A Circle of Wives
A Circle of Wives book cover

A Circle of Wives

Hardcover – March 4, 2014

Price
$11.72
Format
Hardcover
Pages
325
Publisher
Atlantic Monthly Press
Publication Date
ISBN-13
978-0802122346
Dimensions
6.25 x 1.25 x 9.25 inches
Weight
1.22 pounds

Description

From Booklist When Dr. John Taylor, a plastic surgeon who specialized in treating disfigured children, is found dead in his hotel room, the case is assigned to Palo Alto detective Samantha Adams. More accustomed to investigating bike thefts, Samantha is astonished to discover that her first homicide case contains layers upon layers. It seems that Taylor was a bigamist, married to three women at the same time; only his first wife, the icy Deborah, knew of his complicated marital history, as she was obsessed with holding onto the status and the money that came with being married to a wealthy plastic surgeon and even helped manage her husband’s hectic schedule, penciling in time for his two other wives, earth mother MJ and pediatric oncologist Helen. Each chapter, narrated in turn by his wives as well as the detective, reveals a complicated man whose different marriages nurtured different aspects of his personality. LaPlante, coming off the triumph of Turn of Mind (2011), crafts a page-turner that also offers much ironic commentary on the dynamics of love and marriage, emphasizing the great mystery at the heart of any romantic relationship. --Joanne Wilkinson "Marriage is as mysterious as murder in LaPlante’s captivating psychological thriller. . . . a smart, intricate tale about murder and the elusive mysteries of marriage . . . In LaPlante’s world knowing who did the deed is never as fascinating as wondering why." — People (3.5 stars) "The pleasures of this novel—as with LaPlante's last, Turn of Mind —lie less in the plot, which is strewn with only a few clues and red herrings, and more in the sharply drawn and carefully shaded characters. A-" — Entertainment Weekly "A suspenseful, thrilling read but also one that explores the complications of human relationships with grace and understanding. In her darkly funny, lushly drawn mystery, LaPlante offers readers her own revelations about love, loss, and the complicated compulsions that draw us together." — Royal Young, Interview "I finished reading this absorbing novel after 11 last night. That’s the mark of a successful mystery." — Carolyn See, Washington Post "Love is a mystery in this clever whodunit about marriage, passion and deception. . . . Sharply written and observant." — Family Circle "Exhilarating and smart, A Circle of Wives is a wild ride of love, loss, marriage and murder, with a finale that's provocative, thrilling and grand. It all shows that while some deaths are a mystery, so, too, are some loves." — San Francisco Chronicle "Surprising, swift and sure-footed. . . . [LaPlante] has taken an intriguing premise and, having hooked the reader, delivers an equally intriguing book." — Seattle Times "Insightful . . . [An] engrossing tale of tangled relationships, unfilled needs, and the endless human talent for self-deception. The question it plants in the reader’s mind is the most chilling of all: How well do I know the person I love?" — Washington Independent Review of Books "LaPlante’s engrossing second thriller . . . explores love, loss, control, the influence of past relationships, and passion. . . . Captivating." — Publishers Weekly "A page-turner that also offers much ironic commentary on the dynamics of love and marriage, emphasizing the great mystery at the heart of any romantic relationship." — Booklist "In this literary character study built on a mystery’s framework, LaPlante ingeniously constructs characters distinct and original." — Kirkus Reviews "Highly original and captivating." — The Missourian Alice LaPlante is an award-winning writer of both fiction and non-fiction. She teaches creative writing at Stanford University, where she was a Wallace Stegner Fellow and Jones Lecturer. She also teaches in the MFA program at San Francisco State University. Her fiction has been widely published in Epoch , Southwestern Review , and other literary journals. Alice is the author of six books, including the LA Times bestseller Method and Madness: The Making of a Story (W.W. Norton 2009). Her first novel, Turn of Mind , was a New York Times , NPR, and American Independent Booksellers Association bestseller, won the Wellcome Trust Book Prize, was a finalist for the Barnes & Noble Discover Award for Fiction, and was named a New York Times and Booklist Editors’ Choice and a #1 IndieNextPick. She lives with her family in Northern California. Author website: alicelaplante.com Read more

Features & Highlights

  • * An Indie Next Pick* A LibraryReads Selection* An Amazon Best Book of the Month (Mysteries & Thrillers)* A Daily Candy Best Book of March* One of
  • More
  • Magazine’s "Five Thrillers Not to Read After Dark"
  • When Dr. John Taylor turns up dead in a hotel room, the local police uncover enough incriminating evidence to suspect foul play. Detective Samantha Adams, whose Palo Alto beat usually covers petty crimes, is innocently thrown into a high-profile case that is more complicated than any she has faced before. A renowned reconstructive surgeon and a respected family man, Dr. Taylor was beloved and admired. But beneath his perfect façade was a hidden life—in fact, multiple lives. Dr. Taylor was married to three very different women in three separate cities. As the circumstances surrounding his death emerge, Detective Adams finds herself tracking down a murderer through a tangled web of marital deception and revenge.
  • New York Times
  • bestselling author Alice LaPlante’s haunting and complex novel of family secrets dissects—with scalpel-like agility—the intricacies of desire and commitment, trust and jealousy.

Customer Reviews

Rating Breakdown

★★★★★
30%
(367)
★★★★
20%
(245)
★★★
15%
(183)
★★
7%
(86)
28%
(342)

Most Helpful Reviews

✓ Verified Purchase

Surprisingly dull

This author must have a fabulous publicist! There has been a lot of buzz about this book and it sounded really great. Sadly, it falls very short. I did finish it, but before I was very long into it, there was sort of a "so what?" feeling.

None of the characters are likeable so it's hard to warm up to them. Even the female detective (Sam) who is investigating the doctor's death is a mess. There doesn't seem to be any part of her life that is working. She has bounced around careers...even went into law enforcement because she saw a sign in the police department that they were hiring. Her live-in boyfriend treats her with what I considered verbal abuse. So as she investigates the three women married to the same doctor, her disdain for them seems hypocritical.

By the end of the book, Sam says that she, too, could have fallen for John Taylor but part of the issue I have is that it is not really clear WHY any of these women wanted him. His first wife liked the status but she talks of him with disgust and even helped arrange the details of his marrying other women. He is described (by the women who supposedly loved him) as controlling, demanding, overweight and not very attractive. Go figure.

It seemed like the author was trying to find a way to tie it all up so she introduces a FOURTH woman into the equation...not a wife but a fiancée. Yikes. And then the ending (and reveal of the murderer) is complicated and stretches credibility.

If you see the publicity about this book you'll probably be tempted to buy it. Hope you like it better than I did!
20 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

UNBELIEVEABLE

I found this book implausible, there is no way in this age that someone as well known as Dr. John Taylor could have that many secrets and someone not have found them out. If the author had set it a few decades ago, then it might have been more believable. The women all are so stereotypical that you wonder what book they were based from. This is a book to read if you don’t want to engage your mind at all.
11 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Barely lukewarm ---

I was initially drawn to this book because of the abundance of rave reviews and the seemingly interesting premise. Unfortunately, my expectations were not met. It lacked genuineness with a storyline that was quite implausible. Dr John Taylor, a polygamist, who juggled his life among three wives, stretched credibility to the limit.

The writing is good, with simple dialogue, and makes for an easy read. The individual stories were cleverly woven together and all came together for a rather satisfying conclusion. However, I never connected to the characters and found them all unlikeable with little or no depth. There was very little suspense or drama and no real intrigue. I found this book to be barely lukewarm - no spark whatsoever. My rating - 2 stars.
8 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

The Plot Disappoints with No Surprises

I liked the four women alternatingly telling the story with short chapters. But the farther I read, the more I began to suspect I would be disappointed with the ending. I was right. Their are no big surprises and the ending left me disappointed and unsatisfied. A rather straight forward plot with little, if any, character development.
6 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

A rather Underwhelming Murder Mystery.

I have to give it 3 stars because the concept of the plot was interesting, and it was readable, but there was no real passion to any of the characters.
Samantha (Sam), the young detective assigned to solve the murder of John, a doctor with three "wives" has relationship problems of her own, but those problems are never really explained, more of a passing reference made in contrast to the "passion" in the murdered doctor's life.
The author gives us first person thoughts and feelings of each of the three "wives" in various chapters, but those thoughts and feelings are generally not distinct enough in "flavor" to tell which of the "wives" those chapters are about without the help of the name of each of the different wives at the beginning of their chapters.
Not the worst book I have read by far, but not vivid enough for me to recommend to mystery/thriller/police fiction fans.
4 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Three (or four) (or more)

John is dead, and two of his three wives are clueless about the others. I'm not giving away anything that can't be found in the opening pages or in the blurbs.

Alice LaPlant's Turn of Mind was a tour de force, garnering her many fans. This, however, is definitely a sophomore effort. The style is punchy, the tale unspooling through four narrators -- the three wives and a young woman detective assigned to the case. The problem lies in the fact that there is nothing in the first person narrations that differentiates the four women clearly to make them individualistic enough. Also there had to be so much a suspension of belief in order to buy into the premise of a man being able to live a life filled with such secrets. There are simply not enough hours in the day to accomplish what he was supposed to have done, and there has to be some rooting in reality for it to work. This has been praised as more of a novel of motivations and discovery, not so much a whodunnit. Although I was disappointed in this book, I will read her next book since I think she's got a lot to offer, just didn't deliver this time around.
3 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Interesting story, but I just could not get onto it

Alice LaPlante is an interesting writer. She definitely can develop any scene. Her imagery is thorough and compelling. Her characters are thoroughly developed as well. Each woman was crafted as an individual, with a complete back story. However implausible these women can be at times, the minute details are so convincingly portrayed LaPlante convinced me.

Unfortunately, the plot is thin and weak. Compared to the fantastic development of her characters and scenes, it is sad how dull and cliched she menders through the plot. Not formulaic, but the plot is just not as interesting as it should be. And Sam is too much of mess. I could connect with her character, but I just find her to be hard to believe as a plausible detective. Her mannerisms are strange, and frankly I find it out that someone so indecisive is able to follow through this entire case and find details other, better, detectives missed.

It is only OK. If you can borrow it, or get it from the kindle store for a couple of dollars, then I would read it, but do not waste your time if you are looking for a compelling suspense novel.
3 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

psychological thriller

Dr. Taylor is a found dead in his hotel room. He specializes in wives, 3 of them (that we know of) at the same time in different cities. How does a renowned plastic surgeon in treating disfigured children and an active community spokesman manage that in the day of google and facebook? Well, his first wife didn't want a divorce so she arranged his schedule for wife #2 (earth-mother MJ Taylor) and wife #3 (pediatric oncologist Dr. Helen Taylor). The best part is each chapter the narration is taken over by a different wife. Palo Alto detective Samantha Adams is in charge of the investigation and she gets to chime in from time to time.

I loved the premise and the author can certainly spin a story but I think this would made a better Tarantino movie than a novel.
3 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

Murder, Mystery, and Marriage

3.5 out of 5 stars.

Having just read an advance copy of Jennifer Murphy's "I Love You More" I was curious to see how Alice LaPlante would approach her novel, "A Circle of Wives," about three women who all discover they've been "married" to the same, recently deceased man. (Side note, men with multiple wives... maybe these two novels should be treated as cautionary tales; in both the husband is no longer in the land of the living.) Both books focus on unraveling the mystery of the husband's death, though LaPlante takes a different path than Murphy- choosing to narrate her novel from the perspective of each individual wife, and the young, junior detective assigned to the murder case.

What struck me as funny about both "A Circle of Wives" and "I Love You More," is that each novel was less about the relationship between husband and wife, and more about the inter-dynamics of "the other women." LaPlante paints believeable scenarios and encounters that pull the reader in. I did not think I was going to like her naive detective, but found that she was a character that grew on me by the end of the novel. I also appreciate that she gets her own story arc and satisfying resolution.

All of the female characters in LaPlante's novel get equal treatment and attention. Though initially I feared that the cast was a little stereotypical (the "hippie wife", the "first" wife, etc), I was pleasantly surprised at how they developed. If anyone gets the short-end of the stick, it's Dr. John Taylor, who is at the center of this circle of wives. Though we get a good idea of who he was, or at least how he portrayed himself, he's never quite fully in focus.

Overall, I really enjoyed "A Circles of Wives"- though would love to one day read a novel with this premise told from the man's POV. (Seriously, I would love to know what makes someone think it's a good idea to take on three wives...)
3 people found this helpful
✓ Verified Purchase

"Death. Always interrupting things."

This is a terrific book. Palo Alto, CA, detective Sam(antha) Adams usually covers burglaries and small-town crimes, but this time there's a possible murder to investigate when high-profile plastic surgeon John Taylor is found dead in a hotel room in town. Things take a very interesting turn when three women come to his funeral, all claiming to be his wife.

Sam isn't an experienced detective, and people don't always take her as seriously as she'd like. But she doggedly sets out to prove herself by finding the killer, once it's established that the doctor's death was not by natural causes. She's got quite a list of suspects, including the three wives, one wife's flaky brother, and yet another possible lady friend. The chapters are voiced alternately by Sam and wives Deborah, a homemaker; MJ, former hippie, now accountant; and most recent wife Helen, a pediatric oncologist. All of the wives are very well-depicted, full characters with unique voices. I found the back story of Dr. Taylor fascinating; his level of compartmentalization is phenomenal (reminded me of Don Draper in "Mad Men".)

This story is so well done that it's completely believable, and I really felt for the wives when they find out the level of deception they've been living with, and the way they question themselves and ask "how could I not know?" The other question the story raises is how well do any of us know our spouse or significant other? Do we willfully not see things that don't add up, and not question things because it's easier to keep the status quo? And what price do we pay for a certain lifestyle?

As Sam is dealing with her investigation, she is also questioning her own relationship with her boyfriend Peter, and wondering if she's with him for the right reasons.

This book is a great accomplishment. It's got everything going for it - terrific writing, great pace, amazing story, believable characters. Check it out! I recommend it very highly and I look forward to more from the talented Ms. LaPlante.
3 people found this helpful