All for Nothing (New York Review Books Classics)
All for Nothing (New York Review Books Classics) book cover

All for Nothing (New York Review Books Classics)

Paperback – February 13, 2018

Price
$17.95
Format
Paperback
Pages
368
Publisher
NYRB Classics
Publication Date
ISBN-13
978-1681372051
Dimensions
5 x 0.78 x 7.95 inches
Weight
11.2 ounces

Description

“I encountered one masterpiece this year—Walter Kempowski’s epic novel All for Nothing . . . . What an amazing book this is: it was excitedly put into my hands by a writer friend, and I’ve been handing it on, in turn, to anyone who’ll listen to me. . . . What’s remarkable is that Kempowski recounts this grave story almost in a spirit of lightness, with a slightly ironic distance and a quiet, steady humor . . . the result is a book at once searing and utterly unsentimental, a historical epic that doesn’t attempt to hide the fact that it is being written in the twenty-first century, decades after the events.” —James Wood, The New Yorker "A crystalline translation by Anthea Bell . . . All for Nothing isn’t easily appropriated by any ideology. Kempowski’s sympathy for the suffering of his characters and his acknowledgment of the attendant destruction of their civilization are diffused by a fine-grained ambivalence. . . . As a literary response to a long-buried collective trauma, All for Nothing is well worth reading." —Corinna da Fonseca-Wollheim, The New York Times "Memorable and monumental: a book to read alongside rival and compatriot Günter Grass's Tin Drum as a portrait of decline and fall." — Kirkus starred review“ All for Nothing is a beautiful, forgiving and compassionate book that looks beyond the futile divisions people make between themselves. It reaches its last devastating line with poetic sensibility and the grace of a classical tragedy, confirming Kempowski as a truly great writer.” —Carol Birch, The Guardian “Beneath its apparently affectless façade, All for Nothing seethes with human drama, contradiction and complexity. No one is blameless; no one wholly unsympathetic. The result is an astonishing literary achievement.” —Toby Lichtig, The Telegraph "Kempowski’s novel represents one of the culminating achievements of that postwar German self-reckoning, that political and literary renegotiation of the past that has produced important work by Heinrich Böll, Günter Grass, W.xa0G. Sebald, and, lately, Erpenbeck herself. We know that such reckoning required a delicate calculus, 'beyond all political affiliation.' Sebald, in the lectures on the Allied bombing of German cities that he delivered in 1997 (later published under the title “On the Natural History of Destruction”), argued that the 'national humiliation felt by millions in the last years of the war' was the reason that 'no one, to the present day, has written the great German epic of the wartime and postwar periods.' A little less than a decade later, but too late for poor Sebald, Walter Kempowski beautifully proved him wrong." —James Wood, The New Yorker “Kempowski’s idiosyncratic genius lies in his ability to weave this accumulation of human fallibility into something greater. His perspective on a grim slice of history steadily broadens out to become visionary, lending his novel the irresistible pull of great tragedy.” — The Economist “Far more than a great German novel; Kempowski’s late masterwork is a universal tract which suggests that history can only present the facts; it is crafted stories such as this which enable us to grasp a sense of the vicious reality of war.” —Eileen Battersby, The Irish Times Walter Kempowski (1929-2007) was born in Hamburg. During World War II, he was made to serve in a penalty unit of the Hitler Youth due to his association with the rebellious Swingjugend movement of jazz lovers, and he did not finish high school. After the war he settled in West Germany. On a 1948 visit to Rostock, his hometown, in East Germany, Walter, his brother Robert and their mother were arrested for espionage; a Soviet military tribunal sentenced him to twenty-five years in prison, of which he served eight at the notorious "Yellow Misery" prison in Bautzen. In 1957 he graduated high school. His first success as an author was the autobiographical novel Tadellöser & Wolff (1971), part of his acclaimed German Chronicle series of novels. In the 1980s he began work on an immense project, Echo Soundings , gathering firsthand accounts, diaries, letters, and memoirs of World War II, which he collated and curated into ten volumes published over twenty years, and which is considered a modern classic. Anthea Bell is the recipient of the 2009 Schlegel-Tieck Prize for her translation of Stefan Zweig's Burning Secret . In 2002 she won the Independent Foreign Fiction Prize and the Helen and Kurt Wolff Prize for her translation of W.G. Sebald's Austerlitz . Her translations of Zweig's novellas Confusion and Journey into the Past are available as NYRB Classics. Jenny Erpenbeck was born in East Berlin in 1967. She is the author of several works of fiction, including The End of Days , which won the Hans Fallada Prize and the International Foreign Fiction Prize, and most recently, Go, Went, Gone . Erpenbeck lives in Berlin.

Features & Highlights

  • A wealthy family tries--and fails--to seal themselves off from the chaos of post-World War II life surrounding them in this stunning novel by one of Germany's most important post-war writers.
  • In East Prussia, January 1945, the German forces are in retreat and the Red Army is approaching. The von Globig family's manor house, the Georgenhof, is falling into disrepair. Auntie runs the estate as best she can since Eberhard von Globig, a special officer in the German army, went to war, leaving behind his beautiful but vague wife, Katharina, and her bookish twelve-year-old son, Peter. As the road fills with Germans fleeing the occupied territories, the Georgenhof begins to receive strange visitors--a Nazi violinist, a dissident painter, a Baltic baron, even a Jewish refugee. Yet in the main, life continues as banal, wondrous, and complicit as ever for the family, until their caution, their hedged bets, and their denial are answered by the wholly expected events they haven't allowed themselves to imagine.
  • All for Nothing
  • , published in 2006, was the last novel by Walter Kempowski, one of postwar Germany's most acclaimed and popular writers.

Customer Reviews

Rating Breakdown

★★★★★
30%
(130)
★★★★
25%
(109)
★★★
15%
(65)
★★
7%
(30)
23%
(100)

Most Helpful Reviews

✓ Verified Purchase

Magnificent. I keep asking myself how it's possible that I had never heard of the author until last week.

This book is a masterpiece. I discovered it via James Wood's recent review in the The New Yorker. Google Walter Kempowski’s "Epic Novel of Germany in Collapse," and you'll get an exceptionally insightful analysis of the book as well as another of Kempowski's works, "Swansong 1945," which I've just ordered.

There's not much I would add to Wood's review, but I will point out that the translation I read was by Anthea Bell and published by NYRB. This is the same translation that Wood reviewed. There was an earlier English translation by Mario Rubino (Verlag Albrecht Knaus) which may or may not be satisfactory.
39 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

The Riveting Story of the Collapse of East Germany in January, 1945, as Experienced by One German Household

This is the riveting story of a family, the von Globig family, living in East Prussia, in January, 1945, as the Russian army began its ultimate sweep into Germany itself. More specifically, it is the story of Katherina and Ebehard von Globig, and their son, Peter, and their aunt, and a Polish handyman, Vladimir, who lives with them, and two Ukranian young women, Sonya ad Vera, who are maids to the family, and a family friend, Dr. Wagner, a retired teacher retained to teach the son, Peter.

The story relates the experience not only of these people, but also the experience of a cast of five, or six refugees who pass through their home on their way west to escape the advance of the Russian army. And, in particular, it is the story of Drygalski, a German civilian officer charged to maintain order during the last gasps of German hegemony.

The story is beautifully told. Each of the main characters, especially Katherina, as well as each of the interesting refugees whom they house for a night or two at their Georgenhof estate, is incredibly well-develped.

Bottom-line, this is the story of the tragic end of all but one in this extended German household caught in the collapse of their own country.

Though the author, Walter Kempowski, who himself as a boy experienced the destruction of East Prussia, attempts
to tell the story with as little embellishment as possible, it is nonetheless as searing and heartbreaking a story as any novel that I have ever read.

So potent was the story to me that I have read it four times - something that I had never done before.
20 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Fantastic!

Terrific book for narrative and character development. The sparse writing and short paragraphs force you to think. It seems as though there is a sentence or statement on each page that is pregnant with ideas and implications. I found myself putting the book down repeatedly to ruminate. The subject matter itself is dark; the events are traumatic; and yet, I was sad to reach the last page and realize that I couldn't enjoy more of Kempowski's writing. It's a sin that more of his work has not been translated.
19 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

This book is incredible. Everything about the horrors of ...

This book is incredible. Everything about the horrors of the war coming to Germany from Russia is all here but its all by indirection. The writing is flat and subtle. Every word is fraught with meaning and atmospheric. In fact, its downright scary without a single sentence explicitly naming the horrors.
12 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Humane and authentic narrative of an inhuman world

East Prussia, January 1945, temperatures way below zero, German refugees, French prisoners of war, starving Jews, and a relatively well-off family living in a run-down manor, not particularly in love with Hitler and the Reich. This is the setting that takes us into desperate times. The Russian army is overwhelming German defenses in the east, and an endless parade of Germans are moving west, to an unknown fate. In the meantime, a 12-year-old boy is growing up, Peter von Globig, while his father serves the Reich in Italy, plundering goods for Germany, and his beautiful but distracted mother is paralyzed as to what to do next. The booming sounds of distant guns are heard every day, rattling the windows, and are getting closer. Should they all join the refugees and get out? While they remain inert, a series of visitors comes to them seeking shelter from the brutal cold, and Peter's teacher often visits to tutor him, quoting poetry. Peter's auntie is the only one who is focused on the here and now, holding the household together.

This work is pulled from bits and pieces of Kempowski's life. Born in 1929, he embodies the boy Peter. An excellent introduction by Jenny Erpenbeck gives a fine background to this work, but it should be read after finishing the book. Kempowski's writing is unsentimental, clean, strong, and clear. The Prussian winter is felt on every one of its pages, and the thoughts of each character are rendered so believably that you can't help but be a part of their awful and sometimes small triumphs. A unique work. Highly recommended.
7 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Realistic portrayal of Germans in east Prussia as the Russians closed in.

I thought this was a very judicious, value-free portrayal of the lives of a disparate group of Germans facing the collapse of the Third Reich as the Russians moved inexorably forward. Kemowski aboids facile judgements of the characters in this moving novel.
I had no criticism.
7 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Fleeing the barbarian invaders during the East Prussian winter of 1945

This is an important novel set during the evacuation of East Prussia during the first three months of 1945 as Russian troops crossed into Germany and headed west. Something like 2.6 million Germans were resident in this far eastern outpost of Germany. For a variety of reasons, it was only very late into the invasion that 2 million Germans struggled in the most adverse conditions, including panic, to escape. 25.000-30,000 civilians died attempting to avoid the on-coming Russians, whom they rightly feared would engage in most horrendous retaliation in response to the barbarities inflicted during the German invasion of Russia in 1941. The novel sparkles with authenticity due to the fact the author was a childhood resident of this area during the evacuation. A distinguished German author, his own life was full of hardships, including 8 years in a Soviet prison. The translation is excellent and well delivers the emotions the author was seeking to convey.

The central character is the 12 year old Peter, based in part on the author's own experiences. The family is minor nobility, with a father off fighting in Italy, and a mother who seems strangely dreamy and unattached to the realities around her. In addition, the household is made up of Auntie, some Polish maids, and Vladimir an older handy servant. They live in a once grand old mansion, Georgenhof, right adjacent to a major road. The author devotes at least one chapter each to these characters so the reader really gains an insight into their sometimes strange behavior. Also living in the nearby town of Mitkau are several government administrators, including Drygalski who typifies the many unsuccessful Germans who supported the Nazis and got nice jobs as a result. He clearly resents this formerly noble family and is somewhat of a skunk.

Peter's mother without realizing it commits about the most serious offense a German can in housing a "stranger" for one night on his way to safety. Throughout we see the civilian population torn by indecision--should they leave; if so when and how; or will the Russians once again be defeated? So they dither too long and too late--ironically similar to many Jewish people who only decided to leave Germany when it was too late. When it is clear the family must flee, the mother is being held by police and Peter and Auntie must set out on their own into the chaos. The descriptions of the hardships facing the refugees, including being mistreated by one's fellow refugees, being attacked by Russian fighter planes, and always the intolerable and harsh weather, really allow the reader to get a realistic sense of what was going on during this period. However, as Peter tries to board the last boat to safety, one of the most unsavory characters performs an actual act of heroism.

One can read history on the page; here the reader actually senses and feels what the refugees underwent--so, the book make history come vividly alive. The novel is one of the New York Review Book Classics series, rightly acclaimed as one of most important sources for matchless literature, with an unerring eye for excellence and quality. Come join these hapless residents of East Prussia as they cope with the Russian invasion, and you will have invested your time wisely.
6 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Was everything all right now?

All for Nothing is a masterpiece of memory and lyrical prose. Examining a few days at the end of World War II, today's reader knows that East Prussia will soon be invaded and devastated by Soviet troops. But the characters in the novel go on with their static lives of novels and potatoes, unable to comprehend what is happening around them. The action builds slowly in this novel (and is often dispatched in a sentence), with the focus on meticulous and unsparing examination of characters. Except perhaps for young Peter, there are no heroes in this book (though one character does something surprisingly heroic). Each character is viewed from many perspective and each is flawed. Yet even the ridiculous and pedantic Nazi is granted a few bits of humanity, while the fleeing Jew is not treated to the sentimental cliches common in popular literature about the Holocaust: he too is a nuanced character. Kempowski is a master manipulator of tone, letting the reader succumb to pathos and then sneakily subverting it in the next sentence. Readers must make up their own minds about whom to trust, and whom to believe. One of the best novels I've read in a year. Brilliant.
6 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Memorable in many ways!

I found this title as a result of reading an article about the book and the author in the April 2018 NEW YORKER magazine. It is a story set in the cold winter of January 1945 in East Prussia which is located along the coast of the Baltic Sea (Prussia no longer exists and its land is now mostly part of Poland. Approximately 80% of its WW 2 population was German.)
The story opens with a description of an old manor house whose basement is flooded and old pictures of the resident family, the Globigs hang on the walls. The husband is a German officer stationed in Italy. His wife Katharina lives in the house with her 12 year old son Peter and a relative called Auntie who runs the house. There are two servants. The estates land has long been sold off and a subdivision of sterile houses built across the street. Peter’s sister’s grave site is by the side of the passing river and her room remains unchanged. News that the Russian army is advancing but the German administration assure all that the Russians will be stopped. Various views about this are expressed by visitors and refuges that pass by the estate.
It is interesting to note that the events depicted are much the same as in Ruta Septy’s excellent novel SALT AND SEA. The sweep of history and the events of war carry with them a random destiny. Kempowski captures this unpredictability through his writing style using short paragraphs that convey a detachment and lack of sentimentality. Characters separate only to meet again in various ways which normally would seem contrived and coincidental. Yet he manages to make it all so real and arbitrary.
The New Yorker declared the book epic. Yet it is, especially at the beginning very intimate to character and place and then after about 100 pages events push and pull the characters. The Russians are coming. Heil Hitler is more often inserted into the text. Increasingly we follow the 12 year old Peter who like the author Kempowski experiences the choices and vagaries of human nature. He carries with him his microscope. He takes a bit of blood as a sample to view and sees nothing special.
ALL FOR NOTHING offers a metaphor for the upheaval that displaces the old world of the elite aristocracy becoming a new world yet to be created from the winds of war. Kempowski’s book is memorable in many ways.
5 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

a look at the final days of East Prussia through a German family's eyes

"All for Nothing" is the story of a German family in East Prussia just prior to Soviet troops overrunning the area as World War II ends. The characters are a bit one-dimensional, but they represent the variety of types present at the time--the forced laborers, the Jews, the pro-Nazis, and so on. It is interesting to see how people react to the impending Soviet troops--some remain in denial, some flee, and others commit suicide. Interestingly, the Nazi authorities required written permits of these internal refugees, and even arrested people for fleeing or preparing to flee, so some people chose to commit suicide rather than disobey the rules and flee without the permit.
4 people found this helpful