By Fire, By Water
By Fire, By Water book cover

By Fire, By Water

Paperback – Bargain Price, May 18, 2010

Price
$43.68
Format
Paperback
Pages
284
Publisher
Other Press
Publication Date
Dimensions
5.65 x 0.87 x 8.41 inches
Weight
12.8 ounces

Description

From Publishers Weekly Kaplan, a screenwriter, sets his debut novel in 15-century Spain, amid the Inquisition, the attempt to unify the kingdoms of Spain under Christian rule, and the voyage of Christopher Columbus to what the seaman expects will be the Indies. The action centers on the historical figure of Luis de Santángel, chancellor to the king of Aragon and a converso, a Jewish convert to Christianity at a time when the Inquisition sought to repress judaizing. Santángel is friend and financier of Columbus, surviving parent of young Gabriel, and more curious than is prudent about his Jewish heritage. While he learns about Judaism in clandestine meetings, a parallel story unfolds, centering on Judith Migdal, a beautiful Jewish woman who learns to become a silversmith in Granada, located in the last part of Spain under Muslim rule. Santángel's attraction to Judith grows, even as the Inquisition closes in and the prospect of another world to the West tantalizes. Kaplan has done remarkable homework on the period and crafted a convincing and complex figure in Santángel in what is a naturally cinematic narrative and a fine debut. (May) Copyright © Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All rights reserved. “[A] remarkably learned and heartbreaking romantic novel…with a deft blend of straightforwardness and subtlety…Beautifully executed, highly recommended.” — The Minneapolis Star Tribune “Mitchell James Kaplan’s By Fire, By Water must take its place as one of the most important contemporary historical novels with a Jewish theme.” — Ha’aretz“By Fire, By Water is an exciting introduction to the political, social and theological issues of Spain in the late 15th century. Those already familiar with this period will enjoy fleshing out their knowledge with the sights, sounds and, above all, intense emotions of the era.” — Hadassah Magazine “A beautiful tapestry... Despite its epic sweep, By Fire, By Water is also an intimate portrait of a remarkable individual...”xa0—Tirdad Derakshani, Philadelphia Inquirer “ By Fire, By Water contains many well-crafted phrases and much interesting information, but its greatest merit is in demonstrating parallels between a notorious period in human history and disturbing developments in modern life.” — Philadelphia Quarterly “Kaplan, a screenwriter, sets his debut novel in 15-century Spain, amid the Inquisition, the attempt to unify the kingdoms of Spain under Christian rule, and the voyage of Christopher Columbus to what the seaman expects will be the Indies. The action centers on the historical figure of Luis de Santángel, chancellor to the king of Aragon and a converso, a Jewish convert to Christianity at a time when the Inquisition sought to repress ‘judaizing’….Kaplan has done remarkable homework on the period and crafted a convincing and complex figure in Santángel in what is a naturally cinematic narrative and a fine debut.” — Publishers Weekly “Debut novelist Kaplan depicts a turbulent period in 15th-century Spain, focusing on the story of Aragon’s royal chancellor… Deftly moves through a complex web of personal relationships, religious zeal and political fervor.” — Kirkus Reviews "Beautifully written, By Fire, By Water is a powerful story of religion, love and violence--timeless themes honed by Kaplan into an enthralling narrative that doesn't let up until the last sentence." —Simon Read, author of War of Words “Kaplan’s writing is exceptional, his intelligence and research on the subject superb.2010 seems to be the year for new and fabulous voices in the Historical Fiction world and Kaplan is no exception. I look forward to reading many more of his books in the future!” —Amy Bruno, Passages to the Past “This book was like no other book I have ever read.” —Heather Rieseck, The Maiden’s Court “Blending artistry with intense drama and violence, By Fire, By Water takes readers on a picturesque tour of the Iberian Peninsula of the mid-1400s….By Fire, By Water is a finely crafted novel, so well done that it would be hard to imagine how it could be made better. It’s rare to find historical fiction this intense and exquisite.” —Bookreporter.com“A must-read.” — Pittsburgh Jewish Chronicle “A grand novel that shows not only Kaplan's knack for storytelling, but also his eye for details and willingness to do extensive research.” — Pittsburgh Tribune-Review “Kaplan's greatest success is in his ability to portray the inner lives of his characters.” — Washington Jewish Week “This novel recreates a historical moment of vast and far-reaching changes as well as the complex personality of Santángel, the high government official who placed his hopes for redemption far beyond his society’s horizons.” — Reform Judaism Magazine Mitchell James Kaplan , a graduate of Yale, has lived and worked primarily in Paris and Los Angeles as a translator, screenwriter, and script consultant. Currently, he resides in Mt. Lebanon, Pennsylvania, with his wife and two children. This is his first novel. Excerpt. © Reprinted by permission. All rights reserved. “I’ve had time to think,” explained Santángel. “I’ve done a great deal of thinking.Praying. Remembering.” He glanced at the slate-gray sea. “I spent hours, callingup every detail.” He delicately ran his hand along the rim of her ear, down hercheek, under her jaw. “From the first words I heard you pronounce...”xa0xa0xa0She removed his hand from her face, but held his forearm. “What were they?”xa0xa0xa0“Allah alone conquers. The inscription on those beakers you made for thevizier.”xa0xa0xa0“Yes.” She nodded with a nostalgic smile. “Allah alone conquers. Even themost powerful of us, we have little control over our destiny.”xa0xa0xa0“Then our only choice is to embrace that destiny.”xa0xa0xa0“Embrace it? Look around, Chancellor. Look around.”Exiles all around them, some emaciated from long travels, many filthy, triedto board ships, pleaded with sailors, appealed to authorities. As he observed allthis despair, Luis de Santángel felt more powerless than ever. His mind reviewedhis years in the royal court—the perfidy of some, the loyalty of others, thesacrifices, the battles, the triumphs, the fears, the losses. For what good?xa0xa0xa0“No, Chancellor. Our only choice,” said Judith, “is not to embrace ourdestiny in this world, but to hope for a better world.” Her eyes glided to the galleon behind him.xa0xa0xa0“Then I shall accompany you into that world.” Read more

Features & Highlights

  • Recipient of the Independent Publishers Award for Historical Fiction (Gold Medal), the Foreword Book of the Year Award for Historical Fiction (Bronze Medal), and an honorable mention in the category of General Fiction for the Eric Hoffer Award.Luis de Santángel, chancellor to the court and longtime friend of the lusty King Ferdinand, has had enough of the Spanish Inquisition. As the power of Inquisitor General Tomás de Torquemada grows, so does the brutality of the Spanish church and the suspicion and paranoia it inspires. When a dear friend’s demise brings the violence close to home, Santángel is enraged and takes retribution into his own hands.  But he is from a family of
  • conversos
  • , and his Jewish heritage makes him an easy target. As Santángel witnesses the horrific persecution of his loved ones, he begins slowly to reconnect with the Jewish faith his family left behind. Feeding his curiosity about his past is his growing love for Judith Migdal, a clever and beautiful Jewish woman navigating the mounting tensions in Granada. While he struggles to decide what his reputation is worth and what he can sacrifice, one man offers him a chance he thought he’d lost…the chance to hope for a better world. Christopher Columbus has plans to discover a route to paradise, and only Luis de Santángel can help him.   Within the dramatic story lies a subtle, insightful examination of the crisis of faith at the heart of the Spanish Inquisition. Irresolvable conflict rages within the conversos in
  • By Fire, By Water
  • , torn between the religion they left behind and the conversion meant to ensure their safety. In this story of love, God, faith, and torture, fifteenth-century Spain comes to dazzling, engrossing life.

Customer Reviews

Rating Breakdown

★★★★★
30%
(63)
★★★★
25%
(53)
★★★
15%
(32)
★★
7%
(15)
23%
(48)

Most Helpful Reviews

✓ Verified Purchase

great historical fiction!

I ended up loving this book! By Fire, By Water, Mitchell James Kaplan's debut novel, had me interested from the start. It started right in with the suspense, and steadily kept my attention to the end. The characters' struggles were vividly depicted and realistic.

It's taken for granted that historical fiction takes facts and twists them to fit in with the plot line and drum up a little drama. I love how at the end of the book everything that was changed/unchanged is explained. The main body of the narrative was accurate, yet I like to see what has been speculated about and can't be known for certain if it is true or not.

The Spanish Inquisition was a horrible time to live through. No one knew who would accuse whom, who would be arrested and never seen again. The brutality and confusion of this time is particularly emphasized, and I like how the different experiences of just a few characters give a glimpse into what the common people possibly experienced.

By Fire, By Water is great for any historical fiction fan or those that, like me, are new to the genre. I immensely liked this novel and give it 5/5 stars!
5 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

By Fire, By Water

Review: Santangel is the chancellor to the court of Queen Isabella and King Ferdinand in a time when it is dangerous to be a converso, (convert from Judaism to Christianity specifically Catholicism) he is a third generation convert to Christianity through the Catholic church in a time when the Catholic Church still holds great sway in the population's everyday lives, homes, and personal convictions. Santangel must take desperate measures to try to protect those he holds most dear from the prying eyes of the new inquisition in Spain.

While researching the the truth about his past one of Santangel's intimate friend's learns the cost of being on the wrong side of religion in Catholic ruled Spain. Santangel mixes his family up in a plot that brings the head of the new inquisition to his door specifically Torquemada, who is a inquisitor investigating the murder of a high ranking official; this causes tragedies and inquiries to unfold that will change multiple families lives forever in numerous ways.

Judith a young Jewish woman living in Ferdinand and Isabella's kingdom find's the courage to help raise her nephew and take care of his grandfather, after tragedy strikes. Judith also learns how to do metal work and thus keeps the family business going in a time when women were expected to stay behind the scenes and shows remarkable courage in stepping forward in a country where there was prejudice against both her sex, and her religious beliefs. The twist and turns in her story alone could have made a book themselves.

Christopher Colon (Columbus would be the more well known name) is also interwoven throughout the story as a sailor and at one point asks the royals for a grant to go to the new world. He is also involved with some of the plotting / mapping that related to the Hebrew writing (on a map and scrolls) that was connected to Santangel's family being accused of heresy because of their converso background.

The entire novel fit together like a beautiful manuscript. I read it in a day, and could not put it down. I usually read books that have more female characters then male, however this book is easy to relate to, well put together and VERY easy to recommend. I love it.
3 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

time period is interesting but book fell flat

The topic of this book covers a very interesting time period, however I found this book to lack emotional depth or energy. I feel that it lacked proper character development. I found it difficult to understand what motivated Luis at all and I felt virtually no emotional connection to him. The best-portrayed character was Judith, there was depth to her depiction, however not enough to make up for the lack of depth elsewhere. Overall, the book fell flat for me.
2 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Who knew? I certainly didn't.

Who knew? I certainly didn't.
1 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

By Fire, By Water

Luis de Santángel is chancellor to King Fernando (Ferdinand) of Aragon but he is also a third generation Christian, converso, but when the Spanish Inquisition starts in full force it's not safe to have Jewish connections. At the same time Luis grows curious about his Jewish heritage and starts to see theologian in secret but soon catches the eyes of inquisitor and soon finds out that he or his family isn't safe.

We also hear the story of Judith, a Jewish silversmith, who catches Luis' eyes. Luis falls in love with her but is he willing to give up everything for her?

I'm not very familiar with Spanish Inquisition or Jewish religion and the little I know about Inquisition comes from reading Katherine of Aragon's childhood. It is not a pleasant subject giving the worst example of humanity but it's fascinating in a horrible way.

By Fire, By Water is certainly very thought provoking and well researched. While the books has lot of religious themes and has theological discussions it manages to not sound preachy.

It's not action packed but gives one man's journey while trying to find who he is and remaining true to himself.

The only minor problem I had was with the time. I wish it would have been stated better how much time had went on or mentioned on what year was going on.

What a great debut from Kaplan! I truly enjoyed this and couldn't put it down.Can't wait to read more from this author!
1 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Intelligent and well versed

Kaplan is an exquisite writer and for a first novel he surpassed my expectations. This book may be fiction but the story behind it is a vital and elemental part of history. It is a story that shows how dangerous ignorance can be combined with religious fanaticism. This is also part of my history as my paternal side of the family hails from Spain, mainly from Andalusia and Cataluña. I can't help but wonder how many of us in Latin America may be descendants of Jews or "conversos" those who adopted the new "faith" in order to save their own lives. This novel bears a terrific story with beautiful prose that is neither indulgent nor uses cheap sentimentality to get its point across. I hope this is the first of many novels by James Kaplan.
1 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Great Topic but I wanted to know more

I LOVED the idea for this book. A story about the inner workings of Spanish life at the time of the Inquisition, specifically concentrating on the Jewish experience. The author had definitely done his homework; however, although the author's index was vast he took many liberties with history as we know it. Also, his character development was weak. I wanted to know more about the characters. Often there were gaps and it was difficult to suspend belief. However, Mr. Kaplan's work is a quick read and shed's light on a subject that is not often added to historical fiction.