Crow Fair: Stories
Crow Fair: Stories book cover

Crow Fair: Stories

Hardcover – Deckle Edge, March 3, 2015

Price
$12.00
Format
Hardcover
Pages
288
Publisher
Knopf
Publication Date
ISBN-13
978-0385350198
Dimensions
6 x 1.25 x 8.5 inches
Weight
1.05 pounds

Description

“Mysterious and illuminating . . . [McGuane] alternately pounds, kneads, works and reworks his material, shedding his tears into it and wrenching away, peeling and scraping it off his hands in a fruitless attempt to escape; then, wretched but indefatigable, going back to knead it again. This obsessive labor seems to change the molecular structure of the substance, from clay to a kind of porcelain . . . [McGuane] has honed a kind of bluff Western comedy of masculinity [and] turns muck into art, which takes wing in flights of ingenuity.”—Atticus Lish, The New York Times Book Review “Dazzling . . . McGuane rustles up some of his best stories yet . . . [and] continues to burnish his reputation with some of his most accomplished fiction to date.” —O Magazine “One of McGuane’s great gifts is the ability to elicit laughter in dark moments or to jolt the reader of an ostensibly comic tale with a knife twist of pathos or tragedy . . . the only thing [the reader] can expect is to be surprised – by McGuane’s deadpan wit, his hyperactive imagination, and his deep appreciation for the human comedy . . . [ Crow Fair ] serves not merely to make us gape or laugh at man’s essential weirdness but also to recognize a bit of it in ourselves.”—Stefan Beck, The Christian Science Monitor “McGuane has both honed the edge of his already sharp tone and, paradoxically, become more sympathetic to the human condition . . . [he] gives us well-rounded women alongside the men, making for a rich and fascinating portrait of Montana — with hungry bears and fighting trout as wonderful extras.” —Alan Cheuse, NPR“McGuane’s Montana retains wistful and ironic echoes of the Old West . . . with imagery as sparse and striking as the landscape . . . [These] stories highlight the detachment of young from old, husband from wife, neighbor from neighbor, the dying from life itself . . . [through] many funny, sad, and awful, awfully human moments.” — Publishers Weekly (starred review) xa0 “Glum, gleeful, brilliant . . . McGuane’s stories are about the wacked-out order men and women assign to things, but it’s not the true order and merely contributes to a larger confusion that is not far from horror . . . Backdoor irony, you might call it, mixed with black humor.” —John Mort, Booklist (starred review) xa0 “A slyly cutting batch of tales from a contemporary master . . . Seventeen stories, straightforward but well-crafted, that cement McGuane’s reputation as the finest short story writer of Big Sky country . . . The conflicts throughout this book are age-old . . . but McGuane’s clean writing and psychological acuity enliven them all.” — Kirkus (starred review) xa0 “A compelling, emotionally charged collection.” —Lawrence Rungren, Library Journal (starred review) Thomas McGuane lives in McLeod, Montana. He is a member of the American Academy of Arts and Letters and the author of ten novels, three works of nonfiction, and two other collections of stories.Thomas McGuane’s The Bushwacked Piano, The Cadence of Grass, Driving on the Rim, Gallatin Canyon, Keep the Change, The Longest Silence, Ninety-two in the Shade, Nobody’s Angel, Nothing but Blue Skies, Panama, Some Horses, Something to Be Desired, The Sporting Club, and To Skin a Cat are available in Vintage paperback. Excerpt. © Reprinted by permission. All rights reserved. Hubcaps In the hardwood forest, a shallow swamp immersed the trunks and roots of the trees near the lake. Owen and Ben hunted turxadtles among the waterweeds and pale aquatic flowers. The turtles sunned themselves on low branches hanging over the water, in shafts of light spotted with dancing dragonflies. Ever alert, the creatures tumbled into the swamp at the first sound, as though wiped from the branches by an unseen hand. The wild surroundxadings made Ben exuberant. He bent saplings to watch them recoil or shinnied up trees, and he returned home carrying things that interested him—strands of waterweed, bleached muskrat skulls, or the jack-in-the-pulpits he brought to his mother to fend off her irritation at having to wash another load of muddy clothes. Once, Owen caught two of the less-vigilant turtles, the size of fifty-cent pieces, with poignant little feet constantly trying to get somewhere that only they knew. Owen loved their tiny perxadfection, the flexible undersides of their shells, the ridges down their topside that he could detect with his thumbnail. Their necks were striped yellow, and they stretched them upward in their striving. Owen made a false bottom for his lunch box with ventilation holes so that he could always have them with him, despite the rule against taking pets to school or on the school bus. He fed them flies from a bottle cap. Only Ben knew where they were. One afternoon, Owen came back from the swamp to find the flashing beacon of the town’s fire truck illuminating the faces of curious neighbors outside his house. He ran up the short length of his driveway in time to see his mother addressing a small crowd as she stood beside two firemen in obsolete leather helxadmets with brass eagles fixed to their fronts. She looked slightly disheveled in a housedress and golf-club windbreaker, and she spoke in the lofty voice she used when she had been drinking, the one meant to fend off all questions: “Let he who has never had a kitchen grease fire cast the first stone!” She laughed. “Blame the television. Watching The Guiding Light. Mea culpa. A soufflé.” Owen felt the complete bafflement of the neighborhood as he listened. Then her tone flattened. “Look, the fire’s gone. Good night, one and all.” Owen’s father’s car nosed up to the group. His father jumped out, tie loosened, radiating authority. He pushed straight through to the firefighters without glancing at his wife. “Handled?” The shorter of the two nodded quickly. His father spoke to the neighbors: “Looks like not much. I’ll get the details, I’m sure.” Most had wandered off toward their own homes by then, the xa0Kershaws among the last to go. Owen’s father turned to his wife, who was staring listlessly at the ground, placed his broad hand on the small of her back, and moved her through the front door, which he closed behind him, leaving Owen alone in the yard. When Owen went in, his parents were sitting at opposite sides of the kitchen table, the Free Press spread out in front of them. The brown plastic Philco murmured a Van Patrick interxadview with Birdie Tebbetts: it was the seventh-inning stretch in the Indians game. Owen’s father motioned to him to have a seat, which he did while trying to get the drift of the interview. His mother didn’t look up, except to access the flip lid on her silver ashtray. She held a Parliament between her thumb and middle finger, delicately tapping the ash free with her forefinger. His father flicked the ash from his Old Gold with his thumbnail at the butt of the cigarette and made no particular effort to see that it landed in the heavy glass ashtray by his wrist. Commenting on what he had just read, his father said, “Let’s blow ’em up before they blow us up!” “Who’s this?” his mother said, but got no answer. Instead, she turned to Owen. “Your father and I are going to take a break from each other.” “Oh, yeah?” “We thought you’d want to know.” “Sure.” His father lifted his head to glance at Owen, then returned to the paper. Owen knew better than to say a single word, unless it was about the weather. He wanted his parents to be distracted, so that he could fit in more baseball and get any kind of hairxadcut he liked, but he worried about things falling apart entirely. He was unable to picture what might lie beyond that. School, of course, out there like a black cloud. His mother said, “Ma said she’d take me in.” At this, his father raised his head from the paper. “For God’s sake, Alice, no one is ‘taking you in.’ You’re not homeless.” “Why don’t you go someplace, and I’ll stay here? Maybe someone will take you in.” “I’ll tell you why: I’ve got a business to run.” His business, which dispatched plumbers and electricians to emergencies, was called Don’t Get Mad, Get Egan and made the sort of living known as decent. With tradesmen on retainer, he worked from an office, a hole-in-the-wall above a florist’s shop. An answering service gave the impression that it was a bigger operation than it was. “Ma will think you’ve failed.” “Well, you tell Ma I haven’t failed.” “No, you tell her, sport.” “I’m not calling your mother to tell her that I haven’t failed. That doesn’t make sense. Owen, where have you been? You look like you’ve been in the swamp.” “I’ve been in the swamp.” “Would you like to add anything to that?” “No.” His mother stubbed out her cigarette and said, “I think you owe your father a more complete answer, young man.” “It’s nothing more than a little old swamp,” Owen said. “Mind turning that up? It’s the top of the eighth.” Nobody was going anywhere except back to the newspaper. Excerpted from Crow Fair by Thomas McGuane. Copyright © 2015 by Thomas McGuane. Excerpted by permission of Knopf, a division of Random House LLC. All rights reserved. No part of this excerpt may be reproduced or reprinted without permission in writing from the publisher. Read more

Features & Highlights

  • From one of our most deeply admired storytellers, author of the richly acclaimed
  • Gallatin Canyon,
  • his first collection in nine years.Set in Thomas McGuane’s accustomed Big Sky country, with its mesmeric powers, these stories attest to the generous compass of his fellow feeling, as well as to his unique way with words and the comic genius that has inspired comparison with Twain and Gogol. The ties of family make for uncomfortable binds: A devoted son is horrified to discover his mother’s antics before she slipped into dementia. A father’s outdoor skills are no match for an ominous change in the weather. But complications arise equally in the absence of blood, as when lifelong friends on a fishing trip finally confront their deep dislike for each other. Or when a gifted traveling cattle breeder succumbs to the lure of a stranger’s offer of easy money. McGuane is as witty and large-hearted as we have ever known him—a jubilant, thunderous confirmation of his status as a modern master.

Customer Reviews

Rating Breakdown

★★★★★
30%
(71)
★★★★
25%
(59)
★★★
15%
(35)
★★
7%
(17)
23%
(54)

Most Helpful Reviews

✓ Verified Purchase

Beautiful work of literary fiction

Crow Fair by Thomas McGuane is a work of beautifully written literary works of short fiction, each story is set in Big Sky country, and yet while family and friendships appears to be the central theme, each story, there are seventeen in all, are quite different and yet all the stories draw the reader into the messed up lives of the characters, yet their flaws make them even more human and readily accessible to the reader. It is not often I read a collection of short stories I care to share with others, in hopes they too will pick up the collection, but Crow Fair is one of the exceptions. McGuane sense of humanity, tragedy, and wit make for an exceptional collection of short stories that fully engage the reader and often times make the reader pause and reflect. Several of the short stories stayed with me and I caught myself thinking of them long after I had finished the book. I look forward to reading more works my McGuane; he is truly a master of literary prose.
12 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Old Reliable

I can't say that Thomas McGuane produces great literature, but with CROW FAIR I now have read nine of his books over the years. That's more than I have read of William Faulkner. So there clearly is something to McGuane. Here's what I think his appeal is, at least for me: He is an excellent writer; there is plenty of dead-pan humor; his tales are always a little askew, which makes them more entertaining; there are plenty of gimlet-eyed observations about contemporary America (at least, contemporary white America); and he never demands much from the reader. In a way, he is like Elmore Leonard.

CROW FAIR is McGuane's third collection of short stories -- here, seventeen of them. Most of the stories are set in Montana. All feature characters who are social misfits of one stamp or another. They might not all be "losers", but none are winners. Some are angry about it while others are merely rueful. For almost everyone, life has not worked out they way they planned or desired. There are few (if any) stable, enduring marriages.

Yet there is no real sense of tragedy. (The closest is "Hubcaps", which features a mentally handicapped kid, Ben. But "Hubcaps" is more bleak than tragic. It also is anomalous in that it is set in Wisconsin.) For McGuane, alienation and loneliness, failed relationships, the hollowness of the American Dream (or, the Montana Dream) -- all that is simply Life As It Is, worthy of wry or caustic wit but not tragedy.

None of the stories in CROW FAIR take your breath away. Most are quite good. They all are told with a brisk pace. Of the nine McGuane books that I have read, CROW FAIR slots somewhere in the upper middle of the pack. Which means that even at age seventy-five there has been no discernible drop in McGuane's writing or storytelling abilities. It also means that if he comes out with yet another book, I probably will buy and read it, even though I cannot satisfactorily articulate his appeal.
9 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Thomas McGuane at his best - again and again

Thomas McGuane is to contemporary fiction what Herbie Hancock is to jazz - a master. These stories, some of which appeared in The New Yorker, display a command of language, insight into human nature and folly, a compassion for damaged personalities and the wounded heart that you rarely find in modern American literature. McGuane is bold: his novels and stories are acts of serious literature, yet so accessible that the term seems almost highfalutin when used in his neighborhood. He’s the real thing, our American Chekhov.
3 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

If you are Apsáalooke, don't jump to any conclusions--this is NOT about you, and it is a great book.

I have been a fan of Tom McGuane's writing for over 25 years. I am also a Bozemanite, and in possession of a master's degree in Native American Studies, and currently working on a PhD in American Studies focusing on contemporary American Indian art. All of that to say that while I was delighted when Ariana at the Country Bookshelf announced that she had signed first editions of his latest, when I saw the title, I also thought, "Oh, this one is surely going to stir up a bed of rattlesnakes." Why? Because of the title: "Crow Fair." As an academic immersed in a world of Native American issues, I knew it would not be long before someone accused him of misappropriation and or misrepresentation (and that is being kind--more likely he'll be called a racist for daring to be a White person writing about something Native American).

Sure enough, a Native American friend of a Native American friend jumped in on a post featuring the book, and had this to say:

"I read the interview, transcripts, reviews, and excerpts... so far, I can't say that I would like this. As a Crow member, the title is misleading. McGuane makes the statement of, " living where I do among non-literary people I probably want to be able to write things that they could understand... And maybe that's simplified my style a little better — not simplified it, but made it plainer." Is McGuane assuming that people on the Eastern part of Montana, or in the impoverished locations, that they're not literate? To take a title as huge as "Crow Fair", from a people who has strong ties to it, and use it as a series of short stories; it's almost blasphemous. Especially when a non-Native American uses the title. In any case, his audience seem to be non-Native Americans who are illiterate. Well, not illiterate, just people who can read books that are "simplified" or a "simplified" style of writing. *thumbs down*"

I couldn't resist an opportunity to debunk a misconception borne out of ignorance, partly because she didn't even read the story, much less the entire book, and partly because as a non-indigenous person who has worked for social justice my entire life, this kind of "leap before you look" accusation based solely on the fact that the author is White and a title refers to something in a Native American domain continues to bother me. I have no idea if Tom McGuane is a "White ally" to Native American people, but I do know enough about him through his writing and our local community to know that he does them no harm and is not their enemy.

I couldn't let that pass, so I countered. As my response ended up sounding a little like a book review, I thought it might be useful here:

"There is nothing simple about Tom McGuane's writing. And the title "Crow Fair" does not refer to the Apsáalooke people or make any kind of commentary on them in any way. It isn't even about Crow Fair, but rather is the title of the short story within the book that he has chosen to represent the entire collection of short stories.
Having read the book, it is obvious why he chose that story to represent the entire book. That story is about the power that a childhood memory "snapshot" can have in governing the way we navigate and understand the rest of our lives (whether accurately or otherwise). The story is about two very different brothers dealing with their mother's dementia as she is dying. In her dementia, she confuses one of her sons for an old lover, who happens to be a Crow man. It bothers the brother who reminds his mother of this man that she's sees him in himself. His only memory of the man was from an ancient memory from his childhood, when his mother took her sons to Crow Fair because the man had invited her and her children (a lovers' rendezvous).

In the penning of these brothers' memories of that event and the interactions, McGuane confronts stereotypes and racism that most white people don't even know they possess until they are immersed in such a naked, unprepared, cross-cultural immersion. Their experience of the event will likely color their attitudes about such, unless they have other opportunities to form new, better attitudes, which only happens with meaningful interaction, which many people never have, much less seek.

The importance of that story may be lost on you, but it is not lost on me. For non-indigenous people who have never had meaningful relationships with indigenous people, the kind of interaction he describes is very common. For people such as those who might read McGuane's book, a story like "Crow Fair" could cause them to rethink their own experiences, and perhaps reconsider some of their own attitudes. It is subtle, but fiction that tells the truth like that can be a very powerful persuader, precisely because it puts the reader at least one remove from their own situation, allowing them to perhaps examine it a little more closely.

"Crow Fair" is in no way a misappropriation of Apsáalooke culture, nor a slight to Crow people, or indigenous people in general. It is an honest attempt to examine misconceptions and prejudices in a way that might actually get people to see themselves realistically. It is in no way disrespectful, regardless. The worst that could be said about it is that Tom McGuane has created some sad characters that can be easy targets for our social critique of their prejudices and stereotypes. He by no means glorifies or even condones their attitudes and behavior.

It's a good book, and brave. I am certain that Tom McGuane, who has lived in Montana since the 1960s (and nowhere near the Crow reservation--he lives in McLeod, south of Big Timber, where his "non-literary" neighbors are ranchers and farmers--not illiterate, but not academic, either), KNEW that he would likely poke a bed of rattlesnakes with that title. Apparently, he thought it worth the gamble. And here we are, having an important discussion about it, so I think he was right."

In short, the book is fantastic and full of the ironically simple but language-enriched writing I have come to expect from Tom McGuane. Additionally, I hope he doesn't take too much of a bloody nose for "Crow Fair" from indigenous people based on the title, or even the one little short story, alone, because it will be unwarranted.
2 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Not Worth the Time

This is McGuane's first novel in nine years. It is not one of his best in my opinion.

While there are a couple of stories worth reading, such as Crow Fair itself, the bulk of the stories are rather stiff and not up to his former self. The story of the two friends that end up on a fishing trip is really rather haphazard and seems to rate with the entire force of the book.

I realize it just may be me but I think the stories are rather short sighted and not really worth the effort. You may find them more interesting and that is OK. But for me the cost is really not worth the effort especially given his past work which has been really very good. I give it three stars but two would also work.
2 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

I prefer McGuane's earlier work but that's just me

Many years ago, I read a few of Thomas McGuane's then-new novels. Like The Bushwhacked Piano. The Sporting Club. Hilarious, gonzo novels. I didn't keep up with his career for some reason, so I was curious about his new collection Crow Fair. Was McGuane still a gonzo writer? If so, how did he carry that off within a short story? The answers are, No, so he doesn't. The 17 stories in this book are character driven, sensitive, folksy, at times humorous, but not the crazy laugh-out-loud humor of his early works. New Yorker style stories, in that they focus on small but psychologically important events in the characters' lives. Not New Yorker style, in that they take place in Montana. McGuane almost seems like a different writer--but it has been many years.
2 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

In the flavor of old-time storytellers

This collection of stories will appeal to fans of character-driven (as opposed to action-driven) stories. There are no harrowing, edge-of-your-seat moments; rather, the stories are about people, usually in ordinary situations dealing with life. He reminded me more of a modern-day Mark Twain, though with a good bit more profanity than Twain used. If you're looking for leisurely reading to pass the time, you'll probably enjoy this book.
2 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Five Stars

one of the best writers of our time
1 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Munro Goes To Montana

McGuane is one of my favorite authors so I was really excited to read his latest work. I'm sorry to say that it's my least favorite. The characters are a bunch of sad sacks lacking the humor, insight, self deprication, dimension and hijinx I expect from his books. The stories are derivative - Alice Munro in Montana.
1 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

i'm usually a McGuane aficionado but most of these stories read like they come from a collection of outtakes.

"Crow Fair" (the title story", and "Prairie Girl" are the exceptions to my outtakes comment.
these two are worth the price of admission
but i believe i read them before in some mag, probably The New Yorker.
1 people found this helpful