Hitler's War (The War That Came Early, Book One)
Hitler's War (The War That Came Early, Book One) book cover

Hitler's War (The War That Came Early, Book One)

Price
$19.30
Format
Hardcover
Pages
512
Publisher
Del Rey
Publication Date
ISBN-13
978-0345491824
Dimensions
6.53 x 1.57 x 9.6 inches
Weight
1.69 pounds

Description

From Publishers Weekly Alternate historian Turtledove ( The Man with the Iron Heart ) brings the deprivations of war to life in this vision of a very different WWII. After Konrad Henlein is assassinated in Czechoslovakia in 1938, France and England refuse to condone Hitler's plans for annexation, so he invades instead. American Peggy Druce, caught behind the lines, gets a firsthand look at the period military hardware and nationalistic mindsets that Turtledove so expertly describes, though readers looking for more characterization or plotting may be disappointed. Action in the Spanish Civil War and on the Mongolian border muddy the waters, possibly setting up for a clearer plot in subsequent volumes. Until Turtledove reveals more of the direction this scenario will take, there is little to differentiate it from many of his other novels. (Aug.) Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved. Praise for Harry Turtledove’s previous works:“A magisterial saga of an alternate America. . . . A profoundly thoughtful masterpiece of alternate history.” —Booklist, on Man with the Iron Heart “Turtledove’s latest proves that the third time is the charm.” —Publishers Weekly, on The Grapple “A fascinating and enthralling work that will grab and keep reader interest.” —SFRevu.com, on The Grapple “Turtledove is the standard bearer for alternate history.” —USA Today Harry Turtledove is the award-winning author of the alternate-history works The Man with the Iron Heart; The Guns of the South; How Few Remain (winner of the Sidewise Award for Best Novel); the Worldwar saga: In the Balance, Tilting the Balance, Upsetting the Balance, and Striking the Balance; the Colonization books: Second Contact, Down to Earth, and Aftershocks ; the Great War epics: American Front, Walk in Hell, and Breakthroughs ; the American Empire novels: Blood & Iron, The Center Cannot Hold, and Victorious Opposition ; and the Settling Accounts series: Return Engagement, Drive to the East, The Grapple , and In at the Death . Turtledove is married to fellow novelist Laura Frankos. They have three daughters: Alison, Rachel, and Rebecca. Excerpt. © Reprinted by permission. All rights reserved. Chapter One 20 July 1936—outside LisbonGeneral José Sanjurjo was a short, heavyset man in his early sixties. He looked from the light plane to the pilot and back again. “Is everything in readiness?” he asked, his tone saying heads would roll if the pilot told him no.Major Juan Antonio Ansaldo didn’t tell him anything, not right away. Ansaldo was pacing back and forth, his agitation growing with every stride. He watched as Sanjurjo’s aides shoved two large, heavy trunks into the airplane. “Those look heavy,” Ansaldo said at last.“They hold the general’s uniforms!” an aide said, as if to a simpleton. “On the eve of his victorious march into Madrid, he can’t arrive in Burgos without uniforms!”Nervously, Ansaldo lit a cigarette. Who was he, a major, to tell Spain’s most senior—and most prestigious—general what to do? He’d placed himself at the disposal of the Spanish state . . . which Sanjurjo would embody, once he flew from Portugal to Burgos to take charge of the rising against the Spanish Republic.When he flew to Burgos? If he flew to Burgos! The city, in north-central Spain, was a long way from Lisbon. The plane, a two-seater, had only so much fuel and only so strong a motor.“General . . .” Ansaldo said.“What is it?” growled the man people called the Lion of the Rif because of his victories in Spanish Morocco.“¡Viva Sanjurjo!” the general’s men shouted. “¡Viva España!”Sanjurjo preened . . . as well as a short, heavyset man in his sixties could preen. “Now I know my flag is waving over Spain,” he boomed like a courting grouse. “When I hear the Royal March again, I will be ready to die!”That gave Major Ansaldo the opening he needed. “General, I don’t want you to die before you get to Spain, before you hear the Royal March again.”“What are you talking about?” Sanjurjo demanded.“Sir, those trunks your men put aboard—”“What about them? They’re my uniforms, as my aides told you. A man is hardly a man without his uniforms.” At the moment, Sanjurjo was wearing a light gray summer-weight civilian suit. He looked and acted quite manly enough for Ansaldo.“They weigh a lot.” The pilot gestured. “Look at the pine trees all around the airstrip. I need the plane’s full power to take off. I have to make sure I have enough fuel to fly you to Burgos. I don’t want anything to happen to you, Señor. Spain needs you too much to take chances.”General Sanjurjo frowned—not fearsomely, but thoughtfully. “I can’t fly into Burgos like this.” He brushed at the gray linen of his sleeve.“Why not, your Excellency? Why not?” Ansaldo asked. “Don’t you think the people of Burgos would be delighted—would be honored—to give you anything you need? Aren’t there any uniforms in Burgos? God help the rising if that’s true!”“God help the rising.” Sanjurjo crossed himself. Major Ansaldo followed suit. The general took a gold case from an inside jacket pocket and lit a cigarette of his own. He smoked in abrupt, savage drags. “So you think we’ll crash with my uniforms on board, do you?”“When you’re flying, you never know,” the pilot answered. “That’s why you don’t want to take any chances you don’t have to.”Sanjurjo grunted. He took a couple of more puffs on the aromatic Turkish cigarette, then ground it out under his heel. “Luis! Orlando!” he called. “Get the trunks off the plane!”His aides stared as if they couldn’t believe their ears. “Are you sure, your Excellency?” one of them asked.“Of course I’m sure, dammit.” By the way José Sanjurjo spoke, he was always sure. And so he probably was. “Spain comes first, and Spain needs me more than I need my uniforms. As the pilot here says, there are many uniforms. Por Dios, amigos, there is only one Sanjurjo!” The general struck a pose.The aides didn’t argue any more. They did what Sanjurjo told them to do. Wrestling the trunks out of the plane’s narrow fuselage proved harder than stuffing them in had been. It took a lot of bad language and help from three other men before they managed it.Major Ansaldo wondered how many kilos he’d saved. Fifty? A hundred? He didn’t know, and he never would—no scale was close by. But now he would fly with the kind of load the light plane was made to carry. He liked that.“If your Excellency will take the right-hand seat . . .” he said.“Certainly.” Sanjurjo was as spry as a man of half his age and half his bulk.After Ansaldo started the motor, he ran through the usual flight checks. Everything looked good. He gave the plane all the throttle he could. He needed to get up quickly, to clear the trees beyond the far edge of the bumpy field.When he pulled back on the stick, the nose lifted. The fixed undercarriage left the ground. The bumping stopped. The air, for the moment, was smooth as fine brandy. A slow smile spread across General Sanjurjo’s face. “Do you know what this is, Major?” he said. “A miracle, that’s what! To fly like a bird, like an angel . . .”“It’s only an airplane, sir,” said Ansaldo, as matter-of-fact as any pilot worth his pay.“Only an airplane!” Sanjurjo’s eyebrows leaped. “And a woman is only a woman! It is an airplane that takes me out of exile, an airplane that takes me out of Portugal, an airplane that takes me away from the hisses and sneezes and coughs of Portuguese. . . .”“Sí, Señor.” Major Ansaldo knew how the general felt there. If a Spaniard and a Portuguese spoke slowly and clearly, or if they wrote things out, they could generally manage to understand each other. But Portuguese always sounded funny—sounded wrong—in a Spaniard’s ears. The reverse was also bound to be true, but the pilot never once thought of that.And his important passenger hadn’t finished: “It is an airplane that takes me back to Spain, back to my country—and Spain will be my country once we settle with the Republican rabble. It is—what does Matthew say?—a pearl of great price.” He crossed himself again.So did Juan Antonio Ansaldo. “You have the soul of a poet, your Excellency,” he said. General Sanjurjo smiled like a cat in front of a pitcher of cream. Ansaldo did, too, but only to himself; a little judicious flattery, especially flattery from an unexpected direction, never hurt. But he also had a serious point to make: “I’m glad you chose not to endanger the plane—and yourself, a more valuable pearl—with those trunks. Spain needs you.”“Well, yes,” Sanjurjo agreed complacently. “Who would command the forces of the right, the forces of truth, against the atheists and Communists and liberals in the Republic if anything happened to me? Millán Astray?”“I don’t think so, sir!” Ansaldo exclaimed, and that wasn’t flattery. Astray, the founder of the Spanish Foreign Legion, was a very brave man. Colonial fighting had cost him an arm and an eye. He still led the Legion, whose war cry was “¡Viva la muerte!”—Long live death! Men like that were valuable in the officer corps, but who would want such a skeletal fanatic leading a country?“Bueno. I don’t think so, either.” Yes, Sanjurjo sounded complacent, all right. And why not, when he held the rising in the palm of his hand? He couldn’t resist throwing out the name of another possible replacement: “Or what about General Franco?”“Not likely, your Excellency!” Again, Major Ansaldo meant what he said. No one had ever questioned Francisco Franco’s courage, either, even if he wasn’t so showy about displaying it as Millán Astray was. But the plump little general was no great leader of men. With Sanjurjo’s personality, he could stand beside—could, at need, stand up to— Mussolini and Hitler. Franco? Franco had all the warmth, all the excitement, of a canceled postage stamp.“No, not likely at all,” General Sanjurjo said. “Once I get to Burgos, the true business of setting Spain to rights can begin.”“Sí, Señor,” Ansaldo said once more. The light plane droned on: toward Spain, toward Burgos, toward victory, toward the birth of a whole new world. Read more

Features & Highlights

  • A stroke of the pen and history is changed. In 1938, British Prime Minister Neville Chamberlain, determined to avoid war at any cost, signed the Munich Accord, ceding part of Czechoslovakia to Hitler. But the following spring, Hitler snatched the rest of that country and pushed beyond its borders. World War II had begun, and England, after a fatal act of appeasement, was fighting a war for which it was not prepared.Now, in this thrilling, provocative, and fascinating alternate history by Harry Turtledove, another scenario is played out: What if Chamberlain had not signed the accord? What if Hitler had acted rashly, before his army was ready–would such impatience have helped him or doomed him faster? Here is an action-packed, blow-by-blow chronicle of the war that might have been–and the repercussions that might have echoed through history–had Hitler reached too far, too soon, and too fast.Turtledove uses dozens of points of view to tell this story: from American marines serving in Japanese-occupied China to members of a Jewish German family with a proud history of war service to their nation, from ragtag volunteers fighting in the Abraham Lincoln Battalion in Spain to an American woman desperately trying to escape Nazi-occupied territory–and witnessing the war from within the belly of the beast.A novel that reveals the human face of war while simultaneously riding the twists and turns that make up the great acts of history,
  • Hitler’s War
  • is the beginning of an exciting new alternate history saga. Here is a tale of powerful leaders and ordinary people, of spies, soldiers, and traitors, of the shifting alliances that draw some together while tearing others apart. At once authoritative, brilliantly imaginative, and hugely entertaining,
  • Hitler’s War
  • captures the beginning of a very different World War II–with a very different fate for our world today.

Customer Reviews

Rating Breakdown

★★★★★
30%
(153)
★★★★
25%
(128)
★★★
15%
(77)
★★
7%
(36)
23%
(117)

Most Helpful Reviews

✓ Verified Purchase

Buy a different book from Turtledove

I have read much of Turtledove's writing and given many of his books as gifts. I immediately ordered the hardcover version of this book.

Unfortunately Turtledove is not his usual creative, well-written self. The title itself "Hitler's War" is rather tired. He provides a serial narratives of a variety of participants caught in war, who almost universally complain about their tobacco, coffee, or booze. I think Turtledove himself would get tired of reporting the taste of Navy Cut cigarettes and ersatz coffee. While usually gifted presenting the experience at the warrior level, he fails give the usual punch. His usual alternative history talks also at the General Staff level which enhances the drama. Unfortunately, the drama is lacking this time around.

Turtledove can write a great book. Let's hope he doesn't provide a sequel to this one.
16 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Repetitive

After about 125 pages into the book, I'm not sure I can finish. Mr. Turtledove is hitting a wall with his writing. Again, he starts with a very interesting premise, and for a couple of chapters builds some interest.

Then he goes into individual points-of-view, with characters all over the planet, each section adding just a little bit of new information about how the new war is progressing.

But, the points-of-view are so similar that he might as well have a half-dozen POVs, rather than dozens.

The style of writing (third-person `omnipotent' writing style that lets us see what the character is thinking, not just what he says) is almost the same no matter who the character is.

His depiction of the Japanese sergeant and the men in his unit in China could be moved word for word to another chapter and the characters could be Polish Jews, or Americans fighting in Spain for the Republic, and they would say the same thing, and think the same thoughts.

Every character is petty. There is no heroism, no striving for excellence, nobody is anything except the average joe who is only concerned with himself and how he can survive the next few minutes.

I put this book aside to read another I got at the same time. I honestly don't know if I will bother to go back to "Hitler's War" to finish it.
7 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Not a stand-alone, and suffers for it

When I picked up "Hitler's War," I was under the impression that the novel would be one of Turtledove's stand-alone works. These seem to stand out among the author's work, as his narrative is limited to what he can fit between two covers. "Ruled Britannia," in which he paints a quite fascinating portrait of 16th century England dominated by Spain and "How Few Remain," the solo opening in an alternate history where the South won the Civil War, are good examples of this trend.

By contrast, Turtledove's series work tends to fall victim to endless repetition and sometimes sluggish plots. Reviewers complained during the "Southern Victory" series spun off of "How Few Remain" that Turtledove spent too much ink rehashing character traits we were already familiar with or using similar descriptions or dialogue over and over again. He worked to remedy some of these issues during that massive narrative, but unfortunately they seem to have returned in this work. Nearly all of the dialogue seems to focus not so much on the action and politics at hand as it does on a) the terrible quality of cigarettes and other rations during wartime or b) characters privately having doubts about the veracity of their totalitarian government's claims, but at the same time knowing that being indiscreet will get them executed or imprisoned.

The book covers more ground than the "Southern Victory" series, with characters dotting the map from Spain to Mongolia, but this becomes problematic. So many characters are crammed in that there isn't much room to make us feel any empathy for these people. A few do stand out, such as a boisterous American woman trapped in Germany after the outbreak of hostilities and a Jewish family torn between their love for Germany and hatred for Hitler's regime. Most of the other characters just come off as yet another cardboard soldier or pilot running around the battlefield trying to avoid artillery or flak, respectively.

Adding to the problem is the lack of a truly alternate set of events caused by Turtledove's two points of diversion. This is one of the more enjoyable aspects of Turtledove's books, and likely to multiply as time goes on, but only a few points show any major change from what actually occurred in World War II. It is possible this series will improve as it unfolds, but the first offering is nothing special. Turtledove's creative energy would definitely be put to better use if it was focused on single-book stories.
6 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Disappointed again...

I am 70 pages into this book, and I am not very impressed thus far. First off, I must say that I am a big Harry Turtledove fan, and really enjoy the alt history genre. Previous novels by Turtledove such as "Ruled Britannia" and "In The Presence of Mine Enemies" are truly epic works, excellent reads, in my opinion. I have read many of Turtledove's other alt histories, as well. After reading "The Man With The Iron Heart", I came away from that experience feeling dissatisfied, as if we were just being given a trite description of an alternate aftermath to WWII in Germany, with an obvious analog to our own recent history. The plot line is quite intriguing, and like any good alt history, plausible. However, character development and dialogue seemed quite superficial.

"Hitler's War" so far for me is continuing in this vein. The characters, from various ethnic backgrounds and stations in life, all seem to think in the same terms and express themselves in the same way. Europe in 1938 was in real turmoil, and given the actual political developments of that time, absolutely ripe for an alt history treatment. Instead, we are treated to not much more than a graphic novel without the artwork. There is no real narrative description of unfolding events, no analysis of the alt geopolitical situation, and no nuance regarding character development. I realize that folks who read my review may criticize it as jumping to conclusions since I have not finished the book, and they may well be correct in that view.

For anyone interested in alt history, including Harry Turtledove fans who may not have read it, I most strongly recommend that you check out "Ruled Britannia". It is a real Tour de Force. Unfortunately, I can't escape the feeling that Harry is just mailing it in these days.
6 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Written by computer!

Turtledove's style of "alternate history" has begun to wear thin, and for "Hitler's War" he seems to have invested little or no effort in research or even plotting and character selection. By now that pigeon's verbal tics (eg "He would; except that he didn't because he couldn't) and strong interest in the comparative quality of smoking tobacco around the world have lost their power to charm.

The thin reports from foreign correspondents phoning in from various muddy battle fields -- I mean from soldiers and airmen) shed little light on the characters, only a dim glow on the tactics (yes, yes, the little German light Panzers were too light, but they were maneuverable; yes, yes the other team had bigger guns) and nothing at all on the policies of governments which should be directing both strategy and tactics.

There are a lot of reasons why a failure at Munich might have meant the failure of Hitlerian arms. The strongest reason is that the Wehrmacht didn't want to fight in 1938, and would very likely have refused an order to initiate general war. Hitler proved he was right (in the real world) because he said that the UK and France would capitulate, and got away with it only because they did. A lot of generals thought the little corporal was a military genius for that one.

Why did T-dove need a Japanese character group? If I hadn't known before, I might well not have learned in Hitler's War. T-dove certainly doesn't explain -- and, dammit, the man is a professional historian.

I think Harry found a computer program somewhere that generates random battle scenes, random characters, and random locations and then stirs them together and writes his book for him.

If Harry can't give me his best effort, I don't see why I should contribute to his retirement fund. I got this one at the library, and am proud of my foresight in guessing that Hitler's War would be another clinker.
5 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Too many characters, too little characterization. Borrow from a library.

Too many characters for one volume.
Too little characterization.
A narrow idea unmercilessly fleshed out.
I stopped reading this book after the first 100 pages.
I borrowed this book from the library and am glad I did.
5 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

History does not need revision

I am concerned that the current trend by some to rehabilitate Chamberlain has the potential to confuse today's folk. Something people have to remember is that in the summer of 1938, Hitler has his entire army on the border with Czechoslovakia, not France. Facing France he had a few reserve infantry divisions and was outnumbered over 10 to one by France alone. Hitlers general staff, per Bill Shirer's 'Rise and Fall of the 3rd Reich', planned to immediately cave if the French acted. Folk next point out Hitlers Air Force superiority and especially note the superior Me109 as prof that Hitler would have had air superiority. The problem with this was that production of that plane had just begun and Hitler had under a dozen of these aircraft. Finally, when they make this case, they speak of the time Britain had to rebuild its forces between summer 1938 and summer 1939. This is true BUT, it ignores the fact that Hitler was also rearming and building aircraft and tanks over twice as fast as Britain. In 1939 Hitler was far more powerful than in summer 1938. Appeasement gave Hitler the time to conquer Czechoslovakia, make a treaty with the Soviets, conquer Poland and then seize France, Belgium, and Holland. He also was able to integrate the Czech's industrial and military power into the German army, more than doubling the available armor in under a year.
5 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Yet another alternative WW2 - but again he finds more to say

In which World War II starts in 1938 after the Munich peace talks fail ...

This book kicks off yet another alternative version of World War II from Harry Turtledove, and I was quite astonished that he can still find new things to write about that war. But he does and I found it an excellent read.

In the opening paragraph of the book Turtledove makes two changes in real history, and works from there. First, in 1936 General Jose Sanjuro listens to the pilot who warns him not to overload their light plane with heavy trunks full of his uniforms. Consequently the plane does not crash, (as in real history it did) and Sanjuro rather than Franco becomes leader of the Nationalist side in the Spanish civil war.

Then during the Munich negotiations, news comes that the leader of the Sudeten Germans, Konrad Henlein, has been assassinated by a Czech. Hitler, wanting war, uses this as an excuse to press for even more punitive terms against Czechoslovakia in the hope that they will be rejected. Chamberlain and Daladier, finally recognising that Hitler is determined on war and suspecting that he had actually ordered Henlein's murder himself, tell the Germans that if they attack Czechoslovakia Britain and France will honour their obligations to the Czechs. Hitler orders the invasion of Czechoslovakia on the spot and the war starts a year early.

As usual for a Harry Turtledove book, the war is seen through the eyes of a large number of fictional viewpoint characters, one or more from each of the countries involved: these include an American woman caught in Prague by the outbreak of war, a Jewish family in Munich, a German panzer crewman, stuka pilot, and U-Boat skipper, British and Japanese sergeants, a Czech corporal, etc. Major historical figures like Hitler and De Gaulle get mentions as they impact on the lives of the main characters.

Turtledove has done a fair amount of homework on the tactical capabilities of equipment available to the armed forces of all sides in 1938 based on how they actually performed a year later. People who know more about this period of history than I have found a few errors that I missed, but the book expresses very effectively how the relative strengths and weaknesses of the planes, tanks and guns of 1938 would have affected the human beings whose lives depended on that kit. In many ways this is the best aspect of the novel and it is fairly well done.

Unfortunately Turtledove does give in to his worst fault, that of repeating the same information far too many times. For example there must be at least three points in the book in which different characters witness almost identical events when machine gunners attempt to surrender but are shot in cold blood, and the book puts into the mind of different witnesses almost identical thoughts about how hard it is for machine gun crews to surrender. We got the point the first time, Harry!

This is the fifth alternative version of World War II which Turtledove has written. He has previously done stories with aliens from Tau Ceti invading in 1942 (the Worldwar series), a parallel history following pretty much the real track, in a world where technology uses magic rather than engineering (known variously as the Darkness, Derlavi, or 'World at War' series), and an alternative World War II in a history following a Rebel victory in the US Civil War, which has the same roles as in the historical WWII carried out by different people (Settling Accounts). And there is a pair of novels, "Days of Infamy" and "End of the Beginning" which explore the possibility that Japan might have backed up the air strikes on Pearl Harbour with a land invasion of Hawaii.

Having done so many alternative versions of World War II, you would think he would find it impossible to say anything new about them or maintain the reader's interest. Some people obviously do have that problem, as the negative reviews on here demonstrate.

I can only say that this does not describe my experience: the book had me completely hooked: I also enjoyed the next in the series, [[ASIN:034549184X The War That Came Early: West and East (War That Came Early (del Rey))]]. If you liked most of Turtledove's other books, there is a good chance that you will like this one.
4 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Good Premise, Bad Execution

This book had a fairly original premise with World War II breaking out a year earlier because Chamberlain stands up to Hitler at the Munich Conference. The description of the alternate World War II seems inadquate. It is too much like the otl World War II. The Germans defeat the Czechs too easily and Hitler defeats the army coup even though most historians believe that the coup would have succeeded. Turtledove makes another change where the original leader of the Spanish nationalists Sanjuro doesn't die early in the war. This divergence seems to serve no purpose as the absence of Franco doesn't seem to affect the course of the Civil War. The Spanish Nationalists attack on Gibralter also makes no sense given that the nationalists would have a harder time fighting the Republic given that the Republic would be recieving more aid from Britain and France then in otl and the Nationalists would have fewer resources to spare to attack Gibralter.

The dialogue of the characters is very flat. They all keep complaining about the poor quality of the coffee and tobacco.
4 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

too many near-identical battles

About a third of the way through I started skipping, at first a little, then longer and longer passages. It seemed as if I kept reading the same battle scene over and over and over and over again. By the time I got to the two-thirds mark I was skimming and skipping whole chapters. And then the whole book ends in an inconclusive battle that hints that the tide of war is changing.

Well, I'll wait for the last book in the series and sit in the bookstore and read the last few chapters.
4 people found this helpful