From a High Tower
From a High Tower book cover

From a High Tower

Hardcover – June 2, 2015

Price
$26.04
Format
Hardcover
Pages
336
Publisher
DAW
Publication Date
ISBN-13
978-0756408985
Dimensions
6.25 x 1.01 x 9.25 inches
Weight
1.18 pounds

Description

Praise for the Elemental Masters series:“The Paris of Degas, turn-of-the-century Blackpool, and the desperation of young girls without family or other protection come to life in a story that should interest a broad readership .” — Booklist “All in fine fairy-tale tradition …. It’s grim fun, with some nice historical detail, and just a hint of romance to help lighten things.” — Locus “The action and dialogue flow freely, mingling with beautiful descriptions of European countryside and just a hint of romance…. A well-developed heroine and engaging story .” — Publishers Weekly “The fifth in the series involving the mysterious Elemental Masters, this story of a resourceful young dancer also delivers a new version of a classic fairy tale. Richly detailed historic backgrounds add flavor and richness to an already strong series that belongs in most fantasy collections. Highly recommended.” — Library Journal “Lackey’s fantastical world of Elementals, plus her delightful Nan and Sarah, create an amusing contrast for Arthur Conan Doyle’s Sherlock Holmes and John Watson…. The mix of humor, history, fantasy, and mystery is balanced in a way that any reader could pick up the book and thoroughly enjoy it from beginning to end.” — RT Reviews “The Elementals novels are beautiful, romantic adult fairy tales . Master magician Mercedes Lackey writes a charming fantasy.” —Worlds of Wonder“Ms. Lackey is a master in fantasy , and this visit to an alternate historical England is no exception. Vivid characterization and believable surroundings are flawlessly joined in a well-detailed world.” —Darque Reviews"I find Ms. Lackey's Elemental Masters series a true frolic into fantasy ." — Fantasy Book Spot Mercedes Lackey is a full-time writer and has published numerous novels and works of short fiction, including the best-selling Heralds of Valdemar series. She is also a professional lyricist and a licensed wild bird rehabilitator. She lives in Oklahoma with her husband, artist Larry Dixon, and their flock of parrots. She can be found at mercedeslackey.com or on Twitter at @mercedeslackey. Excerpt. © Reprinted by permission. All rights reserved. Prologue “I should be very interested to hear whatever excuse you have for robbing my garden,” said a cold female voice behind him. “I might even let you stammer it out before I give my dogs the order to deal with you. Turn around. Let me look you in the eyes.” Still on his knees in the cold earth, he slowly turned. Behind him, her face clear in the moonlight, was a tall, hawk-faced woman in a long black cloak, her dark hair severely braided and pinned tightly around her face. She had her arms crossed over her chest and stared down at him icily. “Well?” she prompted. “What sort of fairy tale have you to tell me?” He opened and shut his mouth several times without any words coming out. But thenxa0.xa0.xa0. his panic got the better of him, and he fell apart. He groveled. He babbled. He wept without hope that he would get even a crumb of pity from her. He really didn’t know what he was saying, although he certainly went on at length about Maria and the children. He begged and pleaded, he cried shamelessly until he was hoarse. She said nothing. And finally, when he had repeated himself far too many times and ran out of words, she stared down at him in the silence while he waited helplessly for her to set the dogs on him, call for the police, or both. I am going to be savaged. Then I am going to prison. Maria will die, and the children will starve. “Well,” she said at last. “I am actually inclined to believe you.” She looked down at him for another long, cold moment. “And I am not an unreasonable woman, nor am I inclined to make your children suffer for your sins. It is clear that they will probably all starve without you to provide for them. I would not care to have the deaths of children on my conscience. Perhaps I can think of some way you can repay what you stole.” He began to have faint hope. Perhapsxa0.xa0.xa0. perhaps she would let him go? He looked up at her and clasped his hands under his chin, trying to look as prayerful and repentant as possible. “Anything!” he blurted. But she was not finished. “A bargain, then. You owe me, Friedrich Schnittel. You owe me a very great deal. But I won’t have you thrown in prison. In fact, you can come here and gather what you need for your family every day, on condition that you repay me.” “H—” he did not even manage to get all of the word how out before she interrupted him. “You have—or will have—something I want, just as I have something you want. So, this is the bargain: you may continue to help yourself to this garden. I would prefer that you come at night, so that I don’t have other thieves coming to steal from me, and you might as well keep coming over the wall as well, since you are so good at it. Then, when your wife gives birth to this new child, you will give her to me.” He opened his mouth to object. She stared at him with her lips compressed into a thin line. “Don’t try to barter with me. It is this, or I set the dogs on you and have the police take what is left of you to prison. What will it be? Will you feed your eight children and your wife for the trivial price of a baby that is likely to die anyway?” Well, what could he say? If he refused, what would Maria and the children do but starve? What good would it do him or them if he suddenly decided that selling the baby was wrong? “Very wellxa0.xa0.xa0.” he said, slowly. She smiled, as if she had already known he would say as much. “Take what you have. Come back tomorrow night. I’ll even leave sacks for you.” And with that, she turned on her heel and stalked back into the house, her dogs preceding her. They all went in via the kitchen door—which showed not so much as a hint of light—and she closed the door behind her, leaving him chilled and drenched with sweat on the cold earth of the garden.* * * * * It was not an easy birth. When it was over, Maria lay too exhausted to even move beneath a heap of every scrap of fabric that could be spared to keep her warm, and the new baby girl had been tightly wrapped and was being held by Jakob near to the fire. Friedrich was just glad Maria had had three weeks of good food before the birth; he really didn’t think she would have survived this one without the extra nourishment. She’d gone into labor the previous afternoon, and it had gone on until well after sunrise. He was just as tired, since he had served as midwife. He was slowly eating vegetable soup and drinking herb tea, his first meal since she had gone into labor. And he really wasn’t thinking of anything else when the knock came at the door. Before he could say anything, his second oldest, Johann, jumped up to answer it. And fell back again, in astonishment and fear, as the terrible woman in black and one of her dogs pushed their way in. She closed the door behind her and surveyed them all with an icy glare. The children all froze in terror; the tall woman was no less forbidding and formidable in broad daylight than she had been by night. The dog didn’t growl, but he didn’t have to; he looked like a black wolf, which was more than enough to make the children try to inch back until they were squeezed into the corner farthest from her. All but Jakob, who remained where he was, by the fire, the baby clutched in his nerveless hands. Before Friedrich could utter a word, the woman looked around the room and spotted Jakob and the baby. In four strides she had crossed the room, then bent and snatched the baby out of Jakob’s arms. “I’ve come for your part of the bargain, Friedrich Schnittel,” she said. “And now I’ll be gone.” And with that, she turned, stalked out the door, and left. Maria fell into hysterics, of course—he hadn’t told her about the bargain. When he explained, she only became more hysterical, weeping and pushing him away until he just gave up trying to reason with her, and, for lack of anything else to do, made sure the children were all fed. As they all ate, she cried herself into a sleep that was less sleep than collapse, and he stared at her white, tear-streaked face and wondered where the girl he had fallen in love with had gone. When Maria awoke, she refused to speak to him. After a while, he got tired of the silence and decided to make another visit to the garden. The terrible woman had not put an end-date on her part of the bargain, and he was determined to get as much out of it as he could. He was beginning to resent Maria’s attitude. The woman had been right, after all. If not for the food, Maria, the baby, or both probably would have died. And what about the eight other children? Didn’t they warrant some consideration too? Didn’t they deserve to have full bellies for once? Wasn’t one baby likely to die anyway worth bartering away to save the lives of his living children? At this point, he was a little drunk on exhaustion himself, and a little reckless. And he went in—if not broad daylight, certainly just before sundown. By the time he got over the wall, he wasxa0.xa0.xa0. not exactly seething, but feeling far more the victim than the victimizer. And it occurred to him that if he could just get a glimpse inside that house, perhaps he could see that the baby was being treated in a manner far better than he and Maria could ever afford, and perhaps that might make the foolish woman see reason. But as he approached the house—he noticed that the kitchen door was slightly ajar. That’sxa0.xa0.xa0. odd. He made his way carefully to the door, and when nothing came out of it—especially not an enormous, possibly vicious dog—he pushed it all the way open. Nothing. And there was no sound in the house, at all. He ventured inside. The kitchen was utterly empty. And so was the next room. And the next. The caution ebbed out of him, and he began to prowl the entire house while the light lasted: all the rooms, downstairs and the two stories above. No furnishings, only a piece or two, like the great bed in one of the bedchambers, which would have been impossible to move. No sign that anyone had lived here, except for the absence of dust. As he stood there in the empty housexa0.xa0.xa0. a plan formed in his mind. There was a gate to the garden; he had always come and gone over the wall, but now, he ran to it and forced the rusty lock and latch open. Then he ran back to his little room. By this time, he was somewhat incoherent, probably wild-eyed, and talking like a madman. But that was no bad thingxa0.xa0.xa0. the children looked at him with bewilderment and fear and did not ask him questions. With words and a few blows for those too stubborn to obey immediately, he gathered up the children and all of their meager possessions, forced Maria to her feet, and drove them out the door, down the street, and in through the gate. At this point even Maria looked afraid of him and kept any objections to herself. He locked the gate behind them all and herded them in through the kitchen door. “This is our home, now,” he said sternly. “At least it is until someone comes to tell us differently.” The children made up the bed of rags and straw for Maria again, and she crept into it, shivering. Once the family was installed in the kitchen—which alone was three or four times the size of the room they had been living in—he left them there, instructing Jakob to make up a fire with the plentiful firewood that was already there. Then he ran back and forth until he had brought all of the food that they had cached, and their old room was scoured bare of anything remotely useful, down to the smallest of rags. Then he returned to the deserted house, locked the gate behind him, and joined the rest of his family in their new home. Yes. Their home. For it had come to him, as he had seen this empty, echoing house, why should it go to waste? It had been untenanted for as long as he could remember. If that woman came back she could easily evict him and his family, but in the meantime, why should they not save the rent money and live here, where the garden and its bounty were easily accessible? Why not? Maria was terrified at this new version of her husband, who had gone from stealing turnips to “stealing” an entire housexa0.xa0.xa0. and truth to tell, he was not displeased with this. At least it stopped her from reproaching him.* * * * * The strange woman never returned to her house. And Maria never forgave him. Chapter 1 GISELLE leaned out of the window of her room at the top of the tower and drank in all the spring fragrances being carried up to her on the breeze. Her room had the best view of any in the former abbey, and she often wondered who had been the tenant back when the complex had been inhabited by the Sisters of Saint Benedict. The abbess herself? Or perhaps it had been a room devoted to communal prayer? Probably the abbess, she decided. It would have been a good place from which to keep an eye on the entire abbey. Mother said she had no idea why the abbey had been abandoned for so long, to the point where only the tower had been inhabitable when she had first taken it over, and only because the entire tower was built of stout stone. That had been long before Giselle had been born. By the time Mother brought her here as an infant, the tower had been completely renovated, all the other buildings had been reroofed with proper, strong tile, and the building attached to the tower itself, which had probably housed the nuns in their little cells, had been converted into spacious living quarters for Mother. Only the chapel remained in ruins. Mother never explained why she had not rebuilt the chapel, but then, why should she have? It wasn’t as if she and Giselle needed a church. There were four windows in Giselle’s tower room, facing precisely in the four directions of the compass. Giselle preferred the view from the east window, which looked out over the valley meadow to the forest beyond, and to the mountains beyond that. Probably, back when the abbess had lived here, there had been nothing to keep out the winter winds but simple wooden shutters, and only a charcoal brazier to huddle over to keep out the cold. Mother had changed all that. There were proper glass windows and shutters in all the windows now, and a good fireplace on each floor of the tower. Giselle wondered if dwarves had done the work. She’d never seen any here, but then, the work had been completed before she ever got here. Since it had all been stonework, it would have been logical for Mother to have made a bargain with dwarves to accomplish it. Mother was an Earth Master, after all, and dwarves were Earth Elementals. I certainly can’t imagine her allowing ordinary stonemasons here. The nearest village—and it was a very small one—was over two days’ ride away, in the next valley over from the abbey. You couldn’t even see it from the top room of the tower. Giselle had never been there herself, only Mother, driving the cart out to get the things they could not produce for themselves and coming back again days later. Still, it wasn’t as if she could be lonely. Not when she was surrounded by all the Elementals of her own Element, Air. Read more

Features & Highlights

  • The tenth novel in Mercedes Lackey's magical Elemental Masters series reimagines the fairy tale Rapunzel in a richly-detailed alternate Victorian world
  • Giselle had lived fourteen years of her life in an abandoned tower. Her mother kept Giselle, a young Air Master still growing into her abilities, isolated for the sake of herself and others.   This life left her unprepared when a handsome young man appeared at the base of her tower. But when the young stranger entered her window, he tried to force himself on her. She was saved by Mother, an Earth Master, who hurled the man out the window he had climbed in.   The Foresters of the Black Forest were Earth Masters whose job it was to cleanse the ancient forest of evil elementals, and over the next four years, they shared their fighting expertise to teach Giselle self-defense. By the age of twenty, Giselle was an expert markswoman, and it was this skill that she used to survive when Mother died. Cutting her long hair, she masqueraded as a boy to enter shooting competitions, and used the prize money to support herself.   But she could not forget the first man who assaulted her, for when that stranger had fallen from her tower long ago, his body had never been found. In Giselle’s heart, she was certain his magic had helped him to survive the fall. Surely, it was only a matter of time before he found her and sought revenge. Was she prepared to stand against him?

Customer Reviews

Rating Breakdown

★★★★★
60%
(836)
★★★★
25%
(348)
★★★
15%
(209)
★★
7%
(98)
-7%
(-98)

Most Helpful Reviews

✓ Verified Purchase

Less Than I Hoped For

The characters were good, but the action was missing, and the plot was redundant.

Take the long journey from "Blood Red," combine it with the showbiz found in "Steadfast" or "Reserved for the Cat," and you have covered what plot exists in this story. Once again the villain POV that was a hallmark of the first few books in this series, and in more engrossing books, kept us on the edge of our seats, was completely missing. Meeting the villain in the first chapter does not make up for the fact that we neither see nor hear from him again for 90% of the book.

"From A Hight Tower" has wonderful characters, but Lackey is an author that is capable of giving us a story that has more going for it that good characters. Her last few books, especially in the "Elemental Masters" series, have been less than satisfying. As a longtime reader and fan, I have come to expect more from her, and I hope she gives it to us soon.
52 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Hackwork? I think so. 'There are worse things to be' ?? Maybe, but I think she should aim higher.

Ms Lackey's description of a hack in the prologue is faulty, and perhaps a bit defensive. " the definition of a “hack” is this: a strong, dependable horse that can always be relied on to get you where you want to go. There are worse things to be."

In modern usage, I'd say that a hack is more commonly a worn out horse, not fit to ride, not dependable.

It's also a writer producing uninspired, banal work.

Hackwork is formulaic writing, and it's my view that this is exactly what Ms Lackey has been creating, over and over and over. She's managed to create some stories that are quite entertaining, despite their flaws, but in recent books? Where is her attention?

She wrote some successful stories early on and has ridden that horse pretty much to death, dragging short stories out into trilogies even when they might have benefited from a tighter structure.

In recent years, her bad habits have been more and more obvious; her apparent lack of engagement with the characters, the audience and the story draining the life out of even the most compelling moments in reliable old fairy tales. She is a better writer than this, I know it, but her skills have not been evident lately.

I get it, not every novel is high literature, not every author is aiming for that. I really do think that an author with a loyal audience should respect the fact that people are giving up bits of their free time to immerse themselves in the worlds she creates.

I'm not sure why she's made such a point of deriving inspiration from an author most people have never heard of (see the prologue), but it seems to me that she really ought to have done a better job of it.

Despite the huge number of glowing reviews, I found it lifeless and uninspired, moments inexplicably falling flat when they should crackle with energy. There's really no excuse.

Bad writing is a waste of the author's time and mine.

This used to be one of my favorite of her series, but no more.
31 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Of all the fantasy novels that Lackey has written about ...

Of all the fantasy novels that Lackey has written about young women coming of age, this is definitely another one. It's a pleasant light read, but don't expect more than that.
24 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

While I did enjoy the world building this time around

I would give 3.5 stars if I could. It was a pleasant read with some unexpected twists (since it is an adaptation of Rapunzel I thought I knew exactly what was going to happen) but I wish Lackey had included more plot development. Most of the action occurs in the last 5% of the book. While I did enjoy the world building this time around, I realized we were reaching the end before anything REALLY happened. Also, I did appreciate that Rosamund from Book 10 was also in Book 11. Overall, I like the series, I liked the book, but it wasn't an "outstanding, must reread multiple times" kind of book like some of her others.
17 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Rapunzel with a twist, and extras

The latest Elemental Masters novel takes its title from the opening chapter of the book—obviously based on the Rapunzel tale, but with a major twist—but it alludes to other fairy tales as well, and is very much a close sequel to Blood Red, since its protagonist Rosamund von Schwarzwald is a major (though not POV) character in this one. A prologue has a poor man with eight children and a pregnant wife all close to dying of starvation when he notices that the garden of a long-abandoned house somehow seems to have some pretty good crops growing there. And nobody in the house. He picks all the vegatables he can carry and takes them home, and in the next few nights repeats his thefts so that the health of his wife and children improve steadily. But then one night three big dogs corner him, and a woman comes out and accosts him. He begs for mercy, and she agrees to not only let him keep what he’s harvested, but to continue to do so until she tells him otherwise—for the price of the baby his wife is about to bear. He agrees, and when the baby is born the woman comes to their hut and takes her, but tells the man and his family that they can go live in the abandoned house until she tells them otherwise. Snap forward to when the girl is 14, and there’s the Rapunzel-like chapter, which ends with the woman—an Earth Master the girl, named Giselle (who is an Air Mage herself), calls Mother, though she knows who her true parents are—bringing in a couple of members of the Bruderschaft of the Schwarzwald to teach Giselle how to shoot and fight with blades and bare hands. Snap forward another couple of years and Mother has died of pneumonia and Giselle is faced with making a living for herself. She closes up the old Abbey where she and Mother had lived and goes on the road earning some money by pretending to be a boy and winning shooting contests at fairs. After some misadventures she catches on with a Wild West show like the one Buffalo Bill toured Europe (and America) with at about that time (about 1900). Rosamund turns up shortly after, and the two of them become close friends and have several adventures, reminiscent of “Hansel and Gretel,” “The Billy-Goats Gruff,” and a couple of others I more or less recognized but can’t place. Highly enjoyable, and not as full of tension as Blood Red.
4 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

I enjoyed reading some of this

Oh, Mercedes Lackey. I used to adore your writing. What happened? Was it me? Did I change too much? Or is it that your plots now meander, your characters have become boilerplate, and there is no real sense of turmoil or danger?

I enjoyed reading some of this, until I realized I'd gone 100 pages without any real conflict. The conflict, as usual for her newer novels, comes within 40 pages or so of the book ending. *sigh* That's some uneven writing there, Ms. Lackey.

Throw in that the tale this is supposed based off was aborted not long after its inception and instead turned into this weird Wild West show, and I'm at a loss.
3 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Another solid entry in the series

This Elemental Masters novel reworks the Rapunzel story. Giselle was traded by her father to a witch for food for the family. Giselle’s magical stepmother dies, and Giselle is on her own, trying to find a way to maintain her home and independence. It’s Lackey, so it’s good and all fans will want to read it, but I wouldn’t enter the series here—especially since the heroine of the previous book (Blood Red) shows up midway through. It’s entertaining, placing a Wild West show in Germany. It has a leisurely pace, though. Despite a challenge early on, it seems three-fourths of the book is setup. In fact, it has the feel the middle book in a trilogy sometimes has, that the next book will be the reward. Hopefully it will be, for Rosamund the monster hunter (Earth Master) and Giselle the Air Master are well on their way to establishing a kind of partnership. Maybe there is a Sisterhood of Elemental Masters coming up! That would be exciting, and allow a new refreshment to the longrunning series.

I received an EARC for review from the publisher and Netgalley.
2 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Excellent Fun Reading

I've read everyone of Mercedes Lackey's Elemental Masters series. I know the books are written for young adults and I'm 63 years old. I still like the the way she blends elements of old Fairy Tales with the larger fantasy world she has created for the Elemental masters. This one starts with a desperate father in Germany, who trades a new-born child for food to feed his remainder of his starving family. From there there Mercedes combines elements of the Rapunzel fairy tale, with elements drawn from the German writer Karl May and tradition wild west show to create a ripping good new story for the Elemental Masters series. Excellent fun Reading.
1 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Another solid addition to the series

Although, not as good as Blood Red, in my opinion, From a High Tower is still better than most of the more recent Elemental Masters books. I liked the setting of it being a Traveling Wild West show in Germany and welcomed the return of Rosa from Blood Red. The climax and ending were a little abrupt, but not as bad as she has done in the recent past. I wish she'd let up a little on the "Girls are powerful too! " message, as it's so heavy handed and unnecessary- her heroins ARE being powerful, there's no need to point it out over and over and have people oppose them in it in the same tired ways! I also found the dialect she used for the Wild West show leader to be annoying and unnecessary- and if everyone got their "English" from him, shouldn't they all have spoken in that dialect, since she established in Blood Red that the dialect goes along with the language? Genrally, though, it is a solid, entertaining book, and a welcome continuation down the path of well written books in a series that had really taken a horrible turn for the worse.
1 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

better than expected!

This book was a pleasant surprise.I've read many of the author's earlier books but had stopped reading them.Grabbed this one and finished in one sitting.Very entertaining.Don't underestimate this author.A good read!
1 people found this helpful