Here, from Jay Dobyns, the first federal agent to infiltrate the inner circle of the outlaw Hells Angels Motorcycle Club, is the inside story of the twenty-one-month operation that almost cost him his family, his sanity, and his life.Getting shot in the chest as a rookie agent, bartering for machine guns, throttling down the highway at 100 mph, and responding to a full-scale, bloody riot between the Hells Angels and their rivals, the Mongols–these are just a few of the high-adrenaline experiences Dobyns recounts in this action-packed, hard-to-imagine-but-true story.Dobyns leaves no stone of his harrowing journey unturned. At runs and clubhouses, between rides and riots, Dobyns befriends bad-ass bikers, meth-fueled “old ladies,” gun fetishists, psycho-killer ex-cons, and even some of the “Filthy Few”–the elite of the Hells Angels who’ve committed extreme violence on behalf of their club. Eventually, at parties staged behind heavily armed security, he meets legendary club members such as Chuck Zito, Johnny Angel, and the godfather of all bikers, Ralph “Sonny” Barger. To blend in with them, he gets full-arm ink; to win their respect, he vows to prove himself a stone-cold killer.Hardest of all is leading a double life, which has him torn between his devotion to his wife and children, and his pledge to become the first federal agent ever to be “fully patched” into the Angels’ near-impregnable ranks. His act is so convincing that he comes within a hairsbreadth of losing himself. Eventually, he realizes that just as he’s been infiltrating the Hells Angels, they’ve been infiltrating him. And just as they’re not all bad, he’s not all good.Reminiscent of Donnie Brasco’s uncovering of the true Mafia, this is an eye-opening portrait of the world of bikers–the most in-depth since Hunter Thompson’s seminal work–one that fully describes the seductive lure criminal camaraderie has for men who would otherwise be powerless outsiders. Here is all the nihilism, hate, and intimidation, but also the freedom–and, yes, brotherhood–of the only truly American form of organized crime.
Customer Reviews
Rating Breakdown
★★★★★
30%
(597)
★★★★
25%
(497)
★★★
15%
(298)
★★
7%
(139)
★
23%
(458)
Most Helpful Reviews
★★★★★
5.0
AGQAXWUZKG55OBM6ZQ4O...
✓ Verified Purchase
Not the Definitive Case History, but Still a Darn-Good Tale
I remember thinking, years ago, when I first heard about this case, "Man, that'd make a heck of a good book!" And it did.
I'm not going to rehash the plot line, several of the other reviews have covered that nicely. What I will say is that the book holds your attention through every page, only slowing down as you realize that the case is coming to an end. I read the whole thing during one Saturday spent waiting for my daughter to finish her dance lessons - it is that interesting a book.
What always amazes me in these true stories (I'm in the middle of reading William Queen's [[ASIN:0812969529 Under and Alone]]) is how these hyper-paranoid outlaws are repeatedly infiltrated by guys who, essentially, just show up and hang around. If I were looking to setup an OMC (outlaw motorcycle club) I'd have a hard-rule: you must commit a serious felony in our presence - one arranged by the club. They'd still get infiltrated, it'd just be a little harder.
And another point it's not always clear to me is what exactly the 81's are doing that amounts to serious big time crime. I understand that they're violent, use drugs, work hard at being social outcasts, etc., but in this story, most of the crimes depicted amount to selling one or two guns at a time, some drugs and random acts of violence. After having read of the [[ASIN:0676977316 massive and profitable drug operations mounted by the Hells Angels' Canadian chapters]] I'd expected some of that here.
This is not the complete story of this interesting case: It's Jay Dobyns' story and the other case agents, his family, and ATF supervisors are less real that Jay Bird and his Red & White targets. There are some serious tales to be told by people in this book who make appearances and fade away, props used as set decoration where Jay is definitely the star.
Jay Dobyns is a fascinating guy. In the media blitz surrounding the release of this book, I've listened to hours of interviews on podcasts and late night talk radio and he's interesting and very articulate. Given that the book is about a third profanity (okay, I'm exaggerating) I hadn't expected that. He's also incredibly patient. I was listening to one pod-cast interview where the interviewer was slow, rambling, interrupted and generally irritated the heck out of me. Dobyns answered with patience and serious consideration to even the weirdest utterances by the host. Personally, I wanted to check the guy's pupils.
In the book, Jay is brutally honest particularly about himself and his failures to his family and friends. As I read it there were parts where I wondered if he understood that his wife might also read this book! He must have at some point, because his interaction with his undercover "girlfriend", Jenna "JJ" Maguire, is glossed over to the point of almost non-existence.
It's in those interviews that you get to hear about the aftermath of [[ASIN:1599214490 Operation Black Biscuit]] and I urge Dobyns to write the other half of the story: the prosecution that fell apart and, more ominously, the ongoing threats to him and his family. In August 2008 his house burned to the ground and his wife and children barely escaped with their lives.
The story of the ATF infiltration into the most famous of the self-described Outlaw Motorcycle Clubs deserves a wider and more documentary accounting, something along the lines of Lou Cannon's [[ASIN:0813337259 Official Negligence]], everything you ever wanted to know about the Rodney King incident and it's aftermath. I'm left wondering what happened to JJ? As a woman agent in the middle of the male-dominated Hells Angels, her side of the story would be something worth reading.
So, this is a great, though incomplete, telling of Operation Black Biscuit. I hope some enterprising journalist find the time and support to put together what the late Paul Harvey called, [[ASIN:055326074X "the rest of the story."]]
52 people found this helpful
★★★★★
5.0
AEHZ4NFXBLAIWZV5EP6Z...
✓ Verified Purchase
A Raw, Real and Riveting Memoir
Captivating from the first page, NO ANGEL thrusts the reader into the inner world of the outlaw motorcycle gang, the Hells Angels. This is the story of an obsessed man, who with the all-or-nothing mentality in his makeup becomes the first undercover law enforcement agent to penetrate this notorious group.
The story is conveyed with brutal honesty. Jay Dobyns, using the alias "Bird" relies not only on his memories of the two year ATF case known as "Black Biscuit," but also on surveillance tapes and transcripts. They help provide detailed dialog between the operatives and their suspects. He puts you in the dark rooms, smoke-filled clubhouses, beer-soaked bars and inky tattoo parlors as you witness his transformation from a sandy-haired football star and all-American dad to a scary looking dude with a braided goatee. He becomes Bird.
He also becomes a patched Hells Angel, sacrificing everything dear to him in the process: his family, his friends, and nearly his soul. In a moment, however, just before the case shuts down, he experiences a revelation. It's not merely about the good and evil among the Hells Angels or in himself, it was the basic understanding this "brotherhood" was "nothing more than a support group for misunderstood loners held together by hate and money." Immersed in this HATE for so long, he ultimately casts it aside for everything he LOVES, and expresses this personal epiphany with tremendous humility. In spite of a disappointing outcome for Black Biscuit and his exposure as an undercover agent, this makes Jay a hero, and makes NO ANGEL a story worth reading.
There are many characters on both sides of the law and a slew of unfamiliar terminology and acronyms, but photos, glossaries maps and lists are provided to guide the reader. Very well done.
Michele Cozzens is the author of [[ASIN:193217236X Irish Twins]]
45 people found this helpful
★★★★★
2.0
AH26J6KHWI26OYO355MT...
✓ Verified Purchase
NO HONOR
This "expose" of the "inner workings of the HAMC" reads more like an apologia for Agent Dobyns' bad behavior during his undercover role as an outlaw biker. "That drunk girl who I carried into my motel room and spent the night with? I was only PROTECTING her from the evil Hells Angels!" "I didn't cheat on my wife with those two teenagers either." "And I certainly never used illegal substances while I was working OC -- I only PRETENDED to inhale all that weed, and those tapes you have of me tweaked out of my gourd? Well, I attribute that to Hydroxycut and Starbucks pumpkin lattes!" Pathetic.
A lot of the crimes he discusses were not committed by Hells Angels -- many were not even bikers. Do not see how that is relevant. And let us examine some of the horrible crimes he protected the public from. Well, it seems he initiated his very own "buyback" program -- bring in a junk gun worth twenty bucks, and he'll take it off the streets (he stated they were being shipped out of the country) and give you ten times what it's worth in cash. Heck, lotsa folks took him up on it. He was throwing around handfuls of taxpayer dollars not only on buying junk guns but by presenting himself as a "high roller." Then, he claims to have murdered a rival MC member in hopes of being allowed to prospect for HA. He shows them photos of a body in a ditch and hands over a bloody vest with that MC's patch on it. When everyone goes, "Damn, ain't that sumpthin, y'know we never told you to go and do this" he uses that to charge them with "conspiracy to commit homicide" -- which the jury threw out when they heard the facts.
Throughout the book he crows about what a "hero" he is, and repeatedly insults the bikers and their culture. He even goes on to say he doesn't even like motorcycles. But then he goes off on some schizophrenic tangent where he starts talking about how much he respects certain members and how he wishes he could also earn a patch.
I agree with the other reviewer that Jay Dobyns is no Billy Queen -- an ATF UC in a similar situation who actually went deep cover and joined the Mongols rather than wearing fake colors and going home on the weekends. Queen was a lot more honest about his feelings and his experiences as well. Dobyns? I don't think anyone trusts him anymore. But it seems that MANY Federal UC operations are like this . . . which is why UC work is prohibited in most civilized countries. Our tax dollars at work.
26 people found this helpful
★★★★★
5.0
AG3HY7TX4LVAV6W5WHBY...
✓ Verified Purchase
Accurate portrayal of a colossal waste of tax dollars
This is a good book written from the first person perspective of undercover ATF Agent Jay Dobyns. The operation "Black Biscuit" was a lengthy and vastly expensive attempt to infiltrate the Hells Angels in Arizona. The operation was a success from the operative's perspective, but in reality it was a huge waste of tax dollars, which became evident when the case fell apart during prosecution. The most interesting aspect of the book was the internal struggle within Dobyn's life as he tries to balance his undercover role with that of a career law enforcement officer and family man. Dobyns also struggles with the fact that he identifies with and truly likes many of the Hells Angels he is targeting and deceiving everyday. Dobyns does not try to paint himself as a hero and admits to many mistakes, which gives the book credibility.
23 people found this helpful
★★★★★
5.0
AE3DHH4ITYD373F5H5N6...
✓ Verified Purchase
RICK "SHAQ" GOLDSTEIN SAYS: "TO CALL WHAT FOLLOWS... "WHITE-KNUCKLE"... WOULD BE LIKE CALLING A SEVERED LEG A SCRATCH!"
"Donnie Brasco" was an FBI agent going undercover in the Mafia... "Covert" was a New Jersey State Trooper going undercover in the Mafia... and now we have an ALCOHOL, TOBACCO, AND FIREARMS (ATF) agent... going undercover in the Hells Angels... and let me warn you... that this true- life story... by ATF agent Jay Dobyns... aka Jay "Bird" Davis... is a non-stop adrenaline ride... whether... on... or... off... a motorcycle.
The reader is quickly brought up to speed regarding Jay's background which included playing wide receiver for the University Of Arizona Wildcats... where there may have been more talented players than Jay... but none liked hitting more than he did... and that personal characteristic... came in quite handy... when he put his life on the line with some mighty mean OMG (Outlaw Motorcycle Organizations) members... including... but not limited to the world famous HELLS ANGELS.
On one of Jay's first training missions... which involved following up on a warrant for an ex-con believed to be in possession of an illegal weapon... he wound up being held at gunpoint... and during the shootout that killed the ex-con... who was holding a gun to Jay's head... the ensuing "dying-quivers" in the now dead criminal's fingers... released a bullet from the death-gripped gun... that "went in between Jay's shoulder blades, just missed his spine, punctured the top of his left lung, and exited under his collarbone". Jay was left with a "SUCKING-CHEST-WOUND"... and almost died in the hospital. Rather than making him a gun-shy administrator... upon his recovery... the author stated: "THE BULLET PUT THE RUSH OF THE STREETS IN ME AND THROUGH ME. IT GUARANTEED I'D NEVER DIRECT ANYTHING BUT MYSELF, AND CONVINCED ME THAT LARGE DESKS WERE FOR CASTRATED DUMMIES. I THOUGHT, F*** THAT, I'M GONNA BE AN UNDERCOVER."
And so starts a story that's too amazing to be true... but true it is! The writing style is similar to Charlie Huston's "pedal-to-the-medal" novels... except for one major difference... this "ain't" a novel... it's true! Jay who's based in Arizona... where most of the action takes place... with side trips to California... and involves subordinates i.e.: snitches and CI's (Confidential informants)... trips to Mexico... where Federal Agents aren't allowed to go... Jay's first undercover operation which was designed to get "street-cred" with the Hells Angels... is code name: "OPERATION RIVERSIDE"... which involved illegal gun distribution. In addition to having his life constantly on the line infiltrating the worst of the worst OMG's... as Jay "Bird" Davis... Jay tries as hard as possible to somehow remain a positive Fatherly... and husband... presence... in his wife's and two kid's lives. As hard as it is to imagine... existing in the undercover role... try to envision... balancing the family role as well.
Here's a summary of his early juggling act... combining deadly undercover and Fatherhood: "WITHIN TWELVE WEEKS I'D PURCHASED A GRAB-BAG OF GUNS: A CZECHOSLOVAKIAN .32 CALIBER SEMIAUTO PISTOL; A ROHM .22 CALIBER REVOLVER; AN FIE MODEL A27 .25 CALIBER PISTOL; AN INTRATEC TEC-22, 9MM PISTOL WITH COMPATIBLE SILENCER; A SITES SPECTRE HC9 MM SEMIAUTO PISTOL; A RUGER .22 CALIBER MODEL 1022 RIFLE WITH A SAWED-OFF THIRTEEN-INCH BARREL; AND A COLT A/R-15 .223 CALIBER MACHINE GUN. I BOUGHT FORTY-ODD SILENCERS FROM HOLT, WITH McMANAMA ACTING AS A MIDDLEMAN. THE SILENCERS, THE MACHINE GUN, THE SAWED-OFF, AND THE TEC-22 WITH THE SILENCER WERE ALL BANNED WEAPONS. I WAS NEVER ASKED TO FILL OUT ANY PAPERWORK, AS I'D ALWAYS IMPLIED TO THEM THAT I WAS USING THEM FOR KILLS OR THAT I WAS RUNNING THEM SOUTH TO MEXICO TO SELL AT A MARKUP. I DANCED AROUND FOUR MURDER SOLICITATIONS, DELAYING OR BLUFFING, NEVER ACTUALLY KILLING ANYONE FOR MONEY. THEY ALL KEPT ME VERY BUSY."
I'd say so... in addition... his son Jack... kept him busy also. During this time period Jay "made sure to drive down to Tucson twice a week to coach a rabid gang of seven-and-eight-year olds in a T-Ball league." During the entire "OPERATION-RIVERSIDE" he never missed a game, even if he had to drive the entire night.
From that operation... Jack gets involved in "OPERATION-BLACK-BISCUIT"... the actual infiltration of the daunting... and infamous... Hells Angels. During these operations, the reader is treated to a firsthand viewing... of the true "reeking" underbelly of the OMG life(?)style. Here's where the writing style... in addition to its breakneck speed... fully and non-deferentially... describes the decaying humanity... that is all too prevalent... at the other end... of the falsely glamorized... life... of... drugs... guns... misogyny... and all the other criminal... excesses... that remain like... human residue... that even a good storm... can't wash away.
Some examples: "WE WERE LED TO A VIP AREA THAT WAS OCCUPIED BY A FEW OTHER ANGELS AND A SNARL OF SCANTILY CLAD WOMEN. SOME WERE ATTRACTIVE, SOME LOOKED LIKE MUD-FLAPS ON A SNOWY DAY IN MARCH."
"I GAZED ON A CLASSIC METH TRAMP: LINED FACE, SHATTERED TEETH, SUNKEN EYES, BLEACH BLOND HAIR, HER WAIST BULGING OVER HER CUTOFFS"
"THEY STABBED HER REPEATEDLY. THEY TOOK TURNS TRYING TO CUT OFF HER HEAD, WHICH THEY WANTED TO LEAVE ON A FENCEPOST FOR THE VULTURES. HER SPINE GAVE THEM TROUBLE. THEY HACKED AND WEDGED THE KNIFE'S POINT INTO THE VERTEBRA, BUT IT REMAINED STUBBORN."
If you want to see a romanticized version of OMG life... rent a movie... you want to learn about the dregs of society... read this book.
18 people found this helpful
★★★★★
2.0
AFTVOO55MG2BMJR5UIIT...
✓ Verified Purchase
Out Bad With The ATF.............
Very little new here after so much press coverage; especially The Arizona Republic's article about it and and the ad nauseum interviews done by Dobyns.
In short, here is the plot:
Agent infiltrates a local charter of the club.
Agent continues to spend untold dollars collecting "evidence" while delaying arrests for two years (federally fabricated crime).
Agent gives moving narrative about the stress and pressures of undercover work; personal sacrifice, affect on family, all in an attempt to "humanize" his mission while vilifying his targets.
Agent resigns from ATF and files suit: (Note: it is not legal for currently employed Federal agents to write of their exploits), and signs a book deal, bills himself as "expert witness" on outlaw motorcycle gangs, and THEN alleges he and his family are now not safe because the ATF "failed to protect them".
Can we say "pattern and practice" here? Is this a new career path by these guys? Though Dobyns case all but disintegrated and some of his "associates" have now gone on record about all the illegal activities they and Dobyns involved themselves in during the investigation, we are supposed to embrace his heroism?
Instead, I question not only his integrity, but his entire motive. Where does this man's loyalty lie? At present, he is still bad mouthing the ATF and is apparently saying he is a suspect in the arson of his own home.
There is little "star quality" here, little of the brute honesty of Billy Queen who at least had the temerity to admit he enjoyed the "brotherhood" aspect of a 1% environment and admitted his difficulties in testifying.
Jay Dobyns is and always has been about Jay Dobyns. To the casual reader unfamiliar with both the culture and code of the club, it precisely fills the bill ala Yves Lavigne and Dobyns should at least share some of the royalties with his co-stars. To my knowledge their is really only one "expert" on the Hells Angels. He has a long standing record of brutal candor. Sonny Barger swore on his "patch as a Hells Angel" that Dobyns NEVER became a full patch member, and I for one will take his word over Dobyns.
Take away the mystique of the club (something Dobyns has nothing to do with), and reposition the characters as anything other than Hells Angels and you have just another "true crime" novella, another brick in the wall.
From where I sit, Dobyns has betrayed not only the ATF, but his own credibility. Were I him, I would not be thinking "best seller" just yet.
Incidentally, my first clue was the inclusion of the word "harrowing" in the title. Can it be said that one could "infiltrate" the largest motorcycle club in the world in an un-harrowing manner?
Oh yeah. The "industry reviewers" in case you don't know, are paid to write glowing reviews for fledgling "authors".
George Werthern
Tony Tait
Billy Queen
Jay Dobyns
And to come, those ATF agents who took down the Mongols.
Literary chest thumping and little more.
13 people found this helpful
★★★★★
1.0
AFSRF2KP2ADEBZYNQMC6...
✓ Verified Purchase
Like slogging through mud
I love books about outlaw bikers and was looking forward to this one, whuch turned out to be one of the most poorly-written and plodding books I have ever read about anything. I was so disappointed, even mad, that I gave this 1 star instead of 2. Trying to read this was like slogging thru mud, it was so badly-paced and uninteresting (I guess the authors should get credit for turning what should be a fascinating subject into a big bore). Outside of the fact that Jay Dobyns comes across as smarmy and unlikable and self-important, I would not even comment on the characters in the book, their loyalties, their sense of honor, etc., as other reviewers have. This book was so lacking in any sense of tension, immediacy, even danger, as to make it almost unreadable; it's like a bad blog where nobody cares about what is being written except the author ("I got up. I bought some guns. I met some meth-heads. I got a tattoo.", ad nauseum). The 2 authors should read Humter S. Thompson and Yves Lavigne (whose "Three Can Keep a Secret..." is probably the best outlaw biker book available) to see how a book like this should be written.
11 people found this helpful
★★★★★
3.0
AGQUVE6TXA5YY2I5CDL3...
✓ Verified Purchase
What a dead end...
This book certainly was a fast-past, no holds barred account. But in the end, the main conflict in this book was the author's inner struggle.. It really is all about him.. He goes on for almost a whole page about how he made a grilled cheese sandwich for his kid. While just giving you sidelines about the Angels. I do commend him that he blames himself for his fanaticism for the case- plunging into the Angels' thug-life and almost losing his mind.. (Unlike someone like Sarah Palin who writes a book just to cast all her failures on others) But in the end, this shows the government's wasting of money and time. In a post 9-11 world, why should the ATF really care about a bunch of guys in the desert moving low amounts of drugs and alot of firearms in a carry-permit state?? If the Hells Angels were REALLY a problem, wouldn't the communities where they had their clubhouses have put pressure on the state and the police to clean up? Thank goodness he got out in one piece, but he should have been reeled in long before things got way too deep..
9 people found this helpful
★★★★★
3.0
AGE2K4HJQ2C7CQESJKN4...
✓ Verified Purchase
Okay
This book has its moments, but for the most part was not very exciting. I suppose the problem for me is I compared it to "Under and Alone" which is a far more exciting and interesting book about infiltrating a motorcycle club.
7 people found this helpful
★★★★★
3.0
AFIZDONVU77M6OQRL2P6...
✓ Verified Purchase
Decent
The book in my opinion is worth the read, but in no way on the level of "Under and Alone." I read other reviews saying how well written the book was; but I found myself constantly having to reread paragraphs to understand what the author was saying. The book although having a great story line and being very informative, does not flow. I also found myself having to go back to the front to be reminded who characters were.
When I read "Under and Alone", there was no doubt what was happening at anytime, nor who any characters were. The author, Bill Queen, makes you feel as if you were part of the whole investigation.