Among Others
Among Others book cover

Among Others

Hardcover – January 18, 2011

Price
$24.16
Format
Hardcover
Pages
304
Publisher
Tor Books
Publication Date
ISBN-13
978-0765321534
Dimensions
6.48 x 1.17 x 9.32 inches
Weight
1.05 pounds

Description

From Publishers Weekly Starred Review. World Fantasy Award–winner Walton (Tooth and Claw) turns the magical boarding school story inside out in this compelling coming-of-age tale. Welsh teen Morwenna was badly hurt, and her twin sister killed, when the two foiled their abusive mother's spell work. Seeking refuge with a father she barely knows in England, Mori is shunted off to a grim boarding school. Mori works a spell to find kindred souls and soon meets a welcoming group of science fiction readers, but she can feel her mother looking for her, and this time Mori won't be able to escape. Walton beautifully captures the outsider's yearning in Mori's earthy and thoughtful journal entries: "It doesn't matter. I have books, new books, and I can bear anything as long as there are books." Never deigning to transcend the genre to which it is clearly a love letter, this outstanding (and entirely teen-appropriate) tale draws its strength from a solid foundation of sense-of-wonder and what-if. (Jan.) (c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved. From Booklist With a deft hand and a blazing imagination, fantasy writer Walton mixes genres to great effect. Elements of fantasy, science fiction, and coming-of-age novels combine into one superlative literary package that will appeal to a variety of readers across age levels. After engaging in a classic good-magic-versus-bad-magic battle with her mother that fatally wounds her twin sister, 15-year-old Morwenna leaves Wales and attempts to reconnect with her estranged father. She was sent to boarding school in England, and her riveting backstory unfolds gradually as she records her thoughts, feelings, and experiences in a series of journal entries. An ominous sense of disquiet permeates the nonlinear plot as Morwenna attempts to avoid a final clash with her mother. In addition to casting an irresistible narrative spell, Walton also pays tribute to a host of science-fiction masters as she peppers Morwenna’s journal with the titles of the novels she devours in her book-fueled quest for self-discovery. --Margaret Flanagan “A hymnal for the clever and odd—an inspiration and a lifeline to anyone who has ever felt in the world, but not of it.” —Cory Doctorow , New York Times bestselling author of Little Brother “If you love SF and fantasy, if reading it formed your teen years, if you do remember the magic you used to do, if you remember the absolute joy of first discovering those books, then read this.” —Robin Hobb, New York Times bestselling author of Assassin’s Apprentice “A lovely story, unlike anything I’ve ever read before: funny, touching, and gently magical.” —Patrick Rothfuss, New York Times bestselling author of The Name of the Wind JO WALTON’s novel Tooth and Claw won the World Fantasy Award, and the novels of her Small Change sequence— Farthing , Ha’penny , and Half a Crown —have won acclaim ranging from national newspapers to the Romantic Times Reviewer’s Choice Award. A native of Wales, she lives in Montreal. Excerpt. © Reprinted by permission. All rights reserved. THURSDAY 1ST MAY 1975xa0The Phurnacite factory in Abercwmboi killed all the trees for two miles around. We’d measured it on the mileometer. It looked like something from the depths of hell, black and looming with chimneys of flame, reflected in a dark pool that killed any bird or animal that drank from it. The smell was beyond description. We always wound up the car windows as tight as tight when we had to pass it, and tried to hold our breath, but Grampar said nobody could hold their breath that long, and he was right. There was sulphur in that smell, which was a hell chemical as everyone knew, and other, worse things, hot unnameable metals and rotten eggs.My sister and I called it Mordor, and we’d never been there on our own before. We were ten years old. Even so, big as we were, as soon as we got off the bus and started looking at it we started holding hands.It was dusk, and as we approached the factory loomed blacker and more terrible than ever. Six of the chimneys were alight; four belched out noxious smokes.“Surely it is a device of the Enemy,” I murmured.Mor didn’t want to play. “Do you really think this will work?”“The fairies were sure of it,” I said, as reassuringly as possible.“I know, but sometimes I don’t know how much they understand about the real world.”“Their world is real,” I protested. “Just in a different way. At a different angle.”“Yes.” She was still staring at the Phurnacite, which was getting bigger and scarier as we approached. “But I don’t know how much they understand about the angle of the every day world. And this is definitely in that world. The trees are dead. There isn’t a fairy for miles.”“That’s why we’re here,” I said.We came to the wire, three straggly strands, only the top one barbed. A sign on it read “No Unauthorised Admittance. Beware Guard Dogs.” The gate was far around the other side, out of sight.“Are there dogs?” she asked. Mor was afraid of dogs, and dogs knew it. Perfectly nice dogs who would play with me would rouse their hackles at her. My mother said it was a method people could use to tell us apart. It would have worked, too, but typically of her, it was both terrifyingly evil and just a little crazily impractical.“No,” I said.“How do you know?”“It would ruin everything if we go back now, after having gone to all this trouble and come this far. Besides, it’s a quest, and you can’t give up on a quest because you’re afraid of dogs. I don’t know what the fairies would say. Think of all the things people on quests have to put up with.” I knew this wasn’t working. I squinted forward into the deepening dusk as I spoke. Her grip on my hand had tightened. “Besides, dogs are animals. Even trained guard dogs would try to drink the water, and then they’d die. If there really were dogs, there would be at least a few dog bodies at the side of the pool, and I don’t see any. They’re bluffing.”We crept below the wire, taking turns holding it up. The still pool was like old unpolished pewter, reflecting the chimney flames as unfaithful wavering streaks. There were lights below them, lights the evening shift worked by.There was no vegetation here, not even dead trees. Cinders crunched underfoot, and clinker and slag threatened to turn our ankles. There seemed to be nothing alive but us. The star-points of windows on the hill opposite seemed ridiculously out of reach. We had a school friend who lived there, we had been to a party once, and noticed the smell, even inside the house. Her father worked at the plant. I wondered if he was inside now.At the edge of the pool we stopped. It was completely still, without even the faintest movement of natural water. I dug in my pocket for the magic flower. “Have you got yours?”“It’s a bit crushed,” she said, fishing it out. I looked at them. Mine was a bit crushed too. Never had what we were doing seemed more childish and stupid than standing in the centre of that desolation by that dead pool holding a pair of crushed pimpernels the fairies had told us would kill the factory.I couldn’t think of anything appropriate to say. “Well, un, dai, tri!” I said, and on “Three” as always we cast the flowers forward into the leaden pool, where they vanished without even a ripple. Nothing whatsoever happened. Then a dog barked far away, and Mor turned and ran and I turned and pelted after her.“Nothing happened,” she said, when we were back on the road, having covered the distance back in less than a quarter of the time it had taken us as distance out.“What did you expect?” I asked.“The Phurnacite to fall and become a hallowed place,” she said, in the most matter-of-fact tone imaginable. “Well, either that or huorns.”I hadn’t thought of huorns, and I regretted them extremely. “I thought the flowers would dissolve and ripples would spread out and then it would crumble to ruin and the trees and ivy come swarming over it while we watched and the pool would become real water and a bird would come and drink from it and then the fairies would be there and thank us and take it for a palace.”“But nothing at all happened,” she said, and sighed. “We’ll have to tell them it didn’t work tomorrow. Come on, are we going to walk home or wait for a bus?”It had worked, though. The next day, the headline in the Aberdare Leader was “Phurnacite Plant Closing: Thousands of Jobs Lost.”*xa0xa0xa0*xa0xa0xa0* I’m telling that part first because it’s compact and concise and it makes sense, and a lot of the rest of this isn’t that simple. Think of this as a memoir. Think of it as one of those memoirs that’s later discredited to everyone’s horror because the writer lied and is revealed to be a different colour, gender, class and creed from the way they’d made everybody think. I have the opposite problem. I have to keep fighting to stop making myself sound more normal. Fiction’s nice. Fiction lets you select and simplify. This isn’t a nice story, and this isn’t an easy story. But it is a story about fairies, so feel free to think of it as a fairy story. It’s not like you’d believe it anyway. Copyright © 2010 by Jo Walton Read more

Features & Highlights

  • Winner of the 2011 Nebula Award for Best Novel
  • Winner of the 2012 Hugo Award for Best Novel
  • Startling, unusual, and yet irresistably readable,
  • Among Others
  • is at once the compelling story of a young woman struggling to escape a troubled childhood, a brilliant diary of first encounters with the great novels of modern fantasy and SF, and a spellbinding tale of escape from ancient enchantment.
  • Raised by a half-mad mother who dabbled in magic, Morwenna Phelps found refuge in two worlds. As a child growing up in Wales, she played among the spirits who made their homes in industrial ruins. But her mind found freedom and promise in the science fiction novels that were her closest companions. Then her mother tried to bend the spirits to dark ends, and Mori was forced to confront her in a magical battle that left her crippled--and her twin sister dead.
  • Fleeing to her father whom she barely knew, Mori was sent to boarding school in England–a place all but devoid of true magic. There, outcast and alone, she tempted fate by doing magic herself, in an attempt to find a circle of like-minded friends. But her magic also drew the attention of her mother, bringing about a reckoning that could no longer be put off…
  • Combining elements of autobiography with flights of imagination in the manner of novels like Jonathan Lethem’s
  • The Fortress of Solitude
  • , this is potentially a breakout book for an author whose genius has already been hailed by peers like Kelly Link, Sarah Weinman, and Ursula K. Le Guin.
  • One of
  • School Library Journal
  • ’s Best Adult Books 4 Teens titles of 2011 One of io9's best Science Fiction & Fantasy books of the year 2011

Customer Reviews

Rating Breakdown

★★★★★
30%
(596)
★★★★
25%
(496)
★★★
15%
(298)
★★
7%
(139)
23%
(456)

Most Helpful Reviews

✓ Verified Purchase

A stunningly wonderful book

This is a stunningly wonderful book.

I have never read anything that so perfectly captures the experience of being fifteen, a science fiction reader just discovering some of the greats of the field (not to mention fandom!), the new kid in school who doesn't quite fit in, the young woman just starting to reach for adulthood, and not sure where she fits in a family where no one except her imperfectly known father seems to share her interests and concerns.

Of course, Morwenna's problems are in a whole different league from my own at her age. Morwenna's twin sister was killed in a car accident that left Morwenna crippled. That accident was their witch mother's retaliation for their successful thwarting of her spell intended to make her a Dark Queen. Now Morwenna is dependent on the father she's never met.

On the one hand, Morwenna and her father Daniel bond over their love of science fiction. On the other hand, her aunts, his three sisters, decide that she belongs at Arlinghurst, the same boarding school they attended, so that's where she goes. It's a tough transition for her, a crippled girl among enthusiastic athletes, a Welsh girl amongst mostly upper middle class English girls, an enthusiastic reader amongst students who think reading is only for studying. But she's smart, and determined, and doesn't really see any better alternatives, so she finds ways to cope.

And as she struggles to find her own place, and her own friends, and her own path, she discovers that the threat from her mother is not over. Together with all the normal adolescent challenges, Morwenna also does battle with her mother's hostility and ambitions, the ethics of magic, and the desire and opportunity to be reunited with her sister.

This is a beautifully written book, lovingly and convincingly depicting both adolescent angst and the joys of discovering science fiction and the community of science fiction fandom.

Highly recommended.

I purchased this book and have received no compensation from the publisher or anyone else for reading and reviewing it.
73 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Quick and fun, but way too pat

Among Others is a fun, interesting book, and I sped through it in one day. Looking back though, several flaws detract from what might otherwise have been excellent.

Through her journal entries (which are really just regular first-person narration), this book relates the story of Mori, a Welsh teenager and lover of science fiction who is sent to an upper-class English boarding school after fleeing her abusive mother. Mori doesn't fit in with the other girls and spends the bulk of her time reading, primarily science fiction. She's a sympathetic and relatable character, particularly if you were an odd kid who read a lot; I love the way she talks about the inter-house athletic competitions, for instance, which everyone else takes very seriously and she couldn't care less about. The book is well-written and does a great job of keeping questions in the reader's mind at all times, particularly as Mori takes her time in telling us about her past. And the discussions of class tensions in 1970's England, as well as the trouble readers had to take to find books by their favorite authors before the Internet (we're spoiled nowadays!) were interesting.

A couple of minor SPOILERS follow.

But there are several problems. Most notable (and ironic, since Mori criticizes other books for this) is that the book is just way too pat. Mori forms close bonds almost instantaneously with every other reader she meets (and there are a lot of them, as she joins a book club halfway through); the first guy to catch her eye soon becomes her boyfriend; the last couple pages are almost sickeningly sweet. And then there are all the unanswered questions. One subplot deals with Mori's aunts trying to force her to get her ears pierced, which she believes will stop her from doing magic--but she never discovers their motivation. We never find out what's really behind the aunts' relationship with Mori's father, nor why their father committed suicide, despite hints that this would be important. Etc. We're briefly given a lot of fascinating information about Mori's extended family, but it's never followed up on, some of it never referred to again. I'm not sure why the author dangled so many tantalizing hooks if they were irrelevant to the story at hand.

So the book is worth a read, probably especially if you've read much 1970's science fiction (I haven't, and I don't feel that this detracted from my understanding of the book, but someone who's read most of the books Mori discusses would probably enjoy those parts more). Still, it isn't quite what it could have been. If it had been longer, enough to make Mori work harder to earn her happy ending and to flesh out more of the characters and their stories, I suspect it would have been excellent.
62 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Insubstantial and self-indulgent

Things missing from this novel:
*A real plot, an arcing story beyond a set of loosely tense events.
*Believable characterization.
*Consistent focus on how messed up someone would have to be to actually relate to the whole world from a scifi lens.

Instead this book focuses to a fault on listing off the author's personal likes and dislikes in speculative fiction, moving on incessantly to relate the love of science fiction and fantasy. Which is a fine element to have, but one needs more than that to build a story around, a measure of real interest and compelling drama. There just isn't that, instead we have a three hundred page love-letter to genre literature. It's an incredibly shallow representation, brief discussion of the appeal of anarchist politics from The Dispossessed will be followed pages later with gushing over C. S. Lewis. It's literature that writes specifically to and of fandom, without using the potential of speculative fiction to actually unsettle, disrupt or think of alternatives. The explicit fantasy elements in this book appear sporadically and with minimal interest, there is nothing creative that it's used for besides the dubious benefit of comparing them more explicitly to past familiar fantasy elements. Beyond the focus on personal taste, I have to say that most of the views here aren't even quirky enough to be surprising or very useful. Heinlein was great but lost focus in later years, Dick was too weird and depressing, Tolkien is still the best fantasy writer ever. It's the type of thing that can only appeal to SF fandoms, but even in that element is really predictable and redundant. This books surrenders a plausible human construction and any real drama for the sake of self-indulgent didactic live-blogging, and within that content turns out to have nothing of substance to say.

The worst speculative fiction novel from 2011 that I have yet read. In no way does this book measure up to the quality of the material it constantly name-drops.

Similar to and worse than: How to Live Safely in a Science Fiction Universe by Charles Yu. Which I don't particularly like, but handles its self-aware aspect with a lot more complexity and creativity than Walton.

Similar to and better than: Turn Coat by Jim Buthcer. Geeky in-jokes by a protagonist unable to use the internet, no less.
51 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Raised by books

A friend of mine says he was raised by wolves; I always say I was raised by books. Books provided the context, the subtext, and the text of my world. I was an alien, a misfit, uncomfortable in my family and at school. But in books I was the protagonist, I was normal, I was in worlds weird and fantastic, romantic and historical.

It's 1979 and Mor is fifteen. She, too, lives in books. She reveals her world to us and it is weird and fantastic, romantic and historial, all the while seeming ordinary and mundane on the outside.

This is a wonderful book about what it's like to feel different from everybody else, and the hope of discovering that you're not--that there are people enough like you to find community, even if it's not the family you were born into or the kids you grew up with. And it's also a book about how dangerous and necessary it is to change the world, or to refrain from changing the world, with magic and fairies and ghosts and witches.
48 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Magical

This is a wonderful novel. I fell in love with the voice, which reminded me of Dodie Smith's "I Capture the Castle". It's a precocious 15 year old's journal, as she navigates the confusions of adolescence, darkened by her sister's death. She's lost her home with her extended family in Wales, and is living in an English girl's boarding school, with holidays at her father's house -- the father that she just met for the first time. Her world includes fairies, and magic, and Walton does an amazing job of making that both believable, and at the same time making it feasible for it to be all in Mori's imagination. Mori is confident and analytical. She turns that analysis on herself, what she sees around her, and the books she reads. That logical analysis can be quite funny, as she tries to make sense of the scoring system and rules in her new boarding school and family.

She adores books, especially SF and fantasy. This book is a love letter to librarians, to interlibrary loan, and to SF fandom. She mentions all the books she's reading, with wonderful comments on them. It conjures up the wonder of discovering books as a child, if you were one of those kids. While many of the books she mentions are SF or fantasy, not all are. Others that come up include Josephine Tey, Mary Renault, Plato, Shakespeare, and T. S. Eliot. She is thoroughly steeped in SF, though. When she has nightmares, and wakes up terrified, she uses the litany against fear from Dune, and it works.
42 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Nothing happens!

I love other books by Walton very much. This one was a real disappointment. It starts very slowly, and continues that way for the whole book. The first bit of active conflict occurs more than halfway through the book, between Mori and her aunts over their Christmas gift to her, and is brief and low-key. The rest is all hints and memories, anxiety, description, and SF book reviews. There are about 4 pages of good action at the very end.

I enjoy other books that are not full of conflict and action, but when a book begins by hinting of magic and conflict and Ruling the World, and the blurb emphasizes the same, I expect those things to be handled before the last pages. It felt more like a teenage memoir of feelings and social anxieties with fantasy added, especially since all the magic up till the end, other than seeing and talking to fairies, was of the "magic or coincidence?" type.

The book raises expectations that it does not fulfill.
37 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Boring...

Unfortunately, I read enough of the book that I felt I *had* to finish it. It really wouldn't have mattered if I hadn't because nothing really happened. It was utterly unmemorable and moved at an excruciatingly slow pace. The story alluded to and attempted to build upon a conflict - however, I had to read more than half the book before learning what it was. It was revealed in such an anti-climactic manner that it was a total disappointment. There was nearly no fantasy factor and was little more than a diary of a girl who reads far too much. She journals about her thoughts and feelings about her family and classmates (which lack depth) and dozens of book reviews. If I wanted to read book reviews, I would check out the NY Times.
21 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

I do not get it?

I was excited about reading this book after reading all of the reviews. I don't know, Is it me or did this book have no plot whatsoever? What am I missing? I listened to this book on audio and the readers voice was awesome, but the awesomeness ended there. I actually was listening to it one day while I was running and I had to turn it off because there was so much whining about the character getting her ears pierced. Whine, whine, whine, I get enough of that in real life.
I didn't like it at all.
12 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

When you love books, books love you

January isn't even over yet, and I've found my favorite book published in 2011.

There is no better description, anywhere, of what it's *like* to be an SF/F fan/reader than this book. There's a plot, there's magic -- or maybe it's sf, maybe it's steampunk, as our protagonist Mor moves among the fairies of post-industrial Wales -- but most of all, there are *books*.

Mor is 15 in 1979, and you know what they say: "The Golden Age of science fiction ... is twelve". She *reads*, she reads sf and fantasy, she reads the books we read in the late 70s, and she thinks about them. They shape her the way books *do*, when you care.

"When you love books enough, books love you back."
11 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

A novel for bibliotropes

Kids nowadays have it easy. If you're into fantasy, there's a good chance that the books you like have a devoted following and a few dedicated web sites. There may be movie franchises and/or an HBO series about them. You can buy Team Jacob/Team Edward shirts, Harry Potter glasses and A Game of Thrones calendars. There may be book release parties, even people sleeping in front of the bookstore when the next book is due out. There's GoodReads, Shelfari and Librarything, and even if you're not on one of those sites, it's never been easier to connect with other fans and with the authors themselves.

Growing up in the seventies, it was considerably harder to meet like-minded readers or even just find out about the existence of books you might want to read: as unreliable as Amazon release dates can be, they're at least an indication that the author is a) still alive and b) working on the next book in the series. Back then, all you had were the order forms in the back of paperbacks and whatever happened to be stocked in your local library or bookstore. Being a budding SFF fan was a lot more work back then than it is nowadays.

Take Morwenna, the main character of Jo Walton's excellent new novel Among Others. Her main passion in life -- aside from magic -- is reading science fiction and fantasy. She lives her life thinking about Ursula K. Le Guin, Roger Zelazny and Kurt Vonnegut Jr. When she runs away from home -- after successfully preventing her mother's attempt to gain dark magical powers but in the process becoming crippled and losing her twin sister -- one of her main concerns is picking the right books to take along. Whatever else is going on in her strange, lonely life, the early masterworks of science fiction and fantasy are always there for her, and if one famous saying guides her, it might be the famous Erasmus quote: "When I have a little money, I buy books; and if I have any left, I buy food and clothes."

Among Others is essentially the diary of one significant stage of Morwenna's life: after running away, her custody is assigned to her previously absentee father, but because he lives with (and is controlled by) his three sisters, Mori quickly finds herself sent to boarding school. A Welsh girl in England, crippled and shy, she's already an outsider even before she gets thrown into the brutal politics of an all-teenage-girls boarding school. As Mori comments, in her typical wry way: "It's depressing how much boarding school is just like Enid Blyton showed it, and all the ways it's different are ways it's worse."

And "diary" is meant literally here: the novel actually consists of Mori's day-by-day diary entries, describing her arrival at her father's house, her move to the boarding school, occasional trips back home and so on. Before you start thinking that Morwenna is a female and well-read version of Adrian Mole, let me assure you that this diary makes for much more interesting reading than you might expect, because Mori's way of looking at the world is consistently fascinating -- and not just because she can speak to spirits. She's funny, snarky and self-deprecating, and of course well versed in SF and fantasy. It's a true pleasure to read how she deals with the abrupt changes in her life, the prison-like atmosphere of boarding school, and her mother's attempts to contact and control her. Witnessing her growing confidence and the gradual expansion of her social circle, I genuinely found myself rooting for her.

I doubt that someone who doesn't love SF and fantasy would have the same appreciation for Among Others, because it sometimes seems that Mori's feelings about the books she reads are more important than the actual plot of the novel. Mori's excitement about finding other SFF readers, or discovering a new Roger Zelazny novel in a bookstore, is simply infectious. On the other hand, if you're not familiar with the books and authors she frequently mentions, Among Others might not have the same impact on you. Confession: I haven't read Cat's Cradle by Kurt Vonnegut Jr., so I wasn't familiar with some of that novel's made-up vocabulary, which Mori applies to her own life several times, but thanks to Wikipedia I learned what a granfalloon and a karass are -- and I'm now also very curious to read this book! Still, whether you get the exact references or not, anyone who spent some of their darker teenage years finding comfort in books will almost automatically identify and empathize with Mori. (Seeing how absurdly happy she gets when discovering that inter-library loans are not only available but free, I found myself wishing I could transport myself to her time and area to hand her a fully loaded e-book reader.)

Aside from the genuine love for science fiction and fantasy that permeates every ounce of this novel, it also features a loving picture of an isolated, intelligent young woman finding her place in life, and a simple but solid present-day fantasy plot that slowly unfolds to reach a satisfying conclusion. Anyone who enjoyed Graham Joyce's The Tooth Fairy will probably love Among Others (and vice versa). The novel reads smoothly, is never boring, and is very hard to put down. Also, Jo Walton's concept of "deniable magic" made me reconsider magic and its "causality" (for want of a better word) in a whole new way.

Exactly how much of Among Others is autobiographical I don't know, but if Jo Walton's fascinating blog entries at Tor.com are an indication, there's at least one quality she undoubtedly shares with Mori: her love for science fiction and fantasy. There's a wonderful passage in Among Others: without planning, Mori and some friends find themselves heading towards the bookstore almost unwittingly. One person mentions that sunflowers are "heliotropes" -- they automatically orient themselves towards the sun -- and then says that Mori and her friends must be bibliotropes. Borrowing that wonderful word, I think it's fair to say that Among Others by Jo Walton is a novel for bibliotropes. Highly recommended.
10 people found this helpful