And After the Fire: A Novel
And After the Fire: A Novel book cover

And After the Fire: A Novel

Hardcover – Deckle Edge, May 3, 2016

Price
$14.50
Format
Hardcover
Pages
464
Publisher
Harper
Publication Date
ISBN-13
978-0062428516
Dimensions
6 x 1.41 x 9 inches
Weight
1.45 pounds

Description

From Publishers Weekly In Belfer's compelling third novel, an American soldier in 1945 Germany unknowingly purloins a controversial unpublished cantata by the great Johann Sebastian Bach, and it ends up in the hands of the soldier's niece, Susanna Kessler, upon his death. The journey of this manuscript, with lyrics based on one of Martin Luther's anti-Jewish screeds, from Sara Itzig Levyâx80x94a Jewish student of Bach's eldest son and the real-life budding doyenne of Berlin's upper echelonsâx80x94to America is interspersed with Susanna's own inner trajectory to finding normalcy and love in her life after being raped. The author's strengths lie in the historical passages, starting with the 1780s when Sara receives the cantata as a young woman, and continuing through her rise in society, her subsequent marriage, and her confidential gift of the manuscript to her beloved niece's daughter, Fanny (sister to Felix Mendelssohn). Fanny leaves it in a piano bench, where it's discovered by Susanna's uncle. Belfer's (A Fierce Radiance) comprehensive research brings depth and veracity to the novel, intertwining real-life figures and events from the past with the modern-day story and detailing the strong currents of anti-Semitism that have existed in Germany for centuries. The people in Susanna's life, as well as the contemporary situations Belfer portrays, are not as strongly drawn, and the passages about romance and sexual attraction in both the modern and historic realms never quite work. Nevertheless, this is an immersive, page-turning story emboldened by historical fact and a rich imagination. (May)\n “[Belfer’s] virtuoso novel…epitomizes Faulkner’s epigram that the past is never dead—or even past. . . . The novel swells with life’s great themes—love and death, family and faith —and the insistent, dark music of loss.” — USA Today , **** “In Belfer’s hands, fictitious characters blend uncannily with historical ones.” — The New Yorker “Finely written historical fiction layered with richly detailed characters and moral complexity.” — Jane Ciabattari, BBC “[A] compelling blend of fact and fiction.… Based on impressive research, this remarkable novel spans centuries and continents, touching finally on the Holocaust and serving as a paean to Bach’s music.” — Booklist (starred review) “A different species of suspense tale…. Evocative, deeply researched…. Manage[s] to dazzle while delving into dark places.” — Maureen Corrigan, NPR’s Fresh Air “An intellectual thriller and a beautiful love story. What if you came into possession of an historical artifact with the power to alter history and change the world? Sure to establish Belfer as a fearless, provocative writer. Impossible to put down.” — Sara Gruen, #1 New York Times bestselling author of Water for Elephants “A bold and hugely ambitious novel with the transfixing appeal of a best-seller…by a native daughter of the city whose talent is now even beyond the admiration of those of us so impressed by City of Light .…Extraordinary.” — Buffalo News “A fascinating historical novel and poignant love story that will open the eyes and ears of music lovers and please those who enjoy a graceful, spellbinding tale pondering important questions.” — Library Journal (starred review) “Brilliant and mesmerizing…. Since reading And After the Fire , I’ve been trumpeting it as the best novel I’ve had the pleasure of reading in years.” — Elinor Lipman, New York Times bestselling author of Then She Found Me “A remarkably suspenseful story, a literary thriller in the tradition of A.S. Byatt’s Possession .” — Kirkus Reviews “Engrossing. . . . A needy musicologist and his kid, a worldly woman haunted by trauma, the promise of the fabulous discovery of a lost and un-performable work by Johann Sebastian Bach—mix in greed and the drama that is modern New York—and you have the basis of a strong novel. Add to this generations of great names in music and culture, and you get a page-turner to love, even if you’re tone deaf. . . . a compelling and entertaining novel that will send you back to music.” — WOSU Radio “Compelling…. An immersive, page-turning story emboldened by historical fact and a rich imagination.” — Publishers Weekly “Highly readable…. Will delight readers of historical fiction, especially if they are music aficionados who like a good love story thrown into the works…. Belfer proves herself to be that skilled weaver of tales in this intellectual thriller.” — New York Journal of Books “Music pulses through this rich tale of love, morality, and a lost cantata…. Filled with history, gorgeous descriptions of music, and people both real and imagined.” — Washington Independent Review of Books “This latest novel from Belfer…is her most compelling yet…. Told with lyrical beauty (in a tender love scene, the past exists with the present), the novel is like the lost cantata itself, revealing our capacity for darkness, redeemed by the power of unconditional love. A dazzling, transformative novel. Highly recommended.” — Historical Novel Review “Belfer is adept at revealing the complex politics and sentiments, including the religious biases, of 18th-century Europe. The important questions Belfer poses regarding the ethical complexities of art are engrossing.” — BookPage “Blending the gorgeousness of Bach and the horror of anti-Semitism over several centuries should make for unsettling contemplation, and readers of Belfer’s…know that the author will be meticulous with both fact and fiction.” — Library Journal , “Editors’ Spring Picks” “One of the four best novels published to date in 2016.… The research and writing are… splendidly accomplished…. Brilliant.” — AEQAI “Marvelous…. Meticulously structured…. Eloquently and elegantly written. The themes are important and engaging. It is not a novel one will put down easily or forget at its conclusion.” — Jewish Book Council “On as grand a scale as any Bach masterpiece, Belfer’s novel explores the composer’s religious music and its effect on two women living 300 years apart…. Powerfully and emotionally written…. A fascinating, compelling read.” — RT Reviews “An outstanding historical novel…. Compelling.” — BookLoons.com This spellbinding new novel from Lauren Belfer, the New York Times bestselling author of A Fierce Radiance and City of Light , spans centuries and continents to reveal the secret history of a long-lost musical masterpiece—and the two women bound together by its troubled past. Sara Itzig Levy, the daughter of Frederick the Great’s banker, counts herself among the élite of late-eighteenth-century Berlin. A gifted harpsichordist, she hones her musical talents under Wilhelm Friedemann Bach, a son of Johann Sebastian Bach. Kindred spirits, the elderly maestro and his protégée enjoy a close friendship, but their time together is running out. Friedemann’s final gift to his dearest Sara is the original score of one of his father’s cantatas—yet, as she reads its libretto, her gratitude turns to horror. . . . In present-day New York City, Susanna Kessler enjoys a seemingly charmed life with a loving husband and a terrific job. Then a random, devastating act of violence tears it apart. Just as she’s beginning to recover, her beloved Uncle Henry kills himself. He leaves behind a cryptic note alluding to his haunting World War II experiences as an Allied soldier in Germany, and to an artifact he took from the war-ravaged country before returning home. Framed by Susanna’s urgent search for the truth about the disturbing musical score her uncle bequeaths to her, Sara’s richly atmospheric narrative—studded with vibrant, real-life musical figures from Wilhelm Friedemann Bach to Beethoven to Felix and Fanny Mendelssohn—reveals the passions and politics of Enlightenment- and Romantic-era Berlin. Wealth might buy Jews an entrée into German society but, as Sara discovers, a dark anti-Semitism simmers all around her. And as Susanna attempts to fight her demons by plunging deeper and deeper into Sara’s world, harrowing questions about her own family’s past begin to surface. Advance Praise for And After the Fire “It’s a remarkably suspenseful story, a literary thriller in the tradition of A. S. Byatt’s Possession.”— Kirkus reviews “A ‘what if’ novel that begins in the glittering salons of Enlightenment Berlin where, beneath the surface, are sentiments too sinister to be named and culminates in New York present day, And After the Fire is an intellectual thriller and a beautiful love story. What if you came into possession of a historical artifact with the power to alter history and change the world? Sure to establish Belfer as a fearless, provocative writer. Impossible to put down.”—Sara Gruen, #1 New York Times bestselling author of At the Water’s Edge and Water for Elephants “Brilliant and mesmerizing. . . . Since reading And After the Fire, I’ve been trumpeting it as the best novel I’ve had the pleasure of reading in years.”—Elinor Lipman, New York Times bestselling author of Then She Found Me Praise for Lauren Belfer’s previous novels “Enthralling. . . . Belfer’s powerful portrayal of how people are changed in pursuit of a miracle makes this book an especially compelling read.”—Nancy Horan, New York Times bestselling author of Loving Frank, on A Fierce Radiance “A love story and murder mystery rolled into a panoramic family saga and industrial-espionage thriller. . . . Belfer’s prose is heartbreaking, as are her twin themes of love and betrayal.”— USA Today on A Fierce Radiance “Impressive. . . . A stereopticon of a novel, sepia-tinged at the edges yet bursting with color at its center. . . . A powerfully atmospheric book.”— New York Times on City of Light Lauren Belfer’s novel A Fierce Radiance was named a Washington Post Best Novel; an NPR Best Mystery; and a New York Times Editors’ Choice. Her debut novel, City of Light , was a New York Times bestseller as well as a number one Book Sense pick; a New York Times Notable Book ; a Library Journal Best Book ; and a Main Selection of the Book-of-the-Month Club. She lives in New York City. Read more

Features & Highlights

  • National Jewish Book Award Winner!
  • The
  • New York Times
  • -bestselling author of
  • A Fierce Radiance
  • and
  • City of Light
  • returns with a new powerful and passionate novel—inspired by historical events—about two women, one European and one American, and the mysterious choral masterpiece by Johann Sebastian Bach that changes both their lives.
  • In the ruins of Germany in 1945, at the end of World War II, American soldier Henry Sachs takes a souvenir, an old music manuscript, from a seemingly deserted mansion and mistakenly kills the girl who tries to stop him.
  • In America in 2010, Henry’s niece, Susanna Kessler, struggles to rebuild her life after she experiences a devastating act of violence on the streets of New York City. When Henry dies soon after, she uncovers the long-hidden music manuscript. She becomes determined to discover what it is and to return it to its rightful owner, a journey that will challenge her preconceptions about herself and her family’s history—and also offer her an opportunity to finally make peace with the past.
  • In Berlin, Germany, in 1783, amid the city’s glittering salons where aristocrats and commoners, Christians and Jews, mingle freely despite simmering anti-Semitism, Sara Itzig Levy, a renowned musician, conceals the manuscript of an anti-Jewish cantata by Johann Sebastian Bach, an unsettling gift to her from Bach’s son, her teacher. This work and its disturbing message will haunt Sara and her family for generations to come.
  • Interweaving the stories of Susanna and Sara, and their families,
  • And After the Fire
  • traverses over two hundred years of history, from the eighteenth century through the Holocaust and into today, seamlessly melding past and present, real and imagined. Lauren Belfer’s deeply researched, evocative, and compelling narrative resonates with emotion and immediacy.

Customer Reviews

Rating Breakdown

★★★★★
30%
(811)
★★★★
25%
(676)
★★★
15%
(405)
★★
7%
(189)
23%
(621)

Most Helpful Reviews

✓ Verified Purchase

Don't waste your time

If you know only a little of history in general, and even less of music history in particular, you may like this book. Music history is my field, however. If this book had not been the recently featured book of a book club I'm in, I would have stopped reading it barely 50 pages in. One of my pet peeves is when authors insert real, historical people into their fictional stories and then distort what and who those people actually were (all the while justifying that by including a disclaimer saying, "Oh, this is fiction"). This author does that in spades. Also, she had what seemed to me an agenda, and it constantly got in the way of her story. The writing is pedestrian and the modern characters are utterly predictable. Read the one- and two-star reviews on amazon to get more detail.
31 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Interesting premise, stilted dialogue, disappointing plot

I purchased this book after hearing Maureen Corrigan's very positive review. I was extremely disappointed, and rather surprised that Corrigan didn't address any of the problems that plague the book. In fact, I wondered if she actually read it. The set up is intriguing - a woman, Susanna, discovers a Bach cantata by Bach's own hand among her late uncle's possessions, and has to determine how he got it and what to do with it. Running alongside this narrative is a second thread, in which we learn how the manuscript came into the possession of a Jewish woman (Sara Levy) in the 18th century. The story is complicated by the fact that the cantata has a violently anti-Jewish libretto, which makes it potentially controversial because Bach scholars and Bach lovers don't want to believe that a great composer was also a violent antisemite. So far so good. But as others have pointed out, the characters are wooden and the dialogue is so stilted that it grates on the nerves. Belfer "tells" rather than showing - she spells out in intricate detail what we are meant to take away, rather than allowing us to come to those conclusions on our own. But most importantly, Belfer sets up lots of potentially interesting twists and turns, but fails to realize any of them. SPOILER ALERT - don't keep reading if you don't want major plot revelations. For instance, Sara Levy's music teacher, who is Bach's elderly son, seems to have a rather pervy and inappropriate interest in her. Will he attempt to do something untoward? Um, no. He just pines from a distance for a while, before kicking the bucket. Perhaps Sara comes by the manuscript in an unethical way, taking it from her lustful music teacher? Um, no. He gives it to her as a wedding gift. As for the 21st century storyline, Susanna consults two young and attractive Bach experts, Scott and Dan, to get help. Both of them are attracted to her. Love triangle! She develops feelings for Dan, leaving Scott jealous. Will Scott attempt to intervene or connive to win her? Will he do something dastardly? Um, no. He accepts her preference for Dan and moves on with his life. Dan and Susanna both have complicated pasts. Will they find a way to get past their various traumas and make a life together? Um no. While they have sex for a couple of weeks, neither of them seems very motivated to move things forward. Scott and Dan's teacher, Frederic Fournier, is a wily impresario. Will he attempt to intervene in their work on the manuscript and claim the discovery for himself? Um, no. He chats with Susanna at a cocktail party, but she doesn't seem very interested in working with him, so he drops it. He does, however, later help Susanna out with some legal advice and marketing so that she can sell the manuscript. He turns out to be pretty nice! All of them are pretty nice! None of them is mean or evil or too jealous. They are all governed by good will and common sense. That's great! But it's not very interesting as fiction goes. There has to be some crisis, some obstacle to be surmounted, someone actually plotting, or something to engage the reader in the story. Instead we are given a bunch of stilted, mild-mannered characters who demonstrate a complete lack of grit. I am annoyed at myself for trusting Corrigan's review, because the book has the same flaws as the other book by Belfer that I have read (A Fierce Radiance). In addition to these problems, Belfer (who clearly has done a lot of research) includes endless passages full of details that turn out to be entirely irrelevant to the so-called plot. Perhaps a good editor could have helped Belfer to fix these weaknesses, to punch up the dialogue and craft a more suspenseful and satisfying tale. It's a shame that didn't happen, since the basic premise had potential.
30 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

An unforgettable saga of fact and fiction...

A powerful blend of fact and fiction, Belfer has meticulously researched her subject to provide authenticity that captivates the reader from beginning to end. This novel will be of special interest to classical music devotees - and, in particular, to aficionados of Johann Sebastian Bach. When Susanna's uncle, in Buffalo, NY, leaves her a music manuscript appearing to be the original score signed by Bach, the mystery begins. How on earth did the manuscript make it's way from Weimar, Germany to Buffalo and fall into her uncle's hands?

Susanna no longer practices her Jewish religion, but honors her heritage, When she discovers that the music composition is a horrific anti-Jewish cantata, what, at first, seemed to be an epic discovery for the classical music world and of infinite monetary value, becomes her all-consuming quest for answers. What should be done with a music manuscript which has been carefully concealed from the world since 1783, as too dangerous to reveal to a Jewish culture - their persecution by the Nazis down through the years and the lifelong effects of the Holocaust still smoldering?

The novel carries us through the salons of 1783 - 1800's Germany, where the music of Beethoven and Bach was the center of their entertainment. Family members were accomplished musicians and composers. Invitations to Sara Levy's salons were sought after for her skillful mix of guests and the quality of the musical entertainment. Sara was also the original recipient of the Bach cantata.

Susanna enlists experts to assist with her efforts, and as they learn about the manuscript, personal agendas emerge. Susanna decides to travel to Weimar to trace the manuscript's ownership, which must be established before she can decide how to handle its disposition. In the process, Susanna confronts her Jewish roots, which makes her decision even more difficult.

This novel is a stirring view of life in Germany for the Jews, as anti-Semitism is on the rise, and how many generations of the Levy family are affected. Through it all, is the successful effort to conceal this music manuscript. Not until 1945, and WWII, does the manuscript emerge.

And After the Fire, is an unforgettable saga, transporting the reader to a world seldom visited, with a conundrum that keeps the pages turning.
25 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Cliches and poor writing make this hard to stomach

As a lover of Johan Sebastian's Bach's music, European history, and literature I was terribly disappointed in this book. The simplistic, clichee-ridden writing made it impossible for me to finish this book. This author seems unable to create any shadings in her character; they are almost like stock figures from a comic book. Everything is black and white. After having read a few great novels recently with literary merit (e.g., All the light we cannot see), this book panders to any prejudices readers may hold, as opposed to create differentiated insight.

Americans= good people, caught up in bad wars
Jews = heroic victims
Germans = through and through antisemitic and murderous for centuries

Part of the story is set in late 18th century Prussia/Berlin. Compared to other European powers, Prussia was actually one of the first countries in Europe to emancipate Jews into society. The French Revolution furthered that development. However, there is nothing in this book that would help you understand that context. Instead, this book basically presents the tired notion that the Holocaust was basically advocated by Luther and that it pretty much was a foregone conclusion that the Germans finally carried it out 400 years later. After 180 pages I stopped reading and was angry with myself that I wasted my time with this author, when there are so many actually good books to be read dealing with this horrific period of world history. Try W.B. Sebald's "Austerlitz". Beautiful and heartbreaking.
19 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Seriously disappointed.

I'm seriously disappointed. I expected a novel with well researched historic connotations. I got stereotypes and cliches. And the language leaves much to be desired. I was looking forward, based on ratings and reviews, for a novel rich with well defined characters that one can either love or hate. A lost Bach manuscript resurfaces, what a promise of intrigue and sophistication. I got neither.
After finishing this review, I went back to other reviews, especially the single-starred ones. Two of them seemed to echo my feelings exactly: disappointment, grief over the time lost in reading through one third of the novel, frustration over stereotypes and cliches, and bad writing. Read the one-starred reviews, please.
18 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Brilliant.

Once again, Lauren Belfer has written a fascinating, deeply moving novel. The author of City of Light (1999) and A Fierce Radiance (2010), Belfer has made a daring leap across centuries and oceans to tell this story of heartache, love, and healing. Set both in contemporary New York and Germany and nineteenth century Berlin, the narrative features a talented musician named Sara Levy, who harbors a secret, and a contemporary New Yorker, Susanna Kessler, who has been hurt, physically and emotionally. Connecting them are a group of scholars, a remarkable, disturbing music manuscript, and a haunting history of anti-Semitism.

Belfer brings the same intriguing and seamless blend of fact and fiction to this work that she instilled in her earlier (best-selling) novels, and her deep historical research and rich detail about music, art, and the meaning of ancestry, not to mention her talent for dialogue, render this powerful story mesmerizing and provocative. She raises important questions about faith and suffering, about memory and pain and moving on. From the first pages, with its shocking account of a young American soldier in Weimar, Germany, to the last, when we come full circle, the story moves at a page-turning pace. The narrative not only opens a window onto the darkest days of the twentieth century, but also serves as a reflection on the way that that past lives on, for better and for worse. It is a brilliant book.
9 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

A good afternoon's read, the author's characters reflect their eras well.

Fun assembling a story this way. Take an ending or near an ending and work threads into the cloth until the full piece of fabric is inevitable. Not a dense read, but perhaps a bit complicated for those with no background in the subject or its details. Ms Belfer did good research, introduces believable characters based on sympathetic humanity, and entices the reader until the conclusion is obvious. Not exactly light reading, but perhaps I haven't read a whole lot of historical fiction recently. As a lover of most of the subject areas I'm glad I encountered this book, but would pass it on to others of similar interest rather than keep it on my shelves.

Sometimes historical fiction is all we have to figure out what might have happened to get from point A to point B.
6 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

A MEMORABLE READ BY A SUPER TALENTED AUTHOR

This morning I stayed in bed with my coffee, finishing "AND AFTER THE FIRE" by Lauren Belfer. (I taught Lauren high school French in 1967/8. She was a quiet, serious brilliant girl. Now she is a seriously brilliant author) "AND AFTER THE FIRE " is a can't-put-it-down book which takes us on several different trips to oh-so meaningful places where we meet and co-habit for a chapter with compelling characters who come alive and lead us into temptation after temptation. Then, in the next chapter, we leave there and go to another place and time with new colorful people to meet and get to know. Then Lauren Belfer shows us how, despite the centuries between them, they all eventually intermingle. The story centers around a manuscript found/pinched at the end of WWII by Susanna, the main character's, Uncle Henry, an American soldier. Henry dies and leaves Susanna, this mysterious manuscript signed by none other than Johann S Bach. Throughout the book we follow Susanna in her quest for the truth about the document. Her jarring personal story is cleverly woven in throughout. If you like music and want to know more about its role in both 19th and 20th century Germany (and America) GET THIS BOOK.
6 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

A tour-de-force by an author you know will deliver...

Belfer's place in American literature was already secure, but she has leveled up in AND AFTER THE FIRE. Passionately written, meticulously researched and delivered without missing a beat, her latest novel transports you through centuries of famed music, fascinating people, and perhaps the most heartbreaking paradox in all of Western art. Two chapters in, I was swept away, and as the plot developed, I saw into the souls of geniuses such as Bach — glimpsing not only divine inspiration but the bigotry that bedevils our species to this day. This isn't just a page turner but literature of a high order. Bravo, Lauren Belfer!
6 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

A Beautiful Exploration of a Compelling History

I was eager to read After the Fire after Lauren Belfer's last novel, Fierce Radiance became my go-to birthday present (as in next stop for my mother's book club!) Belfer knows how to write a compulsive page-turner, with fantastic characters and a compelling plot -- but she also slips in astute social history and insights about everything from science and war. After the Fire is just as compelling and just as subtly informative. the author begins with a haunting mystery, regarding a Bach manuscript that had disappeared for generations. It falls into the lap of her amateur "investigator," an attractive young Jewish woman in New York who is curious but conflicted. She undertakes a journey to discover the history of the manuscript and the ways it affected the lives of the people who possessed it. She also writes beautifully, and takes you to different places and periods of history with all of your senses engaged.

I've read a fair amount of World War II and Holocaust history. This book was a gentle yet effective treatment of these themes, with a profound grasp of the historical context. As a music lover, I relished the beautifully explored generations of the Bachs and the Mendelsohns, and was impressed by the musical sophistication of the writing. Sometimes highly readable novels go down quickly but leave me unsatisfied at the end. I read this novel hungry for the next plot development, but by the end I also felt that I had learned something, or more importantly, understood something in a new light.
6 people found this helpful