, wrapped in a cozy blanket... The early spring of the Scottish isle will chill your bones, along with the darkness of the book. It's as unsettling as the ocean in the stormy seas and as enigmatic as the Norse myths that accompany it. And the twists — oh, the twists.” — Book Reporter “Johnstone fashions a gripping narrative awash with multiple shocks and secrets. A perfect choice for a winter evening, The Blackhouse freezes the blood as it churns the brain.” —Jay Strafford, Fredericksburg Free Lance Star “Provides pulse-pounding panic.” — Popsugar “Atmospheric and compellingxa0with an excellent sense of place, this literary thriller is somehow both uplifting and heart-breaking, with some very unexpected twists!” — Catherinexa0Cooper, author of The Chalet and The Chateau “One of the most atmospheric novels of the year... cements her reputation as a rising queen of the gothic.” — Crime Reads “One of the best suspense novels of the year... Richly atmospheric, gothic, eerie, and pulse-pounding... Multi-layered and mystical, The Blackhouse will hook you, reel you in, and capture your imagination until the last thrilling twist. — Mystery and Suspense Magazine Carole Johnstone is the award-winning author of the novels Mirrorland and The Blackhouse . She lives in the Highlands of Scotland, although her heart belongs to the wild islands of the Outer Hebrides. Excerpt. © Reprinted by permission. All rights reserved. Prologue Prologue It wasn’t the screams he remembered most, although they crashed to shore inside the howling, furious wind and ricocheted for hours around the high cliffs above the beach. It wasn’t the storm or the roaring, foaming waves that carved great snaking wounds through the wet sand and stole its shape from under his feet. It wasn’t the dark or the flashing torchlight. Or the frantic hours of men pushing boats into the wild surf: motorboats, fishing boats, even old wooden sgoths . All to be smashed into the bay’s high headlands or hurled back onto the shore like stones from a slingshot. It wasn’t the long, tired wails of the women whose silhouettes stood in a clifftop vanguard ahead of the silver-starred inland sky. Nor those waving white arms out on the rocks, which became slower and less frequent as the screamed chorus grew quieter. And it wasn’t the wondering about which of those arms, those bobbing heads that disappeared and sometimes reappeared, belonged to his father. It wasn’t even the eerie silence that came after. The exhaustion of energy and grief and hope. The exhaustion of wind and rain and thunder and sea. It was the tide bell out on those rocks. Its low, heavy ring growing ever more muffled under the weight of water and all that time. And it was the black tower casting an invisible shadow over the sand and bay and calming waves. They were always what he remembered the most. Sometimes they were all he could think about. The tide bell. And the black tower. And knowing that every man on those rocks would never come back. Because of him. Because of what he’d wanted. Because of what he’d done. Read more

Features & Highlights

  • From the author of the “dark and devious...beautifully written” (Stephen King)
  • Mirrorland
  • comes an “atmospheric, thrilling, and utterly captivating” (
  • Booklist
  • ) gothic tale set on a remote Scottish island where the locals are hiding a deadly secret.
  • Maggie Mackay has been haunted her entire life. No matter what she does, she can’t shake the sense that something is wrong with her. And maybe something is… When she was five years old, Maggie announced that a man on the remote island of Kilmeray in Scotland’s Outer Hebrides—a place she’d never visited—was murdered. Her unfounded claim drew media attention and turned the locals against each other, creating rifts that never mended. Now, nearly twenty years later, Maggie is determined to discover what really happened, and what the villagers are hiding. But everyone has secrets, and some are deadly. As she gets closer to the horrifying truth, the island’s legendary and violent storms begin to rage again and Maggie’s own life is in danger… Unnerving, enthralling, and filled with gothic suspense,
  • The Blackhouse
  • is a spectacularly sinister tale readers won’t soon forget.

Customer Reviews

Rating Breakdown

★★★★★
30%
(124)
★★★★
20%
(82)
★★★
15%
(62)
★★
7%
(29)
28%
(115)

Most Helpful Reviews

✓ Verified Purchase

Atmospheric read, with a lot of characters to keep track of

This book has a lot that I really liked, but also a fair amount that I disliked. Overall I'm giving this 4 stars, but I think it lands somewhere between 3.5-4 stars.

What I liked: This is a dark, broody, atmospheric read that was so immersive. I could see the island, feel the rain, and get the same goosebumps our main character did when things got creepy. And I really liked the creepiness! Everything was described in such a vivid manner, that I felt like this would be a great movie or tv series. The mystery was also great and I was very pleased with the twists.

What didn't work for me: Okay my main complaint is there are SO many characters. They remark how remote the island is and how few people live there, but OMG I could never keep anyone straight. I strongly regret not taking notes to remember who was who. I think we needed less people, or they needed to be more memorable and/or introduced more slowly. The book basically begins with our main character walking into a bar and getting introduced to the whole village when I am just getting myself oriented in the plot and meeting our main character plus a few side characters. Then throw a pub full of new people at me with a few sentences to tell me who they are, and I'm just not going to remember. I kept returning to these pages to see who all these dang people were!

My other minor complaint is that this book is just slow, and I had a hard time making myself pick it back up. I don't mind a slow burn mystery if it's building up to an exciting finale, which it did somewhat at the end. But some of the middle just felt so bogged down that I struggled getting through it.

But even with those complaints, the plot and the mystery are really great! This was a memorable read that I could not predict, which is always a win for me.
5 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

3 Stars

The author’s strength in this book is atmosphere. This book is so well crafted in its remote Scottish setting and I absolutely could picture every scene perfectly. In terms of plot and the characters, I rather struggled. There are a significant number of characters here and only a few have distinct enough characteristics to tell them apart. There also are so, so, so many things going on. So many incredibly left-field plot lines that it was overwhelming and I didn’t know how the author would possibly tie everything together. She did in the end, but the ending wasn’t terribly to my liking and had a reveal that I found a tad bit repulsive. I feel this book would have been so much better if she had focused on one or two of the different ideas and plots.
2 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Atmospheric read with a reincarnation theme

This one is a Gothic mystery with some terrific atmospheric vibes. It uncovers Maggie Mackay ‘s journey back to the small village of Blairmore, 2 decades after she visited the same places as a kid claiming to be Andrew MacNeil, murdered by someone in the village. The tight-nit community isn’t too receptive of her this time around either as Maggie slowly tries to piece together the puzzle of the Andrew aka Robert’s death while facing the demons of her past in the process. Things get even more spooky as Co-incidentally she inhabits the same Blackhouse Robert and his family lived in all those years ago. However little does she know about the parallel paths Robert and her life take in this island- will she meet the same end though?

As mentioned earlier, this was a dark atmospheric read which takes its time to set up the town, the characters. It can be drawback too since it’s not one of those fast, “chill at each turn” type of book- it’s a well written psychological thriller. The Gaelic introduced, though tough in some cases (explained in most cases) add authenticity to the plot. The relationship between Charlie and Maggie is another highlight. On the downside the romantic interludes was a let down and as was the reveal in the end which felt a bit forced. On the whole, The Blackhouse, though less than 350 pages long, isn’t a quick 2 days read- but worth the time.
2 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

It’s a slow start, but keep going!

I loved this book so much more than I thought I was going to at the start. The writing was fantastic, and truly brings you to the site of an isolated, Scottish island village, that is consistently battered with storms off the sea.

Maggie McKay repeated one thing over and over again as a child, "I am Andrew McNeil, and I was murdered." This leads her to travel to the Scottish Island of Kilmeray as an adult, where she suspects Andrew McNeil died, in an attempt to uncover the answers she seeks, and the secrets that the islanders are hiding.

I am a sucker for small, creepy child reincarnation stories. I find it both horrifying and fascinating when you hear about children declaring they were someone else in a past life. So that concept hooked me right from the beginning.

The writing was seriously phenomenal. There were no "eye roll" moments in this book. You truly felt you were right there on the island, with the descriptions of the atmosphere. You felt all the feelings that Maggie was feeling. At the end, when everything was revealed and explained, I felt like I was so engrossed in the life and culture on the island, that I understood why everyone did what they did.

- Why Not Five Stars
This is really nitpicky on my part. I just had a tough time getting into it, in the very beginning. The writing is at a much more advanced level than most of the thrillers I end up reading. Overall, it was a really great book.
2 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Dark/ Gothic

I read and absolutely loved this author's dark debut "Mirrorland" and was thrilled to read her sophomore book "The Blackhouse".

Set in a small Irish island, this highly atmospheric novel immerses its audience in a whodunnit mystery with an unreliable narrator, a non-linear timeline and supernatural undertones.

Our protagonist, Maggie, grew up with a mother who was convinced that both she and Maggie were special/gifted. At a young age, Maggie was convinced that she lived a past life as a man named Andrew MacNeil who was murdered. Rather than try to dissuade her, Maggie's mom brought her to the island where Maggie said he died with a producer in hopes of cashing in on the story. The islanders were not welcoming of the intrusion or accusations and Maggie and her mom left empty handed.

Years later Maggie has been sorting through memories of the past trying to make sense of her life. She's also working to overcome severe mental health issues which were exacerbated upon her mother's death. Unable to let go of Andrew without knowing the truth, Maggie decides to return to the island and conduct her own investigation.

The author did a phenomenal job introducing the readers to island life. She carefully created a mentally ill character with realistic attributes- I believe she conducted a fair amount of research to nail this character.

Maggie's investigation was mainly questioning people who did not want to volunteer information which gave us more of a slow burn. All in all I enjoyed the book and am looking forward to Carole Johnstone's next novel!
2 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

The Blackhouse

What the heck was this book suppose to be about? I read the whole thing and I am still not sure what the plot was. I thought this book was pretty boring too. Also, did not really get to the thriller part of this book until like 80% of the book. I did enjoy the setting of this book. But yeah this one was just not for me. The main character thought she was another person the whole time. It was just so weird. This was a bad thriller. Unsure why it has a lot of good ratings. I would not suggest this one.
2 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Setting and atmosphere

Hovering between a 3 or 4 star rating, rounding up to 4. I was really drawn in by the setting and atmosphere. Great writing too! I was lost with so many characters though, who all blended in to one another. Maybe there could have been a page in the front telling who is who. But I enjoyed the overall story for the most part. I liked it better than Mirrorland which I DNF. I would definitely read another book by the author.
1 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

A Brilliant Gothic Thriller Set in Scotland

This is sure to be one of the best suspense novels of 2023. Richly atmospheric, gothic, eerie, and pulse-pounding, Carole Johnstone threads The Blackhouse with supernatural elements and Norse mythology while keeping us firmly grounded on the atmospheric island of Kilmeray. Set in the Outer Hebrides of Scotland, the small fishing village of Blairmore holds so many secrets that it sometimes seems to be a character unto itself.

meet Maggie MacKay when she returns to the village twenty years after a strange incident happened to her when she was five years old. Maggie proclaimed to be a man from the village, Andrew MacNeil, and insisted he was murdered. Believing her daughter was psychic, Maggie’s mom took her to the village with a documentary filmmaker.

The media quickly exploited the story, causing the village locals to turn against them and each other. Haunted by the experience, and now that her mother is dead, Maggie needs to know the truth about what happened when she was five. Maggie discovers that Andrew MacNeil was actually Robert Reid and rents The Blackhouse where Robert, his wife, and child lived, hoping this will help her find the truth. Robert hid a terrible secret and that’s why he changed his name. She’s certain he was murdered even though the villagers insist it was suicide.

Told by Maggie and Robert in alternating chapters, the story twists and turns with new revelations. Maggie knows the villagers are keeping secrets too, especially after she finds out a young boy died the same night Robert did. Neither body was found. As Maggie digs into Robert’s past, someone leaves mummified crows on her doorstep. One villager whispers threats in her ear.

Between battering storms, the villagers’ hostility, and a stalker, Maggie fears for her life. Soon she finds safety in Will who wants to understand her and who tries to keep her safe. They fall in love, but as she draws closer to the truth, she realizes she can trust no one.

Brilliantly written in literary prose, Johnstone captures a world that creeps into your senses while at the same time, making you love these people who gather at the pub and know each other intimately. We learn what it’s like to live off the land and sea and how the peat bogs can mummify yet provide warmth when harvested. At times the village feels evil, and at others, so simply normal. It’s just people banding together to protect their lives and livelihood. Maggie, the outsider, threatens all that, yet in many ways, she belongs to the village. Multi-layered and mystical, The Blackhouse will hook you, reel you in, and capture your imagination until the last thrilling twist. Just remember to breathe.

Thanks to Carole Johnstone, Scribner/Simon & Schuster, and Clare Maurer, Senior Publicist for an arc and a hardcover edition.
1 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Atmospheric slow burn of a mystery

3.5 stars. Probably would've been 4 stars, but the ending was both abrupt and kept going. It's definitely a slow burn of a novel/mystery. Very atmospheric - the island of Kilmeray is almost a character unto itself. I liked Maggie - complex character who grows over the course of the novel. I did enjoy the structure - chapters of the past interspersed with the present. This is a very well written novel, I just didn't enjoy it as much as Mirrorland.

"A remote village. A deadly secret. An outsider who knows the truth.

Robert Reid moved his family to Scotland’s Outer Hebrides in the 1990s, driven by hope, craving safety and community, and hiding a terrible secret. But despite his best efforts to fit in, Robert is always seen as an outsider. And as the legendary and violent Hebridean storms rage around him, he begins to unravel, believing his fate on the remote island of Kilmeray cannot be escaped.

For her entire life, Maggie MacKay has sensed something was wrong with her. When Maggie was five years old, she announced that a man on Kilmeray—a place she’d never visited—had been murdered. Her unfounded claim drew media attention and turned the locals against each other, creating rifts that never mended.

Nearly twenty years later, Maggie is determined to find out what really happened, and what the islanders are hiding. But when she begins to receive ominous threats, Maggie is forced to consider how much she is willing to risk to discover the horrifying truth."

All opinions expressed herein are my own.
1 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Atmospheric

I struggle with slow books, even ones that are well written. I felt as if I were on the island and could not get off as everyone and their brother made an appearance. Maggie came to town; she’s welcomed by some, and she’s greeted with hostility by others. The pub is the meeting/social spot for all but will the villagers be social when she begins asking questions?

Maggie and her mother visited Scotland’s Outer Hebrides after a young Maggie said she was Andrew MacNeil, a dead man. Nothing ever came of this visit, but the villagers remembered. People living in small town/villages always remember!

Twenty years later, Maggie comes back to Outer Hebrides looking for answers. Why do I hear Jack Nicholson shouting "You can't handle the truth!"? But the truth is what she seeks. But there are those with secrets, who can't handle Maggie learning them.

This book is told in two timelines (the 1990's and the present) with the POV of Maggie and Robert.

The atmosphere in this book was spectacular. I thought the author did a fantastic job of setting the stage and I felt as if I had been transported there. But sadly, I struggled with the slowness of the book, and I found that I just didn't love this book. While there were parts that I enjoyed, the rest just bogged things down for me. Others are enjoying this book more than I did, so please read their reviews.

Well written and atmospheric.
1 people found this helpful