is John McPhee's third book on geology and geologists. Following
Basin and Range
and
In Suspect Terrain
, it continues to present a cross section of North America along the fortieth parallel―a series gathering under the overall title
Annals of the Former World
.
Customer Reviews
Rating Breakdown
★★★★★
60%
(125)
★★★★
25%
(52)
★★★
15%
(31)
★★
7%
(15)
★
-7%
(-14)
Most Helpful Reviews
★★★★★
5.0
AGHYGRXLPXJJR5JRETN6...
✓ Verified Purchase
A fascinating tour of Wyoming through the geological ages
I'm not a slow reader, but I rarely read a book in the same 24 hours. This one was an exception. I was immediately drawn in (and by a subject that is not of more than general interest to me), and I more or less did not put the book down until I'd read to the last page.
As a teacher, I'm first of all impressed by how McPhee makes an academic and scientific subject (geology) not just interesting but gripping. For the most part, he personalizes it, introducing an eminent field geologist, David Love, who takes him and us on a tour around Love's home-state, Wyoming, describing over 2 billion years of the geological past as revealed in the cuts along Interstate 80 and in a side trip to Jackson Hole, outside Yellowstone Park. Love is very much a product of his upbringing on an isolated ranch in central Wyoming, his mother educated at Wellesley, his father an immigrant from Scotland who quotes William Cowper and Sir Walter Scott.
Love is independent, old school, hands-on, tireless, scrupulous, an innovative thinker who has made a significant impact over a lifetime in his field, choosing to work for the US Geological Survey after a short period of unhappy employment for an oil company. McPhee captures his very individual point of view, his dedication to science, and his Western perspective in character sketches and fragments of conversation between them. He has a dry sense of humor, colorful turns of phrase, and a toughness that goes along with long periods of field work and sleeping rough under the stars. He's also a grand-nephew of John Muir.
The book actually begins with his mother's wintery journey by horse-drawn coach from Rawlins to central Wyoming, where she has accepted a teaching job at a one-room school. It segues between the story of his parents' courtship in the first decade of the 20th century and his travels with McPhee over 70 years later, finally devoting a long section to Love's own boyhood, growing up on his parents' ranch, with an older brother, among cowboys raising both sheep and cattle. The accounts of surviving blizzards and floods that nearly wipe them out, the visitors passing through who may or may not be hunted killers, even an appearance (possibly two) by Butch Cassidy make this compelling reading for anyone with an interest in the early days of ranching in the West.
There's a brilliant section late in the book as McPhee describes Love's fascination with Jackson Hole while he's still a graduate student at Yale, and after many years of walking the ridges and summits around it, developing a scenario of how it was formed over the eons. McPhee's rendering of this scenario in words is vivid, and in the mind's eye, you can see mountain ranges and seas rise and fall in all manner of climates from tropical to ice age, until the topography assumes its present configuration, which is still changing.
I highly recommend this book. As companion volumes, I also recommend Loren Eiseley's memoir "All the Strange Hours," Geoffrey O'Gara's book about water rights in the Wind River basin, "What You See in Clear Water," and James Galvin's novel, "Fencing the Sky," in which a modern-day cowboy fugitive travels much of this same terrain on horseback.
38 people found this helpful
★★★★★
5.0
AG7V77KYFEMZDCT3HSHK...
✓ Verified Purchase
A towering achievement
In stirring prose McPhee turns the imperceptible pace of geological change exposed in High Plains road cuts into sublime and awesome cataclysms. He incorporates the struggle to survive and prosper of a pioneering ranch family, from whom came an outstanding geologist, John Love. He deciphers the complex story lying behind modern Wyoming, including the soaring Teton Range, evocative Wind River, and Yellowstone. Far more than a guide (with it's helpful time charts and map), McPhee's sensitive writing makes you feel the prodigious forces of the landscape lurking underfoot--almost as unsettling as experiencing an earthquake yourself.
A fun complement to this book is the Wyoming oil geologist mystery Tensleep by Sarah Andrews, or Margaret Coel's Arapaho mystery series.
14 people found this helpful
★★★★★
4.0
AHKXN5MOAHULKXPGAJZM...
✓ Verified Purchase
While studying general Wyoming history I learned by happy happenstance of John McPhee's 1986 book Rising From the ...
While studying general Wyoming history I learned by happy happenstance of John McPhee's 1986 book Rising From the Plains, which unfolds the geological story of the state from the perspective of those American Western pioneers and their descendants who have inhabited the land for the last century. Wyoming geologist David Love is McPhee's focal point. It's challenging to pin down this book. It's a portrait of Wyoming's geology, but also of David Love and his family, and occasionally it's more free-flowing nature writing. While McPhee's material is arranged in a distinctively unusual, if not idiosyncratic, manner, his writing is lovely and always riveting. Even if you are, like I, essentially ignorant of the fundamentals of geology, this book is sure to come as a revelation. I cannot imagine how anyone who discovers this book can fail to be moved by the stateliness of Love's chosen field of study, or by the greater story that the adventure of science collectively has to unfold.
Through a second act of synchronicity while reading this book I stumbled across Ken Burns' 1996 PBS video series called The West. Episode 8 contains extended interviews with David Love in which considerable portions discussed in McPhee's book are recounted. I would advise anyone who enjoys this book to seek out that documentary as well.
13 people found this helpful
★★★★★
5.0
AEBZJCXSDHCHSHQOVSC2...
✓ Verified Purchase
Another great book from a great writer
Well this is another of McPhee's books on geology and as usual it is very well done. But don't let that fool you, even though this book is written about high-country geology it is not too heavily laden with technical jargon nor is it a tedious read. With sly humor and and a witty style the author brings a down to earth (forgive the pun) approach and brings to life the richness of human history and geology in the old west till the present day.
If you are a student of geology then this is a must read along with McPhee's other books on geology...Basin and Range and In Suspect Terrain...but even if you are not interested in the geological processes of the west the book still brings to life the people and country of Wyoming and the old west. Overall this is a great book and while some people may find it tedious if you have a love for the outdoors and the frontiers then this book will definately impart some knowledge unto you and is worth reading.
10 people found this helpful
★★★★★
5.0
AF4RJI4XGXLTY3BPEFK7...
✓ Verified Purchase
Great Historical Family Story
In preparation for a motorcycle trip to the Black Hills and Yellowstone, I read this wonderful book by John McPhee. It's largely a story about the geologist John Love and the Love Ranch in Wyoming. Mixes in the story of his mother and father's trials and tribulations in building the family ranch in the early 1900's with the story of his life and the unique geography of Wyoming. This is a book I would recommend to anyone, even if they were not on their way to Wyoming. Love's mother was a graduate of Wellesley College with a Phi Beta Kappa key who came to Wyoming in 1905 as a school teacher. The frontier was still everywhere and she's one of the real hero's of the book. The story of her life is woven in with the geology and history of the region. John Love grew up on the family ranch, went to Yale for a Ph. D. in geology and became famous for his geological work in the West, and in particular the Grand Teton and Jackson Hole area. The descriptions of family life on the ranch are wonderful. You may want to skim some of the heavier geological descriptions of the state, but even they are full of interesting information. You can't read the book without a renewed appreciation of the geological wonders of our country and the resilience and tenacity of our western pioneers.
7 people found this helpful
★★★★★
3.0
AFYDG3EHLFGTNJVCFOEC...
✓ Verified Purchase
More Biography Than Geology
This is the second John McPhee book I've read and it was a smoother read than "Basin and Range". This slim volume is more about Wyoming geologist David Love than Wyoming geology, but contains interesting passages of Love's background of being raised on a ranch in the desolute Great Divide. The narrative jumps around and is mostly Love pontificating on various aspects of the landscape and mineral riches of Wyoming. McPhee writes with an almost adoring air for the man, so that Love comes across as right in everything, the all-seeing and all-knowing lord of the land. There are no illustrations except for the front cover, a not-very-detailed map of Wyoming, and a hard to read chart of geologic time. I have traveled over much of Wyoming and was thus able to visualize where and what McPhee was describing, but to someone not familiar with the terrain, it would be extremely confusing. His writing style in this book is not as florid as in "Basin and Range" but had plenty of flourishes to wade through, nonetheless. This one will go into the used bookstore box for resale. Not a keeper.
3 people found this helpful
★★★★★
5.0
AFGBZ4TZNB3HHCVC27KW...
✓ Verified Purchase
Living Geology
One of McPhee's best essays is about Wyoming's geologic history and the people that settled there from prehistoric time until today. Both the geology and the lives of the people, native Americans and the Wyoming settlers, are dramatically portrayed through stories about tectonics, overthrusting and the harshness of life on the plains. The story is about the life of the land and the life of a family, including a notable geologists who takes us on a guided tour of Wyoming's unique geologic landscape while recounting stories of the land and his family. A must read.
3 people found this helpful
★★★★★
3.0
AHUNMN7ZFCEEJCFMMHAG...
✓ Verified Purchase
Rock, Paper, Scissors
When people play the game, "Rock, Paper, Scissors", rocks have a chance to win. John McPhee's geology book, "Rising from the Plains" was not a winner. I cannot recommend the book because expectations preclude my patronage. I expect an author with twenty-five published books to adhere to basic tenets of the craft, prescribed by those who are experts in the art. The author's preemptive warning, "This is about high-country geology and a Rocky Mountain regional geologist," should not discourage avid readers if the narrative provided a translation of geo-speak. My knowledge of geology is limited to distinguishing a large rock from a small rock but I am not afraid to learn about earth formations. John McPhee delivers geo-technical terms like, "Ordovician, Cretaceous and Precambrian chert" without description. He assumes readers to be practicing geologists. Published authors habitually demonstrate an innate talent to illuminate scientific terms for unfamiliar readers, but those who tackle "Rising from the Plains" are required to dust off their geology books. Authors should follow basic rules of grammar regarding sentence structure. Twenty words are acknowledged as the maximum required of a sentence. Sentences with more than twenty words are paragraphs. Here is the sentence which brought my reading to a mind-boggling halt: "Twelve miles from Rawlins, the horses were changed at Bell Spring, where, in a kind of topographical staircase-consisting of the protruding edges of the Mesozoic era rose to view: the top step Cretaceous, the next Jurassic, at the bottom a low red Triassic bluff, against which was clustered a compound of buildings roofed with cool red mud." How many of you are able to grasp the meaning of a fifty-seven word sentence? Authors are duty-bound to write sentences of varying length connecting one thought to another. When a reader is disoriented with run-on sentences, they begin to question the merit of finishing the book. "Rising from the Plains" is chocked-full of lofty sentences that confound the reader. I do not blame John McPhee for his prose, I blame the editor. Once an author is in print, they have a relationship with the publisher but that does not give the editor license to ignore common rules of grammar, especially when it affects reader satisfaction and book sales. I give three stars to "Rising from the Plains" because of my respect for the author's descriptive style. I don't recommend reading the book unless you're a Geologist.
2 people found this helpful
★★★★★
4.0
AGXDVRRWI6WLFM5NHG5L...
✓ Verified Purchase
Going Back in Time
As a Undergrad at Gustavus Adolphus and majoring in Environmental Studies with a concentration in Geography (and possibly Geology) I found this book very enjoyable. I'm a slow reader, and I rarely read a book in the same 24 hours, but this book was that great. I was immediately drawn in and loved every part.
I found it fascinating how McPhee took me back in time without making it boring. As a tomboy who dreams of one day owning a ranch of her own and living like the old wild west I would paint a picture as I was reading about what it would be like using the scenery painted in the book. The old memories told by the very knowledgeable Geologist David Love are witty and fun.
Love is independent, old school, hands-on, tireless, an innovative thinker who has made a significant impact over a lifetime in his field, choosing to work for the US Geological Survey after a short period of unhappy employment for an oil company. McPhee captures his very individual point of view, his dedication to science, and his Western perspective in character sketches and fragments of conversation between them. He has a dry sense of humor, colorful turns of phrase, and a toughness that goes along with long periods of field work and sleeping rough under the stars. He's also a grand-nephew of John Muir.
The book actually begins with his mother's wintery journey by horse-drawn coach from Rawlins to central Wyoming, where she has accepted a teaching job at a one-room school. It segues between the story of his parents' courtship in the first decade of the 20th century and his travels with McPhee over 70 years later, finally devoting a long section to Love's own boyhood, growing up on his parents' ranch, with an older brother, among cowboys raising both sheep and cattle. The accounts of surviving blizzards and floods that nearly wipe them out, the visitors passing through who may or may not be hunted killers, even an appearance (possibly two) by Butch Cassidy make this compelling reading for anyone with an interest in the early days of ranching in the West.
Truly, though I just love how it goes back in time and isn't necessarily a autobiography but you get the idea of how this Love lived. I enjoyed reading it and understanding the hardships this man went through and what it is actually like to live without any technology except for the things you invent.
I recommend this book to everyone, but especially inspiring geographers and geologists.
2 people found this helpful
★★★★★
5.0
AFVVJEBGEQ2OAGXUUXAM...
✓ Verified Purchase
For Wyoming Fans
Already having read all of Annals, wanted to own this section for it explication of geology generally and the history of the region and its settlers, early and late. The Bridgers and the Loves are heroes in the best of American traditions.