The Bat: A Harry Hole Novel (1)
The Bat: A Harry Hole Novel (1) book cover

The Bat: A Harry Hole Novel (1)

Kindle Edition

Price
$6.99
Publisher
Vintage Crime/Black Lizard
Publication Date

Description

NATIONAL BESTSELLER • A USA Today Critic’s Pick • Winner of The Riverton Prize for Best Norwegian Crime Novel of the Year • Winner of The Glass Key for Best Nordic Crime Novel of the Year “This is an absolute must for devotees of the riveting train wreck that is Harry Hole.... While the chronological confusion is disconcerting, it adds a layer of dramatic irony to the tale and enhances its tension and power.”xa0xa0xa0xa0 xa0— Booklist (starred review)xa0“Harry is already every bit as volcanic as in his later cases. The big difference is Australia, which Nesbø, seeing it through the eyes of both a tourist and a cultural pathologist, makes you wonder how much different it is from Norway after all.”xa0xa0xa0xa0 — Kirkus Reviews "This debut effort shows Nesbø as an already confident genre craftsman, striking sparks from the familiar genre material of Harry’s fish-out-of-water experience in a foreign land and odd-couple pairing with a mismatched partner."xa0xa0xa0xa0 — Publishers Weekly “Even with this first book Nesbø’s command of the idiom is completely in place—there is absolutely no sense that the writer was finding his feet and aficionados will be very pleased to slide this on to their bookshelves alongside the other Harry Hole novels.” xa0xa0xa0 — The Daily Express “It is fantastic to see a younger Harry, a more loquacious Harry.... [Nesbø is] a terrific writer who knows how to build a story, taking you slowly to the top of a rollercoaster before sending you hurtling towards a solution that you never see coming.” xa0xa0xa0 — Scottish Express “Nesbø is already taking on the clichés, ruthlessly tearing them apart and coming up with new riffs.... Most satisfyingly, we can now see the organic shape that Nesbø always intended his work to take.” xa0xa0xa0 — The Independent (London) JO NESBØ is a musician, songwriter, economist, and #1 New York Times best-selling author. He has won the Raymond Chandler Award for Lifetime Achievement as well as many other awards. His books have sold 55 million copies worldwide and have been translated into 50 languages. His Harry Hole novels include The Redeemer, The Snowman, The Leopard, Phantom, The Thirst, and most recently Knife, and he is also the author of The Son, Headhunters, Macbeth, The Kingdom and several children's books. He lives in Oslo. NATIONAL BESTSELLER • A USA Today Critic’s Pick • Winner of The Riverton Prize for Best Norwegian Crime Novel of the Year • Winner of The Glass Key for Best Nordic Crime Novel of the Year “This is an absolute must for devotees of the riveting train wreck that is Harry Hole.... While the chronological confusion is disconcerting, it adds a layer of dramatic irony to the tale and enhances its tension and power.”xa0xa0xa0xa0 xa0— Booklist (starred review)xa0“Harry is already every bit as volcanic as in his later cases. The big difference is Australia, which Nesbø, seeing it through the eyes of both a tourist and a cultural pathologist, makes you wonder how much different it is from Norway after all.”xa0xa0xa0xa0 — Kirkus Reviews "This debut effort shows Nesbø as an already confident genre craftsman, striking sparks from the familiar genre material of Harry’s fish-out-of-water experience in a foreign land and odd-couple pairing with a mismatched partner."xa0xa0xa0xa0 — Publishers Weekly “Even with this first book Nesbø’s command of the idiom is completely in place—there is absolutely no sense that the writer was finding his feet and aficionados will be very pleased to slide this on to their bookshelves alongside the other Harry Hole novels.” xa0xa0xa0 — The Daily Express “It is fantastic to see a younger Harry, a more loquacious Harry.... [Nesbø is] a terrific writer who knows how to build a story, taking you slowly to the top of a rollercoaster before sending you hurtling towards a solution that you never see coming.” xa0xa0xa0 — Scottish Express “Nesbø is already taking on the clichés, ruthlessly tearing them apart and coming up with new riffs.... Most satisfyingly, we can now see the organic shape that Nesbø always intended his work to take.” xa0xa0xa0 — The Independent (London) --This text refers to an out of print or unavailable edition of this title. From the Artist Jo Nesbo --This text refers to an out of print or unavailable edition of this title. Excerpt. © Reprinted by permission. All rights reserved. Excerpted from Chapter 1 Sydney Something was wrong.At first the female passport official had beamed: “How are ya, mate?”“I’m fine,” Harry Hole had lied. It was more than thirty hours since he had taken off from Oslo via London, and after the change of planes in Bahrain he had sat in the same bloody seat by the emergency exit. For security reasons it could only be tipped back a little, and his lumbar region had almost crumbled by the time they reached Singapore.And now the woman behind the counter was no longer smiling.She had scrutinized his passport with conspicuous interest. Whether it was the photograph or his name that had initially put her in such a cheery mood was hard to say.“Business?”Harry Hole had a suspicion that passport officials in most places in the world would have added a “sir,” but he had read that this type of formal pleasantry wasn’t especially widespread in Australia. It didn’t xadreally matter; Harry wasn’t particularly accustomed to foreign travel or snobbish—all he wanted was a hotel room and a bed as quickly as possible.“Yes,” he had replied, drumming his fingers on the counter.And that was when her lips had pursed, turned ugly and articulated, with a pointed tone: “Why isn’t there a visa in your passport, sir?”His heart sank, as it invariably did when there was a hint of a catastrophe in the offing. Perhaps “sir” was used only when situxadations became critical?“Sorry, I forgot,” Harry mumbled, searching feverishly through his inside pockets. Why had they not been able to pin a special visa in his passport as they do with standard visas? Behind him in the queue he heard the faint drone of a Walkman and realized it was his traveling companion from the plane. He had been playing the same cassette the whole flight. Why the hell could he never remember which pocket he put things in? It was hot as well, even though it was getting on for ten o’clock at night. Harry could feel his scalp beginning to itch.At last he found the document and placed it on the countxader, to his great relief.“Police officer, are you?”The passport official looked up from the special visa and studied him, but the pursed mouth was gone.“I hope no Norwegian blondes have been murdered?”She chuckled and smacked the stamp down hard on the special visa.“Well, just the one,” Harry Hole answered.The arrivals hall was crowded with travel reps and limousine drivers, holding up signs with names on, but not a Hole in sight. He was on the point of grabbing a taxi when a black man wearing light blue jeans and a Hawaiian shirt, and with an unusually broad nose and dark, curly hair plowed a furrow between the signs and came striding xadtoward him.“Mr. Holy, I presume!” he declared triumphantly.Harry Hole considered his options. He had decided to spend the first days in Australia correcting the pronunciation of his surname so that he wouldn’t be confused with apertures or orifices. Mr. Holy however, was infinitely preferable.“Andrew Kensington. How are ya?” the man grinned and stuck out an enormous fist.It was nothing less than a juice extractor.“Welcome to Sydney. Hope you enjoyed the flight,” the stranger said with evident sincerity, like an echo of the air hostess’s announcement twenty minutes earlier. He took Harry’s battered suitcase and began to walk xadtoward the exit without a backward glance. Harry kept close to him.“Do you work for Sydney police?” he initiated.“Sure do, mate. Watch out!”The swing door hit Harry in the face, right on the hooter, and made his eyes water. A bad slapstick sketch could not have started worse. He rubbed his nose and swore in Norwegian. Kensington sent him a sympathetic look.“Bloody doors, eh?” he said.Harry didn’t answer. He didn’t know how to answer that sort of comment down under.In the car park Kensington unlocked the boot of a small, well-xadused Toyota and shoved in the suitcase. “Do you wanna drive, mate?” he asked in surprise.Harry realized he was sitting in the driver’s seat. Of course, they drove on the bloody left in Australia. However, the passenger seat was so full of papers, cassettes and general rubbish that Harry squeezed into the back.“You must be an Aboriginal,” he said as they turned onto the motorway.“Guess there’s no fooling you, Officer,” Kensington answered, glancing in the mirror.“In Norway we call you Australian Negroes.”Kensington kept his eyes trained on the mirror. “xadReally?”Harry began to feel ill at ease. “Er, by that I just mean that your forefathers obviously didn’t belong to the convicts sent here from xadEnxadgland two hundred years ago.” He wanted to show he had at least a modicum of knowledge about the country’s history.“That’s right, Holy. My forefathers were here a bit before them. Forty thousand years, to be precise.”Kensington grinned into the mirror. Harry vowed to keep his mouth shut for a while.“I see. Call me Harry.”“OK, Harry. I’m Andrew.”Andrew ran the conversation for the rest of the ride. He drove Harry to King’s Cross, holding forth the whole way: this area was Sydney’s red-xadlight district and the center for the drugs trade and to a large extent all the other shady dealings in town. Every second scandal seemed to have a connection with some hotel or strip joint inside this square kilometer.“Here we are,” Andrew said suddenly. He pulled in to the curb, jumped out and took Harry’s suitcase from the boot.“See you tomorrow,” Andrew said, and with that he and the car were gone. With a stiff back and jet lag beginning to announce its presence, Harry and his suitcase were now alone on a pavement in a town boasting a population roughly equivalent to the whole of Norway, outside the splendid Crescent Hotel. The name was printed on the door next to three stars. Oslo’s Chief Constable was not known for largesse with regards to accommodation for her employees. But perhaps this one was not going to be too bad after all. There must have been a civil service discount and it was probably the hotel’s smallest room, Harry reflected.And it was.2Gap ParkHarry knocked warily on the door of the Head of Crime Squad for Surry Hills.“Come in,” boomed a voice from inside.A tall, broad man with a stomach designed to impress was standing by the window, behind an oak desk. Beneath a thinning mane protruded gray bushy eyebrows, but the wrinkles around his eyes smiled.“Harry Holy from Oslo, Norway, sir.”“Take a pew, Holy. You look bloody fit for this time of the morning. I hope you haven’t been to see any of the boys in Narc, have you?” Neil McCormack let out a huge laugh.“Jet lag. I’ve been awake since four this morning, sir,” Harry explained.“Of course. Just an in-xadjoke. We had a pretty high-xadprofile corruption case here a couple of years back, you see. Ten officers were convicted, among other things for selling drugs—to one another. Suspicion was raised because a couple of them were so alert—round the clock. No joke xadreally.” He chuckled contentedly, put on his glasses and flicked through the papers in front of him.“So you’ve been sent here to assist us with our investigation into the murder of Inger Holter, a Norwegian citizen with a permit to work in Australia. Blonde, good-xadlooking girl, according to the photos. Twenty-xadthree years old, wasn’t she?”Harry nodded. McCormack was serious now.“Found by fishermen on the ocean side of Watson’s Bay—to be more precise, Gap Park. Semi-xadnaked. Bruising suggested she had been raped first and then strangled, but no semen was found. Later transported at the dead of night to the park where the body was dumped off the cliff.”He pulled a face.“Had the weather been a little worse the waves would definitely have carried her out, but instead she lay among the rocks until she was found. As I said, there was no semen present, and the reason for that is that the vagina was sliced up like a filleted fish and the seawater did a thorough job of washing this girl clean. Therefore we have no fingerprints either, though we do have a rough estimate of time of deathu2008.u2008.u2008.” McCormack removed his glasses and rubbed his face. “But we don’t have a murderer. And what the hell are you gonna do about that, Mr. Holy?”Harry was about to answer but was interrupted.“What you’re gonna do is watch carefully while we haul the bastard in, tell the Norwegian press along the way what a wonderful job we’re doing together—making sure we don’t offend anyone at the Norwegian Embassy, or relatives—and otherwise enjoy a break and send a card or two to your dear Chief Constable. How is she by the way?”“Fine, as far as I know.”“Great woman, she is. I s’pose she explained to you what’s expected of you?”“To some extent. I’m taking part in an invest—”“Great. Forget all that. Here are the new rules. Number one: from now on you listen to me, me and me alone. Number two: you don’t take part in anything you haven’t been instructed to do by me. And number three: one toe out of line and you’ll be on the first plane home.”This was delivered with a smile, but the message was clear: paws off, he was here as an observer. He might just as well have brought his swimming things and a camera along.“I gather that Inger Holter was some kind of TV celeb in Norway?”“A minor celeb, sir. She hosted a children’s program broadcast a couple of years ago. I suppose before this happened she was on her way into oblivion.”“Yeah, I’ve been told that your papers are making a big thing of this murder. Couple of them have sent people here already. We’ve given ’em what we’ve got, and that’s not a great deal, so they’ll soon be bored and bugger off home. They don’t know you’re here. We’ve got our own nannies, so you won’t have to take care of them.”“Thank you for that, sir,” Harry said, and he meant it. The thought of panting Norwegian journalists looking over his shoulder was not a welcome one.“OK, Holy, I’ll be honest with you and tell you how the land lies. I’ve been told in no uncertain terms by my governor that councillors in Sydney would like to see this case cleared up as soon as possible. As usual, it’s all about politics and dosh.”“Dosh?”“Well, we reckon unemployment in Sydney will rise to over ten percent this year, and the town needs every cent we can get from the tourists. We’ve got the Olympic Games just round the corner, in 2000, and tourism from Scandinavia’s on the up. Murder, especially one which hasn’t been cleared up, isn’t a good advert for the town, so we’re doing what we can. We have a team of four detectives on the case plus high-xadpriority access to the force’s resources—all the computers, forensic staff, lab people. And so on.”McCormack pulled out a sheet of paper which he studied with a frown.“In fact, you should be working with Watkins, but since you specifically asked for Kensington, I see no reason to refuse your request.”“Sir, to my knowledge I haven’t—”“Kensington’s a good man. There are not many Indigenous officers who have come up through the ranks like him.”“No?”McCormack shrugged. “That’s just the way it is. Well, Holy, if there’s anything else, you know where I hang out. Any questions?”“Er, just a formality, sir. I was wondering whether sir was the right mode of address to a superior officer in this country, or whether it was a little toou2008.u2008.u2008.”“Formal? Stiff? Yes, I guess it probably is. But I like it. It reminds me that I am in fact the boss of this outfit.” McCormack burst out laughing and concluded the meeting with a bone-xadcrunching handshake.“January’s the tourist season in Australia,” Andrew explained as they lurched forward in the traffic around Circular Quay.“Everyone comes to see the Sydney Opera House and go on boat trips round the harbor and admire the women on Bondi Beach. Shame you’ve got to work.”Harry shook his head. “Doesn’t matter. I break out in a cold sweat around tourist traps.”They emerged onto New South Head Road, where the Toyota sped eastward to Watson’s Bay.“The East Side of Sydney’s not exactly like the East End of London,” Andrew explained as they passed one fashionable house after another. “This district’s called Double Bay. We call it Double Pay.”“Where did Inger Holter live?”“She lived with her boyfriend in Newtown for a while before they split up and she moved to a little one-xadroom flat in Glebe.”“Boyfriend?”Andrew shrugged. “He’s Australian, a computer engineer and met her when she came here on holiday two years ago. He’s got an alibi for the night of the murder and is not exactly the prototype of a murderer. But you never know, do you?”They parked below Gap Park, one of Sydney’s many green lungs. Steep stone steps led up to the windblown park that lay high above Watson’s Bay to the north and the Pacific Ocean to the east. The heat hit them when they opened the car doors. Andrew put on a big pair of shades, which made Harry think of a laid-xadback porn king. For some reason his Australian colleague was wearing a tight suit today, and Harry thought the broad-xadshouldered black man looked a bit comical as he rolled and pitched up the path in front of him to the viewpoint.Harry looked around. To the west he saw the city center with the Harbor Bridge, to the north the beach and yachts in Watson’s Bay and, further in the distance, verdant Manly, the suburb on the northern side of the bay. To the east the horizon curved in a spectrum of various shades of blue. The cliffs plunged down in front of them, and way below the ocean breakers ended their long voyage in a thunderous crescendo among the rocks.Harry felt a bead of sweat running down between his shoulder blades. This heat was giving him goose pimples.“You can see the Pacific Ocean from here, Harry. Next stop New Zealand, after about twelve hundred wet miles,” Andrew said, spitting a thick gobbet off the edge of the cliff. They followed it down for a while until the wind dispersed it.“Good job she wasn’t alive when she fell,” he said. “She must have hit the cliffs on the way down; there were large chunks of flesh torn from her body when they found her.” --This text refers to an alternate kindle_edition edition. From Booklist *Starred Review* When Nesbø’s Harry Hole novels began appearing in the U.S., the Oslo police detective was well into his spiral of alcoholic self-destruction. With the recent appearance of earlier books in the series (The Redeemer, 2013), fans have been able to catch up on the backstory that put Harry in such a bad way. With the U.S. publication of this series debut, we see still more of the detective’s evolution. In Australia as a consulting detective on a murder case in which the victim is a Norwegian native, Harry does what will eventually become his signature: spotting the signs of a serial killer at work and following a convoluted trail with an obsessiveness that puts not only himself but all those around him at risk. Reading this wrenching, emotionally charged tale, which features a fascinating take on the lives of Aboriginals in contemporary Sydney, with full knowledge of what awaits Harry in succeeding, similar cases over the years, we find ourselves wanting to scream, “No, Harry, not again!” But, in fact, this is the first time he loses himself in the chase, inflicting lasting, self-administered body blows on his fragile psyche, and while the chronological confusion is disconcerting, it adds a layer of dramatic irony to the tale and enhances its tension and power. With the future of the series still up in the air after Phantom (2012), this is an absolute must for devotees of the riveting train wreck that is Harry Hole. HIGH-DEMAND BACKSTORY: Any Harry Hole novel is big news in the crime-fiction world, and this retrospectively published series debut will thrill its built-in audience. --Bill Ott --This text refers to an alternate kindle_edition edition. Read more

Features & Highlights

  • INTERNATIONAL BESTSELLER • In the electrifying first installment of the
  • New York Times
  • bestselling series, Harry Hole of the Oslo Crime Squad is dispatched to Sydney to observe a murder case. As he circles closer to the killer, Harry begins to fear that no one is safe, least of all those investigating the murder.
  • The victim is a twenty-three year old Norwegian woman who is a minor celebrity back home. Harry is free to offer assistance, but he has firm instructions to stay out of trouble. Never one to sit on the sidelines, Harry befriends one of the lead detectives, and one of the witnesses, as he is drawn deeper into the case. Together, they discover that this is only the latest in a string of unsolved murders, and the pattern points toward a psychopath working his way across the country.
  • Don't miss Jo Nesbo's latest Harry Hole thriller,
  • Killing Moon
  • !

Customer Reviews

Rating Breakdown

★★★★★
30%
(5.5K)
★★★★
20%
(3.7K)
★★★
15%
(2.8K)
★★
7%
(1.3K)
28%
(5.2K)

Most Helpful Reviews

✓ Verified Purchase

obsessed homicide cop with a dark and terrible secret in his past has become so familiar as ...

The trope of the tortured, alcoholic, obsessed homicide cop with a dark and terrible secret in his past has become so familiar as to elicit eye-rolling when I come across it again. But Jo Nesbo's first Harry Hole novel (although not the first released in the US) manages to rise above cliche. Harry is sent from the Oslo crime squad to sunny Australia to investigate the rape and murder of a Norwegian expatriate who was once a minor celebrity back home. There he encounters an Aboriginal police detective, a cross-dressing clown, and a winsome Swedish barmaid, among other interesting characters. Once revealed, the villain proves suitably chill-inducing, Harry battles the bottle as much as the killer, and all in all, it's a satisfying read. I've only read one other Hole novel, The Redbreast, which was frankly better than this. But this is still pretty good. Recommended.
17 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Strike Out!

Another reviewer said this novel is excruciating, and I agree with that description. Harry Hole is tedious and unlikeable, and the novel plods along. It was translated into English in 2012, but it was first published in 1997, and I found this book, all of the descriptions of people and intereactions between people, very dated. Many people liked this book, but I'm not one of them.
14 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Waste of time

I have read most of the Nordic mysteries, some of them quite predictable and not too well written. Joe Nesbo's The Bat makes the most boring ones worthy of a literature prize.
The Bat is a story of a Norwegian detective sent to Sydney to help investigate the death of a Minor Norwegian celebrity. In the process, he meets characters who could have been interesting had they been better developed by the writer, and learns aboriginal lore to resolve the death as well as several connected murders.
The plot is very predictable, characters could have been very fascinating if properly developed, the drunken stupors seemed irrelevant, and many situations seemed improbable.
I would not recommend this book to anyone.
12 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Harry Hole's Less Than Spectacular Debut

I'm still somewhat new to the world of crime fiction, so I find myself gravitating toward whatever novels have been spotlighted by newspaper reviews and websites like Amazon. The results can be a bit mixed, but I've steadily made my way through some classics like Raymond Chandler's The Long Goodbye and bestselling sensations like The Girl With the Dragon Tattoo. So while the pleasures of crime fiction's esoteric corners are still to be discovered, I'm developing a happy acquaintance with the genre in general.

In the past few years Jo Nesbo has gotten a lot of press for his novels, which have been translated from Norwegian and published in the United States at a pretty rapid clip. This sort of immediate wealth of material is great once you're entrenched in the author's world, but figuring out a place to enter, at least for me, can prove a little daunting. So when I read the first Harry Hole novel, The Bat, was finally being released stateside, I decided to begin at the beginning with Nesbo's most popular creation.

Because Nesbo is a Norwegian author writing about a Norwegian protagonist I, for some reason, expected The Bat would take place in Norway. So I was more than a little surprised when the novel opens with Harry Hole making his way through Australian customs. While this jarred with my expectations of the book, it wasn't a problem in itself. What was a problem - the first in a laundry list - was the way Australian characters constantly slipped into tour guide mode, dedicating large swaths of dialogue to fun factoids about Australia and indigenous folklore. At times it was borderline ridiculous; with characters interrupting, say, a high intensity chase to share some "fascinating" Australian trivia.

But my biggest gripe with The Bat was the mystery at its core. The crime, the clues, and the culprit were all in place, but for some reason the murder of a young Norwegian expatriate fell flat in the telling. The plot turns and revelations never felt well set up or earned; just clunked into place to keep the plot moving. It was as if Nesbo assumes a murder is prima facie interesting, and when he does try to dress up the story's crimes, they're inadvertently silly. Speaking of silly, when the murderer is finally revealed the book nose dives into cartoonish absurdity with a final act so over the top it is positively groan inducing.

The Bat's only real saving grace was Harry Hole, who was an interesting enough character to hold my attention through the story. As a sleuth he's of the standard deeply flawed, genuinely good natured variety. And although his vices are pretty run of the mill, I found his back story and the unpredictability of his character really fascinating and worth following through an otherwise less than dazzling story.

It wasn't surprising to discover this was Jo Nesbo's first published novel. In Harry Hole Nesbo evidently found a character strong enough to sustain a series of thrillers, but it seems pretty evident why US publishers weren't in any particular rush to release The Bat. So as ridiculous as The Bat was, it was enjoyable in a perversely hammy sort of way. I'll certainly give the Harry Hole series another shot, but next time I'll rely on reviews rather than chronological order to make my pick.
12 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Not for me

This is maybe the first book that I could not finish. I got to page 260 of 360 and gave up. Just awful. A recovering alcoholic goes off the wagon because a guy he met 3 days ago has died? Fables and stories that are just page fillers? The main character let's everyone call him the incorrect surname? And he's referred to as "the policeman?" I don't get the good reviews. This was pure rubbish, no pun intended.
10 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

First Book in Series, Not My Favorite, But Answered Questions

The Bat is the first Harry Hole detective story written by that handsome Norwegian Jo Nesbø and I should have read it first. If I had read it first I would have known how to pronounce Harry’s last name (Hoo-leh). I did suspect that the final “e” of Harry’s last name was not silent; that it was pronounced either as long “a” or long “e”. I was wrong on both counts however. I have just been pronouncing his last name in English, which made it seem like a moral judgment or perhaps something symbolic borrowed from Astronomy or Psychology (a black hole in space perhaps).

Reading the first book in the series first would have gone quite far towards explaining Harry’s tortured soul and, perhaps, his addictions. Harry has done something so terrible that he expected to be punished for it. Since the police often protect their own in order to present a united front to the world Harry goes publically unpunished, but remains haunted by private demons.
To solve Jo Nesbø’s first crime Harry is sent to Australia where he takes part in a long and bizarre investigation to find a serial killer of young blonde women. He meets an Aborigine, Andrew Kensington, who works with the Sydney police sometimes and Andrew becomes the first friend Harry has made in quite a while. He also meets a Swedish woman named Birgitta Enquist with long strawberry blonde hair who he thinks he could be falling in love with.

The Sydney aquarium plays an interesting role in the romance of Harry and Birgitta and also in the murders he has to solve. We also have clowns, represented by Otto Rechtnagel, a gay transvestite who has a clown act featuring a guillotine, and then we have wrestlers, especially one, Toowoomba, another Aborigine and a friend of Andrews. The bat, Harry learns, is the Aboriginal symbol of death.

Our Harry, who hates social wrongs, always seems to meet those who have been victimized by some of mankind’s many human rights violations. In this case there are a number of human rights issues in Australia but Aboriginal issues are the greatest of these. Andrew was born during a time when Aboriginal children were taken from their parents to be raised by white folks.

This is not my favorite Harry Hole mystery. There is too much that is strange about Australian life as Harry encounters it. There is too much collateral damage as the case is being solved and there is way too much drinking. I like Harry best when he is straight and sober, but if I had started here I would have had a better understanding of Harry’s behavior. It is always so difficult to write about mysteries because it is so easy to ruin the suspense and destroy things for those who like to read mysteries like they are puzzles to be unraveled, so, although I haven’t told you much, I have told you all I dare.
10 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

How did Jo and Harry survive this book?

i have read all but one of the Harry Hole novels. It's a good thing that Nesbo raised his game. This first book in the series is weak. Annoying descriptions about Harry's alcoholism throughout, coupled with a plot beyond belief.
There were no emotional ties to any of the characters. If Nesbo stopped at this point in the series, he should have killed off Harry to put him and the reader out of their misery.
9 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

This bat does not fly.

“The Bat” features uninteresting characters behaving in unconvincing ways. People make cringe-inducing, cliche-ridden speeches and engage in painfully banal romantic conversations, making much of the book read like a parody of a romance novel: "She looked like a sea nettle jellyfish. He didn't know that a jellyfish could be so beautiful," "Then he kissed her, and she took a long, trembling breath, as though she had been waiting for this kiss for eternity.” The author tries (and fails) to spice up the romance with such maladroit droll repartee as "Oh, good morning, thou quiet, thou joyful beauty! I greet thee.” A cartoonish, violent and unmotivated bar room fight highlights a plot of comic book subtlety that meanders awkwardly through a miasma of stagy dialog and ineptly constructed scenes, artificially seasoned with attempts at outré details (dismembered body parts, drag queen repartee) and oddly inappropriate language: "Harry could feel a gasket beginning to blow.” To make matters worse (as challenging as that task would seem to be) the author makes what would otherwise be simply an unpleasant reading experience into an agonizingly difficult slog by frequent lengthy and tedious digressions, most notably including excruciatingly boring (and irrelevantly detailed) tales of Australian Aboriginal folklore.

This author exemplifies the expression "tin ear" in every possible sense: stylistically, dramatically, esthetically and culturally.

I confess to have completed just half of the book before folding in defeat.
9 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Unlikeable Detective, Inexplicable Police Incompetence, and a Shark Add Up To Nonsense

As many reviewers have said, Harry Hole is hard to like as a person. His alleged relationship with Birgitta is one-sided, narcissistic, and wholly unbelievable. Woman meets man visiting from Norway and due to return soon, starts a relationship with him, catches him in his room with a prostitute, continues the relationship overlooking the prostitution and his out of control alcoholism, trusts him with her life in a hopelessly incompetent police sting and loses her life, and his reaction is that he thinks he may have loved her. The ease with which he sacrifices her is grounds for dismissal at the very least. Sydney police apparently have no standards or procedures for protecting civilians, and allow a visiting disaster like Harry almost free reign. But it is the appearance of the shark at the end that marks this book as a pure nonsense.
6 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Liked the name of the book...thats pretty much it

Not well written. It started off okay...then the person who does the murder isn't brought into the story until half way through the book. What???
The book was lost in the translation, I think... Torturous to read the whole book
6 people found this helpful