Mrs. Poe
Mrs. Poe book cover

Mrs. Poe

Hardcover – October 1, 2013

Price
$12.12
Format
Hardcover
Pages
336
Publisher
Gallery Books
Publication Date
ISBN-13
978-1476702919
Dimensions
6.13 x 1.1 x 9 inches
Weight
3.53 ounces

Description

From Publishers Weekly Cullen, whose previous novels have focused on obscure women from the past, such as Juana of Castile (Reign of Madness) and Sofonisba Anguissola (The Creation of Eve), now turns her attention to Frances Sargent Osgood, a mid-19th-century poet and children's author who, some believe, was romantically involved with Edgar Allen Poe. As the novel opens in 1845, Poe is the toast of literary New York, having just published the sensationally successful poem The Raven. Meanwhile, Mrs. Osgood, recently spurned by her philandering artist husband, is under enormous pressure to publish her work and thereby provide for her two young daughters. At a series of literary salons (many featuring cameos by other famous names of Poe's day), Mrs. Osgood and Poe develop a mutual attraction, as noticed not only by their peers but also by Poe's young and fragile wife, Virginia. Virginia's initially friendly overtures to her romantic rival become increasingly threatening, a nod to the macabre that seems unnecessary and gratuitous, as does the often-awkward insertion of research into the narrative. More successful is Cullen's portrayal of Osgood as a literary woman attempting to make a name (and a living) for herself against the odds. Agent: Emma Sweeney, Emma Sweeney Agency. (Oct.) From Booklist “The Raven,” “The Tell-Tale Heart”—these scary pieces by Edgar Allan Poe stirred the emotions of the literary ladies of his time. But in 1845, Poe stirred up gossip, too, with his attention to Frances Sargent Osgood, a poet deserted by her philandering husband. Poe’s deathly ill, 23-year-old wife (his first cousin, whom he married when she was 13) seems to be suspicious. Taking advantage of letters and published poems, imaginative historical novelist Cullen (Reign of Madness, 2011) cleverly spins a mysterious, dark tale told by Mrs. Osgood about the long-ago intrigue, with just enough facts to make it believable. Celebrities like Louisa May Alcott, Walt Whitman, and John Jacob Astor make cameo appearances. Others—the creator of graham crackers, the author of Bartlett’s Quotations, Horace Greeley—also step in for a fun romp through history. As the story unfolds, we’re left to wonder if Mrs. Poe is Edgar’s Mr. Hyde, or is Poe himself the villain? It’s enough to make the teacups rattle. --Laurie Borman "When struggling poet and betrayed wife Frances Osgood meets Edgar Allen Poe, she is hoping only for a boost in her literary career—certainly not what came next. Swept into an illicit love affair with the complicated, magnetic, and married Poe, Osgood and Poe must together face the consequences, which are no less horrific or revenge-filled than his best loved horror stories—and quite possibly as deadly. Mrs. Poe had my heart racing...Don't miss it!" Author: Sara Gruen, New York Times bestselling author of Water for Elephants and Ape House" Mrs. Poe is a compelling tale of ill-fated love, passion, and the writing life in antebellum New York, rich with period detail and suspense." Author: Jennifer Chiaverini, New York Times bestselling author of Mrs. Lincoln's Dressmaker"Layered with the atmosphere and intensity of Poe's prose, Cullen's Mrs. Poe infuses a tale of tragedy and loss with a spirit of passion and vitality. Fans of historical fiction and Poe will devour this novel." Author: Erika Robuck, bestselling author of Call Me Zelda“Readers can expect a page-turning tale exposing the transgressions, antics, and heroics behind a literary icon. Literary fiction fans and readers who loved Paula McLain’s The Paris Wife will relish another novel based on historical scandal and romance.” Author: Library Journal (starred review)“Part romance, part mystery, part biography, this fictional reenactment of the mistress of Edgar Allan Poe escorts you into the glittering world of New York in the 1840s, when poets were celebrities and the admission of emotions—like silk gowns and glossy beaver hats—were a luxury...A bewitching, vivid trip into the heyday of American literary society." Author: Oprah.com"A vivid portrait of New York's cultural life in the mid-1800s, when writers like Poe were practically rock stars. Don't miss it." Author: People“Is it true that Edgar Allen Poe cheated on his tubercular, insipid young wife with a lady poet he’d met at a literary salon? Cullen makes you hope so.” Author: New York Times" Mrs. Poe is such a compelling novel, bringing history to vivid life. Danger, sensuality, mystery and passion fill the pages of this bewitching story set in the crowded cobbled streets, alleyways,cheap boardinghouses and literary gatherings of mid-nineteenth century New York City. Everyone warns the lovely, near penniless poet Mrs. Osgood, a deserted wife with two young children, to stay away from the dark-eyed writer Edgar Allen Poe who has fallen in love with her. She writes tender verses; he creates blood-curdling tales but he is darker than his writing, carrying secrets of his frail much younger wife and his heinous past. Even when Mrs. Osgood understands that someone is trying to kill her because of him, she cannot put aside her passion until it is almost too late." Author: Stephanie Cowell, author of Claude and Camille"Lynn Cullen seems to have transported herself to Old New York— Mrs. Poe feels that authentic. Without a doubt, this is one of the best historical fiction novels I've read in a long time. Evocative, compassionate, intelligent, sexy and utterly addictive. The passion between Frances Osgood and Edgar Allen Poe burns up the pages while at the same time her relationship with Mrs. Poe makes your heart ache. Truly a book to savor!" Author: M.J. Rose, International Bestselling Author“At once beautiful and heartbreaking, Lynn Cullen has woven together a tapestry of fact and rumor to give us an intimate view into the forbidden love between two complicated, creative lives. Historical fictions fans, you’re in for a treat.” Author: Susan Crandall, bestselling author of Whistling Past the Graveyard"In Mrs. Poe , Lynn Cullen conjures a darkly atmospheric 19th century New York with a masterful hand. Rich with period detail and compelling characters, Mrs. Poe weaves a thread of creeping menace into the true story of Edgar Allan Poe’s obsessive liaison with Frances Osgood for a thoroughly unforgettable and chilling read. Enthralling." Author: Deanna Raybourn, author of A Spear of Summer Grass"The fierce ambitions and dangerous rivalries of literary New York in the 1840s come vividly alive in Lynn Cullen's riveting novel Mrs.Poe . With masterful skill, Cullen tells the story of the real-life fatal attraction between the toast-of-the-town Gothic storyteller Edgar Allan Poe and vulnerable poet Frances Sargent Osgood.The fact that both are unhappily married did not sanction any sort of romance in this judgmental society, and Cullen skillfully charts the course of a fraught and forbidden love affair. As the lonely Mrs. Osgood is pulled further and further into Mr. Poe's dark world, the tensions in the Poes' bizarre marriage explode. Full of longing, this is a story both poignant and shocking—and not easily forgotten." Author: Nancy Bilyeau, author of The Chalice“Clearly composed and carefully researched the book’s vivid prose accentuates the passion, jealousy and hatred that evolve from a tangled three-way relationship that could easily have come straight from the pages of Poe’s stories. A must-read for those intrigued by Poe, poetry and the latter half of 19th-century America.” Author: RT Book Reviews (four stars)“Taking advantage of letters and published poems, imaginative historical novelist Cullen cleverly spins a mysterious, dark tale told by Mrs. Osgood about the long-ago intrigue, with just enough facts to make it believable.” Author: Booklist“Lynn Cullen weaves a dark, sensuous love triangle between three real people, and in the midst of many real historical details, she creates something truly and wonderfully surprising...Devotees of dark historical fiction will devour Mrs. Poe , but so too will fans of Gothic romance and forbidden love stories. This is an invigoratingly creepy historical novel propelled by brilliant pacing. If you like books that send a little shiver up your spine, don’t miss it.” Author: Book Page "Mrs. Poe is an entertaining tale with interesting characters, a vibrant locale, a good dose of romance, and even some intrigue, which is what an historical novel should be." Author: The Copperfield Review"Cullen creates a delicious sense of suspense and impending doom; antebellum Manhattan and the ruling literati cast an irresistible spell." Author: Atlanta Magazine “ Brilliant…a wonderful and fascinating novel… Poe absolutely comes to life in Cullen's novel… Mrs. Poe is truly one of the best historical fiction novels of 2013 and possibly ever.” Author: Examiner.com"With obvious love and admiration for Edgar Allan Poe and his works, the author writes her dialogue scenes with such authenticity you swear you are in the parlor of one of Poe’s closest friends [and have] somehow received an invitation to one of these private gatherings where Mr. Poe will arrive with his ailing younger wife, Virginia, to read his latest published poem." Author: Kimberly Eve Source: Musings of a Writer"If you want to lose yourself in another time and place and become wrapped up in the drama of the life of literary New York and the characters who populated it then look no further. Mrs. Poe is a treasure and one you'll want to reread and research and remember." Author: Stephanie Piro Source: The Militant Recommender"Lynn Cullen's Mrs. Poe delivers the passion for characters that I had found in Anna Karenina , the tragedy that I discovered in Splendor In the Grass , and the thrill ride that I experienced in Poe's eerily written stories." Author: Dilettantish Reader"I'm already a fan of Poe's work. To see another side to him, a softer side to his tormented soul, was refreshing and wonderful. There is no way I can give this novel any less than 5 stars." Author: Literary R&R Book Blog"I absolutely loved everything about this book, starting with the literary references right down to the forbidden romance. Cullen took all the pieces, fact and rumors, about Edgar Allen Poe and the characters around him and wrote a beautiful story that delves into feminism, technological progress, NYC literary society, and so much more." Author: ShelfNotes.com"Coupled with lyrical prose and a fascinatingly complicated love triangle, the book held my attention from start to finish,giving me an insight into the tumultuous life of not only the characters, but of writers and the struggles they faced." Author: GreatHistoricals.com“This is one of the best books that I have EVER read and I strongly encourage you to check it out, Poe fan or not, the writing is just that good.” Author: Ionia Martin Source: Readful Things" Mrs. Poe is a captivating novel. Cullen’s attention to historical detail, lush prose and enlightening evocation of an interesting moment in American literary history make this story a fascinating read.” Source: Arts ATL Lynn Cullen grew up in Fort Wayne, Indiana and is the bestselling author of The Sisters of Summit Avenue , Twain’s End , and Mrs. Poe, which was named an NPR 2013 Great Read and an Indie Next List selection. She lives in Atlanta. Read more

Features & Highlights

  • Inspired by literature’s most haunting love triangle, award-winning author Lynn Cullen delivers a pitch-perfect rendering of Edgar Allan Poe, his mistress’s tantalizing confession, and his wife’s frightening obsession in this new masterpiece of historical fiction to which Sara Gruen says, “
  • Mrs. Poe
  • had my heart racing...Don't miss it!” And make sure to check out the captivating new novel from Lynn Cullen—
  • Twain’s End
  • —where the acclaimed author tells a fictionalized imagining of the relationship between iconic author Mark Twain and his personal secretary, Isabel Lyon.1845: New York City is a sprawling warren of gaslit streets and crowded avenues, bustling with new immigrants and old money, optimism and opportunity, poverty and crime. Edgar Allan Poe’s “The Raven” is all the rage—the success of which a struggling poet like Frances Osgood can only dream. As a mother trying to support two young children after her husband’s cruel betrayal, Frances jumps at the chance to meet the illustrious Mr. Poe at a small literary gathering, if only to help her fledgling career. Although not a great fan of Poe’s writing, she is nonetheless overwhelmed by his magnetic presence—and the surprising revelation that he admires
  • her
  • work. What follows is a flirtation, then a seduction, then an illicit affair…and with each clandestine encounter, Frances finds herself falling slowly and inexorably under the spell of her mysterious, complicated lover. But when Edgar’s frail wife, Virginia, insists on befriending Frances as well, the relationship becomes as dark and twisted as one of Poe’s tales. And like those gothic heroines whose fates are forever sealed, Frances begins to fear that deceiving Mrs. Poe may be as impossible as cheating death itself…

Customer Reviews

Rating Breakdown

★★★★★
30%
(360)
★★★★
25%
(300)
★★★
15%
(180)
★★
7%
(84)
23%
(276)

Most Helpful Reviews

✓ Verified Purchase

Another Griswold-like Insult

Oh, dear God, the very last thing the world needs is another novel about Poe that completely trashes all the known facts about him and transforms the man into a slimy ladies' man, to boot.

Where do I begin? There was NO AFFAIR between Poe and Frances Osgood. There is not one genuine Poe scholar who takes the idea at all seriously. Their relationship was, at most, a platonic acquaintance that lasted only one year. Osgood and her husband were never estranged, and there is no evidence whatsoever that Samuel was ever unfaithful. The Osgoods, by all the known evidence, were completely devoted to each other, and it is as certain as can possibly be that he was the father of ALL her children.

Many women found Poe attractive and fascinating, but in a "fangirl" sort of way. To paint him as a man-about-town womanizer is just absurd. In fact, although Poe loved and revered "womanhood" in an idealistic sense, what we know about him strongly suggests he was asexual.

And what Cullen did to Virginia Poe! To paint this poor young woman as an antebellum version of Glenn Close in "Fatal Attraction" is beyond absurd--it is disgusting.

As an amateur Poe scholar and long-time admirer of his work, I knew I'd dislike this novel when I first heard about it, but I had to read it to appreciate its true horror. And, believe me, I deeply regret that I did. The bland, cliched writing and uneasy lurches between simplistic Harlequin romance-type fiction and ludicrous Gothic horror would be laughable if it wasn't so insulting to our intelligence. I had thought "Poe & Fanny" and "The Raven's Bride" were about as low as Poe fiction could sink. I should have known that eventually, another author would come along to prove me wrong.

Novels like this wouldn't bother me, if it wasn't for the fact that people who don't know anything about Poe will assume it has some sort of biographical reality. I realize historical novelists have to "fill in the gaps" of known history a good deal, but when they directly contradict established facts--and it always seems to be in such an insulting fashion--I really get annoyed.

Basically, Cullen just took the names of real people and concocted fantasy characters and a fantasy storyline that was as close to reality as a Bugs Bunny cartoon.

In short: Well, no, I didn't think much of this book.
90 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Historical romance about Edgar Allan Poe

I don't think I would have ordered this book if I'd realized that it's
an historical romance, not an historical novel. Frances Osgood was a
(real) poet, who was quite popular in the New York literary society of
the 1840s. Horace Greeley, Rufus Wilmot Griswold, Elizabeth Ellet,
and Margaret Fuller, among many others notables, feature in the book. Osgood's connection with Poe was a major scandal, as they were both married, although Frances' husband had left her to dally with some of his portrait subjects. Poe and Frances Osgood wrote anonymous but
apparently quite obvious flirtatious poems to each other, published in
Poe's literary journal. The author works from these facts to invent
the details of both their relationship with each other, and the
relationship between Frances and Poe's wife and his mother-in-law.
These are all very dramatic, overwrought people, as the author draws them.

One aspect of the book that I particularly enjoyed was the friendship
between Frances and her friend Eliza Bartlett, who has taken Frances
and her two young daughters into her home after Frances is thrown out
of the Astor House hotel when her husband left behind a few months of
unpaid bills. The friendship and loyalty between the two women was
delightful. The servants were also real people and part of the story. Another nice thing was that the clothes were not described
constantly in great detail, as in many historical romances.

Frances seemed ambivalent to Poe -- she seemed too quick to accept
others' attempts to portray him as evil and dangerous. Mrs Poe and
her mother seem a bit mad and quite unpleasant.

The book was a fairly easy and exciting read, although it got a bit
repetitive. The romance didn't quite grab me, however. I think it's
very hard to draw an eccentric and extraordinary person like Poe
realistically, and I'm not sure the author succeeded, at least for me.
I was left feeling considerably less sympathy and more pity for Poe
than I had before reading the book.
31 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

The Tell-Tale Lack of Research, or 50 Shades of Poe, or Quoth the Reviewer "Nevermore" (Okay, I'll stop there)

Wouldn't it be great if Fifty Shades of Grey was an historical novel with no handcuffs and very little sex, but the quality of writing and character likability was the same? Said no one ever. No one except, it seems, Lynn Cullen.

My advanced reader's copy included a note from the publisher praising this "highly researched" novel about the "forbidden romance" between Edgar Allan Poe and Frances Sargent Osgood. I'm not sure what qualifies as "highly researched" these days, but I can't imagine this is it. The novel is so filled with anachronistic speech and dubious historical claims that it made me dizzy.

There are the obvious ones, like when our heroine muses that she heard James Polk's kidney stone operation left him "as sterile as a jug of boiled water." The story takes place in 1845. The very concept of sterilization by boiling would not be introduced for several more decades. Or when a character is described as having a "rubbery" face, even though that adjective wouldn't be used until around the end of the century (because, you know, use of rubber was pretty damn limited in 1845).

Then there are the subtler ones, words and phrases that, though they may have existed in 1845, were not used with the frequency they are today, so their overuse in the book gives it a distinctly modern feel. Words like off-putting, outrageous, ridiculous, adolescence, nice and nicer (both used constantly to mean "pleasant" even though that new meaning of the word was only just emerging and wouldn't have been used in every single conversation) are all used with the casual frequency that they are today, to the point of being cliché. And many of these words would have been used slightly differently 170 years ago, a distinction the author never bothers to address. And I don't even know what to say about phrases like "are you kidding me" and "in hot water." Would they have been used in 1845? After a while I was too tired to keep looking them up.

Of course it's not as though she ignores period phrases altogether. She seems to have made a list of "1800's words"--gaslight, hansom cab, reticule--and sprinkled them in as often as she could. Other times she just takes familiar phrases and makes them sound "old timey." When Frances reminds herself that Mr. Poe "put one leg in his pantaloons at a time, just like every other man" I nearly threw the book.

But even without the thoroughly unconvincing historical tone, Mrs. Poe just isn't very well written. There's only so many times I can read phrases like "he gave me a sharp look" or "he looked up sharply" or "he glanced sharply at me" before I lose all faith in the author.

Then there are the errors that just seem lazy, like when Frances sees "a hog feasting on a rotting pumpkin shell" in February. IN FEBRUARY. Considering pumpkins ripen between September and November, how long has that pumpkin shell been rotting on the street? Four months? It's like she included that detail just to annoy me.

Even with aggressive editing (i.e. a page one rewrite) the plot would still be far too much like 50 Shades of Poe for my taste. Frances Osgood is presented as a thoroughly unlikable woman with limited talent or education and an unsatisfying love life (sound familiar?). She has an inexplicable hatred of Edgar Allan Poe, based on his overbearing reputation and the fact that she finds him sexually intimidating. In their first meeting she is physically awkward and socially unimpressive (actually a little rude) but he is immediately taken with her for no damn good reason. He brazenly pursues her with a confusing air of authority, she relents, heaving bosoms ensue, and then he pulls back and insists he is unavailable. No whips or handcuffs though.

Is any of this even remotely historically accurate? By the end I didn't even care. The story was so poorly told that nothing could save it for me.

You can read this and other reviews on my blog, Cozy Little Book Journal.
30 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Author Takes Immense Liberties!

Often an author will take historic events and embellish upon them in order to flesh out the story. But, this author completely fabricates the characters of Poe, his wife, and Frances Osgood - and degrades them all! It's Rufus Griswold yet again. A horrible insult to the actual people - it's so wrong and very sad that these people are maligned when they can not speak for themselves. And the writing is poor - almost reads like a romance novel. Some of the expressions were in the 21st manner of speaking and were disconcerting in a novel that takes place in the 1800s. Don't waste your time and please don't spend money on something that is dishonoring to those who once lived.
17 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Silly, silly book.

After reading the other reviews I had hopes for this book. I am embarrassed to admit I read the whole thing, hoping it would get better. I found the endless list of historical notables at first distracting, then funny and finally just downright silly. An endless list of people who had little or nothing to do with the plot except that they were living in 1845 does not equate with historical accuracy. The characters were flat and lifeless, the plot trite and silly, silly, silly. Don't make my mistake and skip this one.
11 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

A Perfect Read for a Midnight Dreary -- Or Any Time!

This passion play begins on the set of the weekly conversaziones in the Waverly Place parlor of Miss Charlotte Lynch. Lynn Cullen draws back the velvet portières on Victorian society - revealing not just the era's usual suspects by way of literary lights, but Mathew Brady of daguerreotype acclaim, Sylvester Graham of cracker name, and Samuel F. B. Morse of code fame.

The stage is set when the story opens by skipping the light transatlantic for a gossipy dollop of Hungarian crème of the Listztomania that was sweeping the Continent. While Franz was parting pantaloons with his piano playing in the salons of Europe, Edgar Allan Poe was doing a Yankee Doodle Dandy job of making bodices heave with macabre reads here across the pond.

Abandoned wife Fanny Osgood finds herself unable to pay her rent at the Astor House (John Jacob himself has a couple of cameos) and is graciously welcomed with her girls into the home of Eliza and John Bartlett, of quotation reputation.

Known for his scathing evisceration of the contemporary condition of American poetry, Edgar Allan Poe surprised no one more than Frances Sargent Osgood herself by citing her as having rare promise in a lecture he gave, which included roundly trashing Henry Wadsworth Longfellow. Although she hadn't the good fortune to have been in attendance, she soon found herself invited for a private audience with the Elvis of his day.

This is not the dour, deranged, and drunken dramatist of your high school lit class! Edgar Poe was one of the first rock stars in the American firmament. Fainting couches best be close at hand whenever he entered a room. Catnip to most of the ladies who shared the rarified air of the author of the first American literary rage, The Raven, he seemed to have eyes only for fellow poet Fanny Osgood.

Mrs. Poe begins at the decade mark of a marriage that had grown increasingly untenable. He married his first cousin when she was 13, and he twice her age. Spoiler Alert: Cullen disabuses us of Virginia Clemm's being the precious Annabel Lee. She fully fleshes out the whys and wherefores of his lamentable and quasi-incestuous mésalliance. Virginia Poe would have been a shoo-in for Real Housewives of Victorian New York.

With her painstaking research and delight in tossing in a soupçon here and there of fascinating little peripheral details that propel the reader to the parlors and sidewalks of 1845 New York, Cullen has exceeded even her lofty standards. I thought I knew Poe, but his dangerous dalliance with Mrs. Osgood kept me enthralled from entrance to exit. A must-read.
9 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

You must read it!

This book affected me deeply. First of all, I must admit before getting into the following review that I am somewhat of a E.A.P. freak. His life and the mysterious way he often behaved are very interesting and in my opinion, perfect material for a novel of this type.

I expected this to be good, and instead it was great. I don't get the chance to say that very often. If you are not familiar with the famous poet and his life, you can still read this novel without any issue. Lynn Cullen included enough history on him, Virginia and Frances to make the reader feel comfortable and not as though they had been dropped into the middle of someone's life without warning.The relationship she described between Virginia and Frances was exactly what one would have expected if there were a great secret being upheld in such a situation.

I also appreciated the way the author portrayed Muddy. It is very clear that Lynn Cullen did hours of painstaking research before assembling her most amazing novel. Opinions on the life of those who left the world before us are always objective, but this is a testament to what a good imagination and a ready pen can do.

The way she built up the romance between Frances and Edgar was handled wonderfully. Even though the actual nature of their relationship has been debated for long years amongst the more staunch Poe historians, I would like to believe that it could have been very similar to what was penned here. Two literary lovers on the cusp of fame, finding one another and forming an unbreakable bond--what can I say, I am a romantic.

If I had to choose a favourite part of this book, I would definitely say that the realisation of Poe's mistake in Boston and the lingering effects of his decision would be it. Watching the decline of the man through the eyes of this author was vivid, intelligent and sad, all at the same time.

One thing worth a mention and that I found completely refreshing about this story, was that it seemed to intentionally neglect the alcoholism that Poe is famous for. It was mentioned a few times that he had not been drinking since a certain event happened, but the details of his drinking did not consume this story the way that so many others have been built around. Impressive, very.

This book flows well from the very beginning. Even the afterword is full of emotion. I generally leave off of a book with a dry eye, but not this time. Things are not all love and roses at the end of this story. They weren't in reality at that time either. People were dying left and right of consumption (Tuberculosis) and often people died young. I was happy to see that they author did not end this book on an "everyone lives perfectly happy" kind of note.

Do I recommend this book? Absolutely. This is one of the best books that I have EVER read and I strongly encourage you to check it out, Poe fan or not, the writing is just that good.

This review is based on a digital ARC provided by the publisher and Netgalley.
8 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

***PRETTY INTERESTING.....****

Being a fan of historical fiction, and knowing virtually nothing about the personal life of Edgar Allen Poe, I was anxious to read this book. The main protagonist is actually the very married Frances Osgood; estranged from her husband who struggles with monogamy, Poe and Mrs. Osgood find themselves inextricably drawn to each other. It soon becomes apparent to everyone that the two have much more in common than an interest in poetry. Nor does any of it escape the notice of the very young and ailing Virigina Poe....who decides that it is perhaps best to keep her enemies close. She decides that she wants to become good friends with Frances Osgood....or does she really? A series of misfortunes...potentially fatal misfortunes...seem to occur whenever Virginia Poe is near. Is she really as innocent and childlike as she appears....or is there evil afoot?

An interesting read, but I found the protagonist frustratingly unbelievable in some of her actions (running around a deserted, dilapidated old church looking for Poe...among other things). Mr. and Mrs. Poe were certainly the most compelling components of this novel....not surprisingly. Good book, but not one that I can rave over.

DYB
7 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Edgar and Frances

Edgar Allen Poe, in the eyes of modern readers, is many things, including enigmatic, gothic, talented, and a bit crazy. As author Lynn Cullen imagines him, he's talented, enigmatic, and romantic. Yes, romantic. He fell madly "in love" with his young cousin, Virginia, ten years before this novel begins, but the marriage hasn't developed as he might have wished. Instead, Virginia is still childlike and very sickly, and while Edgar does love her, any eroticism that he felt originally has long since dissipated. The constant presence of Edgar's mother in law doesn't help matters. Now he's the toast of New York, and while attending an intellectual salon, meets Francis Osgood, a minor poet trying to eke out a living, as her profligate husband has deserted her and their two daughters. Edgar and Fanny are instantly attracted to one another, and a love affair, first platonic, then increasingly sensual, blooms. But Mrs. Poe, though frequently bedridden, isn't blind, and as her suspicions grow, so does the tension, and, Fanny learns, danger.

Ms. Cullen has skillfully used the few existing grains of factual information about this relationship to piece together a consuming romance which, in the pages of this novel, obsesses both Edgar and Fanny. Her attention to detail, her ability to bring the gas lit streets and mansions of the city to life, and her very human character portrayals, especially of Poe himself, are enthralling. Cameo appearances are made by the literati of the era, and Fanny encounters one famous personage after another. Imagine meeting Louisa May Alcott, Mathew Brady, and Walt Whitman as you sashay down Fifth Avenue. Actually, there's a bit too much celebrity sighting, leading the reader to wonder if anyone ordinary lives in the city, but it's a fun situation to picture. One of the personages in the book, the editor Rufus Griswold, did a thorough character assassination of Poe after his death, and Ms. Cullen has done a service by providing a more sympathetic image of the man, who had to be more complex than the one presented by Griswold. Mrs. Poe is intelligently written, and while it is historical fiction, it's refreshing to shake up one's notions and consider alternative possibilities to biographies believed to have been set in stone.
6 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Imagine if you will....

First we have to realize this is fiction. By definition fiction is "literature in the form of prose, esp. short stories and novels, that describes imaginary events and people". Whether Frances Osgood and Poe actually had an affair or even a flirtation is not relevant. After all I don't think Abraham Lincoln was a vampire slayer either.

Second, once we accept number one, this book becomes a "what if?". It is fairly well written and does a decent job in describing the New York of 1845. It is a romance novel which is not my usual cup of tea, but as a Poe fan I was interested enough to read it, and do have to say it held my interest.

My biggest bone to pick is that it is poorly edited. One would expect a publisher to see that the product they are producing is as accurate as possible. One example: "Mrs. Poe"s face hardened as drew herself upright ". As a reader these kind of errors jar me out of the story and make me regret paying money for a book.

Read it, enjoy it, but realize it is romantic fiction and let your imagination loose.
5 people found this helpful