A Town Like Alice (Vintage International)
A Town Like Alice (Vintage International) book cover

A Town Like Alice (Vintage International)

Paperback – February 9, 2010

Price
$15.99
Format
Paperback
Pages
368
Publisher
Vintage
Publication Date
ISBN-13
978-0307474001
Dimensions
5.21 x 0.76 x 7.99 inches
Weight
9.3 ounces

Description

“Entertaining. . . . Dramatic. . . . Shute is a natural and effective story-teller.” — The New York Times “A ripping tale of budding romance and grace under pressure.” — The Times (London)"A harrowing, exciting, and in the end very satisfying war romance." — Harper's NEVIL SHUTE NORWAY was born in 1899 in Ealing, London. He studied Engineering Science at Balliol College, Oxford. Following his childhood passion, he entered the fledgling aircraft industry as an aeronautical engineer working to develop airships and, later, airplanes. In his spare time he began writing and he published his first novel, Marazan , in 1926, using the name Nevil Shute to protect his engineering career. In 1931 he married Frances Mary Heaton and they had two daughters. During the Second World War he joined the Royal Navy Volunteer Reserve where he worked on developing secret weapons. After the war he continued to write and settled in Australia where he lived until his death in 1960. His most celebrated novels include Pied Piper (1942), A Town Like Alice (1950), and On the Beach (1957). Excerpt. © Reprinted by permission. All rights reserved. IJames Macfadden died in March 1905 when he was forty-seven years old; he was riding in the Driffield Point-to-Point. He left the bulk of his money to his son Douglas. The Macfaddens and the Dalhousies at that time lived in Perth, and Douglas was a school friend of Jock Dalhousie, who was a young man then, and had gone to London to become junior partner in a firm of solicitors in Chancery Lane, Owen, Dalhousie, and Peters. I am now the senior partner, and Owen and Dalhousie and Peters have been dead for many years, but I never changed the name of the firm.It was natural that Douglas Macfadden should put his affairs into the hands of Jock Dalhousie, and Mr Dalhousie handled them personally till he died in 1928. In splitting up the work I took Mr Macfadden on to my list of clients, and forgot about him in the pressure of other matters.It was not until 1935 that any business for him came up. I had a letter from him then, from an address in Ayr. He said that his brother-in-law, Arthur Paget, had been killed in a motor car accident in Malaya and so he wanted to redraft his will to make a trust in favour of his sister Jean and her two children. I am sorry to say that I was so ignorant of this client that I did not even know he was unmarried and had no issue of his own. He finished up by saying that he was too unwell to travel down to London, and he suggested that perhaps a junior member of the firm might be sent up to see him and arrange the matter.This fitted in with my arrangements fairly well, because when I got this letter I was just leaving for a fortnight's fishing holiday on Loch Shiel. I wrote and told him that I would visit him on my way south, and I put the file concerning his affairs in the bottom of my suitcase to study one evening during my vacation.When I got to Ayr I took a room at the Station Hotel, because in our correspondence there had been no suggestion that he could put me up. I changed out of my plus-fours into -a dark business suit, and went to call upon my client.He did not live at all in the manner I had expected. I did not know much about his estate except that it was probably well over twenty thousand pounds, and I had expected to find my client living in a house with a servant or two. Instead, I discovered that he had a bedroom and a sitting-room on the same floor of a small private hotel just off the sea front. He was evidently leading the life of an invalid though he was hardly more than fifty years old at that time, ten years younger than I was myself. He was as frail as an old lady of eighty, and he had a peculiar grey look about him which didn't look at all good to me. All the windows of his sitting-room were shut and after the clean air of the lochs and moors I found his room stuffy and close; he had a number of budgerigars in cages in the window, and the smell of these birds made the room very unpleasant. It was clear from the furnishings that he had lived in that hotel and in that room for a good many years.He told me something about his life as we discussed the will; he was quite affable, and pleased that I had been able to come to visit him myself. He seemed to be an educated man, though he spoke with a marked Scots accent. 'I live very quietly, Mr Strachan,' he said. 'My health will not permit me to go far abroad. Whiles I get out upon the front on a fine day and sit for a time, and then again Maggie - that's the daughter of Mrs Doyle who keeps the house - Maggie wheels me out in the chair. They are very good to me here.'Turning to the matter of the will, he told me that he had no close relatives at all except his sister, Jean Paget. 'Forbye my father might have left what you might call an indiscretion or two in Australia,' he said. 'I would not say that there might not be some of those about, though I have never met one, or corresponded. Jean told me once that my mother had been sore distressed. Women talk about these things, of course, and my father was a lusty type of man.'His sister Jean had been an officer in the WAACs in the 1914-1918 War, and she had married a Captain Paget in the spring of 1917. 'It was not a very usual sort of marriage,' he said thoughtfully. 'You must remember that my sister Jean had never been out of Scotland till she joined the army, and the greater part of her life had been spent in Perth. Arthur Paget was an Englishman from Southampton, in Hampshire. I have nothing against Arthur, but we had all naturally thought that Jean would have married a Scot. Still, I would not say but it has been a happy marriage, or as happy as most.'After the war was over Arthur Paget had got a job upon a rubber estate in Malaya somewhere near Taiping, and Jean, of course, went out there with him. From that time Douglas Macfadden had seen little of his sister; she had been home on leave in 1926 and again in 1932. She had two children, Donald born in 1918 and Jean born in 1921; these children had been left in England in 1932 to live with the Paget parents and to go to school in Southampton, while their mother returned to Malaya. My client had seen them only once, in 1932 when their mother brought them up to Scotland.The present position was that Arthur Paget had been killed in a motor accident somewhere near Ipoh; he had been driving home at night from Kuala Lumpur and had driven off the road at a high speed and hit a tree. Probably he fell asleep. His widow, Jean Paget, was in England; she had come home a year or so before his death and she had taken a small house in Bassett just outside Southampton to make a home for the children and to be near their schools. It was a sensible arrangement, of course, but it seemed to me to be a pity that the brother and the sister could not have arranged to live nearer to each other. -I fancy that my client regretted the distance that separated them, because he referred to it more than once.He wanted to revise his will. His existing will was a very simple one, in which he left his entire estate to his sister Jean. 'I would not alter that,' he said. 'But you must understand that Arthur Paget was alive when 1 made that will, and that in the nature of things 1expected him to be alive when Jean inherited from me, and 1 expected that he would be there to guide her in matters of business. 1 shall not make old bones.'He seemed to have a fixed idea that all women were unworldly creatures and incapable of looking after money; they were irresponsible, and at the mercy of any adventurer. Accordingly, although he wanted his sister to have the full use of his money after his death, he wanted to create a trust to ensure that her son Donald, at that time a schoolboy, should inherit the whole estate intact after his mother's death. There was, of course, no special difficulty in that. I presented to him the various pros and cons of a trust such as he envisaged, and 1 reminded him that a small legacy to Mrs Doyle, in whose house he had lived for so many years, might not be out of place provided that he was still living with them at the time of his death. He agreed to that. He told me then that he had no close relations living, and he asked me if I would undertake to be the sole trustee of his estate and the executor of his will. That is the sort of business a family solicitor frequently takes on his shoulders, of course. I told him that in view of my age he should appoint a co-trustee, and he agreed to the insertion of our junior partner, Mr Lester Robinson, to be co-trustee with me. He also agreed to a charging clause for our professional services in connection with the trust.There only remained to tidy up the loose ends of what was, after all, a fairly simple will. I asked him what should happen if both he and his sister were to die before the boy Donald was twenty-one, and I suggested that the trust should terminate and the boy should inherit the estate absolutely when he reached his majority. He agreed to this, and I made another note upon my pad.'Supposing then,' I said, 'that Donald should die before his mother, or if Donald and his mother should die in some way before you. The estate would then pass to the girl, Jean. Again, I take it that the trust would terminate when she reached her majority?''Ye mean,' he asked, 'when she became twenty-one?'I nodded. 'Yes. That is what we decided in the case of her brother.'He shook his head. 'I think that would be most imprudent, Mr Strachan, if I may say so. No lassie would be fit to administer her own estate when she was twenty-one. A lassie of that age is at the mercy of her sex, Mr Strachan, at the mercy of her sex. I would want the trust to continue for much longer than that. Till she was forty, at the very least.'From various past experiences I could not help agreeing with him that twenty-one was a bit young for a girl to have absolute control over a large sum of money, but forty seemed to me to be excessively old. I stated my own view that twenty-five would be a reasonable age, and very reluctantly he receded to thirty-five. I could not move him from that position, and as he was obviously tiring and growing irritable I accepted that as the maximum duration of our trust. It meant that in those very unlikely circumstances the trust would continue for twenty-one years from that date, since the girl Jean had been born in 1921 and it was then 1935- That finished our business and I left him and went back to London to draft out the will, which I sent to him for signature. I never saw my client again. It was my fault that I lost touch with him. It had been my habit for a great many years to take my holiday in the spring, when I would go with my wife to Scotland for a fortnight's fishing, usually to Loch Shiel. I thought that this was going on for ever, as one does, and that next year I would call again upon this client on my way down from the north to see if there was any other business I could do for him. But things turn out differently, sometimes. In the winter of 1935 Lucy died. I don't want to dwell on that, but we had been married for twenty-seven years and - well, it was very painful. Both our sons were abroad, Harry in his submarine on the China station and Martin in his oil company at Basra. I hadn't the heart to go back to Loch Shiel, and I have never been to Scotland since. I had a sale and got rid of most of our furniture, and I sold our house on Wimbledon Common; one has to make an effort at a time like that, and a clean break. It's no good going on living in the ashes of a dead happiness.I took a flat in Buckingham Gate opposite the Palace stables and just across the park from my club in Pall Mall. I furnished it with a few things out of the Wimbledon house and got a woman to come in and cook my breakfast and clean for me in the mornings, and here I set out to re-create my life. I knew the pattern well enough from the experience of others in the club. Breakfast in my flat. Walk through the Park and up the Strand to my office in Chancery Lane. Work all day, with a light lunch at my desk. To the club at six o'clock to read the periodicals, and gossip, and dine, and after dinner a rubber of bridge. That is the routine that I fell into in the spring of 1936, and I am in it still.All this, as I say, took my mind from Douglas Macfadden; with more than half my mind upon my own affairs I could only manage to attend to those clients who had urgent business with my office. And presently another interest grew upon me. It was quite obvious that war was coming, and some of us in the club who were too old for active military service began to get very interested in Air Raid Precautions. Cutting the long story short, Civil Defence as it came to be called absorbed the whole of my leisure for the next eight years. I became a Warden, and I was on duty in my district of Westminster all through the London blitz and the long, slow years of war that followed it. Practically all my staff went on service, and I had to run the office almost single-handed. In those years I never took a holiday, and I doubt if I slept more than five hours in any night. When finally peace came in 1945 my hair was white and my head shaky, and though I improved a little in the years that followed I had definitely joined the ranks of the old men.One afternoon in January 1948 I got a telegram from Ayr. It read,Regret Mr Douglas Macfadden passed away last night please instruct re funeral. Doyle, Balmoral Hotel, Ayr.I had to search my memory, I am afraid, to recollect through the war years who Mr Douglas Macfadden was, and then I had to turn to the file and the will to refresh my memory with the details of what had happened thirteen years before. It seemed rather odd to me that there was nobody at Ayr who could manage the funeral business. I put in a trunk call to Ayr right away and very soon I was speaking to Mrs Doyle. It was a bad line, but I understood that she knew of no relations; apparently Mr Macfadden had had no visitors for a very long time. Clearly, I should have to go to Ayr myself, or else send somebody. I had no urgent engagements for the next two days and the matter seemed to be a little difficult. I had a talk with Lester Robinson, my partner, who had come back from the war as a brigadier, and cleared my desk, and took the sleeper up to Glasgow after dinner that night. In the morning I went down in a slow train to Ayr. Read more

Features & Highlights

  • From the hugely acclaimed author of
  • On the Beach
  • a
  • tale of love and war that follows its enterprising heroine from the Malayan jungle during World War II to the rugged Australian outback. • “Entertaining ... Dramatic ... Shute is a natural and effective story-teller.” —
  • The New York Times
  • Jean Paget, a young Englishwoman living in Malaya, is captured by the invading Japanese and forced on a brutal seven-month death march with dozens of other women and children. A few years after the war, Jean is back in England, the nightmare behind her. However, an unexpected inheritance inspires her to return to Malaya to give something back to the villagers who saved her life. But it turns out that they have a gift for her as well: the news that the young Australian soldier, Joe Harmon, who had risked his life to help the women, had miraculously survived. Jean’s search for Joe leads her to a desolate Australian outpost called Willstown, where she finds a challenge that will draw on all the resourcefulness and spirit that carried her through her war-time ordeals.

Customer Reviews

Rating Breakdown

★★★★★
30%
(2.2K)
★★★★
25%
(1.9K)
★★★
15%
(1.1K)
★★
7%
(519)
23%
(1.7K)

Most Helpful Reviews

✓ Verified Purchase

Be patient after page 235!

When it comes to WW II, I have no idea about the troubles that happened in Asia. The story was very different and interesting to me. I read up to page ~ 235 very fast. I did not even sleep, it was so engrossing. But after page 235, there is almost nothing about the romance, it is only about stuff that have absolutely no relevance. I read the rest in 2 or 3 days, it was so boring. At that point, I only wanted to finish the book. I can't believe how such a nice story turned into a nightmare.

I don't agree that the description of Japanese soldiers is racist. It is so obvious that the author is careful and emphasizes how humane they really are by repeating "doing their best" and "carrying children".
5 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

I do love this story and recommend it for those who like historical fiction.

The story is about Jean Paget, a young English woman. It is narrated by her solicitor, Noel Strachan. There are essentially three parts to Jean's story. In the first part we come to know her as a serious young woman working as a clerical in a shoe factory in London. She leads a fairly unexciting life when she is contacted by Mr Strachan and told that she has inherited a small fortune from an unknown uncle who has recently died. The monies have been placed in a trust that will be administered by the lawyer. She and the elderly lawyer begin to get to know one another and she shares with him her war experiences. (lots of spoilers ahead)

Jean was working in Malaya in 1941 when the Japanese overran the country and interred the British nationals who were working on the rubber plantations. Jean and thirty other women and children were force marched across the country for 18 months following their capture. The suffered terribly and more than half of them died during this march. Toward the end of their march they encounter two Australians who had been captured and put to work by the Japanese driving trucks through the country. Jean and the Aussie, Joe Harmon are attracted to each other and he on several occasions describes to her his much loved life on a cattle station in West Australia. Joe often steals food for the starving women and children and finally is caught. In front of the party he is crucified. The dispirited group is finally allowed to stop marching and remain in a small Malaysian village growing rice for the duration of the war. Jean through the difficulties of the march has evolved into a strong leader of the group but has been scarred by the experience and haunted by the death of Joe Harmon.

With her inheritance Jean is determined to return to the Malaysian village and dig a well for the women of the village in gratitude for what the villagers did for them during the war. During this experience Jean comes to find out that Joe did not die as she had thought. She sets off for Australia to find him. Unbeknownst to her Joe has recently found out she is not married as he had thought but is a single woman. This causes him to go to London to look for her.

Weeks later they reconnect in Australia, fall in love, marry and start a life on a Western Australia cattle station. Jean invests in the town starting a shoe factory and ice cream parlor. Descriptions of the lonely life in this outpost are good. In the final chapter Mr Strachan her lawyer visits and closes the narrative with Jean and Joe happily married raising a family in a growing town.

The sections of this story that deal with the war years are far and away the strongest part of the narrative. I love books with narrators, I think it gives me comfort that I won't miss any important details but this narrator is pitch perfect in a matter of fact way giving details of the horrific war experience. This is the part of the story that is so memorable to me thirty years after having seen the Masterpiece Theater presentation. Also the sections that deal with Jean and Joe reconnecting are engaging and a fine love story.

The last part of this book set in Australia does not quite live up to the high drama of the war years. It does though give you an idea of how difficult and remote life in the Outback was and maybe still is. The novel is dated in only two ways. Everyone is constantly lighting and smoking cigarettes and the prejudice against the aboriginal peoples is explicit and somewhat shocking when read today. Despite those minor criticisms I do love this story and recommend it for those who like historical fiction.
3 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

A Town Like Alice

A Town Like Alice (1950) is a middle-class myth, about overcoming adversity, finding true love and material success through hard work. It's layered with Christian themes, a sort of mix of the Book of Genesis and the New Testament - Jean Paget is Eve, Joe Harman is Christ (an explicit reference made a number of times), and lawyer Noel Strachan, who narrates the story, is God-like (the all-seeing narrator, he even becomes a God-father). The story begins with two innocents cast out from former comfortable lives into the hell on Earth of Japanese occupied Malay. There, Jean and Joe's desires for one another germinate. For his sins Harman is literally crucified, and Paget must toil the earth for her survival. Harman is later reborn, seemingly risen from the dead, and Paget becomes his follower. The first part in Malay appears to be separate from the later Australia part, but they are mirrors of one another, the former foreshadowing the second, like allegories between the Old and New Testament, the first more brutal and primitive, the second more loving and nurturing. The novel depicts gender roles in a rigid traditional manner, which is typical of Shute's generation who fought WWII. Yet Jean, as an Eve the creator figure, is a leader not only of women, but indirectly men and the community, which she largely births.

I think this novel spoke meaningfully to a generation of women who came of age during the 1930s and 40s, whose entry into the workforce would help fuel the economic miracle of the 1950s and beyond. Now it feels a bit dated, a period piece, but it's still a pleasant story. By analyzing it like a Professor one can extract some useful insights into the history of the time when it was written, which makes it still worth reading, if nothing else for a well told story.
3 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Great Read

I have read this book several times and it is always a good read, based on a little history and a little romance, very entertaining.
2 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

A Town Like Alice

The book started out quite interesting; however, the last third became a recitation of the "wonderful", "super-woman" exploits and accomplishments of the heroine. I do not like "Hollywood" endings!!
2 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Thoroughly enjoyed.

At the end of the book, there is an "Author's Note". Reading the note made this work of Nevil Shute's all the more enjoyable. Shute took an actual event in history and, by way of creative license, wrapped his book around it.

A Town like Alice is a very enjoyable novel. Malaya in World War II is the setting for the first part of the book as the protagonist, Jean, describes her ordeal at the hands of the Japanese. This is the part of the book that Shute adapted from the true events mentioned in the Author's note. Shute has a very natural style of writing that colors in the surroundings and the people without overdoing it. You get enough information to let your mind set the scene. The story moves along at a good pace and keeps you intrigued.

During Jean's ordeal with the Japanese she meets an Australian, Joe, and the two of them form a friendship that, by all accounts, ends with the end of the war. The second part of the book moves us to post-war England and post-war Australia as Jean and Joe reunite. In describing Joe's life in the Australian outback, it comes clear where Shute's strength is, his ability to paint the picture. Your mouth almost dries out reading about the Australian tundra. He uses the Aussie vernacular as in "Bonza" for good, "Crook" for bad, "Tucker" for food and whole host more. It's great stuff.

The story teller, Noel, is an attorney in London tasked with handling the trust fund set up for Jean. He comes across as very quaint and diligent of his duties. A sort of Grandfather figure keeping his eye on Jean whom he describes as "a girl I met forty years too late". His role in the book is one of fairy Godfather almost.

If anything, the novel is too neat and tidy, things and people always seem to be in the right place at the right time. This adds too much a feeling of charm at times but, it doesn't spoil the book. The charmed lives of the two after the war have to be held in contrast to their lives during the war.

In summary, A Town like Alice is well written and plausible. It holds you for the duration and, when done, makes you sit back and think about it.

A great work from Nevil Shute.
2 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Beautiful story on so many levels

This is one of my absolute favorite novels ever. It is the story of a young English girl who perseveres in terrible circumstances, and yet manages to find a brief connection with an Australian man. Their interactions are purely platonic and yet both instinctively are willing to sacrifice for the other, in a way that sometimes you just know things before you know them. She believes him dead, he believes she is married, and they both get on with the business of living, with that short interaction burning in the backs of their minds. At nearly the same time, with new information, they leave their respective continents in search of one another and a need to simply know what might have been. I've experienced love in this way, and it is a very powerful thing to connect with someone on one level or in an isolated way, wonder for years, and then get resolution to those feelings in one way or another. It just so happens that everything else about this story is interesting as well. Without giving much away, the juxtaposition of very proper England, hot colonial Malaya, and the rugged Australian outback is interesting and takes the story far beyond a typical thwarted love tale.

The author is very restrained in style and tone, and I appreciate that he describes situations rather than feelings and emotions. You don't know what the characters are feeling, precisely, but you receive the same information that they have, and good writing fills in the blanks. I don't need to know that 'she was filled with dread' or 'he was terribly sad.' Describe the situation and the feeling will follow. Nevil Shute does this well and I appreciate it. You feel as though you are experiencing each event along with the characters rather than being informed after the fact.

The most important aspect, for me, is that the story truly encompasses real life, in the sense that there is extreme hardship, sadness, relief, love, romance, doubt, sacrifice, jealousy, etc. Few authors manage to do this really well, to subtly point out that real life contains horrors and wonders and many very mundane things in between. Shirley Jackson is another writer, from roughly the same time period also, who does this fabulously well.

Finally, I love Jean as a very modern woman who isn't trying so terribly hard to be modern. Even though this was written and takes place in the 1950s, she is an extremely matter of fact and capable young woman who isn't phased by much and never doubts that she can do anything she pleases, including confronting Japanese officers, farming, starting businesses, traveling the globe, or having a family. She manages to be a survivor, and have it all in the end, on her own terms. That's the inspiration for me. You can follow someone halfway around the world and not be a simpering or silly woman with no ambition or other options. You simply do what you need to do, hold on to what you really want, and make the best of whatever happens from there. Worth the read, and re-read as well.
2 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

A book that stayed with me...

I first picked this book up when I was a young girl in 6th grade. I was perusing the isles of the school library and found this dusty book. Having recently taken up an interest in Australia, this caught my eye. I didn't realize until I was already hooked that the Australia part would be long in coming. It took several afternoons to get through the story, but the tale that unfolded has lingered in the back of my mind in the years since. Every time I come across the story, I sit down and read a few passages. My favorite places to read this story, perhaps because of how I first came upon it, is holed up in some narrow isle, besides a forgotten bookshelf.

The situation that the characters were put in is only mildly about the horrors around them. The way that they coped with each other is the true story. Despite the atrocities that go on both to them and around them, they have to get through the everyday business of surviving, raising children, coping with others and generally keeping as much of their humanity as possible. The strength I found in those women helped me through many trying times, then and afterward. That I can now take this book with me on my Kindle is amazing! I can't wait to share this book with my daughter when she is ready.
2 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Old-Fashioned, but with Heart

A while back, I reviewed Nevil Shute's [[ASIN:B003WUYONY NO HIGHWAY]] under the title "They don't write them like that any more." I might well say the same thing here, though this is the richer book, more general in its appeal, and mining a deeper vein. The story of Jean Paget, a young British typist with remarkable reserves of character, it falls into two unequal parts. In the first, she is marooned in Malaya when the Japanese invade, and spends the War in unofficial charge of a group of women and children prisoners of war that no one knows what to do with. In the much longer second, she journeys to the Australian outback, in the extreme North near the Gulf of Carpentaria, to follow the traces of a man who had helped her during her ordeal. There, she makes it her mission to develop the small community of Willstown, so that it is no longer a place that young people seek to leave as soon as they are old enough. Following the example of Alice Springs, thriving in the midst of near-desert, she wants to make Willstown "A Town Like Alice."

This is the kind of book we used to get from the lending library in my youth, to thrill to its descriptions of distant places and wallow in its romance. And it still works. I admit to having tears in my eyes several times -- but never for long enough to despise myself. Shute's people are remarkably warm, but they are rough-hewn and practical; there is a job to be done and they do it. And his evocation of Malaya and the Australian outback, while completely convincing, is bracing rather than picturesque. Jean herself is a heroine to root for, but primarily for her initiative, persistence, and tact. There is one very interesting scene which, in a more modern novel, would end with the young couple in bed together. Here, however, in accordance with the conventions of the time (and the rather strict morality of the place), Shute manages a neat transition from eroticism to friendly practicality. It works, but the touch of prudery has an old-fashioned air.

The novel is old-fashioned too in the way it opens, with a narrator (Noel Strachan, a London lawyer) who has very little to do with the main story. I associate this device more with the turn of the century ([[ASIN:0451530675 THE TURN OF THE SCREW]] or [[ASIN:1936594145 HEART OF DARKNESS]], for instance), and it is strange to find it in 1950. It makes for a slow and rather confusing start, and although Strachan does play a more active role than the other narrators, he reports things that he could not possibly have known. Partly as a result of this, the novel is rather elusive in its shape. It is a harrowing war story, but this occupies only the first third of the book. It is a romance, but the romance is essentially requited by the two-thirds mark. After that, it rather drifts into material that is interesting rather than absorbing; you are told what happens, and you applaud -- but you do not feel it in the same way. So only four stars -- but I am really glad to have read the book for its first two-thirds at least.
2 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Bought a used copy

Glad I didn’t order the kindle. I hear it was heavily edited. I suppose that was for woke people. Rewriting cultural history is never a good idea.
1 people found this helpful