Autism's False Prophets: Bad Science, Risky Medicine, and the Search for a Cure
Autism's False Prophets: Bad Science, Risky Medicine, and the Search for a Cure book cover

Autism's False Prophets: Bad Science, Risky Medicine, and the Search for a Cure

Paperback – March 29, 2010

Price
$12.59
Format
Paperback
Pages
328
Publisher
Columbia University Press
Publication Date
ISBN-13
978-0231146371
Dimensions
6 x 0.7 x 8.9 inches
Weight
1 pounds

Description

Every child has a right to be vaccinated against deadly diseases. We started Every Child By Two to protect children from diseases. It didn't occur to me that I would also have to protect them from misinformation about life-saving vaccines. Paul A. Offit's book sets the facts straight. -- Rosalynn Carter, former first lady, cofounder of Every Child By Two Autism's False Prophets is a compelling story of heartbroken parents, understandably desperate for an explanation of autism, being taken in by false hopes unsupported by genuine science. This book goes to the heart of a question that affects every aspect of American culture and political life. Are public policies to be determined by evidence and reason or by emotions that, however intense they may be, have nothing to do with reality? -- Susan Jacoby, author of The Age of American Unreason A definitive analysis of a dangerous and unnecessary controversy that has put the lives of children at risk. Paul A. Offit shows how bad science can take hold of the public consciousness and lead to personal decisions that endanger the health of small children. Every parent who has doubts about the wisdom of vaccinating their kids should read this book. -- Peter C. Doherty, Ph.D., St. Jude's Children's Research Hospital and Nobel Laureate in Medicine for fundamental contributions in ImmunologyIn his latest book Paul A. Offit unfolds the story of autism, infectious diseases, and immunization that has captivated our attention for the last decade. His lively account explores the intersection of science, special interests, and personal courage. It is provocative reading for anyone whose life has been touched by the challenge of autism spectrum disorders. -- Susan K. Klein, MD, Ph.D., Case Western Reserve Hospital, and Rainbow Babies and Children's Hospital, Case Medical Center[A] thoughtful and readable study. ― Library Journal (starred review) Enlightening, highly readable and... timely. -- Rahul K. Parikh, M.D. ― Salon.com Arguably the most courageous and most knowledgeable scientist about vaccines in the United States. -- Robert Goldberg ― New York Post [Dr. Offit] has done a huge public service by exposing the tragic and dangerous place the anti-vaccine hysteria has taken us. -- Huntly Collins ― Philadelphia Inquirer An invaluable chronicle that relates some of the many ways in which the vulnerabilities of anxious parents have been exploited. -- Linda Seebach ― Wall Street Journal A good read and an important piece of work. -- Lisa Jo Rudy ― About.com More than a book about a disease, it is an ode to uncorrupted science and a cautionary tale that data alone is never enough. ― SEED magazine [Offit] provides important insight into the fatal flaws of the key arguments of vaccine alarmists. ― Buffalo News A very good read. -- Dom Giordano ― The Bulletin A sobering indictment. -- Isabelle Rapin, M.D. ― Neurology Today Highly recommended. ― Choice A fascinating read... Eloquently and clearly written. -- Stan L. Block, MD ― Infectious Diseases in Children A very helpful book for both medical personnel and parents. ― The New England Journal of Medicine The book is a fantastic read. I recommend it to all physicians and their patients and families. -- Brian Alverson, MD ― Archives of Pediatric & Adolescent Medicine This is a powerful book which should be read by all professionals working in the area ofmedicine. -- Michael Fitzgerald ― Social History of Medicine Paul A. Offit is one of the most respected scientists and clinicians in a field of vital importance to public health. -- Patricia M. Rodier ― BioScience [This] book doesn't just show that the anti-vaccine activists are wrong; it attempts to explain why, in our culture, they tend to win . -- Jason Fagone ― Philadelphia Magazine Detailed but easily readable... should be required reading for any parents who are considering denying vaccination to their children. ― Communication: The Magazine of the National Autistic Society Arguably the most detailed and thorough history available of the current anti-vaccine movement. -- Roy Richard Grinker ― Journal of Autism and Developmental Disorders [A] must-read... it will keep pediatricians and pediatric neurologists awake over the nightmarish possibilities of pseudoscience in the 21st century. -- Roger A. Brumback, M.D. ― Journal of Child Neurology The vast range of professionals who may be enriched, professionally, by the book's contents extends to: psychologists, psychiatrists, neurologists, neuroscientists, speech pathologists, pediatricians, primary care physicians, geneticists, virologists, immunologists, vaccine experts, nurses, infectious disease experts, internists, gastroenterologists, epidemiologists, public health professionals, special education teachers, bioethicists, biochemists, biologists, biostatisticians, endocrinologists, pharmacists, pharmacologists, pharmaceutical industry professionals, health policy makers, journalists, politicians, and trial lawyers. -- Leo Uzych ― Metapsychology Seeking to help readers realize the truth about Autism, Autism's False Prophets is a much need read, not to be missed. ― Midwest Book Review Paul Offit is Chief of the Division of Infectious Diseases at the Children's Hospital of Philadelphia and Professor of Pediatrics at the University of Pennsylvania School of Medicine. He holds a BS in Psychology from Tufts University (1973) and an MD from University of Maryland School of Medicine (1977). He is the author of Autism's False Prophets (CUP 2008) and, most recently, Pandora's Lab (Nat Geo 2017).

Features & Highlights

  • A London researcher was the first to assert that the combination measles-mumps-rubella vaccine known as MMR caused autism in children. Following this "discovery," a handful of parents declared that a mercury-containing preservative in several vaccines was responsible for the disease. If mercury caused autism, they reasoned, eliminating it from a child's system should treat the disorder. Consequently, a number of untested alternative therapies arose, and, most tragically, in one such treatment, a doctor injected a five-year-old autistic boy with a chemical in an effort to cleanse him of mercury, which stopped his heart instead. Children with autism have been placed on stringent diets, subjected to high-temperature saunas, bathed in magnetic clay, asked to swallow digestive enzymes and activated charcoal, and injected with various combinations of vitamins, minerals, and acids. Instead of helping, these therapies can hurt those who are most vulnerable, and particularly in the case of autism, they undermine childhood vaccination programs that have saved millions of lives. An overwhelming body of scientific evidence clearly shows that childhood vaccines are safe and does not cause autism. Yet widespread fear of vaccines on the part of parents persists. In this book, Paul A. Offit, a national expert on vaccines, challenges the modern-day false prophets who have so egregiously misled the public and exposes the opportunism of the lawyers, journalists, celebrities, and politicians who support them. Offit recounts the history of autism research and the exploitation of this tragic condition by advocates and zealots. He considers the manipulation of science in the popular media and the courtroom, and he explores why society is susceptible to the bad science and risky therapies put forward by many antivaccination activists.

Customer Reviews

Rating Breakdown

★★★★★
60%
(181)
★★★★
25%
(75)
★★★
15%
(45)
★★
7%
(21)
-7%
(-21)

Most Helpful Reviews

✓ Verified Purchase

An outstanding defense of real science (UPDATE: 5->2.5 stars)

I read this after the "Panic Virus" (2011), which recounts the history of the autism-vaccine "wars". Although "Panic" provides more history and social context, I still wondered if vaccines could be a factor in a small subset of autism cases. AFP removed those lingering doubts (at least for me) because it provides more medical details and explains the power of large epidemiological studies to detect even rare side-effects (autism can not be considered a rare condition anymore).

AFP also has several chapters on the media's role in creating the vaccine scare. The basic message is that the media/politicians and general public are scientifically illiterate. However, it's important to note that the MMR (and then thimerosal-mercury) link could have been true when it was first proposed back in the late 1990s- no one really knew at the time. Thankfully,the data was available (esp. in countries like Denmark that have extensive medical records) to quickly prove that the hypothesis was wrong. Furthermore, thimerosal was removed from vaccines- starting in Europe first- and yet, autism rates continued to climb.

The key difference with other science "wars" is that sufficient data was available to resolve the debate. In the case of AGW (where crude climate models and proxies are the bane of climate science) and in particle physics where there's zero experimental evidence in favor of string theory and the multiverse, but also insufficient data to reject those theories, the debate continues and likely will for the foreseeable future. Science works and can be trusted- but only when the evidence is there to back it up.

UPDATE (04-05-2020): I'm taking off 2.5 stars because I now realize how one-sided this book is after reading Handley's "How to End the Autism Epidemic" (2018). I recommend the Handley book for the other side of the story, which I found much more compelling.
10 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Wakefield Disgraced

Dr Andrew Wakefield, who is the center of this controversy (and is not the author of this book)was recently struck from the UKs Medical Register in May 2010. His research provided most of the so called evidence for vaccines as a cause for autism Why was his research retracted and he punished by the British medical system?: Performing research without IRB approval, performing unnecessary procedures, and four counts of dishonesty and 12 involving the abuse of developmentally-challenged children. The panel ruled that Wakefield had "failed in his duties as a responsible consultant", acted against the interests of his patients, and acted "dishonestly and irresponsibly" in his controversial research. On February 2, 2010, The Lancet retracted his 1998 publication, noting elements of the manuscript had been falsified.

Case closed.
9 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Must Read!

This book is a must read in my opinion. I want to purchase copies for everyone I know, even if they don't know anyone with Autism.

Having a child with Autism I get very tired of having people constantly insist that it was caused by vaccines or mercury. It is often one of the first questions people will as us. "Do you think his autism was caused by immunizations?" We have never felt that way about him and believe that he doesn't need to be cured but loved allowed to grow up without feeling like people think he is a second class citizen. He shows us a beautiful world we wouldn't normally get to see and it's very refreshing to finally read something that supports our feelings and research we have done about the vaccine/autism discussion. Thank you so much Dr. Offit and all those you mentioned in the book that continue to try and spread the facts. I hope and pray that money, time and media attention can be spent on other ways to help those with Autism!
9 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

One Star

He does not seem objective.
8 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Oh how funny that he thinks babies are born with a vaccine ...

Oh how funny that he thinks babies are born with a vaccine deficiency. Science is never settled. Please remember that!!
7 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

A book of courage which names names

I read this book after touring the Marcus Autism Center in Atlanta, a National Center of Autism. You will not read this book and emerge with a good feeling about human nature, as it exposes those who dupe concerned parents for the sake of their own glory or for pure profit. The need on the part of parents to blame someone, anyone, for their child's condition, has led many of them to abandon all reason. We should be teaching the scientific method, the nature of proof and evidence, and the separation of emotion from fact to every first grader. This book isn't about autism so much as its about seeking too-simple solutions for problems while looking through a haze of emotion, and how very destructive to the innocent that mindset can be.
6 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Very dissatisfied with what I learned!

This review has been edited and updated for a better review:

My fiance was suggested to read this through his psychology class at a local university. I was a public health student at the time and needed something to read -- perfect!

I had an understanding that we need vaccines, but not an understanding of the history behind WHY people believed there was an autism-vaccine link. When I finished reading this book, I was appalled by a few things, not only including junk science and mainly fraud.

This book goes into detail about the junk science (chelation is especially notable) and the reasons for Wakefield producing a fake 'study.' There's quite a bit of history included in the book and it makes me sad to read this, as well as angry. How could people lead parents on like this?
6 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

A refreshing perspective on an old topic

I am a health care professional who works extensively with autistic children, I have had to deal with the sad fall out of people struggling with these issues, Dr. Offit presents the evidence and the facts that the media has chosen not to make public, because it takes the controversy out of the topic. I feel he does a very good job of explaining where these myths came from, and debunking them in an easy to understand way. It is an easy read, I recommend it for any one wanting to understand the controversies surrounding Autism.
6 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Great Way to See Things from the MEDICAL Side

Dr. Paul Offit gives a great overview of the controversies surrounding thimerosal and the MMR vaccine. He thoroughly discredits the arguments of the other side in a scientific, methodical manner. THIS is the book parents need to be reading: a science-based book from a QUALIFIED medical professional.
Parents, if you want to know more about this, read this book or one like it. If this book isn't for you, there is a lot of other information out there, but be careful. Just because someone says they have a Ph.D. does not mean they know anything about medicine (you can have a Ph.D. in many things) and just because someone has a child with autism does not make them an expert on its cause (in fact, no one knows the cause of autism).
Also, for those of you who think Offit is doing this to pad his pockets, the profits from this book are going towards autism research. He's not out to trick you, he wants you to know the truth.
6 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Critical Insight and Knowledge

A wonderful, enlightening book on an increasingly critical subject. Paul Offit is a great writer and knows the subject of medicine and pseudoscience inside and out. I gave this book to several vaccine-skeptical relatives and hope it will enlighten them on the issue.
4 people found this helpful