Christmas Cake Murder (A Hannah Swensen Mystery)
Christmas Cake Murder (A Hannah Swensen Mystery) book cover

Christmas Cake Murder (A Hannah Swensen Mystery)

Hardcover – September 25, 2018

Price
$14.59
Format
Hardcover
Pages
288
Publisher
Kensington
Publication Date
ISBN-13
978-1617732324
Dimensions
5.26 x 0.96 x 7.28 inches
Weight
9.6 ounces

Description

INDULGE IN JOANNE FLUKE’S CRIMINALLY DELICIOUS HANNAH SWENSEN MYSTERIES! WEDDING CAKE MURDER “There are plenty of Fluke’s trademark recipes on view here, and the New York trip and reality‑show frame give the episode a fresh twist.” — Booklist DOUBLE FUDGE BROWNIE MURDER “Lively . . . Add the big surprise ending, and fans will be more than satisfied.” — Publishers Weekly BLACKBERRY PIE MURDER “Lake Eden’s favorite baker, Hannah Swensen finds herself on the wrong end of a police investigation . . . in Fluke’s good-natured 19th installment.” — Kirkus Reviews RED VELVET CUPCAKE MURDER “Culinary cozies don’t get any tastier than this winning series.” — Library Journal “If your reading habits alternate between curling up with a good mystery or with a good cookbook, you ought to know about Joanne Fluke.” — The Charlotte Observer JOANNE FLUKE is the New York Times bestselling author of the Hannah Swensen mysteries, which include Raspberry Danish Murder, Banana Cream Pie Murder , Wedding Cake Murder , and the book that started it all, Chocolate Chip Cookie Murder. That first installment in the series premiered as Murder, She Baked:xa0 A Chocolate Chip Cookie Mystery on the Hallmark Movies & Mysteries Channel. Like Hannah Swensen, Joanne Fluke was born and raised in a small town in rural Minnesota, but now lives in Southern California. Please visit her online at www.JoanneFluke.com. Excerpt. © Reprinted by permission. All rights reserved. Christmas Cake Murder By JOANNE FLUKE KENSINGTON PUBLISHING CORP. Copyright © 2018 H.L. Swensen, Inc.All rights reserved.ISBN: 978-1-61773-232-4 CHAPTER 1 Hannah Comes Home From College Hannah Swensen took her mother's potholders off the hook by the stove and removed a sheet of cookies from the oven. Since her mother only had a single oven, Hannah set the cookie sheet on a cold stovetop burner to let the cookies cool for a minute or two. Then she used a metal spatula to take them off the cookie sheet and move them to the wire rack she'd set on the counter. The familiar scent of the cookies cooling brought tears to Hannah's eyes. These had been her father's favorite cookies. She brushed the tears that threatened to fall away with the back of her hand and sighed. Lars Swensen's funeral had taken place three weeks ago, and Hannah was worried about her mother. Delores was upstairs in the bedroom she'd shared with her husband and she was napping again. She'd taken a lengthy nap every day since the funeral and hadn't come downstairs until Hannah had called her for dinner. Even though Hannah had made some of her mother's favorite foods and Delores had complimented her on her wonderfully tasty meals, she hadn't eaten more than a few small bites. And when Hannah had dashed upstairs to straighten the bed after her mother's lengthy afternoon naps, she'd found her pillow wet with tears. Delores was crying in private, unable or unwilling to share her feelings with anyone. She had cut off all efforts her friends had made to see her by claiming that she was too tired to visit with them. Of course Hannah had discussed this worrisome situation with her sisters, and all three of them had attempted to pull their mother out of her self-imposed isolation. Hannah's youngest sister, Michelle, was still in high school, and she had tried to engage their mother's help in learning her lines for the lead she'd landed in the junior play. Michelle had even talked about cheerleading tryouts and how she hoped she'd get a spot on the cheerleading team, but Delores just didn't seem interested in her youngest daughter's high school life. Andrea, Hannah's middle sister, was married to Bill Todd, a deputy sheriff with the Winnetka County Sheriff's Department. They had purchased a house only blocks from Delores, and Andrea was expecting her first baby. She had attempted to engage their mother's interest by inviting Delores to help her decorate the baby's room, an invitation that normally would have delighted their mother. But instead of jumping at the opportunity to help by doing something she loved, Delores had claimed that she was simply too exhausted to help Andrea. All three Swensen sisters had tried every way that they could think of to get their mother into some activity that would get her involved in small-town life again, but everything they'd tried had failed. Hannah looked down at the cookies she'd baked. They were almost cool enough to eat and for one brief moment, she considered taking some up to her mother for an afternoon treat. Then she'd discarded that notion, fearful that the sight of her father's favorite cookies might remind Delores of Lars. Hannah gave a weary sigh as she realized that all three Swensen sisters were walking on eggshells around their mother, afraid that anything they tried might make things even worse. They knew that they had to do something to help their mother, but they were fresh out of ideas. The doorbell rang, pulling Hannah away from the dilemma, and she hurried to answer the door. It was snowing again, a regular occurrence in Minnesota winters, and the temperature outside was well below zero. Hannah pulled the door open and began to smile when she saw Grandma Knudson, the unofficial leader of the Lake Eden Holy Cross Redeemer Lutheran Church. She was the current pastor's grandmother and everyone in Lake Eden called her "Grandma" as a term of affection and respect. Standing next to Grandma Knudson was another one of her mother's friends, Annie Winters. Annie was the current head of the Lake Eden Children's Home, an orphanage situated just outside of town in a large, rambling brick mansion. "Hello, Hannah. How are you?" Grandma Knudson greeted her. "I'm okay," Hannah answered, giving her a smile before she turned to Annie. "Hi, Annie." "Hello, Hannah. We came to call on your mother." "Please come in," Hannah said, opening the door a little wider. Perhaps Grandma Knudson and Annie would know what to do to help Delores. Grandma Knudson always gave everyone wise advice, and Annie had her doctorate in psychology. "Would you like tea?" Hannah asked them, leading the way to the living room. "That would be lovely, Hannah," Annie answered. "Will your mother join us?" Hannah shook her head. "I'm afraid not. Mother is napping upstairs." "Again?" Grandma Knudson asked, looking more than a little distressed. "I've been here four times and it's the same story." "Yes," Hannah admitted. "She's been taking long naps every afternoon." Annie and Grandma Knudson exchanged glances and then Annie spoke. "You look troubled, Hannah. Tell us why and perhaps we can help." Hannah took a deep breath and blurted out her worries. "It's Mother. Andrea and Michelle and I have done everything we can think of to coax her out of her bedroom, but she still spends more time in there with the door closed than she does in the rest of the house. And when I go up to straighten the bed, her pillow is wet with tears. We're afraid that she's going to withdraw from life completely and we don't know what to do about it!" Grandma Knudson gave a sad little smile. "It's a common reaction, Hannah," she said. "Some wives just don't want to go on with their lives when their husbands die." She turned to Annie. "Isn't that right, Annie?" "Yes, and sometimes husbands feel the same way when their wives die," Annie added. "They think that getting involved in life again is a betrayal in some way." "That's it exactly!" Hannah confirmed, feeling slightly relieved just telling them about it. "What can we do to convince Mother to start living her life again?" "We have to come up with a project that only Delores can accomplish, a project that she can't refuse to accept," Grandma Knudson told her. "That makes sense, but ..." Hannah paused and wiped away a tear with the back of her hand. "Andrea and Michelle and I have tried everything we could think of, but ... nothing has worked." "Did you try things that your mother would enjoy doing?" "Yes. Michelle was chosen for the lead in the junior play and she asked Mother to help her learn her lines. I know that, normally, Mother would have loved to do that, but she claimed that she was too tired to help Michelle." "That's because she would have enjoyed helping Michelle," Annie explained. "And she didn't want to enjoy anything without your father. What did Andrea try?" "Andrea asked her to help decorate the baby's room. And you know how Mother loves to decorate." "Of course she does." Grandma Knudson gave a little smile. "And your mother claimed that she was too tired to help Andrea?" "Yes, that's exactly what she said." "And what did you do, Hannah?" Annie asked her. "I made all of Mother's favorite meals for dinner, but she just pushed the food around on her plate and said she just wasn't hungry. And when I asked her if she'd go antiquing with me to find some unusual Christmas gifts, she told me that she wasn't interested in antiquing anymore." "All right then," Annie said. "Grandma Knudson and I discussed the problem, Hannah, and we think we have a solution for you and your sisters." "What is it?" Hannah leaned forward, eager to hear what two of the women she respected most in Lake Eden wanted them to try. "We came up with a project that your mother won't really want to do, but one that she'll feel guilty about refusing," Annie explained. "Delores won't want to help us, but she's going to feel obligated." Hannah thought about that for a moment and then she gave a little nod. "Yes, I can see how that could work. And you have a project like that?" "Yes," Grandma Knudson said. "We think we have the perfect project. You know Dr. Kalick's niece, don't you?" Hannah began to smile. "Of course I know Essie. She was married to Alton Granger, the owner of the Albion Hotel. I used to go to there for Essie's story-time on Saturday afternoons, and so did Andrea and Michelle. Essie's story-time was really popular in Lake Eden." "So popular that they bussed in all the kids from the Children's Home," Annie added. "Everyone loved to hear Essie's stories, and it gave every mother in town a break for a couple of hours on Saturday afternoons." "That's right." Hannah began to smile. "And I think I see exactly where you're going. Mother used to say that everyone owed Essie a debt of gratitude for telling those wonderful stories and entertaining all the children in Lake Eden. Mother used to drop us off there and go to yard sales and farm auctions." "Perfect!" Grandma Knudson declared. "I think our idea is going to work, Hannah. We went to see Essie at the hospital last week." "At the hospital?" Hannah felt a stab of fear. "Is Essie all right?" "Not really," Annie responded. "We had a long talk with Doc Knight, and he says that Essie can't live alone in those two rooms at the hotel any longer. He said that she wasn't eating right and the flight of stairs to her rooms is simply too much for her to handle. She doesn't have running water, you know, and Essie has to go up and down the stairs to use the bathroom at the café." "But the café closes at nine at night!" "That's why Rose gave Essie a key. She can get in if she needs to." "But you said that Essie can't handle the stairs any longer." "That's right," Annie agreed. "She's fallen a few times, and the last fall was the worst. She was planning to go to your father's funeral, but she fell halfway down the stairs and broke her hip." Hannah felt tears come to her eyes again. "That's awful! What can I do to help her?" Grandma Knudson smiled. "That's exactly the reaction I hope your mother will have when we tell her about Essie. Doc Knight has her in the hospice ward at the hospital." "You mean ... Essie's dying?" "No," Annie was quick to correct her. "Essie's not terminal, but she can't go back to living alone, especially with the stairs and the fact that she doesn't have electricity or running water. It's going to take her a couple of months to heal, and that's why he's keeping her in the hospice ward." "I understand, but what, exactly, do you think Mother could do for Essie?" "She can make Essie very happy," Grandma Knudson said. "You told me that Delores feels she owes Essie a debt of gratitude for inviting you girls to her story- time. That's why we think we know the perfect way for your mother to pay Essie back." "How can she do that?" "We'll tell both of you when your mother gets down here," Annie said. "Go get her, Hannah. Tell her she's got to come downstairs, that we need her help and we won't take no for an answer." "I would ... but ..." Hannah stopped and gave a little sigh. "She'll just say she's too tired." "Then we'll go up and get her," Grandma Knudson declared, springing up from her chair. "Go put on the tea, Hannah. Annie and I will have your mother down here in less than five minutes." Hannah watched the two women climb the stairs to get her mother. If anyone could get Delores out of her bedroom, it would be Annie and Grandma Knudson. She watched them until they'd reached the top of the stairs and then she made a beeline for the kitchen to heat the water for tea. CHAPTER 2 Hannah was setting out the tea tray and a platter of cookies when she saw her mother coming down the stairs with Grandma Knudson and Annie. It had been five minutes since she'd heard them knocking on her mother's bedroom door and here was Delores, walking down the stairs with them. Delores smiled when she saw the tea tray on the living room coffee table. "Oh, good!" she said to Hannah. "I'm so glad you made tea, dear. Do you happen to have any cookies that we can have with it?" "I have Cocoa-Crunch Cookies," Hannah responded, lifting the napkin she'd placed over the platter of cookies. "Perfect!" Delores turned to Grandma Knudson and Annie. "Lars used to say that they were like little bites of heaven. He loved those cookies and so do I." Hannah began to smile. After three weeks of picking at whatever Hannah had made for her, Delores was finally enthusiastic about eating. This definitely reinforced her belief that Grandma Knudson and Annie were miracle workers. Grandma Knudson picked up the cookie platter and passed it to Delores. "Have one, dear." "Thank you," Delores said politely, selecting a cookie and taking a bite almost immediately. "These are wonderful cookies." Hannah felt like turning cartwheels on the living room rug, and if she'd been more athletic, she might very well have been attempting it. "Thank you, Mother," she said as she filled the cups and passed the tea. "As I mentioned upstairs, Annie was the one who found Essie," Grandma Knudson said, turned to Annie. "Tell Delores about it, Annie." Annie drew a deep breath and Hannah could tell that the memory still upset her. "Essie and I had dinner every Sunday at the Children's Home. Essie always met me at the café and that night, she was late. I sat there for a while, waiting for her, but then I began to worry that she was sick, or she'd forgotten, or ... worse." "I had a key to the hotel." Annie stopped speaking and cleared her throat. "I used it and opened the door. And there was Essie at the foot of the stairs, just lying there and not moving." "So Annie called the paramedics," Grandma Knudson reached out to pat Annie's hand continued with the account. "They were there in less than fifteen minutes and they took Essie's vital signs, loaded her onto a stretcher, and took her to the hospital." Annie nodded. "I followed them and when we got there, Doc Knight told me that Essie had broken her hip. He took her into surgery immediately and I waited until he came back to say that she was going to be all right." "That must have been awful for you!" Delores said. "It was ... especially when she wasn't moving and I couldn't tell if she was breathing or not." Annie stopped again to take a sip of her tea. "I'm just so glad I was there that evening. I don't even want to think about what would have happened if it hadn't been our night to have dinner. Essie has been almost like a mother to us at the Children's Home. And she's like a grandmother to the children now." "Annie grew up at the Children's Home," Grandma Knudson explained. "Yes, and Essie was a volunteer. Then, after she married Alton and moved into the hotel, she started her Saturday story-time. She invited me and two of my best friends to come to the hotel after school every day. She always fixed us an after- school snack, and we sat at a booth in the Red Velvet Lounge." Annie stopped to smile at the memory. "You have no idea how special we felt, being in a grown-up place like that! Essie helped us with our homework and then Alton would give us a ride back to the Children's Home. It's a good place, Delores, and I'd like to think that, because of my background, I was able to make it into an even better environment for the children." "You've done that, Annie. No question about it," Grandma Knudson said. "Thank you. The point of all this is that I loved to take Essie out to the Home. Having her there was a chance for me to make sure she had a good breakfast, lunch, and dinner." "That was kind of you, Annie," Delores responded. "Perhaps, but it was also self-serving. Essie was wonderful with the children. They called her Grandma and they all looked forward to seeing her." "It's so sad that Essie didn't have any children of her own," Delores said. "That's not the saddest thing," Grandma Knudson told her. "Doc Knight says that Essie won't be able to go back to her home at the hotel again. I know that almost everybody in Lake Eden would be happy to help Essie out, but you do know how proud she is, don't you?" Delores nodded. "Yes, she's never accepted help from anyone. Lars found out that there was no running water or electricity in those two rooms she had on the second floor, so he found her a battery-operated electric blanket." "How nice!" Annie commented. "Yes, but Essie insisted on paying him for it. He tried to give it to her, but she wouldn't have it. He ended up telling her that it was a sample from the company and all she had to do was pay for the shipping and keep a record of any problems she had with it." "Oh, that was really clever!" Annie exclaimed. "Thank you. It was my idea," Delores beamed, and Hannah realized that she hadn't seen her mother look happy in weeks. "Just a little thing like that made both of us feel good. It's so rewarding to help someone you like." "Exactly!" Grandma Knudson agreed. "That's why we came here today, Delores." "What can I do?" (Continues...) Excerpted from Christmas Cake Murder by JOANNE FLUKE . Copyright © 2018 H.L. Swensen, Inc.. Excerpted by permission of KENSINGTON PUBLISHING CORP.. All rights reserved. No part of this excerpt may be reproduced or reprinted without permission in writing from the publisher.Excerpts are provided by Dial-A-Book Inc. solely for the personal use of visitors to this web site. Read more

Features & Highlights

  • It’s Christmas many years ago, and topping young Hannah Swensen’s wish list is becoming the go-to baker in Lake Eden, Minnesota. But as Hannah finds out, revisiting holiday memories can be murder . . .
  • With her dream of opening The Cookie Jar taking shape, Hannah’s life matches the hectic December hustle and bustle in Lake Eden—especially when she agrees to help recreate a spectacular Christmas Ball from the past in honor of Essie Granger, an elderly local in hospice care. But instead of poring over decadent dessert recipes for the merry festivities, she instantly becomes enthralled by Essie’s old notebooks and the tale of a woman escaping danger on the streets of New York. Hannah’s surprised by Essie’s secret talent for penning crime fiction. She’s even more surprised when the story turns real. As Hannah prepares to run a bakery and move out of her mother’s house, it’ll be a true miracle if she can prevent another Yuletide disaster by solving a mystery as dense as a Christmas fruitcake . . .

Customer Reviews

Rating Breakdown

★★★★★
30%
(1K)
★★★★
25%
(852)
★★★
15%
(511)
★★
7%
(239)
23%
(784)

Most Helpful Reviews

✓ Verified Purchase

Finished With Hannah Books

Ok, I tried. I really, truly did....I have faithfully read every single one of the Hannah Swenson mysteries. This current one is just a sad little prequel to a series I used to love, until the author took it completely off the rails.

Yes, I would get annoyed with the interactions between Hannah and her intrusive, domineering family, Hannah's vacillation between Mike & Norman, Dolores's constant use of the word 'dear,' the endless descriptions of baking, and the salmon-flavored, fish-shaped kitty treats.

And like many readers I was extremely distressed over the turn the books took when Hannah suddenly married Ross. But I have faithfully forged on anyway, and just recently purchased the newest book. I kid you not, I literally had to go back about six books and speed read through them to try to refresh my memory about what all has taken place. Everything is just so disjointed and out of order that it took me about two hours to sort them all out: when did Hannah first see Ross again? When did they fall in love? When were they married and why was Hannah covered in trash? Will she ever remember she owns a cell phone and remember how to use it? Will her friends and family stop eating Hannah's profits at the Cookie Jar, and expecting her to make them dinner on three hours of sleep?? What did she tell Norman and Mike about Ross?
Did they have a honeymoon and if so was her family on it with them?? When did Ross leave and why? Did he and Hannah ever spend more than two days together after the honeymoon? How many more varieties of whippersnapper cookies are Andrea and Hannah going to create?
Where is Ross now and is Hannah even married?
I think I could probably continue to handle even all of that, but while reading through Banana Cream Pie, the conversation between Ross and Hannah regarding whether her pie was present at the murder finally tipped me over the edge. A woman has been brutally murdered and they are discussing in excruciating detail whether her pie was on the scene?? I am sorry Ms. Fluke, but I am truly finished. I worked in mental health for many years and we used to say that if someone made you start feeling crazy, they probably were. That is how these books have started to make me feel. My head is spinning, and I am, finally, finished.
144 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

what happened to this series?

I'm back again with another review in this series. I know, I can't believe it either. The description of this book had me thinking it would go back to the fun stories at the beginning of the series but I was wrong.

This book does take place when Hannah has just left college (because of drama over a man!) and is now living with her mother Delores who is recently widowed after the death of Hannah's father. In the beginning of the book Delores is much more interested in what she's going to wear and eat rather than the fact that her husband just died.

I'm so very sick of the formal tones in these books. Who talks like this? Every sentence that has Delores addressing Hannah includes the word dear. "All right, dear, but..." "Yes of course dear" and from Hannah to her mother Delores: "All right, Mother..." "Don't worry, Mother" "Of course I will, Mother"
Not to mention Hannah having to remind her Mother that she was in the middle of completing her doctorate in English. Delores didn't know this?

Here's an exchange with Hannah and her younger sister Michelle:
"Tell us about it, "Michelle urged, and Hannah gave her an approving look. Michelle had anticipated the question that she would have asked" Good girl Michelle, you get a cookie!

There is some more dialogue where Hannah explains the crackers on a cheese plate to her mother Delores. Ritz crackers, stone ground wheat crackers, carr's water biscuits. Come on. Then Michelle's friend Lisa pipes up with this zinger "The napkins are paper towels from the roll in the kitchen that I folded into quarters and that's because I couldn't find any cocktail napkins" How very dare you Delores to have people over for a cheese plate and not have cocktail napkins! For shame.

Another thing I'm sick of are the disparaging remarks by the author (or authors as it would seem) about Hannah's red hair and body image. In this book it actually states "wonder of wonders, Bertie at the Cut 'n Curl had actually managed to tame her curly red hair into some semblance of normalcy" I'll have you know ma'm that red hair is not abnormal, and neither is curly hair. There are also some remarks about Hannah having a huge butt and hips and being relieved that she could zipper a tacky dress that Delores wanted to buy her. Not to mention all the remarks from Delores herself about how she's gaining weight from eating too many baked goods. But then we have a scene were Delores takes multiple helpings of dinner, has four kinds of pies or cakes, ice cream, bon bons/truffles, and coffee with whipped cream or something and is surprised she is gaining weight. Poor Delores.

Here is the biggest problem with this book though. The "murder" doesn't actually occur until more than 80% of the way through the book. After that it is obvious what happened but of course our genius sleuth Hannah just can't seem to figure it out on her own. I will say when she DOES figure it out the tackiness levels rise as Hannah shares some very personal information with someone that she has no business sharing.

There is a story within a story contained in this book too which Hannah reads aloud (for some reason) to her captivated audience consisting of Delores, Michelle, and Michelle's friend Lisa who apparently never leaves the Swensen house. The little story is laughably bad and predictable. Not to mention the fact that Hannah basically stole it from another character's bedside while that character is in the hospital and just decides to read it to everyone.

The recipes in these books are getting worse and worse as well. Firstly, who wants to bake 8-10 dozen cookies at a time? Secondly, most of the desserts use some kind of Sandra Lee-esque convenience food like cake mix for a cake "recipe", cool whip for frosting, pushing hersheys kisses into cookies for "flair" I mean really. At least give us some interesting baked goods recipes if nothing else.

In short: skip this unless you need a good laugh.

Note: I actually had to stop reading this partway through because the trashy food descriptions were making me physically ill.
20 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Unbelievably poor murder mystery!

Unbelievably poor murder mystery!
Actually rates zero stars.
A 270 page book and the shooting, no murder, does not take place until page 234. Then there is no solving of the since the shooter is caught immediately. All worthless pages of preparing for a party where the shooting takes place. No plot. Look elsewhere for a good read.
9 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Just Ok

Christmas Cake Murder by Joanne Fluke
9/25

I will always read Joanna Fluke, there I have said it and I no longer feel guilty. I have read and reviewed all of the books and the past couple have been the brunt of some critical reviews. Christmas Cake Murder falls into the “let’s say the same set of facts over and over and over” it makes me wonder if for this short novel (novella) Joanne was told it has to be over 200 pages and she went back through and added in the same points so that the reader would not forget that Essie is in the hospice wing of the hospital but only because she has a broken hip, is not terminal but just cannot climb the flight of steps to the two rooms she occupies in the hotel. This is not a spoiler and will also not be the last time you hear about this.
The recipes in this one like all of the others look super easy and delicious. Many made my mouth water. A fun easy read in all, but I wish there was more Murder and intrigue.

I received an ARC from the publisher and chose to write a fair and honest review.
8 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Done With This Series!

First off, thanks to Kensington and NetGalley for approving me to read this one. That said, I really hate the fact that this book was just BAD! I was a big fan of the Hannah Swensen books for many years. I have several recipes that are used often at my house that came from these books. The last book in the series that I read was Red Velvet Cupcake Murder. It finally got on my last nerve with the dreaded "triangle". When I saw that this one was a "prequel" I had hopes that it would be like the earlier books. I was wrong. The writing style is not like I remember for this series. And to say the dialogue was "stilted" is a kindness. I suppose you could say there was a murder in this one, but not like you'd think. There are a couple of recipes in this one that I will probably try, which is why I'm rating this 2-stars. I think this one might be an effort on Ms. Fluke's part to make up to her readers for what has apparently been going on in the last few books regarding Ross. Again, I loved this series for the longest time and do so wish it would return to its glory days. If you are a fan, and have stuck with the series past Red Velvet Cupcake, which is where I got off the train, you will most definitely want to read this one and I do hope you like it.
6 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

I'm so glad I didn't spend money on this

A Christmas murder mystery with recipes?! What's not to love about that?!
Good lord this book was awful. I'm happy at least I merely borrowed it from my local library rather than spend actual money on this pile of crap. I don't know how this is book #20 in a series. The dialogue was wooden, the story was so bland and yet saccharine at the same time. The mini story within the story was actually better written and had a far more interesting plot but I for sure skimmed through the main bulk of the book just to read the 29 pages of mini story. I do not need to read 3 pages about setting the table for dinner, nor chunks of time about reading lamps, gas fire places or other home decor. Even the recipes weren't enough for me to care about.
The whole tone of the book felt like narrator was talking down to her audience, not using big words, explaining every little relationship several times, discussing why everyone was laughing ("partially in relief that Delores had finally returned to the person they knew and loved and partially because the comment she'd made was funny" ::rolls eyes::).

Clearly Ms Fluke has an audience that laps up the 'cosy' series, but to me this was a hugely disappointing start to my reading list for the year and I'll be giving her a big fat F.
5 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Disappointed

The most recent books have not lived up to the first books. This one is particularly disappointing; I’m not certain I will purchase future Hannah Swensen mysteries.
4 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Disapointment

Waited a long time for this "prequel" to come out. It was dreadful. Fortunately, it was also really short, so I didn't have to suffer for too long
3 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Will the real Joanne Fluke please come back?

From the year 2000 (Chocolate Chip Cookie Murder) until 2016 (Wedding Cake Murder), Hannah Swenson balanced relationships with two different men, Mike and Norman. While some reviewers grew tired of this, I found it to be a romantic tension that enhanced the series. Then, a "blast from the past" entered the scene, largely at the engineering of Hannah's mother; and in the twinkling of an eye he and Hannah were married. From this point on the series has gone downhill. The only mystery in Christmas Cake Murder is why I bothered to finish it.
Book number 22 (Raspberry Danish Murder) ended with a cliffhanger that needed to be resolved. But this book completely ignored the question (spoiler alert avoided). Instead it was an unnecessary prequel. If you had read the entire series, you were already familiar with Hannah's entry into the cookie business.
I noted in the copyright information that Joanne Fluke is now incorporated. This leads me to wonder if she is no longer writing, but the books are turned out on an assembly line basis.
Please, Ms Fluke, either go back to 2015 and make the stories interesting again, or admit that the series has run its course and bow out as gracefully as you can.
3 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Boring and lots of fact errors

Very disappointed in this book. The entire book was about the sisters and their mother eating cookies, lighting a fireplace, etc. -- literally, every page just had them eating cookies. The only interesting part was in the middle with the "other story", but that was also disjointed. Another reviewer highlighted all the factual errors (i.e., hospices are not in hospitals; orphanages no longer exist in the US as such; doctors don't allow the public (caters) to read medical records; -- and the list goes on. This was a waste of both time and money and does not pertain to the Hannah Swenson series other than telling people where she got the money for the bakery (SPOILER ALERT). You won't miss a thing by not reading this book. I don't know what the author was doing with this ridiculous book. I think maybe she had a deadline to produce another book and just threw this together in a day or so. I seriously doubt she spent more time than that on this particular book as all it talks about is eating cookies and lighting the fireplace. Again, very disappointed. I may try her next book -- #24 -- which I think picks up on the current timeframe of the series, but if it doesn't, I'm also done with this series. Joanne Fluke, what were you thinking??????
2 people found this helpful