Every Last One: A Novel (Random House Reader's Circle)
Every Last One: A Novel (Random House Reader's Circle) book cover

Every Last One: A Novel (Random House Reader's Circle)

Paperback – March 22, 2011

Price
$15.98
Format
Paperback
Pages
333
Publisher
Random House Trade Paperbacks
Publication Date
ISBN-13
978-0812976885
Dimensions
5.1 x 0.76 x 7.9 inches
Weight
9.4 ounces

Description

“Spellbinding.”— The New York Times Book Review “In a tale that rings strikingly true, [Anna] Quindlen captures both the beauty and the breathtaking fragility of family life.”— People “We come to love this family, because Quindlen makes their ordinary lives so fascinating, their mundane interactions engaging and important. . . . Never read a book that made you cry? Be prepared for a deluge of tears.”— USA Today “Anna Quindlen’s writing is like knitting; prose that wraps the reader in the warmth and familiarity of domestic life. . . . Then, as in her novels Black and Blue and One True Thing, Quindlen starts to pull at the world she has knitted, and lets it unravel across the pages.”— The Seattle Times “Packs an emotional punch . . . Quindlen succeeds at conveying the transience of everyday worries and the never-ending boundaries of a mother’s love.”— The Washington Post “A wise, closely observed, achingly eloquent book.”—The Huffington Post xa0 “If you pick up Every Last One to read a few pages after dinner, you’ll want to read another chapter, and another and another, until you get to bed late.”—Associated Press xa0 “Quindlen conjures family life from a palette of finely observed details.”— Los Angeles Times “[Quindlen’s] emotional sophistication, and her journalistic eye for authentic dialogue and detail, bring the ring of truth to every page of this heartbreakingly timely novel.”—NPR Anna Quindlen is the author of five bestselling novels ( Rise and Shine, Blessings, Object Lessons, One True Thing, Black and Blue ), and six nonfiction books ( Being Perfect, Loud & Clear, A Short Guide to a Happy Life, Living Out Loud, Thinking Out Loud, How Reading Changed My Life ). She has also written two children's books ( The Tree That Came to Stay, Happily Ever After ). Her New York Times column "Public and Private" won the Pulitzer Prize in 1992. Her column now appears every other week in Newsweek . Excerpt. © Reprinted by permission. All rights reserved. This is my life: The alarm goes off at five-thirty with the murmuring of a public-radio announcer, telling me that there has been a coup in Chad, a tornado in Texas. My husband stirs briefly next to me, turns over, blinks, and falls back to sleep for another hour. My robe lies at the foot of the bed, printed cotton in the summer, tufted chenille for the cold. The coffeemaker comes on in the kitchen below as I leave the bathroom, go downstairs in bare feet, pause to put away a pair of boots left splayed in the downstairs back hallway and to lift the newspaper from the back step. The umber quarry tiles in the kitchen were a bad choice; they are always cold. I let the dog out of her kennel and put a cup of kibble in her bowl. I hate the early mornings, the suspended animation of the world outside, the veil of black and then the oppressive gray of the horizon along the hills outside the French doors. But it is the only time I can rest without sleeping, think without deciding, speak and hear my own voice. It is the only time I can be alone. Slightly less than an hour each weekday when no one makes demands.Our bedroom is at the end of the hall, and sometimes as I pass I can hear the children breathing, each of them at rest as specific as they are awake. Alex inhales and exhales methodically, evenly, as though he were deep under the blanket of sleep even though he always kicks his covers askew, leaving one long leg, with its faint surgical scars, exposed to the night air. Across the room Max sputters, mutters, turns, and growls out a series of nonsense syllables. For more than a year when he was eleven, Max had a problem with sleepwalking. I would find him washing his hands at the bathroom sink or down in the kitchen, blinking blindly into the open refrigerator. But he stopped after his first summer at sleepaway camp.Ruby croons, one high strangled note with each exhale. When she was younger, I worried that she had asthma. She sleeps on her back most of the time, the covers tucked securely across her chest, her hair fanned out on the pillows. It should be easy for her to slip from beneath the blanket and make her bed, but she never bothers unless I hector her.I sit downstairs with coffee and the paper, staring out the window as my mind whirrs. At six-thirty I hear the shower come on in the master bath. Glen is awake and getting ready for work. At six-forty-five I pull the duvet off Ruby, who snatches it back and curls herself into it, larval, and says, “Ten more minutes.” At seven I lean over, first Alex, then Max, and bury my nose into their necks, beginning to smell the slightly pungent scent of male beneath the sweetness of child. “Okay, okay,” Alex says irritably. Max says nothing, just lurches from bed and begins to pull off an oversized T-shirt as he stumbles into the bathroom.There is a line painted down the center of their room. Two years ago they came to me, at a loose end on a June afternoon, and demanded the right to choose their own colors. I was distracted, and I agreed. They did a neat job, measured carefully, put a tarp on the floor. Alex painted his side light blue, Max lime green. The other mothers say, “You won’t believe what Jonathan”—or Andrew or Peter—“told me about the twins’ room.” Maybe if the boys had been my first children I would have thought it was insane, too, but Ruby broke me in. She has a tower of soda cans against one wall of her bedroom. It is either an environmental statement or just one of those things you do when you are fifteen. Now that she is seventeen she has outgrown it, almost forgotten it, but because I made the mistake of asking early on when she would take it down she never has.I open Ruby’s door, and although it doesn’t make a sound—she has oiled the hinges, I think, probably with baby oil or bath oil or something else nonsensically inappropriate, so we will not hear it creak in the nighttime—she says, “I’m up.” I stand there waiting, because if I take her word for it she will wrap herself in warmth again and fall into the long tunnel of sleep that only teenagers inhabit, halfway to coma or unconsciousness. “Mom, I’m up,” she shouts, and throws the bedclothes aside and begins to bundle her long wavy hair atop her head. “Can I get dressed in peace, please? For a change?” She makes it sound as though I constantly let a bleacher full of spectators gawk as she prepares to meet the day.Only Glen emerges in the least bit cheerful, his suit jacket over one arm. He keeps his white coats at the office. They are professionally cleaned and pressed and smell lovely, like the cleanest of clean laundry. “Doctor Latham” is embroidered in blue script above his heart. From upstairs I can hear the clatter of the cereal into his bowl. He eats the same thing every morning, leaves for work at the same time. He wears either a blue or a yellow shirt, with either a striped tie or one with a small repeating pattern. Occasionally, a grateful patient gives him a tie as a gift, printed with tiny pairs of glasses, an eye chart, or even eyes themselves. He thanks these people sincerely but never wears them.He is not tidy, but he knows where everything is: on which chair he left his briefcase, in what area of the kitchen counter he tossed his wallet. He does something with the corners of his mouth when things are not as they should be—when the dog is on the furniture, when the children and their friends make too much noise too late at night, when the red-wine glasses are in the white-wine glass rack. It has now pressed itself permanently into his expression, like the opposite of dimples.“Please. Spare me,” says my friend Nancy, her eyes rolling. “If that’s the worst you can say about him, then you have absolutely no right to complain.” Nancy says her husband, Bill, a tall gangly scarecrow of a guy, leaves a trail of clothing as he undresses, like fairy-tale breadcrumbs. He once asked her where the washing machine was. “I thought it was a miracle that he wanted to know,” she says when she tells this story, and she does, often. “It turned out the repairman was at the door and Bill didn’t know where to tell him to go.”Our washer is in the mudroom, off the kitchen. There is a chute from above that is designed to bring the dirty things downstairs. Over the years, our children have used the chute for backpacks, soccer balls, drumsticks. Slam. Slam. Slam. “It is a laundry chute,” I cry. “Laundry. Laundry.”Laundry is my life, and meals, and school meetings and games and recitals. I choose a cardigan sweater and put it on the chest at the foot of the bed. It is late April, nominally spring, but the weather is as wild as an adolescent mood, sun into clouds into showers into storms into sun again.“You smell,” I hear Alex say to Max from the hallway. Max refuses to reply. “You smell like shit,” Alex says. “Language!” I cry.“I didn’t say a word,” Ruby shouts from behind the door of her room. Hangers slide along the rack in her closet, with a sound like one of those tribal musical instruments. Three thumps—shoes, I imagine. Her room always looks as though it has been ransacked. Her father averts his head from the closed door, as though he is imagining what lies within. Her brothers are strictly forbidden to go in there, and, honestly, are not interested. Piles of books, random sweaters, an upended shoulder bag, even the lace panties, given that they belong to their sister—who cares? I am tolerated because I deliver stacks of clean clothes. “Put those away in your drawers,” I always say, and she never does. It would be so much easier for me to do it myself, but this standoff has become a part of our relationship, my attempt to teach Ruby responsibility, her attempt to exhibit independence. And so much of our lives together consists of rubbing along, saying things we know will be ignored yet continuing to say them, like background music.Somehow Ruby emerges every morning from the disorder of her room looking beautiful and distinctive: a pair of old Capri pants, a ruffled blouse I bought in college, a long cashmere cardigan with a moth hole in the sleeve, a ribbon tied around her hair. Ruby never looks like anyone else. I admire this and am a little intimidated by it, as though I had discovered we had incompatible blood types.Alex wears a T-shirt and jeans. Max wears a T-shirt and jeans. Max stops to rub the dog’s belly when he gets to the kitchen. She narrows her eyes in ecstasy. Her name is Virginia, and she is nine years old. She came as a puppy when the twins were five and Ruby was eight. “Ginger” says the name on the terra-cotta bowl we bought on her first Christmas. Max scratches the base of Ginger’s tail. “Now you’ll smell like dog,” says Alex. The toaster pops with a sound like a toy gun. The refrigerator door closes. I need more toothpaste. Ruby has taken my toothpaste. “I’m going,” she yells from the back door. She has not eaten breakfast. She and her friends Rachel and Sarah will stop at the doughnut shop and get iced coffee and jelly doughnuts. Sarah swims competitively and can eat anything. “The metabolism of a hummingbird,” says my friend Nancy, who is Sarah’s mother, which is convenient for us both. Nancy is a biologist, a professor at the university, so I suppose she should know about metabolism. Rachel is a year older than the other two, and drives them to school. The three of them swear that Rachel drives safely and slowly. I know this isn’t true. I picture Rachel, moaning again about some boy she really, really likes but who is insensible to her attentions, steering with one hand, a doughnut in the other, taking a curve with a shrieking sound. Caution and nutrition are for adults. They are young, immortal.“The bus!” Alex yells, and finally Max speaks. This is one of the headlines of our family life: Max speaks. “I’m coming,” he mumbles. “Take a sweatshirt,” I call. Either they don’t hear or they don’t care. I can see them with their backpacks getting on the middle-school bus. Alex always goes first.“Do we have any jelly?” Glen asks. He knows where his own things are, but he has amnesia when it comes to community property. “It’s where it’s always been,” I say. “Open your eyes and look.” Then I take two jars of jelly off the shelf inside the refrigerator door and thump them on the table in front of him. I can manage only one morning manner, so I treat my husband like one of the children. He doesn’t seem to mind or even notice. He likes this moment, when the children have been there but are suddenly gone. The dog comes back into the room, her claws clicking on the tiled floor. “Don’t feed her,” I say, as I do every morning. In a few minutes, I hear the messy chewing sounds as Ginger eats a crust of English muffin. She makes a circuit of the house, then falls heavily at my feet.After he has read the paper, Glen leaves for the office. He has early appointments one day a week and late ones three evenings, for schoolchildren and people with inflexible jobs. His office is in a small house a block from the hospital. He pulls his car out of the driveway and turns right onto our street every single morning. One day he turned left, and I almost ran out to call to him. I did open the front door, and discovered that a neighbor was retarring the driveway and a steamroller was blocking the road to the right. The neighbor waved. “Sorry for the inconvenience,” he called. I waved back. Read more

Features & Highlights

  • Mary Beth Latham has built her life around her family, around caring for her three teenage children and preserving the rituals of their daily life. When one of her sons becomes depressed, Mary Beth focuses on him, only to be blindsided by a shocking act of violence. What happens afterward is a testament to the power of a woman’s love and determination, and to the invisible lines of hope and healing that connect one human being to another. Ultimately, as rendered in Anna Quindlen’s mesmerizing prose,
  • Every Last One
  • is a novel about facing every last one of the things we fear the most, about finding ways to navigate a road we never intended to travel.

Customer Reviews

Rating Breakdown

★★★★★
30%
(810)
★★★★
25%
(675)
★★★
15%
(405)
★★
7%
(189)
23%
(622)

Most Helpful Reviews

✓ Verified Purchase

exploitative, contrived

"how many times have we told them we don't care what they do," the father says to the mother when a noise wakes him in the wee hours of the morning, "so long as they don't wake us up" and the mother goes back to sleep. This seems like an allegory for the book itself -- the parents don't seem to care what is going on under their noses, just so long as the kids don't disturb their lives and make them deal with it.

I had to blink at this sentence when I first read it, as I had been blinking at many of the incidents in the book. The fourteen year olds (from highschool on) have a midnight curfew during the week, 2am on weekends. The kids drink. Experiments in sex and drugs are hinted at. The girl has a bout with anorexia. One boy is seriously depressed and to me may have some developmental disorder.

Regarding the tragedy, there's enough foreshadowing dropped in the front part of the book to flatten any surprise (though I read no reviews and had no jacket blurb to warn me). The parents take both the anorexic girl and depressed boy to a shrink but they seem more irritated at the necessity of doing it than concerned for what is going on in their kids lives. Neither parent has one single meaningful conversation with their kids that leads them to taking preventative action.

As I read it became glaringly apparent who would do the tragegy, and still the parents do nothing to ward it off. I kept reading even though the lead up to the action consumed the entire first half of the book. I admired One True Thing enormously, though I haven't been impressed with anything else the author has written, that I had hope. So I read on, hoping for great writing, and fearing the worst.

And it was the worst. Great writing is not picking the worst tragedy of the week out of the headlines, and milking it for emotional profoundness (the latter which was not in evidence BTW). It's just exploitation.

One True Thing was heartfelt and personal, but since then, it seems the author is milking headlines to contrive her stories. As if just by putting your characters in a controversial situation, that's literature, so long as you can turn a pretty phrase around it.

Quindlen can turn some pretty phrases, but this was not literature, more like movie of the week trash. It's as if the author is trying to marry her old columns about her family life with her reporting of tragedy. Unfortunately, I found it left me unmoved. The characters seemed caricatures, the tragedy contrived, there was no plot to speak of, just mundane life up to the tragedy, and then accounting of mundane life afterwards. And the tragedy was so ridiculously excessive, it just offended me as a reader. I didn't think it was necessary. It was gratuitous violence, just to shock the reader in an attempt to make the story and characters more profound. I just felt it cheapened the whole effort. When it happened, my sole reaction was "who needs this".

And I found the main character's inability to act on any of the things she foreshadows really annoying. Her kids are having problems, she narrates them in her internal dialogue, but doesn't really do anything. There are some truely disquieting foreshadowings, she still takes no action. She hires illegals for a low wage, and moons over their bad living conditions, and miserable lives, but keeps on doing it.

After the tragedy, she just continues the same inaction -- she doesn't deal with the tragic events much more than she dealt with the events leading up. She puts one kid in therapy because HE asks for it. Eventually enough time passes and she gets involved in other projects and she moves on. How is that profound?

I wish Quindlen would stop writing from headlines in an attempt to be culturally profound and just write a novel from the heart. She has the skills to do it, but it seems not the emotional courage to write from her own life and not pick a tragedy of the week from the headlines.
7 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Get real, Mom

I am a big fan of Anna Quindlen, but this book left me angry and cold. Up until the "big event" occurs, the family is duly portrayed as a middle class, comfortably off family with the usual teenage issues. The mother hovers over the teens and never faces reality. Come on, what mother could not be aware that someone is living in her garage? She sees sign after sign, but sweetly ignores them in her suburban soccer mom way. She should have called the police when she knew her daughter was being stalked. I think the whole book is an indictment of bland American parents who ask nothing of their kids, who expect or demand no work or respect from them, and who give and hover incessantly, ignoring the hard truths al the while. The tragedy would not have happened if Mary Beth had an ounce of strength and honesty in her sweet suburban soul. As a schoolteacher, I have seen so many parents who cannot believe that Johnny or Susie is failing in high school and smoking pot under the bleachers after they're dropped off in the Lexus at school in the morning.
5 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Heavy-Handed!

This is a hard one to call, mostly because it is a well-written work, created with craft and heart and thought. Ms. Quindlen obviously thinks highly of her readers, for she has spent time trying to get it right. I detected neither insincerity nor shallowness. Most of the characters were authentic and alive, I had a good grasp of them, the adults as well as the teenagers.

Nonetheless, after about a hundred pages in, when still nothing much was happening to thrust the book forward - just pretty prose followed by pretty prose describing very mundane things - I started to get antsy. I was beginning to dislike the book. And I realized how important it is, not just to write well and truthfully, but to TELL A STORY THAT KEEPS US RIVETED. To do that, you need characters who have a want, a goal, an aim, and they act upon it, skirting obstacles, fighting obstacles, etc. In fact, the plot point that finally turns the story into another direction is not the main character''s doing, but comes from outside, almost like a deus ex machina. So it''s not even the main character, Mary Beth Latham, who moves the story forward. She just floats along, in the first half of the book merrily, in the second half like a zombie. She barely acts. This may be true-to-life, BUT IT DOESN'T MAKE FOR A GOOD STORY. And this so sloooows down the book.

Another thing that bothered me, was that I really didn't know what Quindlen wanted us to come away with. Why did she write this story? Just to remind us that bad things happen to good people? Did she have to be so extreme about it? She - watch out: SPOILER!! - ' kills off three wonderful people with one fell swoop and leaves the wife and mother a frozen, closed off soul. Was that necessary? I wondered why she did it. This may sound callous, but wouldn't one death have been enough? By killing off three she turned her story into MELODRAMA, the stuff of NIGHTMARES and not everyday life, the stuff of BAD TELEVISION and WOMEN''S AFTERNOON TALK SHOWS.

By the end of the book - ' yes, I read it to the last page, testament to Quindlen's writing skills - ' well, by the end, I actually disliked the book fiercely. Why? Because it was heavy-handed. In my eyes: a sin. She puts us up against the wall and almost FORCES us to weep. I felt exploited.

Oh, and another thing, it's minor in comparison to the above, but it was irksome: there are many minor characters that come in and out of Mary Beth''s life. As Quindlen does little to characterize these people I kept on getting confused: wait a sec, who''s Nancy? Who''s Kevin? Who''s Ricky? Towards the end this was no longer a problem, but until half-way through the book it was an added distraction.

Therefore, though I wish I didn't have to - I liked three of Quindlen's previous books a lot - I am giving this book just two stars.
5 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Good Book Club Selection

This was a very good book that held my interest throughout. It built from a slow beginning to points where I had trouble putting it down. The ratings from my book club were a bit mixed, as the story line came close (at some points) to our own life experiences. It led to a lot of compare and contrast discussion as well as, how I would have, how I have, managed some of the issues detailed in the story line. I would recommend it for a book club selection as lively discussion is so much desired and the range of human emotions is such that everyone will find a talking point.
4 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

The first 175 pages were boring. Didn't want to finish but it was for ...

The first 175 pages were boring. Didn't want to finish but it was for a book club reading. Everyone said it would get better but had my doubts. My friend said to skip to 175 that before it was boring. After 75 boring pages that is what I did. Did get better but lots of boring to get to that point in the story.
4 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Haunting and Lovely

** THIS REVIEW IS ABOUT THE AUDIOBOOK VERSION OF THE BOOK ***

For a long time, I wasn't going to read this book because of a little fight I was having with Anna Quindlen. (The fight, of course, was all one-sided. She has no idea I exist or had a problem with her.) First of all, I thought Quindlen's Rise and Shine was sub-par (Strike 1). Then I read her tiny little book of "wisdom" called Being Perfect and thought it was (to quote myself) "a money grab." (Strike 2.) Then I saw she did ANOTHER money grab book (defined as a very short book sold for quite a bit of money) and that was it for me. (Strike 3.) So Anna Quindlen was out (like a strike-out in baseball in case you weren't following my metaphor). But I kept seeing reviews for Every Last One popping up on various book blogs. Everyone kept praising it, but there was a Fight Club-esque feel to the plot (every review alludes to something Very Bad but you never really get a sense of what it is). The more reviews I read, the more my curiosity was aroused. What was this Bad Thing that happened to the main character in the book--a small-town wife and mother named Mary Beth Latham? I needed to know exactly what happened. So I decided that Anna Quindlen hadn't actually struck out with me ... it was more of a 3 and 2 pitch situation (to use another baseball metaphor) and this book Every Last One would be the final pitch--the pitch that would decide my future relationship with Anna Quindlen's novels.

So I downloaded the book from Audible and began listening. With a pitch-perfect narration by Hope Davis, I quickly found myself drawn into the story of the Latham family--Mary Beth (worried, busy mom), Glenn (her ophthalmologist husband whose as perplexed by their children as she is), 17-year-old Ruby (who is flowering into a vibrant young woman full of a healthy sense of self and her place in the world), and the 15-year-old twins Max and Alex (Alex is the popular, outgoing jock while Max is the artistic recluse who seems to have fallen into a depression). Knowing only that something Very Bad happens, I listened to the book with a sense of dread; with each phone call or event, I was sure I had figured out what was going to happen. (Not one of my guesses panned out ... though I did start to sniff around the edges at one point.) As Hope Davis (who really became Mary Beth for me) shares Mary Beth's view of her world, I found myself relating to her more and more. She felt so real and lived in. Life in the Latham household felt authentic and true, and I was getting involved in their lives. Then the Very Bad thing happened (and don't think I'm going to tell you either ... listen or read the book yourself) and it was like I was punched in the stomach. I was just stunned. Tears sprang to my eyes, and I remember inhaling sharply. "No," I thought. "This can't be." The book after the Bad Thing (it almost dissects the book in half) was equally well done and believable. You find yourself in this dark place with Mary Beth, and when I got to the end of the book, I was in tears.

As you may have guessed, the 3/2 pitch ended up in a home run. Every Last One was a brilliant book. It was emotional, wrenching, lovely, true--all the things that I used to admire about Quindlen's writing before our little spat. I'm so glad I gave her one last shot as this was one of the most powerful books I've read this year. I also suspect that audio is the way to go with this one. Hope Davis's narration was simply marvelous. She gave Mary Beth a real voice--full of sighs, hesitation, questioning and emotion. She made an emotional book come alive in a way that it might not have done on the page--proving, once again, that a well-done audiobook with a talented narrator can elevate a book and make it something even more special than it already is.

Well done, Ms. Quindlen and Ms. Davis. Well done.
4 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Some Good and Most Really Bad

Some of the wrting is really good. Lyrical and metaphorical. Nice.

HOWEVER, the voice and flat personality of the main character was sooo irritating that I could not stand her by the end, or any of the characters.

Part of the irritation is the present tense the author chose which was very much a WRONG choice.

I say

She says

I walk

I run

Makes it sound very stupid and choppy.

I hated the way the siblings treated each other. Alex was horrible to his twin brother Max which made him unlikable and it also felt false. Twins are usually very close and why not write them as close? It would have added some depth.

None of the characters were likable. I couldn't have cared less about any of them. What's up with that?

Spoiler.
The tragedy. No way did it have to be to this magnitude. That was ridiculous and unrealistic. The grief was no where near portrayed for that kind of devastation. The story would have been so much better if Ruby was the only victim.

Get this. Alex never sees his mother cry. "I didn't want to upset you" she says. What the heck??? I got divorced and I cried all the time. When I was driving in the car, when I was stirring the soup, when I watched TV, when I listened to music. Not sobbing but I could not
keep the tears from rolling down my cheeks and my kids saw that. This lady loses almost everyone. After one year she'd still be barely functioning.
4 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

This Novel Pulled Me In and Kept Me Up Past My Bedtime!

When a book grabs me and I become lost in the story and I'm awake way past my bedtime, I have to send kudos to the author. This doesn't happen that many times. That said, I was largely bored by the first half of the book but once I reached the tragic part, the story became so much more weighty and dramatic. I would have enjoyed the first half more had there been more interaction between husband and wife or if the family struggles hadn't been lost in a sea of team sports and trivial arguments. This could be the type of thing that resonates with many so-called soccer moms today. I parented an only child who didn't play sports so it all became a blur to me. Oh, and something else that I notice other reviewers have mentioned--she had so many friends and acquaintances that it was hard to keep track of them all in addition to her children's friends. So many female names! I'd get mixed up--who are these females she has just encountered--her friends or her children's friends? I'll admit that I'm getting too old for a large mix of characters especially when they don't particularly distinguish themselves but just kind of melt into the crowd.

But once I got past all this, the story became the tragedy that it is and I cried a lot during the second half of the book. I was reading the interview with Quindlen at the end of the book and she claims that she and Mary Beth Latham have nothing really in common other than being married and having three children. But I would add one more thing--evidently there is a disbelief in an afterlife because Mary Beth feels that she will never see her family members again. Quindlen has no belief in an afterlife either. It is noted that someone removes all the sympathy mail Mary Beth receives that include mentions of "a better place" or an afterlife. Is it her mother? Perhaps. My memory fails me here. But I know that Quindlen mentioned in her memoir Lots of Candles, Plenty of Cake that she was disturbed after her mom's death when people told her that her mom was in "a better place." She added that she did not then and still doesn't have a belief in life after death. To me, a belief in the afterlife offers a measure of comfort that is lacking when this belief is absent (my apologies to atheists, agnostics, and all non-believers in eternal life everywhere).

Don't look for any traditional happy endings here, but I will state that there is hope in the final pages. Mary Beth has a son whom she loves deeply, a mother who has become a friend, and some good women friends. One tends to feel that although her life is indelibly marked by deep tragedy that she could eventually taste true happiness in life.
3 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Haunting and disturbing

Quindlen is often presented as a "woman's" author. I think that trivializes her. When Hillary Clinton is president, I am certain that I will think of her as a great president, not as a great female president. That said, Quindlen is a great observer and describer of the vagaries and conditionality's of human life. On a very intimate level, this book is a study in theodicy and the eternal debate of free will versus determinism. It is a very disturbing study of how we are complicit in our own evil and how we are the unwitting victims of that evil. Quindlen's sympathy and empathy for her characters compels us to engage them compassionately and not critically. I see this book very much in the tradition of Madam Bovary and Anna Karenina. And, yes, I am a male, but I am first a person, and that it is to whom this novel speaks.
3 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

I get a feeling this isn't her best novel

Unlike a lot of readers I didn't actually realise that anything really traumatic was going to happen to the family in this story - the blurb on the UK edition is incredibly misleading (and fortunately I didn't read some of the reviews here either) - so I was quite enjoying the book on its own merits and was truly stunned when suddenly over a couple of pages everything in Mary Beth's life is turned on its head. Up on till then I had been finding her quite an irritatingly self-absorbed character, ridiculously indulgent to her children - running upstairs to her daughter's room everytime she calls, and letting one of her sons get off with not washing or doing any household chores - wondering how it would all pan out so I was genuinely curious to find out how the author would show this character developing in the aftermath of tragedy. Well the novel plods on for a few more chapters but by the end I was till waiting for some kind of catharsis, anything to tie the whole thing together and make it work as a piece of fiction. Sorry, but unlike others I didn't find this at all authentic as a study of grief and it didn't actually move me in any way. Mary Beth's woolly liberal forgiveness towards the person who made her life a living hell didn't ring true in the slightest, and I suspect that survivors of violent events rarely decide to move to the middle of nowhere just a few months later. The author tries to introduce a theme of guilt - is Mary Beth suffering because of her behaviour towards a former friend? but this is a character so inherently satisfied with herself that she doesn't even seem capable of feeling guilt - so that ends up going nowhere. I was hoping for some kind of confrontation with Deborah who actually seemed more sinned against than sinning to me, but no she is just written off as a crazy person with no closure for that particular storyline.

I would definitely look for more books by this author as I like her writing style but I think she kind of bit off more than she could chew here. I think to write about these kind of events you either need to be a great writer or have experienced it for yourself to make it feel authentic to the reader.
3 people found this helpful