Reacher Said Nothing: Lee Child and the Making of Make Me
Reacher Said Nothing: Lee Child and the Making of Make Me book cover

Reacher Said Nothing: Lee Child and the Making of Make Me

Hardcover – November 24, 2015

Price
$23.90
Format
Hardcover
Pages
368
Publisher
Bantam
Publication Date
ISBN-13
978-1101965450
Dimensions
5.7 x 1.1 x 8.5 inches
Weight
1 pounds

Description

“[Andy] Martin, an unabashed fan of [Lee] Child’s work, conveys his excitement at hanging out with Child.” — Publishers Weekly “In more than seventy tight vignettes . . . Child, his backstory, and his work come alive. Martin’s irrepressible glee about the project is infectious. Recommended for fans of Child’s work or aspiring novelists who could benefit from an insider’s view of the messy, complicated, and transcendent act of writing.” — Library Journal “Amazingly enjoyable and genuinely enlightening, largely because Lee Child is as thoughtful and as amusing as you’d think from reading his great thrillers.” — Sullivan County Democrat “An unusual entry in the annals of literary biography . . . fascinating . . . I could not stop reading.” —Sarah Weinman, The Crime Lady “One-of-a-kind . . . It’s funny, serious, a kind of mock-heroic and heroic together. It’s quizzical and respectful, sophisticated and self-deprecating.” —Professor Dame Gillian Beer “Andy Martin is no mere ‘Reacher Creature,’ as fans of Lee Child’s Jack Reacher are known. He’s something of a Reacher Teacher. Martin’s book is the perfect accompaniment to all things Reacher. It explores, it explains, and it entertains. Like a detective novel, Reacher Said Nothing takes you down alleys and lanes and streets cast in shadow—but the journey isn’t urban, it’s in the boulevards and byways between your own ears. Andy’s writing is a brainiac’s delight.” —Sam Fussell, author of Muscle Andy Martin is a former fellow of the Cullman Center for Scholars and Writers at the New York Public Library. A native of Britain, he lectures at the University of Cambridge for the Department of French. He is the author of Waiting for Bardot, The Boxer and the Goalkeeper, Walking on Water, The Knowledge of Ignorance, Stealing the Wave, and Napoleon the Novelist . Excerpt. © Reprinted by permission. All rights reserved. IT ENDED the way it was always going to have to end. With a burial. xa0 Lee stubbed out a final Camel filter cigarette (except it was anything but final) and breathed out a cloud of New York Times no. 1 bestseller smoke. Leaned back in his chair and scrutinized the last sentence of Personal: xa0 O’Day was to be awarded three more medals posthumously, and a bridge was to be named after him, on a North Carolina state route, over a narrow stream that most of the year was dry. xa0 Always good to end with a death, of course. Posthumously…it was like hammering a last nail into the coffin. Or more, planting a gravestone. There was a finality to it. A valediction. But then it was a pointlessly inadequate memorial. He liked anything to do with bridges and routes (so much sheer hard labor had gone into them), but he particularly liked the dried-up stream. So the bridge was pointless too. xa0 And his own stream, the great flow of inspiration that had kept the novel afloat for the last eight months—hadn’t that about dried up now too? “A narrow stream that most of the year was dry.” Could that be…me? xa0 What the hell, it was all like a diary anyway, only masquerading as an adventure. xa0 THE END.” He didn’t write it down. Didn’t need to. He knew he was supposed to put it in for the benefit of the typesetters, but he didn’t see the necessity. That great sense of an ending—the release, the relief, the closure, that satisfying last expulsion of smoke—it all had to be contained in the rhythm and feel of the last sentence. The End had to be nailed right there. Those concluding lines, like the final notes of a Beethoven symphony, a coda, had to have some kind of dying cadence to them, a falling away, an elegiac cessation that said, “I’ve said everything I needed to say.” So you really didn’t need to write “THE END” too. It offended his sense of economy. Two words too many. If it was the right sentence, the sentence would say it for him. xa0 He couldn’t hit SEND just yet though. He would have to wait a couple of days, let it percolate in his head, see what subliminal second thoughts might bubble up. But all the loose ends had been tied up with a bow. Personal, his nineteenth Jack Reacher novel—done. xa0 Word count: 107,000. Substantially across the crucial one hundred thousand line. That’s what it said on the contract. Anything shorter and it would be too short. Still, 107,000 was relatively short for him. The Enemy, for example, was a full 140k. But it was enough. His books had been getting shorter and tighter. He loved the beginning, that gorgeous feeling when nothing has been screwed up yet. Loved the ending too, that great rush towards the finale, when it was all downhill. But the middle—the middle was always a struggle—by around page 2 it was like rolling the rock up the hill again day after day. He’d developed a cunning strategy for Personal though, had pretty much outwitted the middle—he just left it out, fast-forwarded straight from the beginning right through to the end, without a pause, nonstop. Problem solved. xa0 Anyway, it had been a blast, the whole way—Paris, London, Romford—so fuck it, it would have to do. He wasn’t going to change it now. xa0 He glanced at the time on the computer screen: 10:26, Tuesday night. April 15, 2014. (Reacher, he considered, would know what time it was automatically, without having to check with a mere machine—but of course, he—Lee—was not Reacher, he had to keep reminding himself. There was so much Reacher could do—about the one thing he couldn’t do was write a novel about his own experience. Which was why Reacher still needed him.) He’d written the first line on September 1, 2013. It had to be Septemberxa01. Every year. Without fail. Now it was over. xa0 xa0 xa0 Lee turned his head away from the screen and looked out of the big window to his left. Tonight the Empire State Building was lit up orange and green—pistachio, like some dumb giant ice-cream cone. It didn’t used to look that way. Once it had had only clean vapor lights, white light or maybe yellow, so it was like looking up at heaven. Now, with the coming of LED, it could look like anything anybody wanted—it could be red, white, and blue on July 4, for example. But mostly it looked like a bad 1970s disco light show. It used to be an immense, stately edifice, he thought. Now it’s ice cream. Like dressing Jack Reacher up like a disco dancer. It was this view that had convinced him to come and live here, on 22nd Street, on the twenty-fifth floor of a building across from the Flatiron Building. Now—cheapened, stupid, gaudy—the view made it less of a wrench to leave. Farewell, Empire State; I loved you once. Or maybe twice. xa0 He still remembered that feeling he’d had when he first came here. The romance. With the Empire State framed in the window, it would be like living in the offices of the Daily Planet in Metropolis: oh look, isn’t that mild-mannered, neatly suited Clark Kent up there in the clouds, looking out masterfully on the world (with lovely Lois Lane by his side)? And wouldn’t his superhuman powers extend to writing too? It was logical. Wouldn’t a writer from Krypton be all-powerful, all-conquering—a Superman among writers? xa0 My Home in America. That other great work of literature that always sprang back to mind—was never really out of his mind. His genesis and exodus. The book of commandments that had guided him here in the first place. He had come across it, aged five, in the old Elmwood Public Library, in Birmingham. It was just lying there on the floor. He’d picked it up. A stiff, cardboard sort of book, mostly illustrations with just a few words. With pictures of children in their faraway homes—he remembered a new England colonial “saltbox,” an isolated farmhouse on the prairies, and a Californian beach house with surfboards and palm trees. But the picture he always went back to (he borrowed the book and took it home and eventually returned it, much thumbed, but he had carried it around with him in his head ever since, pristine and perfect, a portable Garden of Eden) was the one of the apple-cheeked boy who lived in New York. He lived on the nth floor of some lofty Manhattan apartment block, reaching right up into the sky, with a bird flying by. And he was looking out of his window at the Empire State Building. Lee Child was that boy, half a century later. He had always wanted to be him, had just temporarily been trapped in the wrong country or the wrong body. xa0 It was like a brain transplant—or metempsychosis—or déjà vu, he must have been that New York boy in a previous life, and somehow he had contrived to get back to what he always had been. A kid in a skyscraper. xa0 And yet now he was leaving. xa0 The apartment he called his “office” had been emptied out. Hoovered clean. The white walls were a blank. It was not just the end of one novel, it was the end of a whole string of novels, the end of an era that would forever be identified with this place. Another time, he might have stood up and picked up the red Fender he kept in the corner for celebratory moments like this one. Plugged it in and switched on the amp. Turned the volume up high. Put the strap over his head and hoisted up the mast of the guitar, stared out into the night and tightened the fingers of his left hand over the frets and wound up his right arm and unleashed the plectrum over the strings. And some mighty earth-shattering chord would rip out into the darkness, accompanied by obscene pelvic thrusting. xa0 Except all the guitars had been shipped back to England. And…oh yeah, he couldn’t play a note. He was no musician. The guitars were just there for inspiration. Maybe he’d come back as a rock star. (Or maybe a soccer player? Georgie Best or Lionel Messi would do.) xa0 Even his desk had been taken: he was perched on an old diningxa0table, white, circular, sitting on a black dining chair. Not evenxa0a decent ashtray (the saucer was full of butts—where was hexa0supposed to empty it? The wastebasket had gone too). He felt like a refugee crouched in the corner of an abandoned building. Squatting. Like the last man left alive, staring out at the abyss, the ruined deserted city that was once New York. Just him and a few postapocalyptic rats. And a coffee machine. xa0 He took the phone out of his pocket and switched it back on. It pinged with a text from his daughter, Ruth. xa0 “Hey, Doof!” it began (short for dufus). xa0 Lee smiled. Okay, not quite all alone. She was the one who had started it, all the talk about moving. Maybe she was right though, maybe he had been vaguely dissatisfied. And now he was really dissatisfied. xa0 He’d had to finish by April. Moving date was the 24th. Most of the furniture had already gone. The books had all gone. They’d left him the computer, the old Mac desktop. Now it was doomed. He wasn’t going to take it with him. He shut it down for the night. It didn’t know it was junk just yet. Shhh. Read more

Features & Highlights

  • Fans of Lee Child know well that the muscular star of his bestselling novels, Jack Reacher, is a man of few words—and a lot of action. In
  • Reacher Said Nothing,
  • Andy Martin shadows Child like a literary private eye in a yearlong investigation of what it takes to make fiction’s hottest hero hit the page running. The result is a fascinating, up-close-and-personal look into the world and ways of an expert storyteller’s creative process as he undertakes the writing of the much anticipated twentieth Jack Reacher novel,
  • Make Me
  • .   Fueled by copious mugs of black coffee, Lee Child squares off against the blank page (or, rather, computer screen), eager to follow his wandering imagination in search of a plot worthy of the rough and ready Reacher. While working in fits and starts, fine-tuning sentences, characters, twists and turns, Child plies Martin with anecdotes and insights about the life and times that shaped the man and his methods: from schoolyard scraps and dismal factory jobs to a successful TV production career and the life-changing decision to put pencil to paper. Then there’s the chance encounter that transformed aspiring author James Grant into household name “Lee Child.” And between bouts at the keyboard in an office high above Manhattan, there are jaunts to writers’ conventions, book signings, publishing powwows, chat shows, the Prado in Madrid, American diners, and English pubs.
  • “Can I—the storyteller—get away with this?”
  • Lee
  • Child ponders, as he hones and hammers his latest nail-biter into fighting trim. Numerous bestsellers and near worldwide fame say he can. Jack Reacher may be a man of few words, but
  • Reacher Said Nothing
  • says it all about a certain tall man with a talent for coming out on top.
  • Praise for
  • Reacher Said Nothing
  • “Martin, an unabashed fan of Child’s work, conveys his excitement at hanging out with Child.”
  • Publishers Weekly
  • “In more than seventy tight vignettes . . . Child, his backstory, and his work come alive. Martin’s irrepressible glee about the project is infectious. Recommended for fans of Child’s work or aspiring novelists who could benefit from an insider’s view of the messy, complicated, and transcendent act of writing.”
  • Library Journal
  • “Amazingly enjoyable and genuinely enlightening, largely because Lee Child is as thoughtful and as amusing as you’d think from reading his great thrillers.”
  • Sullivan County Democrat
  • “An unusual entry in the annals of literary biography . . . fascinating . . . I could not stop reading.”
  • —Sarah Weinman,
  • The Crime Lady
  • “One-of-a-kind . . . It’s funny, serious, a kind of mock-heroic and heroic together. It’s quizzical and respectful, sophisticated and self-deprecating.”
  • —Professor Dame Gillian Beer
  • “Andy Martin is no mere ‘Reacher Creature,’ as fans of Lee Child’s Jack Reacher are known. He’s something of a Reacher Teacher. Martin’s book is the perfect accompaniment to all things Reacher. It explores, it explains, and it entertains. Like a detective novel,
  • Reacher Said Nothing
  • takes you down alleys and lanes and streets cast in shadow—but the journey isn’t urban, it’s in the boulevards and byways between your own ears. Andy’s writing is a brainiac’s delight.”
  • —Sam Fussell, author of
  • Muscle

Customer Reviews

Rating Breakdown

★★★★★
30%
(67)
★★★★
25%
(56)
★★★
15%
(34)
★★
7%
(16)
23%
(51)

Most Helpful Reviews

✓ Verified Purchase

Partial success

Initially quite interesting but the digressions grew more frequent as the book went on, occasionally verging on silly when simple concepts were mapped to philosophical and linguistical constructs. Doing an analysis deconstructing particular sentences and then ascribing deeper meanings Child was probably not aware of seems more an exercise of displaying the knowledge of this book's author. This goes on more and more as the book progresses. The first part of the book is fun, entertaining, and enlightening. As Child progresses in his work. "Reacher Said Nothing" loses much of its tight focus and is almost a random collection of academic assertions. Do these really apply? Should they really apply? I suppose it is up to the reader.

The book certainly has much to offer, but the reading of it is somewhat hit or miss. Reading it will give you a sense of Child's writing process, but not too much of it. You'll get his opinions on small facets of the book and what it takes for him to write one. I couldn't help but feel as though I was getting the outside of the puzzle and while the frame might grow more and more complete, the middle never comes clearly into focus.

The book is probably better if you are a complete Reacher-holic and think the books can do no wrong. As a general detailing of the creative process going into a contemporary bestseller, it is probably the best thing we have, probably by a lot. But it still lags a bit with some of the more obscure academia references, too many invocations of Beckett, and it was a bit annoying digging out the symbolism that didn't seem to be put in on purpose.One can take piece already written and deconstruct it far past the point of anything that had been in the author's mind.

All in all, a fine book whose earlier promise gets lost in the academic musings of the author. Though they always return us to Child, Reacher and the book that his is writing, a good many of them break the spell over and over. If you have an interest, by all means read the book. It's not for a casual trip into the mind and process of Lee Child, but it may be the best we ever get. If you can get past the author's self-indulgences, it's not a bad thing at all.
31 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Lee Child at Work: The Making of "Make Me"

On September 1, 1994, an aspiring author went to the store and bought the paper on which he would write Killing Floor, the first novel to feature the protagonist who would become the legendary Jack Reacher.

Oh, what a difference a couple of decades can make. On that date in 1994, Jim Grant had been recently fired from British television and was virtually broke. Hoping desperately that he might find something he could do to support himself and his family, he sat down with a pencil and a pad of paper, attempting to reinvent himself as a novelist. Twenty years later, having created one of the most successful franchises in the history of thriller novels, "Lee Child" sat down at his sleek Apple computer in his very expensive home in New York City (one of several that he has around the world) to begin the twentieth book in the series.

In this case, he was accompanied by Andy Martin, a literary scholar from the University of Cambridge who also happens to be a huge fan of both Jack Reacher and the man who created him. From the first line to the last, Martin would shadow Child through the process of writing the book that became Make Me.

I came to this book, immediately after reading Make Me, both as a fan of the Reacher series and as a writer who was very interested to see how someone much more successful than I at this business approached his craft. It's both encouraging and at the same time very frustrating to see that Lee Child and I work in much the same way, although he obviously makes it work much better than I.

It's nice to see, for example, that his work habits are at least as loose as my own--actually maybe even worse. He allows himself to be constantly distracted, especially in the early stages of the process. There's always email to check, coffee to drink, and a fair amount of time spent doing things totally unrelated to the project at hand.

Like me, and like most other writers, I suspect, Child would argue that even when he's watching soccer or doing something equally mindless, the novel is constantly working itself out somewhere in the subconscious regions of his mind. As with most of us, that's probably true some of the time and not so much true at others.

Fledgling writers who've gone out and bought five or six of those books that purport to tell you the formula for writing a novel, will probably be gravely disappointed to learn that one of the most commercially successful writers of the modern age does virtually none of the things that those books advise: He doesn't outline; he doesn't create complex biographies for each of his characters; he doesn't post notes all over the place tracking the plot; the man just sits down and starts writing without the slightest idea where the book might be going. He figures that it will all work itself out somehow, and so far it has, for the most part brilliantly.

It's a lot of fun to watch the new Reacher novel take shape but certainly no fan of the series would want to read this book without first reading Make Me. There are way too many spoilers, which is no doubt inevitable in a book like this. One might argue that Martin sometimes gets carried away discussing literary theory and other such matters that might be of interest principally to academics like himself, but that's a fairly small complaint.

Martin devotes one chapter of the book to a trip on which he accompanied Child to the 2014 Bouchercon Convention in Long Beach, California. Bouchercon is a Major Deal--a huge convention that annually brings together several hundred crime fiction writers and fans.

Child was still in the process of promoting Personal, the nineteenth of the Reacher novels, and he was very much in evidence as the convention progressed. I remember that we had a drink together in the hotel bar at that Bouchercon--along with about eight thousand other people, of course. As always, there were a lot of other big names in attendance--people like Michael Connelly, for example--but watching Child and the crowd of writers and fans orbiting around him, I remember thinking that Child was something like a supernova while the rest of us, especially people like me, were rank pretenders who had drifted in from some galaxy far, far away.

I doubt very much that reading this book is going to make me a better or more successful writer. But in the several times I have seen him, Lee Child has always impressed me as a genuinely nice guy, and it's good to see that someone who, like so many of the rest of us, was once down on his luck and only dreaming of being a hugely successful author was smart enough--and lucky enough--to make it work. Reacher Said Nothing is a very interesting book that should appeal to large numbers of "Reacher Creatures" and other writers as well.
10 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

"But I Digress"

... might be a better title for this book since that is what Martin does throughout. I had hoped for some insight on the creative process utilized by Lee Child, one of my favorite authors, instead most of the book seems to be digressions about Martin himself - what he ate, wore, where he went etc. Strange side journeys into comments about authors and issues that only a professor could love (he teaches at Cambridge) like the decision to use the the preterite tense versus the pluperfect, side arguments with Child over the number of words in a sentence (some obsession over the number of words in book) and tallying things like the day in March when Child finished 2,173 word while drinking 19 mugs of coffee and smoking 26 Camel cigarettes. Some of the material is interesting - how Jim Grant chose the name Lee Child to write under, some snarky comments about David Baldacci who many feel based his character Puller on Child's Jack Reacher, some mutual admiration tidbits about the Stephen King and Child but most of the book is far off the point. The book is dedicated to "All those loyal readers of Lee Child who may have bought this book by mistake." Guess I would fall into that category but my mistake was one of expectations.
7 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

NO THANK YOU!!!!!!

Don't know why I wasted time with this book. I ended up with four sides of notes that charted why this was not worth reading but, alas, I did force my self to finish it. The author manages to intrude himself into so much of the narrative that you begin to wonder if this is really about Mr. Child or the "oh-so-clever" Andy Martin.....If you like the Reacher series and have read the latest installment I'd suggest you skip this book...but if you must give it a try don't say you were not warned ... it would be more productive to spend your time watching paint dry!
7 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

91 Pages and I Quit

I don't mean to be a grump, but this book is a fraud on the reader. Ninety-one pages in, we've gotten a serious (sort of) discussion of the writing of the first page of Make Me. Ninety-one pages in, it's mostly about the author (Andy) and how neat it is to hang out with the guy who writes as Lee Child (Jim) and all the cool stuff you can do with Jim in Manhattan, with digressions about how much money Jim makes and what a cool and everyday-guy he is. Child has produced some absolutely first-rate dramatic fiction. There may be, somewhere in this bloated piece of fan-fawning, insight into his thinking and his methods. But on the evidence of the first third, the book is a self-indulgent display of contempt for the reader's time.
6 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Good book for writers to read.

The author can be really annoying at times. What's worst is that he's at his most annoying right at the beginning. I was so annoyed it took me months to go back and read on. First of all, I find the Lee Child Jack Reacher books to be wonderfully clever and witty. Reacher doesn't need to beat people up for me to appreciate his view of the world. And there are those Lee Child bits, like 'mattress on a waterbed,' 'grain silo as big as an apartment house,' to me they just clunk and annoy, but I don't forget them. There's clearly something more than big guy beats up the bad guys. (I also laughed several times a day lugging around my 35 pound back pack while trying not to stink for two months in Japan. 'Reacher and his folding toothbrush,' crack me up every time.) What I found was almost all the best Lee Child writer stories are in this book, there are some very valuable Lee Child writer tips, questions, theories here. Pages 136-139. Just great--worth the cost of the book and putting up with Martin (gosh, what am I doing that's like this??? We are only annoyed by what we are doing wrong that we see in other people, and those stuck in the same space with us for long periods of time, (train, car, bus, marriage... ), all others we don't care for we ignore.)
4 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Andy Martin says plenty

The blurb lies. No, not the one that says, "Warning: Contains Spoilers". No I'm talking about the one on the back, "Reacher said nothing. Lee Child says alot". Actually it's Andy Martin who "says alot". And it's not about "the making of Make Me"; it's about Martin's musings that run the gamut from Freud to Stendahl and even Edward Docx, or just some intellectuals you never heard of. And in the process he uses words that even I* have never seen, or know the meaning of, e.g. praxis, oneiric (as in 'oneiric cliche'), logocentric, sesquipedalian; and since Martin is a French scholar (which we are not allowed to forget), there are the occasional French words, e.g. vraisemblance, which he helpfully translates for us as "true-seemingness". This is why I say that in the process of promising to deliver unto us the real Lee Child, what we get is an Andy Martin tour de force (now he's even got me using foreign words!), showing us how clever, urbane and highly educated he is. I'd still like to read a book about the making of Make Me.

* and I have a pretty good vocabulary
4 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

A frenzied fit of oversharing in Lee Child's shadow.

We are promised a “fly on the wall” view of Lee Child writing a book – but instead the fly starts to describe the fuzz on it’s belly in detail.
Yes, there are some tidbits of information about Jack Reacher’s creator. But to get to them you’ll have to rut through the heaps of stuff the author smuggles into this book – as if he hopes we’ll become so endeared with him narrating the minutae of his life, blubbering in “academic” jargon about his insights into the mysterious workings of literary craft – of which he is an expert, of course – that diminishing reappearances of Lee Child in the pages will be seen as something natural: there are definitely a much more important things to relate than the tall guy’s trivia.
It feels like Andy is jumping on spot all the time to try to look down at the bestsellers’ author – Dr. Martin is much more perceptive, much better educated, hugely more likable than him.
This yearning to be liked is almost endearing but definitely and obviously pathetic: see how “the fly” describes every time they order food together what is ordered – so you can see for yourself how much healther , more nice his choice is: Lee Child is taking some really bad stuff – fried eggs, bacon, but the doctor goes with tofu and oregano smoothies.
You can get a hint that Andy’s mental superiority is not limited to the food choice, he sees more, his perception is much more finely tuned.
As can also be seen in that, that and that episode. And in this one too.
The guy steps into the Lee Child’s shadow – under pretext - and goes on the frenzied fit of oversharing.
I don’t think there is another reader besides Andy’s pal Joel who wants to see in this book Andy’s pal Joel. And anyone at all willing to learn how border formalities went for Andy before his flight to the USA. Or before any other flight ever.
I’ve dumped this book halfway through. Yes, there’ll definitely be some nuggets of Lee Child lore. But to get to them one has to get ten times as much insight into the lives of Andy, Joel and other closet geniuses of their circle. Maybe it’s even worth it . I just can’t go on, I pass.
In Russia we have a question for the guys like Andy Martin and Joel Rose. It’s kind of rude but sums it all up pretty well: - If you are so smart – why you’re so poor? –
Lee Child’s publishers were totally right objecting to this project and calling Dr. Martin toxic. Maybe Lee Child’s decision to go on was just a show of his independence, his right to decide for himself. I don’t know. I don’t see how could there be any other reason.
2 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

A writers almanac of great ideas AND very entertaining!

Loved this book and wished it was 3440 pages, not 344 pages. This is one I will read again for the same reason I read it the first time. For fun.

First it was a very clever idea to follow a famous writer for a year while he creates his next hit. So, 1 star for that. And the chemistry between the id of Child and the studied analysis of Martin was perfect. No star for that--it's just a nice bonus to the enterprise.

Another star for execution. I have never read Lee Child. I was more interested in the book's concept. So, being able to examine writers' block, say, from the ground was fascinating. Child's remedy? Another cigarette and cup of coffee. Or, of writers' research? I was shocked that unlike Brad Thor, for example, Child takes no notes, does no research. Instead he depends on his scandalous memory. Or this. We discover that Child has no title or plot to "Make Me" deep into the story. Ok, writer, what are you going to do about that?

Third star for being witty on just about every page. There is not a single page that does not have measurable amperage. This places him, in my pantheon of writers with Buckley, Henry James, or Wodehouse. Page 332: "The truth was I had not read a single page of 'Make Me.' I had read pixels of it on the screen. I had dipped into a few scrappy printouts. Not a genuine cast iron page among them."

Forth star for being smart. Urbane, never pedantic. He knows the difference. Child knows the difference. The reader feels it. Example. A Lee Child line: "She touched the screen and the phone made a sound like a shutter." Martin's take: "Nice parataxis" I said. "No subordination." And the simile, of course. Oh yeah, and the sibilance." I had to spend some time with this, and look up a few words, but what a joy to connect Child's writing with Martin's. It reminded me of studying Robert Frost and discovering just how difficult it must have been for him to choose single syllable Anglo-Saxon words to populate his poems that also overflowed with irony and hidden meaning. Lines like these are so plentiful that you think you are listening to Chopin: "And this is the natural habitat of myth--not Mount Olympus or the Black Forest, but the voids, the dark interstellar spaces, and the undiscovered country."

Fifth star for being not at all what some of the reviews of this book on Amazon claim. When I see a few reviewers claim there is too much Martin, and not enough Child it shows me that some just do not understand the relationships that great writers share. To call Martin a mere "fanboy" is absurd. I can guess Child would never call him that. Pound served as Yeats's secretary in Sussex in 1913, and they were co-editors on literary journals. Beckett served as Joyce's secretary when Joyce wrote Finnegans Wake. Literally, Joyce spoke, and Pound wrote. Are Pound and Beckett lesser luminaries than Yeats and Joyce? All the reviewers are demonstrating is their ignorance of the collaborative nature of professional writers.

My only regret is that I didn't dog ear every page I liked and highlight all the great lines. I guess I knew I would read it again and discover these gems once again. Plus it is hard for me to write in hardback books. I sense some adult shaking his head in disgust. Finally, though I share a name with Andy Martin, I am not THAT Andy Martin. I would, however, be happy to be confused with him!
1 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Great Book - Perfect for the Reacher audience

The first thing about buying a book like this is to know exactly why and what you are buying it for. This is a book first and foremost for those who are interested in Jack Reacher, Lee Child, and/or how Lee Child writes or approaches fiction and the job/experiences of being a famous novelist. It is not a book on Writing. It is not even a book on Writing like Lee Child or even Writing Reacher. It's not really about Reacher, per se. But, it touches on all of those things and I enjoyed every single page and every single word. You see I am interested in all of those things and it didn't bother me one iota that is wasn't any of those things specifically or completely.

This is a biography of a specific novel: "Make Me" and how/what was happening when it was written. And contrary to some reviews, that process IS laid bare here. It is not a biography of Lee Child, but I think you get a pretty complete picture of who he is (or at least who he becomes when he sits down at a typewriter and becomes Lee Child writing a Reacher Novel). I felt at the end of it that I understood what Lee Child (and alternately the author Andy Martin) went through in the 220 or so days that passed from the first sentence to the last one.

This was an interesting idea and it something that I found fascinating and hard to put down. I have read all the Reacher books and this, in its own way, is a Reacher book, too. As Martin skillfully points out: Reacher is alive. He exists. Child is channeling him in a way like a reporter so we can live in his world. It reads at times like a buddy story and Martin is a fanboy, but so what. I enjoyed that, too. Jim Grant is both Lee Child AND Jack Reacher. Buy this book if you are needing a Reacher fix, or want to know more about how Jim Grant became Lee Child. Buy it if you want to understand how Child conceives of plots and stories (or rather doesn't) and how he is able to write a new Reacher novel every year. This book surpassed everything I anticipated and it was a great read. If you are expecting a Writers Workshop, get Stephen King's On Writing. This isn't that at all.
1 people found this helpful