Land of Love and Drowning: A Novel
Land of Love and Drowning: A Novel book cover

Land of Love and Drowning: A Novel

Hardcover – July 10, 2014

Price
$23.24
Format
Hardcover
Pages
368
Publisher
Riverhead Books
Publication Date
ISBN-13
978-1594488337
Dimensions
6.25 x 1.25 x 9 inches
Weight
1.25 pounds

Description

From School Library Journal Gr 9 Up—The Virgin Islands is the main character in this debut novel. St. Thomas, like its inhabitants, comes of age after it transfers from Danish to American rule in the early 1900s. Distinctive multiple narrators tell the story of the wealthy Captain and his beautiful but "wild" wife, Antoinette; his daughters, Eeona and Anette; and his son Jacob, conceived with his mistress. When Bradshaw's ship sinks, taking the lives of his crew with him, the island and his family are changed forever. Eeona longs to escape the islands, Anette craves the security of a committed relationship, and Jacob falls in love with the wrong woman. History is reflected in their lives and times: when World War II breaks out, Jacob and his friends head to the mainland as soldiers only to face a racism that did not exist at home; the rise of civil rights on the mainland fuels a growing rebellion on St. Thomas. Mature themes weave throughout these stories, including sexuality and incest. Recommend to teens who enjoy strong characters, a tumultuous historical time period, and a setting that embraces music, madness, and Caribbean magic.—Connie Williams, Petaluma High School, CA "Yanique spins a series of seductive tales covering six decades and three generations living in the Virgin Islands in her first novel, which draws upon her own family history."—NPR, Great Reads of 2014"It's a tired cliché to call a place a character, but in Tiphanie Yanique's gorgeous debut, St.Thomas in the U.S. Virgin Islands makes for a textured and fascinating protagonist. At the beginning of the novel, in the early 20th century, the island is in flux as it goes from Danish to American ownership. At the same time, sisters Eeona and Anette find their fortunes changing drastically when their father, Captain Owen Arthur Bradshaw, who's something of a local legend, drowns in a shipwreck. The untouchably beautiful Eeona and the earthy but equally seductive Anette must evolve and fend for themselves as Saint Thomas becomes a tourist hot spot and their dead father's secrets continue to haunt them at every turn—as we're often reminded, it's a small island. Yanique's many artful touches—switched perspectives, deeply idiomatic dialogue, island folklore, strokes of magical realism—are so arresting that it's easy to overlook the mastery involved in intertwining the history of a place and the lives of two unforgettable women."—Entertainment Weekly "In Land of Love and Drowning , three generations of beautiful Bradshaw women bewitch the men of St. Thomas through the islands' transfer to American control, World War II, segregation and the aftermath of a catastrophic hurricane. Secrets and jealousies shadow the relationship between two sisters and set them apart from other islanders as they all lurch through historical changes. . . .xa0Yanique has written the best kind of summer read—lurid, yet layered and literary."—NPR.org"A feat of tropical magical realism.”— Vanity Fair “Spellbinding.”— Elle “Sink or swim is the guiding theme in this fantastical, generational novel.”— Marie Claire "This hypnotic tale tracks a Virgin Islands family through three generations of blessings and curses. It starts in 1900, with a shipwreck that orphans two sisters and the half-brother they've just met, and then spinso out magic, mayhem, and passion."— Good Housekeeping "Axa0debut novel about three generations of a Caribbean family. It reads lush and is graced with rotating narrators, each of whom has a distinct and powerful voice."— USA Today "The novel provides readers with beautiful, imaginative prose via a story set in the Virgin Islands.”— Ebony "Through the voices and lives of its native people, Yanique offers an affecting narrative of the Virgin Islands that pulses with life, vitality, and a haunting evocation of place."— Publishers Weekly (starred)"Bubbling with talent and ambition, this novel is a head-spinning Caribbean cocktail."— Kirkus (starred)“A few years ago, Tiphanie Yanique wowed us with her phenomenal story collection, How to Escape from a Leper Colony . Now she brings us this astonishing and wondrous novel. Multilayered, multigenerational and epic in both talent and scope, Land of Love and Drowning is a stunning first novel about family, history, home and much, much more. Tiphanie Yanique’s tremendous talents and incredible storytelling will astound you and leave you breathless.”—Edwidge Danticat“ Land of Love and Drowning is a gorgeous incantation of a novel, a masterly fusion of place, language, and seductive storytelling that will hold you spellbound from its first pages to the last. Tiphanie Yanique takes on all of it—the bitter and the sweet, love and loss, betrayal and faith, as well as the distant machinations of state that push us about like so many minnows on ocean tides—and does so with a grace and a wisdom that are nothing short of profound. This book is an absolute marvel.”—Ben Fountain, author of Billy Lynn’s Long Halftime Walk “ Land of Love and Drowning is a marvel—epic and sweeping, yet intimate as a secret. It’s a tour de force combining naturalism and lyricism, myth and history. This is a story that feels ancient and modern at the same time. Tiphanie Yanique is a prodigiously talented new writer with a sharp voice, wicked humor, and compassion beyond measure.”—Tayari Jones, author of Silver Sparrow “What a miracle this book is. Tiphanie Yanique unites the sweep of history and the tenderest movements of the heart in writing so beautiful it’s breathtaking. Both an epic and a three-generation love poem, it’s irresistible.”—Stacey D’Erasmo, author of The Sky Below “In Land of Love and Drowning , Tiphanie Yanique paints a poignant, electrifying panorama of the Virgin Islands. Breaking writerly rules left and right, Yanique’s sentences seem effortless, free. Yet watch as these assemble into a family saga of unforgettable gravitas. A magnificent story, marvelously told.”—Claire Vaye Watkins, author of Battleborn Tiphanie Yanique is from Saint Thomas, Virgin Islands. The author of the story collection How to Escape from a Leper Colony , she is a 2010 Rona Jaffe Writers’ Award winner and was named by the National Book Awards as one of 2011’s “5 Under 35.”xa0 She teaches at the New School and lives in Brooklyn and Saint Thomas. Excerpt. © Reprinted by permission. All rights reserved. ***This excerpt is from an advance uncorrected proof***Copyright © 2014 Tiphanie Yanique 1. Owen Arthur Bradshaw watched as the little girl was tied up with lace and silk. He jostled the warm rum in his glass and listened to the wind. The storm outside wasn’t a hurricane. Just a tropical gale. It was the season for storms. Lightning slated through the heavy wooden shutters that were closed but unfastened. The thunder was coming through the walls built with blue bitch stone. There was no one outside walking in the rain. That sort of thing was avoided. A scientist visiting from America had brought the lace and the silk. They were all at the house of Mr. Lovernkrandt, an eminent Danish businessman. Denmark was giving up on the West Indies and American was buying in, but Mr. Lovernkrandt was not leaving. The scientist was tying the girl up. He was demonstrating an experiment that had become stale on the Continent, an experiment of electricity. The little girl was very beautiful. And she was very little. And she was very afraid. She was also very brave. Captain Bradshaw thought on his daughter, Eeona, who was not unlike this American girl. Only Eeona was more beautiful and at least as brave. --- The people who had come together to make Captain Owen Arthur Bradshaw could be traced back to West Africans forced to the islands as slaves and West Africans who came over free to offer their services as goldsmiths. Back to European men who were kicked out of Europe as criminals and to European women of aristocratic blood who sailed to the islands for adventure. Back to Asians who came as servants and planned to return to their Indies, and to Asians who only wanted to see if there was indeed a western side of the Indies. And to Caribs who sat quietly making baskets in the countryside, plotting ways to kill all the rest and take back the land their God had granted them for a millennium. Owen Arthur had been raised from a poor upbringing to a place of importance and ownership. He was the captain and owner of a cargo ship. And now he was among the important men who sat in this living room and watched through the haze of the oil lamps as a girl was hoisted off the ground via lace and silk and a hook in the ceiling. The little girl’s body jerked as the American scientist tugged. Her body jerked until she was a few feet off the ground, but she did not cry out. Owen Arthur Bradshaw was not sure how much longer he could bear to watch. But it was essential for him to be at this gathering. The host, Mr. Lovernkrandt, was a rum maker and Owen Arthur had always shipped rum. But with Americaness would come Prohibition, and Owen Arthur needed to ensure he was included in any of Lovernkrandt’s nonliquor endeavors. He pressed his own earlobe between his thumb and forefinger. Success and solvency should have been on his mind, but Owen Arthur could not help but watch the American girl with a father’s tenderness. This little girl was pale-faced and blond, and Owen’s little girl, Eeona, was honey-skinned and ocean-haired. But still he looked at this strange little girl as though looking on his own child. The first half of him desired that he had created this little girl. She was a pretty yellow thing. The lower half of him desired the girl. How young could she be? He put his mouth to his glass and tilted it until the warm sweetness met his lips. She will outlive me, he thought to himself. And who was the “she” he was referring to? Perhaps his wife, who was just then sitting at home doing the sewing that it seemed God had created her to do. Or perhaps he was speaking of his mistress, who was at that moment sitting in her home playing the piano he had bought her, making a music that only God or the Devil could bless. Or perhaps he was actually speaking of his daughter, whom he loved like he loved his own skin. Perhaps he was speaking of the little girl to whom the scientist was now attaching cords of metal. Perhaps the little girl was, in a way, all women to him, as all women might be to a certain kind of man. Owen Arthur is right. All these shes will outlive him, though he cannot bear the thought of his women going on. He knows his daughter will live forever, in the way all parents do, simply because parents generally die first. But Owen will not die of old age. Owen will die of love. The Danish West Indies will become the United States Virgin Islands and then this patriarch will die. And perhaps these things are the same thing. “Behold,” the American is saying in his strange accent. He hands the girl a glass ball and then whispers to her, “Do not drop it or I will punish you.” She does not make a move to suggest she has heard. She only takes the glass ball in both her hands. And then the first miracle happens—her hair begins to rise. The storm outside begins to howl. “Christ, have mercy.” This is what the Christians whisper. The Jewish and Muslim men for whom these islands have been a refuge, mutter “Oy, Gotenu” and “Allahu Akbar” under their breaths respectfully. Yes, America will bring us progress. Here is progress before us. Lightning claws through the window, as though hunting. And Owen Arthur watches the girl’s hair rise towards the ceiling until it is sticking up like so many angel horns. Oh, the stories these men will tell of this night. How they will embellish one part, shrink the other. How they will make this night real again and again, some in Arabic or Danish or Yiddish or English, others in that Caribbean language that tourist guidebooks will call “Creole.” The story will become more real than the night itself because the story of it will last, while this wet night will soon be over. And here we are putting it down, so that it may last forever. But Owen Arthur thinks on his firstborn. His only child, thus far, who has survived to life. His honey-skinned Eeona. Her hair, too, has a life of its own. He has combed it himself and knotted it into braids and found that he can get lost in its forest. He collects the pieces of her hair from the brush and burns them himself, so that no one can steal them and put a curse on her. Owen himself is not a hairy man, he does not even sport the sideburns so popular for men of this time and place. His daughter has the glorious hair on her head but otherwise she, too, is smooth all over. Eeona is so beautiful that many call her pure and they think on the virgin hills. Or they call her pristine and they think of the clear and open ocean. Or they might use terms such as untouched or undefiled, but then they are cautious because they know that their words alone might spoil her. So on damp nights men imagine that they are angels and may touch her as they please, but when they wake, they sign themselves with the cross. And if available, they pat handfuls of holy water on their chests. They do not really wish to pollute little Eeona. They only wish to witness a bit and then return, like a tourist might. The American scientist takes the ball from this other little girl in this parlour. Now he prepares for the real triumph. He will make the little girl into a miracle. The scientist raises the vial to the little girl’s face. The little girl is wise as little girls must be. She does not flinch, but she closes her eyes. The scientist touches the vial to her nose. White lights spark like lightning about her face. She cries out, but the men clap louder. They have seen electricity! They have seen the future! “Mr. Lovernkrandt,” the scientist says, “you must try.” The vial is passed to the man of the house, who has been standing near a window that is fastened but not sealed—the legs of rain kicking at his back. He steps forwards, and with great hesitation that might be mistaken for trepidation were he not a wealthy man, he presses the vial to the brave girl’s nose. He feels the shock in his hand and up his wet sleeve and lurches away. “Mercy,” he exclaims so loudly that no one hears the little girl cry out again. His face is hot. For a moment he had thought he would be paralyzed. But he had survived. Owen feels the rain sneaking through as kisses from a tiny mouth. Now he raises his hand. “I should like to try,” he says. The American scientist smiles as Owen Arthur steps forwards. He passes Owen the vial. Owen walks towards the little girl. She is suspended so that he and she are level. Their eyes meet. He bends towards her and caresses her earlobe gently, for he enjoys the feeling of that soft skin. “Men are foolish when pretty girls are involved,” he says loud enough for all to hear, and then he dashes the vial onto the floor. The great men snort. Many look away, ashamed that they had not had Captain Bradshaw’s integrity. “My apologies, Mr. Lovernkrandt. I seem to have broken the American’s instrument. I am afraid I have ended the game.” Owen thinks on the major shipping deals he must have lost now. Thinks on how his business has depended on Lovernkrandt’s rum for more than a decade. But then he thinks on something else. “I fear most that it is past this little girl’s bedtime.” He touches the girl’s hair then tips his hat and takes his leave into the storm. Science is just a kind of magic, and magic just a kind of religion, and Owen Arthur knows all about this because Owen owns a ship and men who spend their lives on water know that magic is real. As he stands in the rain, the lightning brightening the way ahead of him, Owen cannot decide to which house he will walk. Lovernkrandt’s house, so well positioned at the center of town, is not far from the opening of the sea. Wherever Owen goes, the sea will be at his side either way. A small wall of stone has been built to block the bay. So it is no longer really a beach but a proper harbour. Still, it would be nothing at all for Owen to walk to the ocean right now. He has done it before. He swam in this harbour as a boy. The ocean, look now, is coming to him. The waves are bounding over the seawall, leaping, like animals, like little girls. If he keeps the sea on his right then he will go past the market square where entrepreneur ladies sell their produce and straw creations. There, Rebekah lives in a small house with her sons. None of these sons are his, yet. If he puts the sea on his left, he will pass the smaller fish market where men haul in the catch of the day before dawn. Beyond, Owen’s wife, Antoinette, lives in Villa by the Sea. It is a wealthy but modest estate where their daughter and their cook, Miss Lady, and their groundskeeper, Mr. Lyte, all live. The house is at the shallow edge of the harbour. The living and dining rooms are separated from each other by a line of linen curtains, which makes the house feel like a ship at sail. From the Villa by the Sea balcony the captain can see his own ship docked farther into the bay. Now Owen Arthur thinks of the little girl’s hair rising into the air and he faces the beach. He waits until his whole body has received the rain. Then he goes towards his Eeona, because the little orphan girl reminded him of her. Owen cannot see into the future, but he can see into the past, and this is a magic we all have. As he walks, the sea is at his side, but the rain is at his back, pushing him towards his only child. The waves slip over his shoes. When Owen arrives, he goes to his wife, who is telling a story to little Eeona in the parlour. This family will know itself through stories told in time and others told too late. In this way they are no different from any other tribe. “Holy Ghost,” his wife cries when she sees him wet, as though he’d been drowning. “Lady!” Antoinette calls. “A towel, a change of clothes for the captain. Quickly.” Eeona has no restraint. She runs to her father and he picks her up and puts her to his chest, even though he will make her wet and they will both be sick over this. When Miss Lady comes from upstairs with the towels, she knows to bring two. At this moment it is only the one child and she is in love with her father. It is no large thing that this daughter will, in time, kill Owen Arthur. No large thing at all. Family will always kill you—some bit by bit, others all at once. It is the love that does it. In her womb mother Antoinette is carrying another child. But she does not want more children, so this child, like the three before it, will be made to know the island ways of washing the womb. But women do not always have their way. This child will survive and will be the last of Owen’s children. She will be called Anette. Anette Bradshaw will be as different from her elder sister as water is from land. The elder sister will be so stunning that men will scare of her. But not Anette. Boys will stick to the younger sister like the slick of mango juice. A trinity of men will feel the love of her like casha bush burring their scalp in sleep. Anette’s own image will grace the silver screen. The islands will drop the BOMB because of her say so. But baby Anette has not come as yet. Right now it is only Eeona and Papa, with Mama there watching. 2. A N E T T E Don’t mind I ain born as yet. I is the historian in this family. Teacher of history at the Anglican school where all the fancy families does send their children. So is me could really tell you what happen on Transfer Day. If anyone know the history is me. Nowadays people think historians are stuffy types, but history is a kind of magic I doing here. Read more

Features & Highlights

  • Recipient of the 2014 American Academy of Arts and Letters Rosenthal Foundation Award
  • A major debut from an award-winning writer—an epic family saga set against the magic and the rhythms of the Virgin Islands.
  • In the early 1900s, the Virgin Islands are transferred from Danish to American rule, and an important ship sinks into the Caribbean Sea. Orphaned by the shipwreck are two sisters and their half brother, now faced with an uncertain identity and future. Each of them is unusually beautiful, and each is in possession of a particular magic that will either sink or save them. Chronicling three generations of an island family from 1916 to the 1970s,
  • Land of Love and Drowning
  • is a novel of love and magic, set against the emergence of Saint Thomas into the modern world. Uniquely imagined, with echoes of Toni Morrison, Gabriel García Márquez, and the author’s own Caribbean family history, the story is told in a language and rhythm that evoke an entire world and way of life and love. Following the Bradshaw family through sixty years of fathers and daughters, mothers and sons, love affairs, curses, magical gifts, loyalties, births, deaths, and triumphs,
  • Land of Love and Drowning
  • is a gorgeous, vibrant debut by an exciting, prizewinning young writer.

Customer Reviews

Rating Breakdown

★★★★★
30%
(225)
★★★★
25%
(188)
★★★
15%
(113)
★★
7%
(53)
23%
(171)

Most Helpful Reviews

✓ Verified Purchase

Review of Land of Love and Drowning

If you are any sort of reader you know that there are different categories of books. There's easy, light reads that can be finished in an afternoon, there's tense, gripping reads that won't release you until you turn the last page - and even then, you struggle with moving on from them for several days to weeks. And then there's the type of book that weaves a spell around you. It slowly entrances you in a way that hides the entrancement and, when you finish it, you end up dreaming about it and feeling caught in an otherwordly-type of spell. That's what I've been doing today. I finished LAND OF LOVE AND DROWNING by Tiphanie Yanique last night and I dreamed I was in her world all through the night and woke up in a daze this morning.

That's some powerful storytelling, folks.

It's the kind of story-telling that I love, too. The incorporation of myths and gods, of tall tales and history; the weaving of all of these things until you don't know (or care) what is true and what's not. Add into it real events dealing with parts of the world I had never even heard of and... well, it was a heck of a story.

Still, there were some flaws. I wasn't gripped by the first 100 pages, in fact, I dabbled with putting the book down and not finishing it at all. While it was interesting, it was very strongly dealing with some issues that made me more than a little uncomfortable. As the book progressed, I understood more that it was more about symbolism and feminine power - but still, that's hard to grasp in the opening chapters of a book, especially if the story is one that's not often told. I have absolutely no doubt that people with a broader worldview than my own or more knowledge of the culture and society living in the USVI may view this differently. I'm just a single reviewer and, while I appreciate the education and feel enriched by the story, it doesn't take away from the fact that I had to push myself to get past those first 100 pages.

I think Yanique is going to be an author to watch. She tied the civil rights movement in to the lives being lived in the USVI in a way I've never seen before. She talked about characters that were familiar to me from my readings in other areas (Western African literature and Native American). I was thrilled to see a version of the trickster that I don't come across often being spoken of and I was entranced by the idea of the duane.

More than anything else, LAND OF LOVE AND DROWNING has kindled a curiosity in me about the USVI and the British Virgin Islands. I want to know more and, if the other books I find that take on these subjects and the locations are only half as good as LAND OF LOVE AND DROWNING, then I consider myself fortunate.
56 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

What's the fuss about?

I'm not sure what the fuss about this book has been all about. I had read reviews of it in at least 3 magazines saying it is such a great novel. That made me really excited to read it and get to review it. I have been so disappointed. Honestly, the best part has been laughing every time they say "What the ass?". Not really high recommendation there.

The parents are disgusting (incest and abortions), the girls are vapid and uninteresting. The half-brother (and his mother) are almost close to noble in their motives, although they're not really likable either. The pace is like molasses. It takes forever to get to anything resembling a story.

The one thing good is the description of the islands.

I will admit that it is beautifully written, it is lyrical and descriptive. I just really hated the story line. If I had known more about the story, other than that it was a story of a family throughout the generations in USVI, I would probably not have requested it to review.

I have a personal review limit that I will not read less then half a book before I give up on it. Usually by that point, I'm hooked and will read the whole book. I found myself counting the pages to halfway so I could stop reading it, in good conscience. I tried to like it. I tried to keep reading it but it sat on the counter looking at me, without being touched for three days so I realized I just really didn't want to read anymore and didn't care about what was going to happen past the point where I stopped reading.

REVIEW NOTE:
I realize that some people will mark this as "unhelpful" simply because they disagree with my review. Please don't be unfair. If we disagree, we disagree. That doesn't mean it's not helpful or an honest review.
23 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Not An Enjoyable Read

I really enjoy multi-generational family stories particularly when they occur in exotic settings. For this reason, I really looked forward to Land of Love and Drowning. However, being a realist, I don't really enjoy stories of mysticism, magic and/or spirits...there has to be great narrative or characterization or incredible language...which explains why I did not like this book. I sometimes could not tell if something was really happening or just occurring in the narrator's imagination or dreams. Some of the language of this book is truly beautiful...descriptions of gold-glinted waves rippling around the islands. Probably to induce authenticity from her own childhood in St. Thomas, the author uses language that I can only assume was traditional island language...but this technique can also be interruptive. I am pretty good at figuring out the meaning of a word from the context of the words around it, but I could not figure out the meaning of "bazadie" or "bawna. " Googling these words, which is disruptive to the flow of reading anyway, provided no help, except that I did find a You Tube video of "bawna," which showed a group of children chanting a song...this did not further my understanding at all. Eeona's narration was easier to follow; Anette's narration is much harder to follow at times..."Is a big running me and Gertie do." I have read and completely enjoyed other books containing spirits and magic...Forever by Pete Hamill, The Golem and the Jinni by Wecker..but Land of Love and Drowning just did not have the story line, the language or the characters that would make me enjoy the book..
11 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Gorgeous writing but problematic pacing

TL;DR: The book is phenomenally written, and Yanique does a phenomenal job juggling multiple narrative voices. However, the book's pacing is unfortunately slow, and there are problems with Yanique's inclusion of incest, especially as it relates to the islanders.

The stand-out feature of this book the writing, which is breathtakingly beautiful. Yanique has a sense for language, and I finished the book not for the plot but to ensure I wouldn't miss a minute of Land of Love and Drowning's linguistic beauty. Her prose is remarkably tonal, and she manages to turn phrases in ways that are resonant and powerful. As other reviewers have noted, her words wrap around you and draw you into the Virgin Islands, and they won't let you leave until the very last period.

Likewise, Yanique paints a compelling portrait of a family. Each character works as an individual and as a part of the narrative, and they drift in and out of the story not unlike the tides. The movement of the novel and the characters' arcs mimics the ocean in its swells and eddies, which is yet another tribute to Yanique's talent as a storyteller. This book, like many modern novels, doesn't have a strong central plot beyond telling the story of an island family, but that mythical narrative manages to sustain the work better than a traditional plot might have.

Having said that, the biggest issue with this novel is its pacing. It took me nearly a month to finish, largely because the narrative drags along for large stretches before it picks up again. That's not to say that I think the book should have advanced from crisis to crisis in a quickstep; rather, Land of Love and Drowning's structure needed tightening. That's what makes this book a three-star rather than a four-star read for me. Ultimately, the pacing of the book hampered my enjoyment of it.

I also feel like I need to touch on incest, which figures prominently into the narrative. I'm still not quite sure what to do with it: part of me wants to read it as a productive critique of the nuclear family, but it seems like much more. I wasn't bothered by its inclusion, but I was troubled by how it works toward Othering Virgin Islanders. In a book that clearly loves island culture and history, making incest such a prominent thread creates problems in that it reinforces (still prevalent but unfortunate) colonial ideas about cultural difference and degeneracy, especially as it relates to native masculinities. It doesn't work to the islanders' favor, in other words.

Lastly, I hated the author's note at the end of the book. It detracts from the magic of the narrative, and I sincerely dislike when authors try to show me how much research they conducted. Good authors do research, which invariably shows through the narrative. Yanique's afterward is a strange list of minutae that takes away from the overwhelming magic of her narrative. A story like Land of Love and Drowning's doesn't need justification. It stands on its own.

Even with the weird foibles in Land of Love and Drowning's, the beauty of Yanique's prose alone makes this a recommended read. I get the feeling I'll be chewing over this novel for a long time.
10 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

A Solid Debut!

I suppose this novel can be described as a love story, a history lesson, and a magical tale set amid the beautiful, yet seductive, Caribbean landscape. It focuses on the life and times of two sisters and their half-brother as they cope with abandonment, love, and fate. Early on, they grapple with the newness and unknowns bestowed upon St. Thomas as part of the U.S. Virgins Islands and struggle with the concepts of belonging, freedom and equality which are implied entitlements that surely come with the transfer. Freedom, equality, and a sense of belonging are haunting themes that recur throughout the novel in each of the central characters' plots.

In an era where social standing and family name reflected status and commanded respect, the beautiful, elder sister (Eeona) attempts to cling to their social standing and possessions after the untimely death of their parents leave them destitute and her single. What follows is decades of longing for her freedom instead of the burden of mothering a much younger and free-spirited sister (Anette). Eeona's vanity and desire to rise above her station causes her to dismiss numerous suitors leaving her loveless and alone. Where Eeona is the island's ice queen, Anette is the sensuous red-head, whose warm, fiery spirit seemingly accepts the kindness of any man who loves her, eventually birthing a child from three of them. She fails to marry her true love because Eeona and his mother expressly forbid it; however a daughter is born shortly after the thwarted nuptials. Abandoned by his father when he was an infant, their half-brother enters manhood during WWII and battles the enemy and Jim Crow in the segregated American South. He eventually becomes a doctor and returns to the island to practice.

To comment further could spoil the plot, so I'll simply mention that a novel such as this wouldn't be complete without its fair share of secrets (which everyone seems to know except those affected by it), heartbreak, struggle, folklore, and taboo/perversion. According to the Author's Note, some aspects of the novel were biographical, or at least may have been inspired by the lives, loves, and adventures of her grandparents. Kudos for her to memorialize them in her debut novel!
10 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Swimming in Holy Water

This novel is quite good, I think, but rather hard to analyse, qua novel. This difficulty arises from the fact that whilst, yes, this novel, is part history of the U.S. Virgin Islands, part a multi-generational family history, its main pull for the reader lies in the powerful incantatory poetics of the prose, told partly in Annette’s rambling, luxuriant, dialect. In other words, reviewing what is so original and powerful in the book is like trying to parse a wild poem, place a pattern on the mists rising from the sea at daybreak or to net a mermaid. Analysis becomes paralysis. This poetic power is put to best effect in the first 150 or so pages. After that, it lagged for me and became somewhat predictable.

But those first pages are marvellously powerful. The reader feels that s/he is being woven into a spell, lovely and haunting as the islands themselves are described:

“But these islands are just too beautiful. You walk out of your own front door into cathedrals. You step down your own stairs up towards an altar. God speaks from a bougainvillea bush, from Mountain Top. You go to the beach and swim in holy water. The beauty, like God’s grace, is ubiquitous and it is blinding.”

But, of course, an entire 350 page history cannot be wholly told under such a magical enchantment, and God’s blinding grace does not fall into some very shadowy areas indeed of the interwoven histories described herein. As the narrative voice says of Annette’s feelings for Jacob on the beach, “This was either a major mistake or this was the man of her life - that these two things could be the same thing did not occur to her.” It does occur many times for the reader before the turning of the last page.

I’d recommend the book to lovers of the sea and of poetry, particularly the poetry of Derek Walcott, who is quoted in the book, and is the greatest living poet of whom this reader is aware.

In response to the question, “What makes Caribbean literature unique?” Walcott replied:

“It may seem so simple to say that it is sea. But it is the sea.”

Author Tiphanie Yanique manages in this novel to convey elaborately why this is so.
8 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Incest, sibling rivalry and sexual jealously - not my favorite subjects.

The summary did not prepare me for the incest, sibling rivalry and sexual jealousy in the beginning of the book. The author seems very talented but the themes are much too dark and disturbing for my taste. The characters in the beginning have few, if any, redeeming features and I sent the book back after reading the first few chapters.
4 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

A jaunt to the past...

I lived for 3.5 years on St. Thomas as a girl. I could look out my bedroom window and see down to the ocean in Fortuna Bay. So reading this book was bittersweet for me... it took me back to my childhood and the slow rhythms and the quiet earth magic of living on the island. (No, I never saw any 'actual' magic.) (And no, I haven't ever been back, much to my sadness.)

This book is beautifully written, but as other reviewers have stated, it is not for everyone. It is not a fast read; you have to take your time with the stories and the characters. It includes a level of magic that requires a heavy dose of suspension of disbelief. It includes incest and abortion, which are very uncomfortable. It meanders in and out, very much like the tides. It includes dialect native to the islands, and in some cases you just sort of have to guess at the meaning from the context, so a glossary would have been helpful. (I used to speak the patios, but it's been so many years I've forgotten most of it.) It includes a lot of history, which could sometimes bog the reader down (but usually was seamlessly interwoven with the story). It includes many many characters, many of whom are one- or barely-two-dimensional.

But I still enjoyed it, mainly because I loved the beautiful prose, and liked Anette's streak of rebellion. While reading, you can't help but feel as if you are there on the islands, smelling the salt air. I liked the three main points-of-view: Anette, her older sister Eeona, and the Old Wives, who serve as the omniscient narrator. I think the different voices balanced the book. I also did enjoy remembering some of the history that I had forgotten, or learning more about a particular incident.

This book made me think, and I will probably continue to do so for quite some time.
4 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Beginning is unenjoyable to read, so I stopped reading the book.

I could not get into this book at all. Within the first 30 pages a small girl is held captive as a science experiment, an incestious relationship is revealed and an insecure mother is a pretty awful mom to the one aforementioned daughter. I could not finish it and had no desire to find out what happens. The way the subject matter read made me squirm uncomfortably and I put it down after 60 pages or so. I typically cannot read stories with crimes against children in them, I am also turned off by horror movies for the same reasons. I mention this because this subject matter was not mentioned anywhere in the book's description and if I have been made aware of it I would never had selected this book to review. I received it before reviews were present that do mention this fact about the book's storyline.

Subject matter aside, there was a literary tool that I did not care for. Some chapters are in the dialect of each narrating character, some chapters are told from the point of view of a third-person omniscient narrator. I did not care for the way this was executed. This is a hard balance to maintain for any author, a good example of it done well is The Poisonwood Bible, by Barbara Kingsolver.

I have read the other reviews and realise that my distaste for this novel is probably my own inability to get past the way the beginning subject matter is presented. Others seem to not be bothered it and enjoy the rest of the story. But if you find yourself having the same reactions I do to the mentioned themes, you may also want to pass on this one. According to several other reviews, the enjoyable story starts around page 100, I could not make it that far.

I do want to add that I have read books in the past that do cover unsavory types of subject matter. I found The Blue Notebook, by James A. Levine, to be harrowing, heartbreaking and beautifully told. It covers subject matter of the worst kind but in a way that felt like an honest education and not just a plot device.
4 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Just below the surface

" ... men who spend their lives on the water know that magic is real."

On the surface, Tiphanie Yanique's "Land of Love and Drowning" is a multigenerational tale of a family in the Virgin Islands in the early 20th century. As such, it is an interesting enough novel, detailing the ways in which the characters interact -- their lives and loves and travails. The reader gets a taste of the island culture: the flavor of the language, the beauty of the landscape, the aroma of indigenous cooking.

But when the reader dives deeper, into the warm depths of "Love and Drowning", he finds an entire world hidden below the relative calm above. Strong currents of racism, roiling storms of war, schools of segregation, and whirlpools of adultery lie in wait.

The transfer of the Virgin Islands from Danish rule to American guardianship turns out to be simply the exchange from one type of colonialism to another. The Americanization of the Virgin Islands brings the foreign concept of private property ownership, and the fencing off of the beaches. There was a gain in material comforts, but it was in exchange for a loss of liberty.

With the influx of American cars and plumbing and electricity came American racism and segregation. The fences on the beaches extend into daily life, with restrictions based on color lines. Miscegenation was frowned on, the historical mixing of African and European and Asian and Carib. Islanders who served in the armed forces returned from the mainland disillusioned; they had expected to be accepted by their new American compatriots, only to find doors closed to them.

Yanique skillfully interweaves the personal stories with the larger events to create a whole cloth - we see history from the personal perspective of the characters, and each is given equal weight. Placed against the magical, mystical background of the islands, "Land of Love and Drowning" gives us the Virgin Islands as microcosm; where Jim Crow and Hollywood intersect with the ebb and flow of the Caribbean and the bleached bones of a shipwreck, lying just below the surface.
" ... men who spend their lives on the water know that magic is real."

On the surface, Tiphanie Yanique's "Land of Love and Drowning" is a multigenerational tale of a family in the Virgin Islands in the early 20th century. As such, it is an interesting enough novel, detailing the ways in which the characters interact -- their lives and loves and travails. The reader gets a taste of the island culture: the flavor of the language, the beauty of the landscape, the aroma of indigenous cooking.

But when the reader dives deeper, into the warm depths of "Love and Drowning", he finds an entire world hidden below the relative calm above. Strong currents of racism, roiling storms of war, schools of racism and segregation, and whirlpools of adultery and incest lie in wait.

The transfer of the Virgin Islands from Danish rule to American guardianship turns out to be simply the exchange from one type of colonialism to another. The Americanization of the Virgin Islands brings the foreign concept of private property ownership, and the fencing off of the beaches. There was a gain in material comforts, but it was in exchange for a loss of liberty.

With the influx of American cars and plumbing and electricity came American racism and segregation. The fences on the beaches extend into daily life, with restrictions based on color lines. Miscegenation was frowned on, the historical mixing of African and European and Asian and Carib. Islanders who served in the armed forces returned from the mainland disillusioned; they had expected to be accepted by their new American compatriots, only to find doors closed to them.

Yanique skillfully interweaves the personal stories with the larger events to create a whole cloth - we see history from the personal perspective of the characters, and each is given equal weight. Placed against the magical, mystical background of the islands, "Land of Love and Drowning" gives us the Virgin Islands as microcosm; where Jim Crow and Hollywood intersect with the ebb and flow of the Caribbean and the bleached bones of a shipwreck, lying just below the surface.
4 people found this helpful